What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Consensus Top 350 Albums of All-Time: 68. Automatic for the People – R.E.M. (231 Viewers)

Two more random “one-vote” albums from each participant:



Jeb

1,438. Lapalco - Brendan Benson


@Mister CIA

920. Stephen Malkmus - Stephen Malkmus


@Eephus

520. 16 Lovers Lane – The Go-Betweens


@krista4

684. If You’re Feeling Sinister - Belle and Sebastian
These 4 were nearly on my list....certainly top 120 for me.

16 Lovers Lane was in my 71-80 range.
I chose to list a different Belle and Sebastian but Sinister is great.
I already had listed 2 Pavement albums and a Silver Jews' album that prominently features Malkmus so opted not to include that debut solo.
And Lapalco was in the 120 range.
 
Speaking of "China Cat Sunflower/I Know You Rider," I'm surprised not to see Europe '72 on the list. I know people went with more studio than live albums, but you would think the Dead are an exception. Europe '72 might not have my favorite version of most of their songs (though I do think it is my favorite "Morning Dew"), but it is consistently strong from start to finish and a good representation of the band at their peak.
I think of live Dead music as "different" in that they're not really albums, I'm just experiencing experiences. Not sure if that makes sense.

I listen to random Dead and JGB shows all the time.
 
74. The Southern Harmony and Musical Companion – The Black Crowes (309 points)

@BrutalPenguin #2 :headbang:
@turnjose7 #3 :headbang:
@KarmaPolice #7 :headbang:
@Barry2 #16
@ConstruxBoy #18



The Southern Harmony and Musical Companion is the second studio album by American rock band the Black Crowes, released on May 12, 1992. It was the first album by the band to feature Marc Ford on lead guitar, replacing Jeff Cease, who was fired the year before, and the first to feature keyboardist Eddie Harsch. The album's name derives from the full name of the Southern Harmony, an influential 1835 hymnal compiled by William Walker.
I need to check this out. Didn’t realize the whole album was so beloved. I’ve never given Black Crowes a proper listen and this feels like a good place to start.
I'd be curious on your thoughts when you listen. I think you'll dig it. Their other albums are hit and miss for me, but the songs that hit are fantastic. If you like Southern Harmony, my recommendation for you and others is their 2009 albums Before the Frost.... Until the Freeze. It was recorded live and has some great energy to it.

Wow, I absolutely love Before the Frost...Until the Freeze, but it would be quite jarring going from Southern Harmony to that. Early Crowes like Southern Harmony is gritty, dirty blues rock. Before the Frost is essentially jamgrass. So I'm not disagreeing with the recommendation. Just want @Ilov80s to know what he would be getting into. Most people would say Amorica is theirsecond best album. That, Shake Your Money Maker, Before the Frost, and Three Snakes and One Charm are all top notch albums and any would be a good follow up.

Actually, for anyone who is checking out the Crowes for the first time, after Southern Harmony I would recommend their most popular live album, Freak n' Roll...Into the Fog. It has all their "hits," and most of it is the hard rock style that is probably most commercially appealing, but it also has an acoustic set and a few numbers where they get into the lengthy Dead-like jams that were really the highlight of their live shows (especially in that era). That version of "My Morning Song" is one of my favorite recordings of any track ever, and that is the band's best lineup as well. My second favorite song off the album.
A fair stance. Just personally for me I find it the most consistent album of theirs after Southern Harmony. I prefer Three Snakes over Amorica, but some could be the album cover for Amorica as well . :lol: Can't go wrong, and I think people will find a surprising wealth of new songs however they go if they haven't listened to much of the Crowes. I also second the live album recommendation as well. That is the live album of theirs I listen to the most, and love that Morning Song jam The show I was randomly watching this morning started with a killer version of it.
I just listened to it on a walk. Remedy is such a killer song but nothing else really jumped out at me. I liked it all but couldn’t distinguish between one song and another. I like their vibe and style in general though.
 
71. Saturday Night Fever (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) – Various Artists (325 points)


@zamboni #8 🕺
@krista4 #20
@Uruk-Hai #21
@simey #23
@Mister CIA #29
@Dennis Castro #32
@higgins #42
@Tau837 #68


Saturday Night Fever is the soundtrack double album (in 2 Long Play records) from the 1977 film Saturday Night Fever starring John Travolta. The soundtrack was released on November 15, 1977 by RSO Records. Prior to the release of Thriller by Michael Jackson, Saturday Night Fever was the best-selling album in music history, and still ranks among the best-selling soundtrack albums worldwide, with sales figures of over 40 million copies.
So many ways to go for the song choice, but has to be from the Bee Gees. Inclined to go with "How Deep Is Your Love" - my #1 Bee Gees song from the earlier MAD countdown - but open to suggestions from the other voters (and anyone else).
 
@Mister CIA

808. Live at Budokan – Cheap Trick

920. Stephen Malkmus - Stephen Malkmus
Was scrolling to see to see if one of my obscure picks from the 70s showed up in this post. Nope, not yet, and it gives me a little hope that this little gem might still make the cut. Counting on @krista4 aand @simey to give it some gravity. I'm referring to an artist whose reputation is built upon being a one-album wonder.

Mildly surprised to see I'm the only one who picked Live at Budokan.

Odds are I had it on my list but accidentally deleted it somewhere along the way. :bag:

I'm shocked that the Cheap Trick record didn't get multiple votes. Great choice on the Malkmus.
 
