What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dennis Dixon (1 Viewer)

Faust

MVP
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2008/writ...ixon/index.html

Thoughts? Could he rebound back from this injury to be the best QB in this year's class? I like the points made in bold.

The training facility at the University of Oregon looks like the spa at a five-star boutique hotel, if all the guests were between 18 and 23 and the bulk of them weighed more than 300 pounds. The floors are finished oak, the walls smoked glass, the lighting soothingly dim. The 15,000-square-foot complex includes 25 stainless steel massage tables, a pharmacy lit with green neon and examination rooms for a dentist and an ophthalmologist. So many flat-screen televisions hang from the walls that SportsCenter is within constant sight, even during eye exams.

The only screen not tuned to SportsCenter, in fact, is the one broadcasting Dennis Dixon's lower half. It is a Tuesday in mid-March, and Dixon is running on one of three underwater treadmills, each of which is equipped with a pair of submerged cameras. As Dixon runs, he can watch his legs churn on the screen in front of him. Even more remarkable, the NFL can watch too. Tony Fisher, an intern in the football office, stands about five feet from Dixon, recording his every move with a Sony Handycam. Fisher then edits the footage and posts it to Dixon's personal website, dennisdixon10.com, so that NFL coaches, scouts and general managers can monitor the progress of his surgically repaired left knee.

This is rehab, Oregon style, where even a torn ACL can seem glamorous. The Ducks already have more than 300 uniform combinations, lockers with Internet ports and a training facility featured in Interior Design, all thanks to Nike founder and Oregon überbooster Phil Knight. For five months Oregon has deployed its considerable resources to another project: reconstructing the quarterback who was once the nation's best and preparing him for the NFL draft on April 26-27. In a field crowded with intriguing but relatively unknown QB prospects, Dixon is the true wild card -- a known superstar who became a forgotten man.

The week of Nov. 4 started with big plans. Hotel representatives from New Orleans were calling the Oregon football program to get a room count for the national championship game. The school was launching a website for Dixon's Heisman Trophy campaign. None of it was premature. The Ducks were 8-1 and second in the nation, with three winnable games remaining. Dixon, their 6' 4", 205-pound senior quarterback, was the most dynamic dual threat west of Tim Tebow, piling up 230.4 yards passing and 61.0 rushing per game. He was making a serious move up the draft charts.

There was just one kink in the plans. In the fourth quarter of a 35-23 victory over Arizona State on Nov. 3, Dixon ran an option right, kept the ball for an 11-yard gain and was tackled around the legs. He felt his left knee twist but never heard a pop. After a few seconds of screaming, he jumped up and jogged gingerly to the sideline. The crowd at Autzen Stadium let out a relieved roar. Trainers examined the knee and said it was stable. Dixon wanted to go back in, but with the Ducks ahead by 19 the coaches wouldn't let him. Precautionary reasons, they said.

An MRI taken the next day revealed that Dixon's left ACL was three-quarters torn. "I was shocked," said Oregon head trainer Kevin Steil. Dixon could still run and cut. The swelling was minimal. Dixon didn't understand why he didn't show more symptoms. Steil consulted three doctors, who presented Dixon with two options: He could have surgery immediately, or he could postpone it and try to play on the knee. Coach Mike Bellotti made his position clear to the QB: "It's not in your best interest to play for us anymore."

For a young football star, it seemed the ultimate dilemma: Give up a shot at the Heisman and a national championship, or suit up and jeopardize your future draft status. Four months later, over dinner in Eugene, Dixon thought back on his decision to keep playing and said, "It really wasn't so hard."

Practicing with the injury was easy; keeping it a secret was not. Outside of coaches, trainers and doctors, no one knew the results of Dixon's MRI. He did not tell his teammates, his roommates, even his father. "I didn't want anybody to panic," he says.

On Nov. 15, Oregon played a Thursday night game at Arizona, a nationally televised showcase for Dixon and the Ducks. Before the kickoff Dennis Dixon Sr. visited his son in the locker room and found him stretched out on a massage table. "Dad, I've been keeping something from you," Dixon said. His father laughed. "No you haven't," he said. "I could tell you were hurt."

Trainers fitted Dixon for a knee brace, and coaches devised a game plan to keep him in the pocket as much as possible. "We were holding our breath," said trainer Kim Terrell. On the game's first series Dixon scrapped the plan and ran 39 yards for a touchdown. The medical staff exhaled. But later in the first quarter Dixon faked a handoff, rolled left and planted his left foot in the turf. The foot stuck. The knee buckled. He went down without being touched. The ACL was completely shot. "It was like someone punched you in the stomach," said James Harris, Oregon's director of sports nutrition. "And as soon as you started to breathe, someone punched you in the stomach again."

The Heisman was gone. So was the national title. Dixon would not play another down for Oregon; the Ducks lost to Arizona and then dropped their final two regular-season games. Dennis's father rushed from the stands to the field, and when he got there, his son's first words were, "I don't regret a thing." As Terrell helped Dixon off the field, he asked her, "Did you see my touchdown?" Then: "When do we start rehab?"

It started that night. Dixon's mother, Jueretta, had died of breast cancer the summer after his senior year at San Leandro (Calif.) High, and Dennis's father didn't know if his son would be able to get on a plane for Eugene. Sitting in an otherwise silent visitors' locker room at Arizona, he reminded Dennis, "This can't be worse than losing your mom." With that, Dixon walked back onto the field and put on a headset, Oregon's new assistant quarterbacks coach.

Because he wanted to travel with the team, Dixon didn't have surgery until Dec. 15. Two days later he was walking without crutches. After five days he was riding a bike. In two weeks he was throwing, and a month after that, he was running. Day after day, as Dixon lay on a massage table in the training center, Terrell tested the knee's range of motion and Dixon watched the myriad televisions tuned to ESPN. The draftniks didn't mention him as they talked about other quarterbacks -- Matt Ryan, Brian Brohm, Chad Henne -- whom he had outplayed for 2 1/2 months.

Agent pitches to potential draftees are often superficial, all about dropping names and promises. Jeff Sperbeck of Octagon went to Dixon in early January with a concrete proposal. He wanted to turn Dixon's dormant Heisman website into a platform to broadcast his rehab. The site would rebuild Dixon's image as trainers rebuilt his knee. He wouldn't be ready to work out in February at the NFL combine or in March on Oregon's pro day, but the Internet could help persuade skeptical NFL general managers that Dixon was still worth drafting.

The plan appealed to Dixon's taste for transparency. "Besides," he says, "I don't mind the spotlight." Oregon, with its sophisticated approach to marketing and technology, offered the perfect backdrop. Terrell would explain Dixon's regimen. Offensive coordinator Chip Kelly would put him through drills and film study. Fisher would record his progress and edit, with Sperbeck's help. Kyle Wiest, an assistant in the football office, would update the site. Says Fisher, "Nobody had done anything like it."

Dixon, who graduated last June with a sociology degree and a 3.27 GPA, has full access to the training center. When he arrives daily at 9 a.m., Harris has a creatine shake waiting for him. When he leaves, as late as 5 p.m., Harris has another shake ready -- chocolate milk with glutamine and whey protein. "We would do this for any of our former players," says director of football operations Jeff Hawkins. "But Dennis is special. We owe it to him."

