Consensus PPR Dynasty Rankings- RB1 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

This should work better than the dynasty draft polls.

 

[Gandalf]

This should work better than the dynasty draft polls.

I went McCoy but all three are so close in my mind. The big question for me is when to take Richardson and obviously a lot depends on where he lands. Many people on this site think he belongs in the elite tier. It will be interesting to see how people vote.

 

[jeter23]

This should work better than the dynasty draft polls.

I went McCoy but all three are so close in my mind. The big question for me is when to take Richardson and obviously a lot depends on where he lands. Many people on this site think he belongs in the elite tier. It will be interesting to see how people vote.

I nearly included him and will have him in the next poll.

 

[jeter23]

We may have to call these 3 a tie for #1 and move on.

 

[Ack88]

Voted Foster. He's such a natural fit for how they block. It's amazing how he shoots through holes. Also like that he's fared much better against stout Ds like Baltimore and Pittsburgh than most other runners. Had Foster not had the nagging hammy, this wouldn't be all that close. (McCoy owner in one dynasty)

 

[solorca]

I'll take McCoy. I think all three are similar in talent and production, but McCoy is the youngest and holds more dynasty value for me based on that.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

I went McCoy. He's the youngest and I'm an eagles fan

 

[fruity pebbles]

Don't see how this isn't lesean, hes a year and a half younger than the other two. For a rb that's a lot when value falls through the floor at 27.

 

[stp-d]

Don't see how this isn't lesean, hes a year and a half younger than the other two. For a rb that's a lot when value falls through the floor at 27.

i thought it was 28? now 27... Next the seniors in college will have lost trade value compared to the red shirts.

 

[golfguy]

Don't see how this isn't lesean, hes a year and a half younger than the other two. For a rb that's a lot when value falls through the floor at 27.

i thought it was 28? now 27... Next the seniors in college will have lost trade value compared to the red shirts.

27? come on. there is no real indications of anything except post 30. 27 is still young for a rb. the bigger concern is # of carries. not so much age

 

[fruity pebbles]

Don't see how this isn't lesean, hes a year and a half younger than the other two. For a rb that's a lot when value falls through the floor at 27.

i thought it was 28? now 27... Next the seniors in college will have lost trade value compared to the red shirts.

Dropoff in production seems to be around 28-29 usually doesn't it? People are anticipating. Some wont trade for a 26 yo rb. Try trading a 27 yo back in a dynasty. You'll hear age concerns.

 

[fruity pebbles]

Don't see how this isn't lesean, hes a year and a half younger than the other two. For a rb that's a lot when value falls through the floor at 27.

i thought it was 28? now 27... Next the seniors in college will have lost trade value compared to the red shirts.

27? come on. there is no real indications of anything except post 30. 27 is still young for a rb. the bigger concern is # of carries. not so much age

Age not carries has shown to be much more indicattive.

 

[golfguy]

Don't see how this isn't lesean, hes a year and a half younger than the other two. For a rb that's a lot when value falls through the floor at 27.

i thought it was 28? now 27... Next the seniors in college will have lost trade value compared to the red shirts.

Dropoff in production seems to be around 28-29 usually doesn't it? People are anticipating. Some wont trade for a 26 yo rb. Try trading a 27 yo back in a dynasty. You'll hear age concerns.

that doesn't make it true and people always love the new 22 yr old RB who is going to the next........

 

[fruity pebbles]

Don't see how this isn't lesean, hes a year and a half younger than the other two. For a rb that's a lot when value falls through the floor at 27.

i thought it was 28? now 27... Next the seniors in college will have lost trade value compared to the red shirts.

Dropoff in production seems to be around 28-29 usually doesn't it? People are anticipating. Some wont trade for a 26 yo rb. Try trading a 27 yo back in a dynasty. You'll hear age concerns.

that doesn't make it true and people always love the new 22 yr old RB who is going to the next........

Faulk, Alexander, Tomlinson, Westbrook all had big dropoffs after their 28 yo season. Lot of big names begin their descent there. Some go longer but a 27-28 yo back is long in the tooth.

 

[geoff8695]

I agree that it's close, but I'll give the nod to Foster who is most likely to supply owners with the best fantasy pts. per game at the RB position. Houston's recent success, and Foster's new 5 yr. deal pretty much ensures the coaching philosophy and offensive scheme will remain in place for the foreseeable future.