Also, in response to the earlier topic about the best 3 album debut of a band. I thought that was interesting and didn't get enough discussion. Assuming you are limiting it to studio albums (because otherwise you can bring in the Allmans and it is a whole different story), I would put the Crowes into consideration here too. Jimi is obviously a great choice as well, but Shake Your Money Maker, The Southern Harmony and Musical Companion, and Amorica is about as good of a three album run as I can imagine. I really don't know if there is a single song on those 3 consecutive albums that I don't really like. I'm not sure I could even say that about the stretches of albums the Stones, The Beatles, The Who, or Zeppelin had later in their careers. Almost every album by those groups have at least one song that I find a little weak. If pressed I guess I could be forced to say the same about "P.25 London" on Amorica, but even that I really like and that is the only one I could even imagine considering a weak link on those three.
I'm a long time All Music user for reviews and they have Moneymaker as 4 stars with Southern and Amorica as 4.5 stars.
Conversely, Hendrix starts with three straight 5 stars and then Band of Gypsys is 4.5 stars. They have Zeppelin's first SIX albums as 5 stars.
Maybe they lean classic rock?
 
71. Saturday Night Fever (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) – Various Artists (325 points)


@zamboni #8 🕺
@krista4 #20
@Uruk-Hai #21
@simey #23
@Mister CIA #29
@Dennis Castro #32
@higgins #42
@Tau837 #68


Saturday Night Fever is the soundtrack double album (in 2 Long Play records) from the 1977 film Saturday Night Fever starring John Travolta. The soundtrack was released on November 15, 1977 by RSO Records. Prior to the release of Thriller by Michael Jackson, Saturday Night Fever was the best-selling album in music history, and still ranks among the best-selling soundtrack albums worldwide, with sales figures of over 40 million copies.
So many ways to go for the song choice, but has to be from the Bee Gees. Inclined to go with "How Deep Is Your Love" - my #1 Bee Gees song from the earlier MAD countdown - but open to suggestions from the other voters (and anyone else).

I'm on board with this choice!
 
72 (tie). Houses of the Holy – Led Zeppelin (323 points)

@Dennis Castro #19
@New Binky the Doormat #21
@Mt. Man #29
@Tau837 #34
@shuke #37
@Dwayne_Castro #37
@Dreaded Marco #41
@Yo Mama #49
@Ghost Rider #52
@timschochet #68

Houses of the Holy is the fifth studio album by the English rock band Led Zeppelin, released on 28 March 1973 in the United States and on 30 March 1973 in the United Kingdom by Atlantic Records. The album benefited from two band members installing studios at home, which allowed them to develop more sophisticated songs and arrangements and expand their musical style. Several songs subsequently became fixtures in the group's live set, including "The Song Remains the Same", "The Rain Song" and "No Quarter". Other material recorded at the sessions, including the title track, was shelved and released on the later albums Physical Graffiti (1975) and Coda (1982). All instruments and vocals were provided by the band members Robert Plant (vocals), Jimmy Page (guitar), John Paul Jones (bass, keyboards), and John Bonham (drums). The album was produced by Page and mixed by Eddie Kramer.
Cool. Someone please add “The Song Remains the Same.”
I did not see The Song Remains the Same on there yet. So, I just added.
 
This album is what made me a Crowes fan for life. Money Maker was really good, if a little overplayed. This album has soul like no other (IMO). The number of covers that they do live shows a true love and understanding of music. My Morning Song is my favorite, but as you said, Thorn in My Pride defines the Crowes sound. Please add Thorn in My pride.
Added Thorn in My Pride to the playlist.
 
some could be the album cover for Amorica as well . :lol:
:lol: I was pulling up The Black Crowes on iTunes to pull up Southern Harmony. Sort of a “whoa” when I saw the Amorica cover in the album list. Must have blocked that one out.

Listened to Southern Harmony a lot back in the 90s, but it has been awhile. Forgot how good it was.
There was a G-rated version of the Amorica cover that was sold at Walmart and such. I guess that's not what's usually found online.
 
some could be the album cover for Amorica as well . :lol:
:lol: I was pulling up The Black Crowes on iTunes to pull up Southern Harmony. Sort of a “whoa” when I saw the Amorica cover in the album list. Must have blocked that one out.

Listened to Southern Harmony a lot back in the 90s, but it has been awhile. Forgot how good it was.
There was a G-rated version of the Amorica cover that was sold at Walmart and such. I guess that's not what's usually found online.
Well, iTunes at least is all-in on the pube version.
 
1,302. Dixie Chicken – Little Feat
I thought this one would have got at least one second vote.
If we did this 6 months later, I would have had this and possibly another Little Feat on there. Odd day of albums, because I was just doing more Little Feat listening this morning with The Last Record Album and Time Loves a Hero. I had strongly considered doing them for a MAD31, but didn't think I could do them and Wikkid's love for them justice. They have been one of my recent loves over the last couple years and I've been working on a playlist for them as well for myself. Long story short, I basically added all of Dixie Chicken to the playlist when I went through the other week and that has been my favorite of theirs since giving them an honest try a few years ago. Great band.
 
For my own 2

Primus - Pork Soda - Primus sucks so I didn’t really expect any matches but IIRC My Name Is Mud was featured on Beavis and Butthead and that was enough for me to go out and buy it

That’s definitely an all time Primus song (just got to see that live a few weeks ago such an awesome bass line)

Les also broke out Diamondback Sturgeon at that show for the first time in awhile

Mr. Krinkle is another favorite of mine as well as Welcome to this World

Overall a bit of a silly album but I was like 13 at the time so I loved it. Been awhile since I’ve listened all the way through I might have to fire this one up for old times sake

Geto (sic) Boys - We Can’t Be Stopped
Pretty sure they were still Ghetto Boys when I got this in 91. Another one of the first CDs I ever owned (I still remember watching that boombox CD player roll down the conveyor belt at Service Merchandise)

little Lambskin was definitely into all of the dirty rap and I know I originally bought this because of Mind Playin Tricks On Me (one of my all time favorite rap songs I can still sing along with this one pretty well)
Im Not A Gentleman is the only other track I can recall at this time but I remember liking the entire album
Again this is 100% a nostalgia pick but I enjoyed it at the time
Pretty sure the slight age difference added to the divergence of albums voted on, and the Primus fans spread out their votes. I gave the debut a hefty amount of points, but that was the only one on my list.
 