Before the website's launch in mid-February, Sperbeck e-mailed the link to more than 100 NFL general managers, personnel directors and coaches. Oakland Raiders offensive coordinator Greg Knapp shot back a reply: "I wish everyone had this." Nevertheless, when Dixon attended the combine later that month to participate in interviews, some G.M.'s were surprised that he wasn't on crutches and weren't aware he had begun throwing. "Look at my site," Dixon pleaded. "Just look at it."

When Fisher started filming workouts in mid-February, Dixon could barely drop back. By mid-March he was shuffling from side to side in the pocket, lofting 60-yard fly patterns to former Ducks teammates Jordan Kent (now with the Seahawks) and Cameron Colvin and firing 15-yard slants to roommate Leon Murry. After one of Dixon's passes hit Murry in the ribs, the receiver collapsed in a heap, gasping, "My lungs!"

Dixon played outfield in the Atlanta Braves system last summer and was a finalist last fall for the Draddy Trophy, given to the top scholar in college football. In other words, he has options outside of football. But no QB in this draft has longer arms (36.25 inches) or bigger hands (9.75-inch span) or a faster 40 time (4.49 seconds last year at Oregon). When Dixon was a junior, Bellotti told him he was a better prospect than Vince Young. And that was before Dixon completed 67.7% of his passes in 2007, with 20 touchdowns and just four interceptions. Mike Mayock, the NFL Network's draft expert, believes Dixon is a better passer than Young but not as explosive a runner. He projects Dixon as a fourth-round pick. Asked where Dixon would have been drafted if he hadn't been injured, Mayock said, "Who knows?"

Last Thursday, when Dixon walked to the 50-yard line at Oregon's indoor practice facility, 10 NFL scouts stood in a line, beneath a banner that read blitz this. They had come to witness the rebirth of Dennis Dixon.

Most potential draft picks have multiple opportunities to impress. For Dixon, this was the Senior Bowl, the combine and pro day rolled into one -- the first time he was throwing for an audience since that Arizona game. Fisher stood with the scouts, his Handycam rolling. The sideline was packed with people who'd hastened Dixon's recovery -- doctors, trainers, coaches, staffers and, of course, his father. No one spoke above a whisper.

Dixon threw every kind of pass, even the Hail Mary. He missed a few. He favored his knee a little. But at the end Jeff Horton, a St. Louis Rams offensive assistant, was shaking his head in admiration. "This guy had surgery three-and-a-half months ago, and you see him here today -- his arm strength, his mobility," said Horton. "I think he helped himself a lot."

A few scouts playfully asked Oregon coaches not to send video of the workout to other teams. But Fisher was already hustling up to his office with his Handycam, ready to download and edit the new footage. By nightfall it was online.

 
Always liked the guy and thought he was one of the best in college. He was the stud in that offense, not Stewart. I think Stewart is an amazing talent, but he was able to do alot of what he did because Dixon was such a threat. Just not sure how Dixon's skills will translate to the NFL.

I sure hope he does well though.

 
Good read - It'll be interesting to see which team picks him and where... I'd personally like to see Minnesota grab him. Great fit for the future IMO.

 
That's a pretty incredible story and an amazing recovery from an ACL tear. Im sure the kid will be drafted before atleast the end of the 5th round, later than he would have hoped. But Im sure at some point he's going to get his shot to be a difference maker. I wouldnt mind seeing him get picked up by NE and sit behind Brady for a couple of years. He's got some pretty skinny legs. So not only does he need to fully recover from that tear. He really needs to bulk up in the legs and probably add about 20lbs.

 
twitch said:
That's a pretty incredible story and an amazing recovery from an ACL tear. Im sure the kid will be drafted before atleast the end of the 5th round, later than he would have hoped. But Im sure at some point he's going to get his shot to be a difference maker. I wouldnt mind seeing him get picked up by NE and sit behind Brady for a couple of years. He's got some pretty skinny legs. So not only does he need to fully recover from that tear. He really needs to bulk up in the legs and probably add about 20lbs.
and learn to take snaps from behind center learn to be a pocket passer, learn to read defenses, and become a better passer. Remember two years ago he couldn't beat out Brady Leaf for the starting job in an offense perfect for him and not a good fit at all for Leaf.
 
That's a pretty incredible story and an amazing recovery from an ACL tear. Im sure the kid will be drafted before atleast the end of the 5th round, later than he would have hoped. But Im sure at some point he's going to get his shot to be a difference maker. I wouldnt mind seeing him get picked up by NE and sit behind Brady for a couple of years. He's got some pretty skinny legs. So not only does he need to fully recover from that tear. He really needs to bulk up in the legs and probably add about 20lbs.
:lmao: I also think that falling to the later rounds is great motivation for a player to "prove that they made a mistake" in passing him over - and this scenario would give him a chance to fully recover to play behind somebody for a few years.
 
Dixon was probably my favorite player to watch last year in college football up until he tore his ACL. He lit up Michigan in the Big House. Unfortunately, so did Dexter Jackson, among others. It would be a shame if he doesn't get a shot to play QB in the NFL. I think there will be a few teams willing to give him that chance though. He's an excellent buy low prospect for dynasty leaguers.

 
No pity party for former Oregon star

By Michael Silver, Yahoo! Sports 3 hours, 5 minutes ago

SPRINGFIELD, Ore. – The 2008 NFL draft was less than 15 minutes old when Dennis Dixon, a young man once projected to be one of its most conspicuous selections, decided it was all too much to bear.

Shaking his head in disgust, the former Oregon quarterback fled the bachelor pad he rents near campus to collect his thoughts alone.

“I don’t even want to look at this,” Dixon said Saturday afternoon before opening a sliding glass door and stepping into the backyard. “I mean, it’s just mind-boggling.”

Left behind on an old-school big screen television in Dixon’s living room was a tight shot of Boston College quarterback Matt Ryan in the green room of Radio City Music Hall in New York City. The Atlanta Falcons were about to choose Ryan with the No. 3 overall pick, making him a soon-to-be-multi-millionaire and essentially entrusting him to displace Michael Vick as the face of the franchise.

ADVERTISEMENT

Across the continent Dixon, who six months ago had emerged as the best college football player in America, spent a few minutes pacing aimlessly on his surgically repaired left knee while waiting to go to Oregon’s spring football game. His return to Autzen Stadium would allow him to socialize with ex-teammates and coaches, but its larger purpose was to take his mind off the draft on a day he knew he’d almost certainly be ignored.

Later Saturday, a couple dozen friends and family members were due to descend on the rented house to hang out and enjoy the meat-filled feast prepared by Dixon’s father, Dennis Sr. This was shaping up as a classic pity party. But, to his credit, the younger Dixon wouldn’t allow it. His smile returned shortly after Ryan’s selection reminded him of what might have been, and even as quarterbacks Joe Flacco, Brian Brohm and Chad Henne left the board, Dixon stayed upbeat and philosophical.

“Trust me,” Dixon Sr. said Saturday evening, “my son has this all in perspective.”

When you say goodbye to your mother at age 20 – when your voice is the last thing she hears as she dies in your father’s arms – perspective is not a subtle sensation. You can lose what seemed to be a clear path to a Heisman Trophy, a national championship and the prospect of guaranteed millions and spin it as yet another challenge, an opportunity for your competitive fire to burn more intensely than the brightest of draft-podium spotlights.

