Consensus Dynasty Rankings- QB1 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

This should work better than the dynasty draft polls.

 

[jeter23]

Other? Brady? Luck?

 

[Texasmouth]

The "other" vote more than likely came from a redskins fan with their new savior.

 

[Abraham]

I'd take Tom Brady over all of those guys.

 

[metoo]

Rodgers, I don't think it's close.

 

[jeter23]

I'd take Tom Brady over all of those guys.

So, you were the "other" vote? How many years of top 5 production do you think Brady has left?

 

[Abraham]

I'd take Tom Brady over all of those guys.

So, you were the "other" vote? How many years of top 5 production do you think Brady has left?

3 or 4, maybe 5,I take that over the fact that Matt stafford and cam newton have each had one great season do far.

 

[nickdib]

I'd take Tom Brady over all of those guys.

So, you were the "other" vote? How many years of top 5 production do you think Brady has left?

3 or 4, maybe 5,I take that over the fact that Matt stafford and cam newton have each had one great season do far.

Why do you take brady over Rodgers?

 

[Gandalf]

I'd take Tom Brady over all of those guys.

So, you were the "other" vote? How many years of top 5 production do you think Brady has left?

3 or 4, maybe 5,I take that over the fact that Matt stafford and cam newton have each had one great season do far.

Makes sense if your team is in position to win it all but it is hard to imagine that from this point forward, for the rest their careers and barring injury, that Stafford wont out produce Brady. We are probably looking at bother 10 years+ with stafford versus 2-3 for Brady.

 

[jeter23]

I'd take Tom Brady over all of those guys.

So, you were the "other" vote? How many years of top 5 production do you think Brady has left?

3 or 4, maybe 5,I take that over the fact that Matt stafford and cam newton have each had one great season do far.

Makes sense if your team is in position to win it all but it is hard to imagine that from this point forward, for the rest their careers and barring injury, that Stafford wont out produce Brady. We are probably looking at bother 10 years+ with stafford versus 2-3 for Brady.

I can see Brady over Cam/Stafford if you are worried about last year being a fluke, but I see no way to tank him over Rodgers.

 

[Gandalf]

I'd take Tom Brady over all of those guys.

So, you were the "other" vote? How many years of top 5 production do you think Brady has left?

3 or 4, maybe 5,I take that over the fact that Matt stafford and cam newton have each had one great season do far.

Makes sense if your team is in position to win it all but it is hard to imagine that from this point forward, for the rest their careers and barring injury, that Stafford wont out produce Brady. We are probably looking at bother 10 years+ with stafford versus 2-3 for Brady.

I can see Brady over Cam/Stafford if you are worried about last year being a fluke, but I see no way to tank him over Rodgers.

The only argument that I would make is that Rodgers has had concussions. Barring that Rodgers > Stafford. But to me that is a significant issue for a guy I am going to build around.