74. The Southern Harmony and Musical Companion – The Black Crowes (309 points)

@BrutalPenguin #2 :headbang:
@turnjose7 #3 :headbang:
@KarmaPolice #7 :headbang:
@Barry2 #16
@ConstruxBoy #18



The Southern Harmony and Musical Companion is the second studio album by American rock band the Black Crowes, released on May 12, 1992. It was the first album by the band to feature Marc Ford on lead guitar, replacing Jeff Cease, who was fired the year before, and the first to feature keyboardist Eddie Harsch. The album's name derives from the full name of the Southern Harmony, an influential 1835 hymnal compiled by William Walker.
I need to check this out. Didn’t realize the whole album was so beloved. I’ve never given Black Crowes a proper listen and this feels like a good place to start.
I'd be curious on your thoughts when you listen. I think you'll dig it. Their other albums are hit and miss for me, but the songs that hit are fantastic. If you like Southern Harmony, my recommendation for you and others is their 2009 albums Before the Frost.... Until the Freeze. It was recorded live and has some great energy to it.

Wow, I absolutely love Before the Frost...Until the Freeze, but it would be quite jarring going from Southern Harmony to that. Early Crowes like Southern Harmony is gritty, dirty blues rock. Before the Frost is essentially jamgrass. So I'm not disagreeing with the recommendation. Just want @Ilov80s to know what he would be getting into. Most people would say Amorica is theirsecond best album. That, Shake Your Money Maker, Before the Frost, and Three Snakes and One Charm are all top notch albums and any would be a good follow up.

Actually, for anyone who is checking out the Crowes for the first time, after Southern Harmony I would recommend their most popular live album, Freak n' Roll...Into the Fog. It has all their "hits," and most of it is the hard rock style that is probably most commercially appealing, but it also has an acoustic set and a few numbers where they get into the lengthy Dead-like jams that were really the highlight of their live shows (especially in that era). That version of "My Morning Song" is one of my favorite recordings of any track ever, and that is the band's best lineup as well. My second favorite song off the album.
A fair stance. Just personally for me I find it the most consistent album of theirs after Southern Harmony. I prefer Three Snakes over Amorica, but some could be the album cover for Amorica as well . :lol: Can't go wrong, and I think people will find a surprising wealth of new songs however they go if they haven't listened to much of the Crowes. I also second the live album recommendation as well. That is the live album of theirs I listen to the most, and love that Morning Song jam The show I was randomly watching this morning started with a killer version of it.
I just listened to it on a walk. Remedy is such a killer song but nothing else really jumped out at me. I liked it all but couldn’t distinguish between one song and another. I like their vibe and style in general though.
Surprised a little at the review, but you gave it a listen and that's what this is all about!
 
Lonesome Dreams - 32pts

Perfect timing, as I was just talking to my daughter about this one yet again. I recently talked to her about trying to listen to full albums. Not that I am pushing her to only listen that way or anything, more that she might find a song or two more that she would want on her favorites since she seemed to like another song a lot. Also fittingly, this was the response to @Ilov80s' discussion about opening 3 albums that I had in my head. Especially for a recent artist to the discussion, I would put Lord Huron in the mix. Lonesome Dreams is the debut and just a fantastic, atmospheric album that begs to be listened to start to finish as the songs flow together. They are also by far the band that has the highest hit rate for me as far as recommending new music to people that haven't heard them. In hindsight I probably underrated this one on my list. I'm still holding out hope for a surprise showing from them in the top 70...

My daughter's favorite was She Lit A Fire, but her new favorite discovery that she has listened to repeatedly is Ghost On the Shore, so I will leave that here in case anybody wanted a preview.


Not going to bother with any more King Diamond hot takes.
 
@Pip’s Invitation

1,351. Zen Arcade - Hüsker Dü

1,456. Abandoned Luncheonette – Daryl Hall & John Oates

This is good timing given that I saw Bob Mould last night. Zen Arcade (my #56) is the record that signaled Hüsker Dü was a special band; their material before it is mostly standard hardcore punk. In addition to noise and intensity, the double album offers tunefulness -- there are acoustic guitars, pianos and bright melodies -- and experimentation -- the final track is a 14-minute mindf@ck of an instrumental. It is a sprawling achievement for '80s punk and is responsible for turning non-punks on to the talents of Mould and Grant Hart.

Mould's frenetic opener Something I Learned Today:


Hart's extremely intense but melodic Turn on the News:


The psychedelic but frightening instrumental Dreams Reoccurring (I'll spare you the 14-minute Reoccurring Dreams):


Abandoned Luncheonette (my #61) is the second and best album from Daryl Hall & John Oates. It has a mellow, communal vibe that is markedly different from their highly polished '80s work, but tons of interesting arrangements that prevent it from turning into a hippie snoozefest. Unlike with their later albums, here the principals are presented as equals, with four songs by Hall, three by Oates and two by both of them.

She's Gone, my #1 H&O song (which I took in the US Countdown), which was not a hit until 3 years after the album was released:


Hall's title track, which has dynamics that recall the early work of Springsteen and Joel:


Oates's Had I Known You Better Then, the one Oates song Hall says he wishes he had written:

 
Neutral Milk Hotel

This is one of the albums you feel the need to listen all the way through when you get the itch. Not a bad song on it and it flows so well. It has a rare quality in that it is deeply moving, but also one you want to crank up in the car and scream out the lyrics. I LOOOVE YOUU JEEEEESUS CHRIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIST!

Ask me what song to add to the playlist and it will change probably every day. Today, it's Holland, 1945. I feel like it's as good a standalone song, it rocks, has great horns, and is as good lyrically as anything else on the album.