And as the first day of the draft passes without your name being called, you can bite your lip and remind yourself that the sun will come out tomorrow.

Sometime Sunday morning, Dixon hopes, a franchise will take a chance on him and make him the fifth or sixth or seventh or eighth quarterback selected. He has no idea which team that might be, and he’s not particularly consumed with wondering where he’ll end up. Unlike Ryan or former Ducks teammate Jonathan Stewart (the running back who went 13th overall to the Carolina Panthers) or the other players who got plucked off the board in Saturday’s first two rounds, Dixon doesn’t have the luxury of weighing the benefits of certain situations against others in visualizing his ideal rookie season.

He simply seeks the chance to make somebody’s team.

“All I want is an opportunity,” Dixon said Saturday. “Those other guys are getting the money right now, but tell me who’ll ultimately be getting it done on the field, and that means a lot more to me. As a little kid, I always dreamt of being a professional in the National Football League. Now it’s here. I just want to have that opportunity, one way or the other.”

As a 6-foot-4, 205-pounder with a good arm, excellent mobility and obvious leadership skills, Dixon remains an enticing option for a team looking to develop a young quarterback for a future shot at a starting job. Since undergoing reconstructive knee surgery after tearing his ACL last November – partially in a 35-23 victory over Arizona State that vaulted Oregon to a No. 2 national ranking, and completely in a Nov. 15 defeat to Arizona in which everything fell apart – Dixon has made a promising recovery, one he and his agent, Jeff Sperbeck, wisely documented in real time on an Oregon-sponsored website.

Realistically, Dixon is a player who seems destined to spend 2008 sitting and learning, preparing for a shot in 2009 or beyond. Even before his injury, some scouts viewed Dixon’s success as a product of the spread offense and believed he’d need to adapt to running a pro-style offense to have a shot at making it in the NFL.

Dixon is confident that he’ll pull it off. Then again, by the most ingrained of standards, he knows he has already made it in a much grander context.

“In our household, it was all about education,” says Dixon’s younger sister, Danitra, who works as a clothing buyer in Los Angeles. “It was school before play, and that was definitely no joke.”

An excellent student at San Leandro High School in the San Francisco Bay Area, Dixon completed his sociology degree at Oregon last June after just 3½ years on campus. In the fall he was a finalist for the Draddy Trophy, given to the top scholar in college football.

He says his mother, Jueretta, who died in February 2004 after a long battle with breast cancer, was the inspiration for his academic success.

“My dad had me in numerous sports,” Dixon says. “I played anything with a ball. My mom was really the one who stayed on me as far as my grades. One of my goals was to earn my college degree and to finish early, and I did. I think she would be proud of me.”

Another thing Jueretta passed on to her son was a streak of relentless optimism. She concealed her illness from her children for as long as she could because she feared it would cause them to lose focus on their academic achievements. Even when her condition worsened and she knew the end was near, Jueretta refused to mope in front of Dennis.

Partially paralyzed by a stroke shortly before Christmas 2003, Jueretta’s mood brightened a few weeks later when Dennis flew home from Eugene.

“She was sitting in a wheelchair in the middle of the living room,” Dennis Sr. recalls of his wife, whom he had started dating in high school, 37 years earlier. “When he walked in that door, she lit up like a Christmas tree.”

He stayed the weekend, and before returning to school, Dixon understood that he almost certainly wouldn’t see his mother again. “I actually got a chance to say goodbye,” he recalls, but this was no maudlin scene out of a Hollywood movie.

“We pretty much just talked and giggled the whole time,” he says. “I was just joking with her, showing her this tattoo on my arm that says ‘I’ll Holler’ and which always used to make her laugh. Even in that moment, she was real positive.”

Dixon, who took one of the family’s cars back to school, saved his tears for the drive to Eugene, checking in every two hours by phone. Less than a week later he called to talk to Jueretta, who was preparing to go to a chemotherapy appointment. His father answered the phone.

“Fifteen minutes earlier she had looked at me and said, ‘Dennis, take me to the water,’ ” Dixon Sr. recalls. “She was already at peace, and I knew it. Dennis called at exactly 11 o’clock, and I held her as I put the phone to her ear. She heard his voice and, in another second, she was gone.”

At Jueretta’s funeral, her son vowed to a packed church that he would honor his mother by achieving the academic goals she’d helped instill. Dixon delivered in the classroom and thrived on the football field, becoming a popular and inspirational presence on a talented team that faded after he suffered the season-ending injury.

He remains very much at home in his familiar collegiate environment, as Saturday’s visit to the spring game in Autzen showed. Clad in a loose polka-dotted tie and black dress shirt while casually roaming the sidelines, Dixon was the life of the party. He slapped hands and swapped stories with current and former Ducks, many of whom would come to his house later that evening, and was especially animated when current Oregon quarterback Justin Roper completed his first pass for a 67-yard gain.

Dixon also went upstairs to work a luxury box full of influential alums, including Nike chieftain Phil Knight.

“When he calls,” Dixon said, laughing, “you go.”

Wherever Dixon goes in the draft Sunday – or, in a worst-case scenario, if he doesn’t get picked and is forced to scramble for a free-agent deal – he knows he has already achieved something far more valuable than the millions which might have been.

“I wish my mom would’ve been here to see this,” he said, a few minutes after Saturday’s second round expired and the no-pity party began in earnest. “I wish she could’ve seen her young boy grow up to be a young man, humbled and driven and focused on the task at hand.”

Dixon looked down at the iPhone clipped to his jeans, a Bluetooth headset in his right ear. The call he was waiting for still hadn’t come.

But make no mistake – the kid is already a pro.

 
I hope my Jags can get him in the 5th. They can IR him for 2008 and run with Garrard and Cleo Lemon. By 2010 they might have a quality young QB at a cheap price. Jacksonville would be a good situation for him with no real pressure for at least 2/3 season.

 
That's a pretty incredible story and an amazing recovery from an ACL tear. Im sure the kid will be drafted before atleast the end of the 5th round, later than he would have hoped. But Im sure at some point he's going to get his shot to be a difference maker. I wouldnt mind seeing him get picked up by NE and sit behind Brady for a couple of years. He's got some pretty skinny legs. So not only does he need to fully recover from that tear. He really needs to bulk up in the legs and probably add about 20lbs.
and learn to take snaps from behind center learn to be a pocket passer, learn to read defenses, and become a better passer. Remember two years ago he couldn't beat out Brady Leaf for the starting job in an offense perfect for him and not a good fit at all for Leaf.
We have a winner!!! :thumbup:
 
Pittsburgh was a great place to land - he will have time to rehab his injury further and won't be rushed into the line-up

I find it easy to root for this guy

 
Pittsburgh was a great place to land - he will have time to rehab his injury further and won't be rushed into the line-upI find it easy to root for this guy
Great if he wants to hold a clipboard.I like Dixon too, but given that the Squealers (sorry, Browns Fan, old habits and all) just paid Knievelberger 197 bajillion dollars I wouldn't hold my breath on him seeing much action in a black hat anytime soon. (and by soon I mean ever)
 
Pittsburgh was a great place to land - he will have time to rehab his injury further and won't be rushed into the line-upI find it easy to root for this guy
Great if he wants to hold a clipboard.I like Dixon too, but given that the Squealers (sorry, Browns Fan, old habits and all) just paid Knievelberger 197 bajillion dollars I wouldn't hold my breath on him seeing much action in a black hat anytime soon. (and by soon I mean ever)
Injuries happen all the time so you never know, just ask Dixon.
 
