[DYNASTY] QB #30 (1 Viewer)

[Tick]

1 - Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts

2 - Carson Palmer Cincy Bengals

3 - Tom Brady New England Patriots

4 - McNabb Philadelphia Eagles

5 - Eli Manning New York Football Giants

6 - Marc Bulger St. Louis Rams

7 - Daunte Culpepper Minnesota Vikings

8 - Michael Vick Atlanta Falcons

9 - Drew Brees San Diego Chargers

10 - Ben Roethlisberger Pittsburgh Steelers

11 - Matt Hasselbeck Seattle Seahawks

12 - Byron Leftwich Jacksonville Jaguars

13 - Jake Delhomme Carolina Panthers

14 - Jake Plummer Denver Broncos

15 - Matt Leinart

16 - Charlie Frye Cleveland Browns

17 - Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers

18 - Trent Green

19 - David Carr

20 - Vince Young

21 - Rex Grossman

22t - Kyle Boller

22t - Chris Simms

24 - JP Losman

25 - Aaron Brooks

26 - David Garrard

27 - Alex Smith

28 - Jason Campbell

29 - Aaron Rodgers

Who is #30?

If you vote other, please specify.

Also, please comment on your vote, and list any player that should be nominated for the next round.

Waiting list: Walter, Orton, Warner, Drew Bledsoe*, Omar Jacobs*, Chad Pennington*, Brett Favre*

*Removed for getting 0 votes.

Final results:

Brian Griese [ 4 ] [9.09%]

Matt Schaub [ 14 ] [31.82%]

Billy Volek [ 3 ] [6.82%]

Kerry Collins [ 2 ] [4.55%]

Steve McNair [ 6 ] [13.64%]

Jay Cutler [ 4 ] [9.09%]

Joey Harrington [ 6 ] [13.64%]

Patrick Ramsey [ 0 ] [0.00%]

Mark Brunell [ 2 ] [4.55%]

Andrew Walter [ 3 ] [6.82%]

Other [ 0 ] [0.00%]

Schaub wins.

 

[wannabee]

McNair

 

[Tick]

I voted McNair here. He's really not that old, and now that it looks like he's coming back next season, I could see him sticking around for even longer if the Titans don't draft a QB in the first.

 

[Tick]

bumpWhat's with this new "Posts in this topic" thing? Never noticed it before.EDIT - ah, I had clicked "Outline"

 

[Slinger]

Matt Schaub because he's young and we've seen him play a handful of games. He's a good guy to stash and wait for when he's traded to another team (so we all hope).

 

[Floyd The Barber]

This is in no way meant to be a criticism of the good work Tick is doing... but I've seen enough of Chris Simms to know that he will overperform his #22 ranking in this survey.Jon Gruden is to quarterbacks what Mike Shanahan is to running backs. And now he has the best pure quarterback he's ever had in Simms - in terms of arm strentgh, accuracy and touch.A full off-season of first team coaching from Gruden should elevate his game considerably in 2006 and by 2007 he could be Top 5-10. In my opinion anyway.

 

[Cookiemonster]

This is in no way meant to be a criticism of the good work Tick is doing... but I've seen enough of Chris Simms to know that he will overperform his #22 ranking in this survey.

Jon Gruden is to quarterbacks what Mike Shanahan is to running backs.  And now he has the best pure quarterback he's ever had in Simms - in terms of arm strentgh, accuracy and touch.

A full off-season of first team coaching from Gruden should elevate his game considerably in 2006 and by 2007 he could be Top 5-10.  In my opinion anyway.

I'm shooting for him in a REDRAFT.

sleeper!

edit to add-I believe Clayton makes an impact when healthy next year. O-line improves enough to get A.Smith into routes more. Cadillac is better next year, and is already a VERY good blocker. Another year to be more familiar w/ blitz pick up makes for a solid passing year for the future star in Tampa. Simms will be a better QB than Gannon was and Gruden made him an MVP. Maybe not next year, but in the near future Simms will make pro-bowls.

 

[Keys Myaths]

Other: Brad Smith--unknown.Hey, it could happen. I'm NOT A BLIND HOMER!!

 

[Tick]

Chris Simms is a turd.