I can't think of a better song off of this album. This is the song that drew me in. I'm a big fan but it's a challenging listen at times, and I didn't rank it but that doesn't mean I don't have a lot of love for it. I got my niece this record as a “bridge the gap" record but didn't hear too much about it, so I'm assuming it didn't bridge the gap (we get on pretty good regardless, which is really nice).
 
Last edited:
72 (tie). Marquee Moon – Television (323 points)

@zamboni #4 :headbang:
@landrys hat #5 :headbang:
@Dreaded Marco #7 :headbang:
@rockaction #14
@Pip's Invitation #33
@kupcho1 #39

Marquee Moon is the debut studio album by American rock band Television, released on February 8, 1977, by Elektra Records. In the years leading up to the album, Television had become a prominent act in the New York music scene and generated interest from a number of record labels, eventually signing a record deal with Elektra. The group rehearsed extensively in preparation for Marquee Moon before recording it at A & R Recording in September 1976. It was produced by the band's frontman Tom Verlaine and sound engineer Andy Johns.

Just an album that I came to late but love. I needed to wrap my head around the extended jams but once I did it just took off in my estimation. This is a really high ranking, but I won't second-guess myself. I'm not going to put pressure on about a song (I don’t regardless but you know . . . ) because, again, I don't think you can go wrong and every day I put on a different one, whether it's the first ("See No Evil") to the last ("Torn Curtain") each one sticks with me. A mixture of jam band and angular punk, this is a masterclass in everything (except for traditional vocal greatness, but Verlaine's is fitting and fantastic regardless).
 
Last edited:
71. Saturday Night Fever (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) – Various Artists (325 points)


@zamboni #8 🕺
@krista4 #20
@Uruk-Hai #21
@simey #23
@Mister CIA #29
@Dennis Castro #32
@higgins #42
@Tau837 #68


Saturday Night Fever is the soundtrack double album (in 2 Long Play records) from the 1977 film Saturday Night Fever starring John Travolta. The soundtrack was released on November 15, 1977 by RSO Records. Prior to the release of Thriller by Michael Jackson, Saturday Night Fever was the best-selling album in music history, and still ranks among the best-selling soundtrack albums worldwide, with sales figures of over 40 million copies.
We had this on vinyl and wore it out. My pre-tween self loved it. Probably should have considered it. I used to tell the kid next door who was 13 and obsessed with the Beatles that the Bee Gees were better than the Beatles. :laugh:
 
71. Saturday Night Fever (Original Motion Picture Soundtrack) – Various Artists (325 points)


@zamboni #8 🕺
@krista4 #20
@Uruk-Hai #21
@simey #23
@Mister CIA #29
@Dennis Castro #32
@higgins #42
@Tau837 #68


Saturday Night Fever is the soundtrack double album (in 2 Long Play records) from the 1977 film Saturday Night Fever starring John Travolta. The soundtrack was released on November 15, 1977 by RSO Records. Prior to the release of Thriller by Michael Jackson, Saturday Night Fever was the best-selling album in music history, and still ranks among the best-selling soundtrack albums worldwide, with sales figures of over 40 million copies.
We had this on vinyl and wore it out. My pre-tween self loved it. Probably should have considered it. I used to tell the kid next door who was 13 and obsessed with the Beatles that the Bee Gees were better than the Beatles. :laugh:

wikkid story. I told him I was raised on this and The Beach Boys/The Beatles and he was all, I want to talk to your parents you poor child or something like that, appalled our generation didn’t grow up with classical, to which I wanted to respond that his generation changed the school curriculum and stopped going to church or mass, but I let it go or forgot or something.

But he’s right; this is music to listen to once you’ve gotten the basics and then it’s wonderful dance stuff with a bit of palate-cleansing schmaltz.

But I’ve mentioned this album before and I think it’s in a surprising spot here but a great choice nonetheless.
 
1,103. Cheap Thrills – Big Brother & The Holding Company

Janis is at her most Janis here. Freak flags are flying.

1,013. Who Are You – The Who

The high points are awesome but the album isn't consistent enough for me to rank. Which ties into my Who hot take that is still to come.

1,080. Tusk - Fleetwood Mac

I finally listened to this in its entirety a few years ago. It was said to be the most expensive album ever made up until that time, but that's not reflected in the sound at all. Did they spend all of it on the title track (with the marching band and all) and cocaine? Many of the Buckingham songs are downright low-fi by his standards, and have a certain charm because of it. But most of the highest points here are the Nicks tunes -- especially Sara, Sisters of the Moon and Angel.

459. Pelican West - Haircut 100

1,062. The Golden Age of Wireless - Thomas Dolby

Holy '80s, kupcho!

701. Vivid – Living Colour

Just saw these guys with Doc Oc. Probably should have considered this, but on any given day I can't decide whether I prefer this album or Time's Up.

1,263. Can't Buy a Thrill – Steely Dan

536. The Royal Scam – Steely Dan

My Steely Dan vote(s) went elsewhere.

1,242. Fly Like an Eagle – Steve Miller Band

Some people call it overproduced, some people call it too mainstream, some people call it BORRRRING (Whoo-woo!), but I speak of the greatness of this album. Between Miller's early work and his mid-70s peak, I couldn't decide on a record of his to put forward.

1,147. When the Pawn... – Fiona Apple

Please tell me he typed out the whole title on his ballot. :laugh:

580. Life - Dope

Much like how BLOCKED_PUNT has never heard of some of my favorite TV shows, I have never heard of this.

1,351. Healing - Todd Rundgren

1,386. Hermit of Mink Hollow – Todd Rundgren

Todd at his most experimental and Todd at his most commercial. Binky celebrates his entire catalog.
 
But I’ve mentioned this album before and I think it’s in a surprising spot here but a great choice nonetheless.

I expected this to chart but not this highly. Pleasantly surprised.
The fact that I ranked this #8 shows how far my music tastes have evolved in my old age. No way would I have touched this stuff as a kid and probably through my high school years.
 