Wonderful article. SLASH part 3 couldn't have asked for a better situation to be drafted into. If anyone knows how to get some use out of him this is where. I am sure when healthy they will find ways to get him involved. Not necessary QB ing.

 
That's a pretty incredible story and an amazing recovery from an ACL tear. Im sure the kid will be drafted before atleast the end of the 5th round, later than he would have hoped. But Im sure at some point he's going to get his shot to be a difference maker. I wouldnt mind seeing him get picked up by NE and sit behind Brady for a couple of years. He's got some pretty skinny legs. So not only does he need to fully recover from that tear. He really needs to bulk up in the legs and probably add about 20lbs.
and learn to take snaps from behind center learn to be a pocket passer, learn to read defenses, and become a better passer. Remember two years ago he couldn't beat out Brady Leaf for the starting job in an offense perfect for him and not a good fit at all for Leaf.
And Tom Brady couldn't beat out Brian Griese...and then shared time with Drew Henson.NFL.com analysis: Prior to his injury, he led the Pac-10 in passing efficiency by completing 172-of-254 passes (67.7%) for 2,136 yards and 20 touchdowns with just four interceptions. Demonstrates very good balance and body control driving back from center...Quick and decisive, making good progression reads...Has worked on becoming more compact with his over-the-top delivery, showing a quicker release than he did in the past...Steps into his throws better and his compact, natural release has greatly reduced turnover totals...Has the functional arm strength to make all the throws...Can fire the ball into tight areas and showed in 2007 that he can unleash the deep ball without having to wind up like he did in the past...Looks to have much better velocity and zip on the ball after refining his release point as a senior and it is now rare to see his targets having to adjust
 
Pittsburgh was a great place to land - he will have time to rehab his injury further and won't be rushed into the line-upI find it easy to root for this guy
Great if he wants to hold a clipboard.I like Dixon too, but given that the Squealers (sorry, Browns Fan, old habits and all) just paid Knievelberger 197 bajillion dollars I wouldn't hold my breath on him seeing much action in a black hat anytime soon. (and by soon I mean ever)
He would likely have been holding a clipboard for a couple of years no matter where he went, he's way too raw to step in and play any time soon at the NFL level. It was probably a good landing spot for him because although he won't be the starting QB any time soon, Pittsburgh is pretty well known for getting guys like Dixon on the field in a variety of ways. Expect to see him play WR early in his career and serve as the #3 QB as well.
 
Did anyone watch the Steelers game? How did he look?

I found this observation from CBS Sportsline ( interview with Arians )

http://fantasynews.sportsline.com/fantasyf.../story/10916468

And just to do some due diligence on behalf of our dynasty league owners, could you tell me about how rookie quarterback Dennis Dixon has looked early on?

Arians: I've been real pleased. Dennis is a very conscientious, hard-working kid who has been hurt in his development by the style of offense he played in. They're great in college, but when those fast quarterbacks come out against fast defenses, they don't get to run anymore. It's just a matter of calling plays, taking snaps from center and handing them off, typical fundamentals that a lot of these kids coming out of spread offenses never do. We had a kid, Omar Jacobs, a couple of years ago who may have never called a play in the huddle. A coach would signal the play in from the sideline, and he'd never use a snap count, it was a silent count. Just the minute details of playing quarterback. Dennis has worked extremely hard. He's got a real good arm, he needs to continue to work on his accuracy when he has to slide in the pocket. I think this kid is a heck of a talent. It's gonna take some time.

 
QB Dennis Dixon deserves first-team reps

By James Walker

The Pittsburgh Steelers have fewer than three weeks before their regular-season opener against the Atlanta Falcons. Therefore, it's now or never for quarterback Dennis Dixon to share first-team reps with Byron Leftwich.

Pittsburgh is in a unique situation with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger due to serve a conditional six-game suspension. But if the Steelers are truly holding an "open" competition to replace Roethlisberger -- which is often debated in Pittsburgh -- it's confusing that Dixon spent this offseason and training camp working with backups and, in some cases, players who won't make the team. The Steelers simply could have named Leftwich the starter months ago and moved forward.

Dixon has been stellar in the preseason, completing 13 of 15 passes for 210 yards in two games. There is no reason to get overly excited about Dixon playing well against opposing backups. But his performance should be enough to spark the Steelers' curiosity to see what he can do against a first-team defense.

But based on the past few months, there is no guarantee that will be the case. It's also unlikely Dixon suddenly will get promoted in Week 1 with little or no work with the starters. So everyone should know within the next week or two if Dixon is truly in the running.

Is Dixon the best option for Pittsburgh at quarterback? It's too early to say.

But in our opinion, Dixon deserves an opportunity.

 
QB Dennis Dixon deserves first-team reps

By James Walker

The Pittsburgh Steelers have fewer than three weeks before their regular-season opener against the Atlanta Falcons. Therefore, it's now or never for quarterback Dennis Dixon to share first-team reps with Byron Leftwich.

Pittsburgh is in a unique situation with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger due to serve a conditional six-game suspension. But if the Steelers are truly holding an "open" competition to replace Roethlisberger -- which is often debated in Pittsburgh -- it's confusing that Dixon spent this offseason and training camp working with backups and, in some cases, players who won't make the team. The Steelers simply could have named Leftwich the starter months ago and moved forward.

Dixon has been stellar in the preseason, completing 13 of 15 passes for 210 yards in two games. There is no reason to get overly excited about Dixon playing well against opposing backups. But his performance should be enough to spark the Steelers' curiosity to see what he can do against a first-team defense.

But based on the past few months, there is no guarantee that will be the case. It's also unlikely Dixon suddenly will get promoted in Week 1 with little or no work with the starters. So everyone should know within the next week or two if Dixon is truly in the running.

Is Dixon the best option for Pittsburgh at quarterback? It's too early to say.

But in our opinion, Dixon deserves an opportunity.
Dixon is the best option for the Steelers to WIN games in Big Ben's absence. I said this months ago, Dixon should be the starter during this stretch. Leftwich is a statue with a telegraphed delivery, recipe for disaster once the real bullets start to fly. Dixon would present matchup problems for DCs as he can wreck a well-conceived blitz plan for big plays, scoring plays. With Pittsburgh's o-line not the greatest strength of the team, a mobile, athletic, play-making QB would serve them well. They could design a game plan (formula) similar to what the Titans run with VY and CJ2k. The stretch plays with bootleg action would be the staple of the offense and something that would put defenses on their heels. With Leftwich under center, defenses will be on the attack.
 
QB Dennis Dixon deserves first-team reps

By James Walker

The Pittsburgh Steelers have fewer than three weeks before their regular-season opener against the Atlanta Falcons. Therefore, it's now or never for quarterback Dennis Dixon to share first-team reps with Byron Leftwich.

