No, I said, "he gets overpraised because he was such a critics darling," which was more about praise than actual popularity since not every artist that is popular gets praised a lot (see: Nickelback).
The topic of the thread is "Do you like Elvis Costello's Music?", and that was your response. I'm not going to discuss a disingenuous take.
Also - I showed you three other examples - it's fine if some one does not like an artist/band, but it's uniformed and a bit insulting when those people then try to make up reasons (in a derogatory manner) why some one else does - because its so inconceivable to them that some one could possibly like something they don't.
There’s a lot of music fans out there and most musicians have their fare share of fans for many different reasons and while some of those things may have been true at the beginning- at our age people just like what they like. It’s not about “street cred”.