For my own 2

Primus - Pork Soda - Primus sucks so I didn’t really expect any matches but IIRC My Name Is Mud was featured on Beavis and Butthead and that was enough for me to go out and buy it

That’s definitely an all time Primus song (just got to see that live a few weeks ago such an awesome bass line)

Les also broke out Diamondback Sturgeon at that show for the first time in awhile

Mr. Krinkle is another favorite of mine as well as Welcome to this World

Overall a bit of a silly album but I was like 13 at the time so I loved it. Been awhile since I’ve listened all the way through I might have to fire this one up for old times sake

Geto (sic) Boys - We Can’t Be Stopped
Pretty sure they were still Ghetto Boys when I got this in 91. Another one of the first CDs I ever owned (I still remember watching that boombox CD player roll down the conveyor belt at Service Merchandise)

little Lambskin was definitely into all of the dirty rap and I know I originally bought this because of Mind Playin Tricks On Me (one of my all time favorite rap songs I can still sing along with this one pretty well)
Im Not A Gentleman is the only other track I can recall at this time but I remember liking the entire album
Again this is 100% a nostalgia pick but I enjoyed it at the time
Pretty sure the slight age difference added to the divergence of albums voted on, and the Primus fans spread out their votes. I gave the debut a hefty amount of points, but that was the only one on my list.

I have one more ranked but it’s one of their most hated albums I think so no chance it makes it
 
1,103. Cheap Thrills – Big Brother & The Holding Company

Janis is at her most Janis here. Freak flags are flying.

1,013. Who Are You – The Who

The high points are awesome but the album isn't consistent enough for me to rank. Which ties into my Who hot take that is still to come.

1,080. Tusk - Fleetwood Mac

I finally listened to this in its entirety a few years ago. It was said to be the most expensive album ever made up until that time, but that's not reflected in the sound at all. Did they spend all of it on the title track (with the marching band and all) and cocaine? Many of the Buckingham songs are downright low-fi by his standards, and have a certain charm because of it. But most of the highest points here are the Nicks tunes -- especially Sara, Sisters of the Moon and Angel.

459. Pelican West - Haircut 100

1,062. The Golden Age of Wireless - Thomas Dolby

Holy '80s, kupcho!

701. Vivid – Living Colour

Just saw these guys with Doc Oc. Probably should have considered this, but on any given day I can't decide whether I prefer this album or Time's Up.

1,263. Can't Buy a Thrill – Steely Dan

536. The Royal Scam – Steely Dan

My Steely Dan vote(s) went elsewhere.

1,242. Fly Like an Eagle – Steve Miller Band

Some people call it overproduced, some people call it too mainstream, some people call it BORRRRING (Whoo-woo!), but I speak of the greatness of this album. Between Miller's early work and his mid-70s peak, I couldn't decide on a record of his to put forward.

1,147. When the Pawn... – Fiona Apple

Please tell me he typed out the whole title on his ballot. :laugh:

580. Life - Dope

Much like how BLOCKED_PUNT has never heard of some of my favorite TV shows, I have never heard of this.

1,351. Healing - Todd Rundgren

1,386. Hermit of Mink Hollow – Todd Rundgren

Todd at his most experimental and Todd at his most commercial. Binky celebrates his entire catalog.
Dope is OK. I had their debut that I thought was good

Debonaire is a good song and was featured in some movie I think

They also do a cover of Spin Me Right Round
 
72 (tie). Houses of the Holy – Led Zeppelin (323 points)

@Dennis Castro #19
@New Binky the Doormat #21
@Mt. Man #29
@Tau837 #34
@shuke #37
@Dwayne_Castro #37
@Dreaded Marco #41
@Yo Mama #49
@Ghost Rider #52
@timschochet #68

Houses of the Holy is the fifth studio album by the English rock band Led Zeppelin, released on 28 March 1973 in the United States and on 30 March 1973 in the United Kingdom by Atlantic Records. The album benefited from two band members installing studios at home, which allowed them to develop more sophisticated songs and arrangements and expand their musical style. Several songs subsequently became fixtures in the group's live set, including "The Song Remains the Same", "The Rain Song" and "No Quarter". Other material recorded at the sessions, including the title track, was shelved and released on the later albums Physical Graffiti (1975) and Coda (1982). All instruments and vocals were provided by the band members Robert Plant (vocals), Jimmy Page (guitar), John Paul Jones (bass, keyboards), and John Bonham (drums). The album was produced by Page and mixed by Eddie Kramer.
"Our first guest speaker comes from the year 400 BC, a time when most of the world looked like the cover of the Led Zeppelin album, Houses of the Holy. We were there. There were many steps and columns. It was most tranquil."
 
1,103. Cheap Thrills – Big Brother & The Holding Company

Janis is at her most Janis here. Freak flags are flying.

I just read Joan Didion's "Slouching Towards Bethlehem" last night and they make a cameo. Twice, I think. Great essay. I almost just re-posted a bit, but I don't want to hold people captive. Any interested inquires, just shoot me a line.
 
For my own 2

Primus - Pork Soda - Primus sucks so I didn’t really expect any matches but IIRC My Name Is Mud was featured on Beavis and Butthead and that was enough for me to go out and buy it

That’s definitely an all time Primus song (just got to see that live a few weeks ago such an awesome bass line)

Les also broke out Diamondback Sturgeon at that show for the first time in awhile

Mr. Krinkle is another favorite of mine as well as Welcome to this World

Overall a bit of a silly album but I was like 13 at the time so I loved it. Been awhile since I’ve listened all the way through I might have to fire this one up for old times sake

Geto (sic) Boys - We Can’t Be Stopped
Pretty sure they were still Ghetto Boys when I got this in 91. Another one of the first CDs I ever owned (I still remember watching that boombox CD player roll down the conveyor belt at Service Merchandise)

little Lambskin was definitely into all of the dirty rap and I know I originally bought this because of Mind Playin Tricks On Me (one of my all time favorite rap songs I can still sing along with this one pretty well)
Im Not A Gentleman is the only other track I can recall at this time but I remember liking the entire album
Again this is 100% a nostalgia pick but I enjoyed it at the time
Pretty sure the slight age difference added to the divergence of albums voted on, and the Primus fans spread out their votes. I gave the debut a hefty amount of points, but that was the only one on my list.