Pittsburgh is in a unique situation with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger due to serve a conditional six-game suspension. But if the Steelers are truly holding an "open" competition to replace Roethlisberger -- which is often debated in Pittsburgh -- it's confusing that Dixon spent this offseason and training camp working with backups and, in some cases, players who won't make the team. The Steelers simply could have named Leftwich the starter months ago and moved forward.

Dixon has been stellar in the preseason, completing 13 of 15 passes for 210 yards in two games. There is no reason to get overly excited about Dixon playing well against opposing backups. But his performance should be enough to spark the Steelers' curiosity to see what he can do against a first-team defense.

But based on the past few months, there is no guarantee that will be the case. It's also unlikely Dixon suddenly will get promoted in Week 1 with little or no work with the starters. So everyone should know within the next week or two if Dixon is truly in the running.

Is Dixon the best option for Pittsburgh at quarterback? It's too early to say.

But in our opinion, Dixon deserves an opportunity.
Dixon is the best option for the Steelers to WIN games in Big Ben's absence. I said this months ago, Dixon should be the starter during this stretch. Leftwich is a statue with a telegraphed delivery, recipe for disaster once the real bullets start to fly. Dixon would present matchup problems for DCs as he can wreck a well-conceived blitz plan for big plays, scoring plays. With Pittsburgh's o-line not the greatest strength of the team, a mobile, athletic, play-making QB would serve them well. They could design a game plan (formula) similar to what the Titans run with VY and CJ2k. The stretch plays with bootleg action would be the staple of the offense and something that would put defenses on their heels. With Leftwich under center, defenses will be on the attack.
Dixon is a total enigma. HE went to Michigan and destroyed them (back when MICH was good.) The guy can play but the NFL is about politics sometimes as much as ability. Who knows what is going on behind the scenes but they maybe dont think he is mature enough for the burden. They will be forced to play him though by week 3.
 
Leftwich is Tim Tebow only Tebow took the time and worked his butt off to change his throwing motion to adjust to NFL playing. Lefty has maybe the slowest deleivery I ever saw.. But the first 6 games Wallace value takes a decent hit :hot: Ward will likey be his go to guy being the vet and the short pattern dump off guy. Also hurts Mendy a little as Dixon I could see stealing a few scores as well.

 
QB Dennis Dixon deserves first-team reps

By James Walker

The Pittsburgh Steelers have fewer than three weeks before their regular-season opener against the Atlanta Falcons. Therefore, it's now or never for quarterback Dennis Dixon to share first-team reps with Byron Leftwich.

Pittsburgh is in a unique situation with quarterback Ben Roethlisberger due to serve a conditional six-game suspension. But if the Steelers are truly holding an "open" competition to replace Roethlisberger -- which is often debated in Pittsburgh -- it's confusing that Dixon spent this offseason and training camp working with backups and, in some cases, players who won't make the team. The Steelers simply could have named Leftwich the starter months ago and moved forward.

Dixon has been stellar in the preseason, completing 13 of 15 passes for 210 yards in two games. There is no reason to get overly excited about Dixon playing well against opposing backups. But his performance should be enough to spark the Steelers' curiosity to see what he can do against a first-team defense.

But based on the past few months, there is no guarantee that will be the case. It's also unlikely Dixon suddenly will get promoted in Week 1 with little or no work with the starters. So everyone should know within the next week or two if Dixon is truly in the running.

Is Dixon the best option for Pittsburgh at quarterback? It's too early to say.

But in our opinion, Dixon deserves an opportunity.
Everyone has an opinion but the only one that counts is the coaching staff of the Steelers. That organization has won 6 SB's, it would be MY OPINION to back them in evaluating and determining who they want as the QB for the first 4 games of the season. They are seeing the QB's play everyday and they are professionals at their craft. Many Steeler fans are quick to back their organization when it comes to how this team has been run over the years, I'm surprised there's not a little more general faith in the Steeler coaching staff to determine who's best for the team.

In the end, both of these guys really aren't that good, they're OK at best. Don't get mad at your coaching staff, point figures at Big Ben, he is the only reason he's not out there leading this team. Don't get caught up in "Oh, this team would have been better if Dixon would have been out there instead of Leftwich." That's all crap, the team would have been better with Ben Rothlesberger out there. There's no time for development for Dixon, Big Ben is coming back week 6 so this is not a situation to grow in, it's who can win out of the gate, not who will be a better QB with a little playing time under his belt. I'll support who the coaches decide to start and not boo and complain about their decision, because after all, it isn't them who created this situation, it's Big Ben.

 
Everyone has an opinion but the only one that counts is the coaching staff of the Steelers. That organization has won 6 SB's, it would be MY OPINION to back them in evaluating and determining who they want as the QB for the first 4 games of the season. They are seeing the QB's play everyday and they are professionals at their craft. Many Steeler fans are quick to back their organization when it comes to how this team has been run over the years, I'm surprised there's not a little more general faith in the Steeler coaching staff to determine who's best for the team.
I agree this part. The Steelers are going to play the QB they think gives them the best chance to win. So far Dixon has looked great but it is only preseason and he is playing against backups. It is nice to play well in preseason but it doesn't necessarily carry over into the regular season when opposiong defenses actually game-plan and you are playing against starters. Right now defenses are pretty vanilla and Dixon isn't being asked to read defenses much or audible, etc. These are critical aspects of the game.If the Steelers believe that Leftwich gives them a better chance to win the first four games then I'll go with it. I do think Dixon may have opened the coaching staff's eyes to the possibility of bringing him on occasion as a change of pace to Leftwich though.
 
My opinion: The Steelers plan on a loose platooning of QBs for the first 4-6 weeks, but don't want to tip their hand. Lefty will be the starter, but Dixon will get 2-4 series per game. The Falcons will be surprised by this and the Steelers will use it to their advantage. The remaining 3 teams on the opening schedule will have to prepare for 2 different QBs with 2 different skill sets.

 
It's a tough call because each QB brings things the other doesn't. Leftwich is slow as a glacier, but as proven against the Giants, he can make a play with his feet occasionally by following his blocking and also is much better at reading defenses and is much more accurate than Dixon. The toss to Wallace for the 68 yard TD against the Giants was thrown about as perfectly as you can throw a deep ball - it practically tucked itself into Wallace's arms. Leftwich throws the ball vertically even better than Roethlisberger does.

Dixon, on the other hand, may be 12 for 14 thus far, but is making a lot of dump-off throws and check downs and otherwise making plays with his feet. They use a different set of plays when Dixon plays, it's much more of a dink-and-dunk offense rife with option plays that allow Dixon to make a quick read and take off if necessary. The problem with this is that while he's doing a great job of executing it vs 2nd and 3rd team defenses, it may not work consistently against starters. And if they manage to shut down the option plays and force him to stay at home and make plays down the field with his arm, I fear there will be more turnovers than touchdowns.

