[DYNASTY] DB #33 (1 Viewer)

[Tick]

Please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round. If you must assume a scoring system, go with 0.5 points per half-tackle, 3 points per sack / INT / FF / FR.

Cornerbacks and Safeties are rolled together.

1. Troy Polamalu

2. Adrian Wilson

3t. Ed Reed

3t. Gibril Wilson

5. Roy Williams

6. Charles Tillman

7. Bob Sanders

8. Madieu Williams

9t. Mike Brown

9t. Michael Lewis

11. Sean Taylor

12. Terrence McGee

13. Brian Dawkins

14. Adam Archuleta

15. Michael Boulware

16. Kerry Rhodes

17. Ronde Barber

18. Terrance Kiel

19. Erik Coleman

20. Antoine Winfield

21. Tony Parrish

22. Dunta Robinson

23. Nick Collins

24. Chris Gamble

25. Deangelo Hall

26. Rodney Harrison

27. Greg Wesley

28. Nate Clements

29. Thomas Davis

30. Kenoy Kennedy

31. Stuart Schweigert

32. Nathan Vasher

Who's #33?

(waiting list: Bryan Scott*, Donovin Darius, Mike Doss, Tank Williams, Deltha O'Neal, Marcus Trufant)

* = removed from the list for a bit due to getting 0 votes.

FYI, I'm going to either DB36 or Feb 12, whichever comes first.

Final results:

Darrent Williams [ 3 ] [15.79%]

Josh Bullocks [ 3 ] [15.79%]

Nick Ferguson [ 3 ] [15.79%]

Champ Bailey [ 1 ] [5.26%]

Marlon McCree [ 2 ] [10.53%]

Darren Sharper [ 6 ] [31.58%]

Chris Hope [ 1 ] [5.26%]

Sammy Knight [ 0 ] [0.00%]

Other [ 0 ] [0.00%]

Sharper wins. I'm cutting it off here.

 

[Red Herring]

Sharper. After Sharper and Knight, the talent drops a bit, with Bailey the class of the rest

 

[houndirish]

I decided to get cute here and go with Bullocks sheerly for the upside potential. I'm thinking a talented safety in New Orleans is going to get plenty of chances. I like Ferguson too. He finished 36th among DB's in my league last year. After a year of learning he should steadily improve. Sharper and Knight are proven veterans but both are a bit long in the tooth for me.

 

[Red Herring]

Sharper and Knight are proven veterans but both are a bit long in the tooth for me.

Agreed they are certainly aging. I just put more stock in being sure of what I'm getting for a few years than in a player that has upside yet to be realized. Especially at safety, where losing a step can be covered more easily by skill and experience and they can eek out 1-2 extra productive years.I guess for me it comes down to being sure of good solid production through, say 2009-2010 tops, meanwhile I can either pick up a FA that comes on or grab a rookie in the next couple years to replace them when they retire. Do I take them before a Boulware or Archuleta? Hells no! But when we get into the marginal players, I'd rather have the vet and go after a youngster next year