I have one more ranked but it’s one of their most hated albums I think so no chance it makes it
Dan, did you vote for Antipop??
 
For my own 2

Primus - Pork Soda - Primus sucks so I didn’t really expect any matches but IIRC My Name Is Mud was featured on Beavis and Butthead and that was enough for me to go out and buy it

That’s definitely an all time Primus song (just got to see that live a few weeks ago such an awesome bass line)

Les also broke out Diamondback Sturgeon at that show for the first time in awhile

Mr. Krinkle is another favorite of mine as well as Welcome to this World

Overall a bit of a silly album but I was like 13 at the time so I loved it. Been awhile since I’ve listened all the way through I might have to fire this one up for old times sake

Geto (sic) Boys - We Can’t Be Stopped
Pretty sure they were still Ghetto Boys when I got this in 91. Another one of the first CDs I ever owned (I still remember watching that boombox CD player roll down the conveyor belt at Service Merchandise)

little Lambskin was definitely into all of the dirty rap and I know I originally bought this because of Mind Playin Tricks On Me (one of my all time favorite rap songs I can still sing along with this one pretty well)
Im Not A Gentleman is the only other track I can recall at this time but I remember liking the entire album
Again this is 100% a nostalgia pick but I enjoyed it at the time
Pretty sure the slight age difference added to the divergence of albums voted on, and the Primus fans spread out their votes. I gave the debut a hefty amount of points, but that was the only one on my list.

I have one more ranked but it’s one of their most hated albums I think so no chance it makes it
Dan, did you vote for Antipop??
:yes:
 
1,103. Cheap Thrills – Big Brother & The Holding Company

Janis is at her most Janis here. Freak flags are flying.

1,013. Who Are You – The Who

The high points are awesome but the album isn't consistent enough for me to rank. Which ties into my Who hot take that is still to come.

1,080. Tusk - Fleetwood Mac

I finally listened to this in its entirety a few years ago. It was said to be the most expensive album ever made up until that time, but that's not reflected in the sound at all. Did they spend all of it on the title track (with the marching band and all) and cocaine? Many of the Buckingham songs are downright low-fi by his standards, and have a certain charm because of it. But most of the highest points here are the Nicks tunes -- especially Sara, Sisters of the Moon and Angel.

459. Pelican West - Haircut 100

1,062. The Golden Age of Wireless - Thomas Dolby

Holy '80s, kupcho!

701. Vivid – Living Colour

Just saw these guys with Doc Oc. Probably should have considered this, but on any given day I can't decide whether I prefer this album or Time's Up.

1,263. Can't Buy a Thrill – Steely Dan

536. The Royal Scam – Steely Dan

My Steely Dan vote(s) went elsewhere.

1,242. Fly Like an Eagle – Steve Miller Band

Some people call it overproduced, some people call it too mainstream, some people call it BORRRRING (Whoo-woo!), but I speak of the greatness of this album. Between Miller's early work and his mid-70s peak, I couldn't decide on a record of his to put forward.

1,147. When the Pawn... – Fiona Apple

Please tell me he typed out the whole title on his ballot. :laugh:

580. Life - Dope

Much like how BLOCKED_PUNT has never heard of some of my favorite TV shows, I have never heard of this.

1,351. Healing - Todd Rundgren

1,386. Hermit of Mink Hollow – Todd Rundgren

Todd at his most experimental and Todd at his most commercial. Binky celebrates his entire catalog.
Dope is OK. I had their debut that I thought was good

Debonaire is a good song and was featured in some movie I think

They also do a cover of Spin Me Right Round
I don't think they are well known or popular but it's one of the few full albums I've listened to so....I've always liked this one
 
1,103. Cheap Thrills – Big Brother & The Holding Company

Janis is at her most Janis here. Freak flags are flying.

1,013. Who Are You – The Who

The high points are awesome but the album isn't consistent enough for me to rank. Which ties into my Who hot take that is still to come.

1,080. Tusk - Fleetwood Mac

I finally listened to this in its entirety a few years ago. It was said to be the most expensive album ever made up until that time, but that's not reflected in the sound at all. Did they spend all of it on the title track (with the marching band and all) and cocaine? Many of the Buckingham songs are downright low-fi by his standards, and have a certain charm because of it. But most of the highest points here are the Nicks tunes -- especially Sara, Sisters of the Moon and Angel.

459. Pelican West - Haircut 100

1,062. The Golden Age of Wireless - Thomas Dolby

Holy '80s, kupcho!

701. Vivid – Living Colour

Just saw these guys with Doc Oc. Probably should have considered this, but on any given day I can't decide whether I prefer this album or Time's Up.

1,263. Can't Buy a Thrill – Steely Dan

536. The Royal Scam – Steely Dan

My Steely Dan vote(s) went elsewhere.

1,242. Fly Like an Eagle – Steve Miller Band

Some people call it overproduced, some people call it too mainstream, some people call it BORRRRING (Whoo-woo!), but I speak of the greatness of this album. Between Miller's early work and his mid-70s peak, I couldn't decide on a record of his to put forward.

1,147. When the Pawn... – Fiona Apple

Please tell me he typed out the whole title on his ballot. :laugh:

580. Life - Dope

Much like how BLOCKED_PUNT has never heard of some of my favorite TV shows, I have never heard of this.