I'm pretty sure that's the Steelers' concern at this point as well. If forced to go through his reads and throw away from coverage rather than simply playing instinctively and being able to scramble and/or make easy throws on almost every play, that the offense will stall and/or cough the ball up too much. I think they're more comfortable playing a guy like Leftwich, who is going to take a bunch of sacks, but also will protect the football and not put the defense in horrible spots too often. With a defense like the Steelers have, they don't need to score 30 points a game to win games, so I think they're more comfortable having Lefty go out there and score 20 ppg and play field position and rely on the D to keep them in games.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's a tough call because each QB brings things the other doesn't. Leftwich is slow as a glacier, but as proven against the Giants, he can make a play with his feet occasionally by following his blocking and also is much better at reading defenses and is much more accurate than Dixon. The toss to Wallace for the 68 yard TD against the Giants was thrown about as perfectly as you can throw a deep ball - it practically tucked itself into Wallace's arms. Leftwich throws the ball vertically even better than Roethlisberger does.Dixon, on the other hand, may be 12 for 14 thus far, but is making a lot of dump-off throws and check downs and otherwise making plays with his feet. They use a different set of plays when Dixon plays, it's much more of a dink-and-dunk offense rife with option plays that allow Dixon to make a quick read and take off if necessary. The problem with this is that while he's doing a great job of executing it vs 2nd and 3rd team defenses, it may not work consistently against starters. And if they manage to shut down the option plays and force him to stay at home and make plays down the field with his arm, I fear there will be more turnovers than touchdowns.I'm pretty sure that's the Steelers' concern at this point as well. If forced to go through his reads and throw away from coverage rather than simply playing instinctively and being able to scramble and/or make easy throws on almost every play, that the offense will stall and/or cough the ball up too much. I think they're more comfortable playing a guy like Leftwich, who is going to take a bunch of sacks, but also will protect the football and not put the defense in horrible spots too often. With a defense like the Steelers have, they don't need to score 30 points a game to win games, so I think they're more comfortable having Lefty go out there and score 20 ppg and play field position and rely on the D to keep them in games.
I recall this certain Dixon playing very admirably vs the Ravens last season in his 1st career NFL start. Once teams see lead-foot Leftwich under center, it'll be hunting season with a myriad of blitzes.......I say the offense will be hard-pressed to keep drives alive with Leftwich, who may deliver an occassional great long ball, but the key thing will be having the time to sit back in the pocket and deliver it. Pocket passers who hold onto the ball too long are the easiest guys in the NFL to prepare for and contain. I'm not a Steelers fan, but just an observer of the situation here. If I were an opponent, I would love to see #4 trotting out there instead of #10. Dixon is a winner, and an underrated talent who is a future starter in this league, mark my words. He could be starting on a number of teams right now if he wasn't behind Big Ben. Leftwich is an emergency QB at this point, and with Dixon on board, there should not be an emergency call necessary.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's a tough call because each QB brings things the other doesn't. Leftwich is slow as a glacier, but as proven against the Giants, he can make a play with his feet occasionally by following his blocking and also is much better at reading defenses and is much more accurate than Dixon. The toss to Wallace for the 68 yard TD against the Giants was thrown about as perfectly as you can throw a deep ball - it practically tucked itself into Wallace's arms. Leftwich throws the ball vertically even better than Roethlisberger does.Dixon, on the other hand, may be 12 for 14 thus far, but is making a lot of dump-off throws and check downs and otherwise making plays with his feet. They use a different set of plays when Dixon plays, it's much more of a dink-and-dunk offense rife with option plays that allow Dixon to make a quick read and take off if necessary. The problem with this is that while he's doing a great job of executing it vs 2nd and 3rd team defenses, it may not work consistently against starters. And if they manage to shut down the option plays and force him to stay at home and make plays down the field with his arm, I fear there will be more turnovers than touchdowns.I'm pretty sure that's the Steelers' concern at this point as well. If forced to go through his reads and throw away from coverage rather than simply playing instinctively and being able to scramble and/or make easy throws on almost every play, that the offense will stall and/or cough the ball up too much. I think they're more comfortable playing a guy like Leftwich, who is going to take a bunch of sacks, but also will protect the football and not put the defense in horrible spots too often. With a defense like the Steelers have, they don't need to score 30 points a game to win games, so I think they're more comfortable having Lefty go out there and score 20 ppg and play field position and rely on the D to keep them in games.
I recall this certain Dixon playing very admirably vs the Ravens last season in his 1st career NFL start. Once teams see lead-foot Leftwich under center, it'll be hunting season with a myriad of blitzes.......I say the offense will be hard-pressed to keep drives alive with Leftwich, who may deliver an occassional great long ball, but the key thing will be having the time to sit back in the pocket and deliver it. Pocket passers who hold onto the ball too long are the easiest guys in the NFL to prepare for and contain. I'm not a Steelers fan, but just an observer of the situation here. If I were an opponent, I would love to see #4 trotting out there instead of #10. Dixon is a winner, and an underrated talent who is a future starter in this league, mark my words. Leftwich is an emergency QB at this point, and with Dixon on board, there should not be an emergency call necessary.
Dixon did get them to overtime at Baltimore, but he was also 12-26 on the game and threw the game away with a bad INT after the Steelers had the ball with a chance to win the game. That's what you get with Dixon, he's a guy that can move the chains effectively with his mix of skills, but he can also kill you in the clutch due to a lack of experience/accuracy. The key is measuring the risk/reward you get with Dixon vs. the consistency of Leftwich. I have a feeling that if the Steelers' D is porous as it was at times last year w/o Polamalu and Smith, and they need to switch to a more high-octane offense, you'll see a lot more Dixon. If the defense is stout and only allowing 11 points a game as they did in the 2008 season, you'll see the steadier Leftwich out there.
 
It's a tough call because each QB brings things the other doesn't. Leftwich is slow as a glacier, but as proven against the Giants, he can make a play with his feet occasionally by following his blocking and also is much better at reading defenses and is much more accurate than Dixon. The toss to Wallace for the 68 yard TD against the Giants was thrown about as perfectly as you can throw a deep ball - it practically tucked itself into Wallace's arms. Leftwich throws the ball vertically even better than Roethlisberger does.

Dixon, on the other hand, may be 12 for 14 thus far, but is making a lot of dump-off throws and check downs and otherwise making plays with his feet. They use a different set of plays when Dixon plays, it's much more of a dink-and-dunk offense rife with option plays that allow Dixon to make a quick read and take off if necessary. The problem with this is that while he's doing a great job of executing it vs 2nd and 3rd team defenses, it may not work consistently against starters. And if they manage to shut down the option plays and force him to stay at home and make plays down the field with his arm, I fear there will be more turnovers than touchdowns.

