Dynasty Qb #10/11/12 (1 Viewer)

[Tick]

These are consensus dynasty rankings for year 2007

If you vote other, please specify.

Also, please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round.

I like the chatter lets keep that going as we vote.

1. Peyton Manning

2. Carson Palmer

3. Tom Brady

4. Drew Brees

5. Donovan McNabb

6. Matt Hasselbeck

7. Philip Rivers

8. Mike Vick

9. Eli Manning

Results:

Vince Young - Tony Romo - Matt Leinart [ 8 ] ** [7.92%]

Vince Young - Matt Leinart - Tony Romo [ 41 ] ** [40.59%]

Matt Leinart - Vince Young - Tony Romo [ 26 ] ** [25.74%]

Matt Leinart - Tony Romo - Vince Young [ 12 ] ** [11.88%]

Tony Romo - Vince Young - Matt Leinart [ 8 ] ** [7.92%]

Tony Romo - Matt Leinart- Vince Young [ 6 ] ** [5.94%]

Young: 8*1+41*1+26*2+12*3+8*2+6*3 = 171

Lienart: 8*3+41*2+26*1+12*1+8*3+6*2 = 180

Romo: 8*2+41*3+26*3+12*2+8*1+6*1 = 255

10. Young

11. Leinart

12. Romo

 

[norton17]

Young shouldnt even be in this ranking b/c he should be much higher.

He's producing like a top 10 QB right now and his potential is McNabb like

 

[Ariakis]

This 3 tier voting approach has a flaw. Whoever is voted for at #10 has multiple voting points at 11-12. Those who vote Romo at 10 if Young wins would surely vote him at #11 over Leinart too.

 

[snorlax]

This 3 tier voting approach has a flaw. Whoever is voted for at #10 has multiple voting points at 11-12. Those who vote Romo at 10 if Young wins would surely vote him at #11 over Leinart too.

That can be accounted for in the way votes are counted by using an instant runoff system, but it's not going to matter for this poll anyway.

 

[Cannon Fodder]

This 3 tier voting approach has a flaw. Whoever is voted for at #10 has multiple voting points at 11-12. Those who vote Romo at 10 if Young wins would surely vote him at #11 over Leinart too.

By the way it's looking I don't think it's gonna matter. It appears as if Young and Lienert are going to run far away from Romo.

 

[Benchwarmers]

bump

 

[Duckboy]

Voted Leinart-Young-Romo but Young is closing the gap imo.

 

[Tick]

This 3 tier voting approach has a flaw. Whoever is voted for at #10 has multiple voting points at 11-12. Those who vote Romo at 10 if Young wins would surely vote him at #11 over Leinart too.

I add one point for a first place vote, 2 for a second, 3 for a third. Lowest total gets 10th place, middle gets 11th, highest gets 12th.

 

[Cannon Fodder]

This 3 tier voting approach has a flaw. Whoever is voted for at #10 has multiple voting points at 11-12. Those who vote Romo at 10 if Young wins would surely vote him at #11 over Leinart too.

I add one point for a first place vote, 2 for a second, 3 for a third. Lowest total gets 10th place, middle gets 11th, highest gets 12th.

When do you close it and move on to #13?

 

[Biabreakable]

This 3 tier voting approach has a flaw. Whoever is voted for at #10 has multiple voting points at 11-12. Those who vote Romo at 10 if Young wins would surely vote him at #11 over Leinart too.

I am not sure if I like this approach to voting because people who voted for #10 might vote for entirely different players than the choices given. But the ties are difficult to break also and seem to happen often. So I am not sure what the best solution may actualy be.