1,351. Healing - Todd Rundgren

1,386. Hermit of Mink Hollow – Todd Rundgren

Todd at his most experimental and Todd at his most commercial. Binky celebrates his entire catalog.
Dope is OK. I had their debut that I thought was good

Debonaire is a good song and was featured in some movie I think

They also do a cover of Spin Me Right Round
I don't think they are well known or popular but it's one of the few full albums I've listened to so....I've always liked this one
Oh man is my love for covers stronger than my hate for U2?
 
1,103. Cheap Thrills – Big Brother & The Holding Company

Janis is at her most Janis here. Freak flags are flying.

1,013. Who Are You – The Who

The high points are awesome but the album isn't consistent enough for me to rank. Which ties into my Who hot take that is still to come.

1,080. Tusk - Fleetwood Mac

I finally listened to this in its entirety a few years ago. It was said to be the most expensive album ever made up until that time, but that's not reflected in the sound at all. Did they spend all of it on the title track (with the marching band and all) and cocaine? Many of the Buckingham songs are downright low-fi by his standards, and have a certain charm because of it. But most of the highest points here are the Nicks tunes -- especially Sara, Sisters of the Moon and Angel.

459. Pelican West - Haircut 100

1,062. The Golden Age of Wireless - Thomas Dolby

Holy '80s, kupcho!

701. Vivid – Living Colour

Just saw these guys with Doc Oc. Probably should have considered this, but on any given day I can't decide whether I prefer this album or Time's Up.

1,263. Can't Buy a Thrill – Steely Dan

536. The Royal Scam – Steely Dan

My Steely Dan vote(s) went elsewhere.

1,242. Fly Like an Eagle – Steve Miller Band

Some people call it overproduced, some people call it too mainstream, some people call it BORRRRING (Whoo-woo!), but I speak of the greatness of this album. Between Miller's early work and his mid-70s peak, I couldn't decide on a record of his to put forward.

1,147. When the Pawn... – Fiona Apple

Please tell me he typed out the whole title on his ballot. :laugh:

580. Life - Dope

Much like how BLOCKED_PUNT has never heard of some of my favorite TV shows, I have never heard of this.

1,351. Healing - Todd Rundgren

1,386. Hermit of Mink Hollow – Todd Rundgren

Todd at his most experimental and Todd at his most commercial. Binky celebrates his entire catalog.
Dope is OK. I had their debut that I thought was good

Debonaire is a good song and was featured in some movie I think

They also do a cover of Spin Me Right Round
I don't think they are well known or popular but it's one of the few full albums I've listened to so....I've always liked this one
Oh man is my love for covers stronger than my hate for U2?
not a cover
 
For my own 2

Primus - Pork Soda - Primus sucks so I didn’t really expect any matches but IIRC My Name Is Mud was featured on Beavis and Butthead and that was enough for me to go out and buy it

That’s definitely an all time Primus song (just got to see that live a few weeks ago such an awesome bass line)

Les also broke out Diamondback Sturgeon at that show for the first time in awhile

Mr. Krinkle is another favorite of mine as well as Welcome to this World

Overall a bit of a silly album but I was like 13 at the time so I loved it. Been awhile since I’ve listened all the way through I might have to fire this one up for old times sake

Geto (sic) Boys - We Can’t Be Stopped
Pretty sure they were still Ghetto Boys when I got this in 91. Another one of the first CDs I ever owned (I still remember watching that boombox CD player roll down the conveyor belt at Service Merchandise)

little Lambskin was definitely into all of the dirty rap and I know I originally bought this because of Mind Playin Tricks On Me (one of my all time favorite rap songs I can still sing along with this one pretty well)
Im Not A Gentleman is the only other track I can recall at this time but I remember liking the entire album
Again this is 100% a nostalgia pick but I enjoyed it at the time
Pretty sure the slight age difference added to the divergence of albums voted on, and the Primus fans spread out their votes. I gave the debut a hefty amount of points, but that was the only one on my list.

I have one more ranked but it’s one of their most hated albums I think so no chance it makes it
Dan, did you vote for Antipop??
:yes:
Between this revelation and seeing BP vote for Fear of the Dark, I am starting to question the sanity of you youngsters.

In the words of big brother @Pip's Invitation - put the bong down, boys! ;)
 
69 (tie). The Doors – The Doors (328 points)


@Snoopy #5 :headbang:
@Dreaded Marco #10 :headbang:
@jwb #16
@zamboni #16
@Dennis Castro #41
@Pip #42
@Dan Lambskin #46
@BroncoFreak_2K3 #54


The Doors is the debut studio album by the American rock band the Doors, released on January 4, 1967, by Elektra Records. It was recorded in August 1966 at Sunset Sound Recorders, in Hollywood, California, with Paul A. Rothchild serving as producer. The album features the full length version of the band's breakthrough single "Light My Fire" and the lengthy closer "The End" with its Oedipal spoken word section. Various publications, including BBC and Rolling Stone, have named The Doors one of the greatest debut albums of all time.
 
For my own 2

Primus - Pork Soda - Primus sucks so I didn’t really expect any matches but IIRC My Name Is Mud was featured on Beavis and Butthead and that was enough for me to go out and buy it

That’s definitely an all time Primus song (just got to see that live a few weeks ago such an awesome bass line)

Les also broke out Diamondback Sturgeon at that show for the first time in awhile

Mr. Krinkle is another favorite of mine as well as Welcome to this World

Overall a bit of a silly album but I was like 13 at the time so I loved it. Been awhile since I’ve listened all the way through I might have to fire this one up for old times sake

Geto (sic) Boys - We Can’t Be Stopped
Pretty sure they were still Ghetto Boys when I got this in 91. Another one of the first CDs I ever owned (I still remember watching that boombox CD player roll down the conveyor belt at Service Merchandise)

little Lambskin was definitely into all of the dirty rap and I know I originally bought this because of Mind Playin Tricks On Me (one of my all time favorite rap songs I can still sing along with this one pretty well)
Im Not A Gentleman is the only other track I can recall at this time but I remember liking the entire album
Again this is 100% a nostalgia pick but I enjoyed it at the time
Pretty sure the slight age difference added to the divergence of albums voted on, and the Primus fans spread out their votes. I gave the debut a hefty amount of points, but that was the only one on my list.