I'm pretty sure that's the Steelers' concern at this point as well. If forced to go through his reads and throw away from coverage rather than simply playing instinctively and being able to scramble and/or make easy throws on almost every play, that the offense will stall and/or cough the ball up too much. I think they're more comfortable playing a guy like Leftwich, who is going to take a bunch of sacks, but also will protect the football and not put the defense in horrible spots too often. With a defense like the Steelers have, they don't need to score 30 points a game to win games, so I think they're more comfortable having Lefty go out there and score 20 ppg and play field position and rely on the D to keep them in games.
I recall this certain Dixon playing very admirably vs the Ravens last season in his 1st career NFL start. Once teams see lead-foot Leftwich under center, it'll be hunting season with a myriad of blitzes.......I say the offense will be hard-pressed to keep drives alive with Leftwich, who may deliver an occassional great long ball, but the key thing will be having the time to sit back in the pocket and deliver it. Pocket passers who hold onto the ball too long are the easiest guys in the NFL to prepare for and contain. I'm not a Steelers fan, but just an observer of the situation here. If I were an opponent, I would love to see #4 trotting out there instead of #10. Dixon is a winner, and an underrated talent who is a future starter in this league, mark my words. Leftwich is an emergency QB at this point, and with Dixon on board, there should not be an emergency call necessary.
Dixon did get them to overtime at Baltimore, but he was also 12-26 on the game and threw the game away with a bad INT after the Steelers had the ball with a chance to win the game. That's what you get with Dixon, he's a guy that can move the chains effectively with his mix of skills, but he can also kill you in the clutch due to a lack of experience/accuracy. The key is measuring the risk/reward you get with Dixon vs. the consistency of Leftwich. I have a feeling that if the Steelers' D is porous as it was at times last year w/o Polamalu and Smith, and they need to switch to a more high-octane offense, you'll see a lot more Dixon. If the defense is stout and only allowing 11 points a game as they did in the 2008 season, you'll see the steadier Leftwich out there.
Leftwich is a pocket passer and not very accurate. He's like a streaky jump shooter who doesn't get hot very often.
 
It's a tough call because each QB brings things the other doesn't. Leftwich is slow as a glacier, but as proven against the Giants, he can make a play with his feet occasionally by following his blocking and also is much better at reading defenses and is much more accurate than Dixon. The toss to Wallace for the 68 yard TD against the Giants was thrown about as perfectly as you can throw a deep ball - it practically tucked itself into Wallace's arms. Leftwich throws the ball vertically even better than Roethlisberger does.

Dixon, on the other hand, may be 12 for 14 thus far, but is making a lot of dump-off throws and check downs and otherwise making plays with his feet. They use a different set of plays when Dixon plays, it's much more of a dink-and-dunk offense rife with option plays that allow Dixon to make a quick read and take off if necessary. The problem with this is that while he's doing a great job of executing it vs 2nd and 3rd team defenses, it may not work consistently against starters. And if they manage to shut down the option plays and force him to stay at home and make plays down the field with his arm, I fear there will be more turnovers than touchdowns.

I'm pretty sure that's the Steelers' concern at this point as well. If forced to go through his reads and throw away from coverage rather than simply playing instinctively and being able to scramble and/or make easy throws on almost every play, that the offense will stall and/or cough the ball up too much. I think they're more comfortable playing a guy like Leftwich, who is going to take a bunch of sacks, but also will protect the football and not put the defense in horrible spots too often. With a defense like the Steelers have, they don't need to score 30 points a game to win games, so I think they're more comfortable having Lefty go out there and score 20 ppg and play field position and rely on the D to keep them in games.
I recall this certain Dixon playing very admirably vs the Ravens last season in his 1st career NFL start. Once teams see lead-foot Leftwich under center, it'll be hunting season with a myriad of blitzes.......I say the offense will be hard-pressed to keep drives alive with Leftwich, who may deliver an occassional great long ball, but the key thing will be having the time to sit back in the pocket and deliver it. Pocket passers who hold onto the ball too long are the easiest guys in the NFL to prepare for and contain. I'm not a Steelers fan, but just an observer of the situation here. If I were an opponent, I would love to see #4 trotting out there instead of #10. Dixon is a winner, and an underrated talent who is a future starter in this league, mark my words. Leftwich is an emergency QB at this point, and with Dixon on board, there should not be an emergency call necessary.
Dixon did get them to overtime at Baltimore, but he was also 12-26 on the game and threw the game away with a bad INT after the Steelers had the ball with a chance to win the game. That's what you get with Dixon, he's a guy that can move the chains effectively with his mix of skills, but he can also kill you in the clutch due to a lack of experience/accuracy. The key is measuring the risk/reward you get with Dixon vs. the consistency of Leftwich. I have a feeling that if the Steelers' D is porous as it was at times last year w/o Polamalu and Smith, and they need to switch to a more high-octane offense, you'll see a lot more Dixon. If the defense is stout and only allowing 11 points a game as they did in the 2008 season, you'll see the steadier Leftwich out there.
Leftwich is a pocket passer and not very accurate. He's like a streaky jump shooter who doesn't get hot very often.
He's a career 58.3% passer, which was his exact % with the Steelers in '08. Not stellar, but better than anything we've seen yet from Dixon (not counting pre-season.) He also was way above his career average with a 8.4 YPA with Pittsburgh, probably due to playing on a very good team for the first (and last) time in his career, but also a small sample size. He also has a career 2.7% INT percentage, which is lower than Roethlisberger's (and Peyton Manning's for that matter.) Bottom line : he doesn't turn the ball over a lot and you know what you're getting. Dixon is a wildcard.
 
Leftwich was no better than mediocre behind a weak line in Tampa last year for 2.5 games, and at times quite awful (Giants game). He eventually was replaced in that game by a younger, more mobile QB. Granted, Tampa was not a playoff contender like Pittsburgh is, but I don't know any team that gives up on the season in week 3. The Bucs determined that Leftwich was simply not good enough to help them win games. I'm afraid Pittsburgh will discover the same thing. It's not that Dixon will necessarily help them win right away either, but I can't see how he could be worse than Leftwich. Plus, Pitt would be able to give their young QB some valuable experience. This has disaster written all over it for Pitt.

 
Dixon did get them to overtime at Baltimore, but he was also 12-26 on the game and threw the game away with a bad INT after the Steelers had the ball with a chance to win the game. That's what you get with Dixon, he's a guy that can move the chains effectively with his mix of skills, but he can also kill you in the clutch due to a lack of experience/accuracy. The key is measuring the risk/reward you get with Dixon vs. the consistency of Leftwich. I have a feeling that if the Steelers' D is porous as it was at times last year w/o Polamalu and Smith, and they need to switch to a more high-octane offense, you'll see a lot more Dixon. If the defense is stout and only allowing 11 points a game as they did in the 2008 season, you'll see the steadier Leftwich out there.
:IBTL: Dixon played okay in his one and only career start last year against the Ravens but the game was like a tale of two halfs. Here are Dixon's stats in 1st half:8/10/87, 1 TD, 0 Int, Passer Rtg: 127.9Here are Dixon's stats in the 2nd half/OT:4/16/58, 0 TD, 1 Int, Passer Rtg: 16.1It seemed to me like the Ravens defense was playing it close to the vest in the first half since they didn't know much about Dixon. Once they figured him out they threw all kind of looks at him and Dixon had trouble.Obviously lots of QB's struggle in their first couple of starts and that doesn't mean Dixon can't or won't improve. However I am not so sure the Steelers can gamble the first four games of this season to find out.
 
Leftwich was no better than mediocre behind a weak line in Tampa last year for 2.5 games, and at times quite awful (Giants game). He eventually was replaced in that game by a younger, more mobile QB. Granted, Tampa was not a playoff contender like Pittsburgh is, but I don't know any team that gives up on the season in week 3. The Bucs determined that Leftwich was simply not good enough to help them win games. I'm afraid Pittsburgh will discover the same thing. It's not that Dixon will necessarily help them win right away either, but I can't see how he could be worse than Leftwich. Plus, Pitt would be able to give their young QB some valuable experience. This has disaster written all over it for Pitt.
You may be right about Leftwich but remember that he played in 5 games for the Steelers in 2008 and his stats were pretty good:21/36/303, 2 TD, 0 Int, Passer Rtg: 104.3Maybe when Leftwich plays on a better team he isn't so sucky.
 
I agree with Leftwich as the starter. And I love the idea of using Dixon on a couple series per game, or in special situations, or whatever.

Why does anyone thing Dixon deserves reps with the first team if the Steelers don't? After the Detroit game Arians said Dixon runs too often when people are open down field... why would that be different if he played with the first team?

 
I just wish they'd give him a chance. He hasn't even taken reps with the first team in practice.
I don't see any point in giving Dixon reps with the first team in practice. The thing going against Dixon is his lack of experience and that isn't going to change by taking a few snaps in practice with the first team.The Steelers coaching staff has already decided to go with Leftwich because of experience and he and Ben are already sharing the first team reps. Splitting them between three QBs would be silly.
 
Dixon played okay in his one and only career start last year against the Ravens but the game was like a tale of two halfs. Here are Dixon's stats in 1st half:8/10/87, 1 TD, 0 Int, Passer Rtg: 127.9Here are Dixon's stats in the 2nd half/OT:4/16/58, 0 TD, 1 Int, Passer Rtg: 16.1It seemed to me like the Ravens defense was playing it close to the vest in the first half since they didn't know much about Dixon. Once they figured him out they threw all kind of looks at him and Dixon had trouble.
The Ravens came out and said that they switched to a zone scheme at half time & it confused Dixon pretty badly. Anyone know what kind of scheme Dixon has faced in the 1st 2 preseason games?
 
Dixon played okay in his one and only career start last year against the Ravens but the game was like a tale of two halfs. Here are Dixon's stats in 1st half:8/10/87, 1 TD, 0 Int, Passer Rtg: 127.9Here are Dixon's stats in the 2nd half/OT:4/16/58, 0 TD, 1 Int, Passer Rtg: 16.1It seemed to me like the Ravens defense was playing it close to the vest in the first half since they didn't know much about Dixon. Once they figured him out they threw all kind of looks at him and Dixon had trouble.
The Ravens came out and said that they switched to a zone scheme at half time & it confused Dixon pretty badly. Anyone know what kind of scheme Dixon has faced in the 1st 2 preseason games?
The Ravens blitzed like crazy and all Dixon had to do was throw to his first receiver, which is all he did. In the second half the Ravens made him actually have to read the defense, and he performed terribly.
 
Dixon played okay in his one and only career start last year against the Ravens but the game was like a tale of two halfs. Here are Dixon's stats in 1st half:8/10/87, 1 TD, 0 Int, Passer Rtg: 127.9Here are Dixon's stats in the 2nd half/OT:4/16/58, 0 TD, 1 Int, Passer Rtg: 16.1It seemed to me like the Ravens defense was playing it close to the vest in the first half since they didn't know much about Dixon. Once they figured him out they threw all kind of looks at him and Dixon had trouble.
The Ravens came out and said that they switched to a zone scheme at half time & it confused Dixon pretty badly. Anyone know what kind of scheme Dixon has faced in the 1st 2 preseason games?
The Ravens blitzed like crazy and all Dixon had to do was throw to his first receiver, which is all he did. In the second half the Ravens made him actually have to read the defense, and he performed terribly.
Arians play calling in the 2nd half of that game was just as terrible.
 
It's a tough call because each QB brings things the other doesn't. Leftwich is slow as a glacier, but as proven against the Giants, he can make a play with his feet occasionally by following his blocking and also is much better at reading defenses and is much more accurate than Dixon. The toss to Wallace for the 68 yard TD against the Giants was thrown about as perfectly as you can throw a deep ball - it practically tucked itself into Wallace's arms. Leftwich throws the ball vertically even better than Roethlisberger does.Dixon, on the other hand, may be 12 for 14 thus far, but is making a lot of dump-off throws and check downs and otherwise making plays with his feet. They use a different set of plays when Dixon plays, it's much more of a dink-and-dunk offense rife with option plays that allow Dixon to make a quick read and take off if necessary. The problem with this is that while he's doing a great job of executing it vs 2nd and 3rd team defenses, it may not work consistently against starters. And if they manage to shut down the option plays and force him to stay at home and make plays down the field with his arm, I fear there will be more turnovers than touchdowns.I'm pretty sure that's the Steelers' concern at this point as well. If forced to go through his reads and throw away from coverage rather than simply playing instinctively and being able to scramble and/or make easy throws on almost every play, that the offense will stall and/or cough the ball up too much. I think they're more comfortable playing a guy like Leftwich, who is going to take a bunch of sacks, but also will protect the football and not put the defense in horrible spots too often. With a defense like the Steelers have, they don't need to score 30 points a game to win games, so I think they're more comfortable having Lefty go out there and score 20 ppg and play field position and rely on the D to keep them in games.
:excited:
 
It's a tough call because each QB brings things the other doesn't. Leftwich is slow as a glacier, but as proven against the Giants, he can make a play with his feet occasionally by following his blocking and also is much better at reading defenses and is much more accurate than Dixon. The toss to Wallace for the 68 yard TD against the Giants was thrown about as perfectly as you can throw a deep ball - it practically tucked itself into Wallace's arms. Leftwich throws the ball vertically even better than Roethlisberger does.Dixon, on the other hand, may be 12 for 14 thus far, but is making a lot of dump-off throws and check downs and otherwise making plays with his feet. They use a different set of plays when Dixon plays, it's much more of a dink-and-dunk offense rife with option plays that allow Dixon to make a quick read and take off if necessary. The problem with this is that while he's doing a great job of executing it vs 2nd and 3rd team defenses, it may not work consistently against starters. And if they manage to shut down the option plays and force him to stay at home and make plays down the field with his arm, I fear there will be more turnovers than touchdowns.I'm pretty sure that's the Steelers' concern at this point as well. If forced to go through his reads and throw away from coverage rather than simply playing instinctively and being able to scramble and/or make easy throws on almost every play, that the offense will stall and/or cough the ball up too much. I think they're more comfortable playing a guy like Leftwich, who is going to take a bunch of sacks, but also will protect the football and not put the defense in horrible spots too often. With a defense like the Steelers have, they don't need to score 30 points a game to win games, so I think they're more comfortable having Lefty go out there and score 20 ppg and play field position and rely on the D to keep them in games.
:excited:
:banned: I can't say its ever good form to quote oneself even if you are spot on in your analysis especially with a good posting.......just sayin
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I just wish they'd give him a chance. He hasn't even taken reps with the first team in practice.
I don't see any point in giving Dixon reps with the first team in practice. The thing going against Dixon is his lack of experience and that isn't going to change by taking a few snaps in practice with the first team.The Steelers coaching staff has already decided to go with Leftwich because of experience and he and Ben are already sharing the first team reps. Splitting them between three QBs would be silly.
I know it is bad form to quote yourself but dang it I really think Tomlin has been screwing the pooch all preseason with the way he has been handling the QBs.I really hopes he gives Leftwich the entire 1st half with the first team on Thursday and then plays Dixon with the 2nd team in the 2nd half. Sit Ben and Charlie, we already know what they can do...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top