I have one more ranked but it’s one of their most hated albums I think so no chance it makes it
Dan, did you vote for Antipop??
:yes:
Between this revelation and seeing BP vote for Fear of the Dark, I am starting to question the sanity of you youngsters.

In the words of big brother @Pip's Invitation - put the bong down, boys! ;)
I’ll do a writeup later. I know they were trying to appeal to the Nu Metal crowd and it put a strain on the band but there’s some good stuff
 
69 (tie). Violent Femmes – Violent Femmes (328 points)


@Rand al Thor #3 :headbang:
@Juxtatarot #17
@Psychopav #24
@Nick Vermeil #25
[USER=7586]@landrys hat
#27
@Dr. Octopus #52
@Dreaded Marco #52
@Idiot Boxer #59
@Mt. Man #60
@BrutalPenguin #63


Violent Femmes is the debut album by Violent Femmes. Mostly recorded in July 1982, the album was released by Slash Records on vinyl and on cassette in April 1983, and on CD in 1987, with two extra tracks, "Ugly" and "Gimme the Car".

In 2002, Rhino Records remastered the album, filled out the disc's length with demos and added another disc of live tracks and a radio interview for a 20th anniversary special edition, with liner notes by Michael Azerrad.
 
Last edited:
1,103. Cheap Thrills – Big Brother & The Holding Company

Janis is at her most Janis here. Freak flags are flying.

1,013. Who Are You – The Who

The high points are awesome but the album isn't consistent enough for me to rank. Which ties into my Who hot take that is still to come.

1,080. Tusk - Fleetwood Mac

I finally listened to this in its entirety a few years ago. It was said to be the most expensive album ever made up until that time, but that's not reflected in the sound at all. Did they spend all of it on the title track (with the marching band and all) and cocaine? Many of the Buckingham songs are downright low-fi by his standards, and have a certain charm because of it. But most of the highest points here are the Nicks tunes -- especially Sara, Sisters of the Moon and Angel.

459. Pelican West - Haircut 100

1,062. The Golden Age of Wireless - Thomas Dolby

Holy '80s, kupcho!

701. Vivid – Living Colour

Just saw these guys with Doc Oc. Probably should have considered this, but on any given day I can't decide whether I prefer this album or Time's Up.

1,263. Can't Buy a Thrill – Steely Dan

536. The Royal Scam – Steely Dan

My Steely Dan vote(s) went elsewhere.

1,242. Fly Like an Eagle – Steve Miller Band

Some people call it overproduced, some people call it too mainstream, some people call it BORRRRING (Whoo-woo!), but I speak of the greatness of this album. Between Miller's early work and his mid-70s peak, I couldn't decide on a record of his to put forward.

1,147. When the Pawn... – Fiona Apple

Please tell me he typed out the whole title on his ballot. :laugh:

580. Life - Dope

Much like how BLOCKED_PUNT has never heard of some of my favorite TV shows, I have never heard of this.

1,351. Healing - Todd Rundgren

1,386. Hermit of Mink Hollow – Todd Rundgren

Todd at his most experimental and Todd at his most commercial. Binky celebrates his entire catalog.
Dope is OK. I had their debut that I thought was good

Debonaire is a good song and was featured in some movie I think

They also do a cover of Spin Me Right Round
I don't think they are well known or popular but it's one of the few full albums I've listened to so....I've always liked this one
Oh man is my love for covers stronger than my hate for U2?
not a cover
Oh thank god
 
69 (tie). Violent Femmes – Violent Femmes (328 points)


@Rand al Thor #3
@Juxtatarot #17
@Psycopav #24
@Nick Vermiel #25
@landrys hat #27
@Dr. Octopus #52
@Dreaded Marco #52
@Idiot Boxer #59
@Mt. Man #60
@BrutalPenguin #63


Violent Femmes is the debut album by Violent Femmes. Mostly recorded in July 1982, the album was released by Slash Records on vinyl and on cassette in April 1983, and on CD in 1987, with two extra tracks, "Ugly" and "Gimme the Car".

In 2002, Rhino Records remastered the album, filled out the disc's length with demos and added another disc of live tracks and a radio interview for a 20th anniversary special edition, with liner notes by Michael Azerrad.

Most people had this as a record that was meaningful in their sophomore year in high school. It's bratty enough and deals with high school teachers (no colleges really threaten your permanent record unless you do something pretty drastic), parents (c'mon Dad, gimme the car), and other concerns perfect for a fifteen or sixteen year-old. I came late to that game, so I had this as a sophomore in college. Man was this ever a soundtrack, along with They Might Be Giants and Screeching Weasel, to the spring of that year.
 
69 (tie). The Doors – The Doors (328 points)


@Snoopy #5 :headbang:
@Dreaded Marco #10 :headbang:
@jwb #16
@zamboni #16
@Dennis Castro #41
@Pip #42
@Dan Lambskin #46
@BroncoFreak_2K3 #54


The Doors is the debut studio album by the American rock band the Doors, released on January 4, 1967, by Elektra Records. It was recorded in August 1966 at Sunset Sound Recorders, in Hollywood, California, with Paul A. Rothchild serving as producer. The album features the full length version of the band's breakthrough single "Light My Fire" and the lengthy closer "The End" with its Oedipal spoken word section. Various publications, including BBC and Rolling Stone, have named The Doors one of the greatest debut albums of all time.
A vote for “The Crystal Ship” here.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top