Dynasty Rookie #10 (1 Viewer)

[Mr. Peterson]

1. Darren McFadden, RB - Raiders

2. Jonathan Stewart, RB - Panthers

3. Rashard Mendenhall, RB - Steelers

4. Kevin Smith, RB - Lions

5. Matt Forte, RB - Bears

6. Felix Jones, RB - Cowboys

7. Chris Johnson, RB - Titans

8. Ray Rice, RB - Ravens

9. Matt Ryan, QB - Falcons

 

[Cookiemonster]

I say Hardy 'cause he's got the least amount between him and a starting gig. He's got the right situation to be a big performer w/ an up and coming young QB, an established #1 on the other side, a solid run game and an improving O-line. I think Buffalo is a team on the verge of making waves and Hardy is one of the few WRs from this years' class who made #1 on quite a few people's lists at one time or another. Avery made a late run up some boards and may be legit, but he's got to beat out Bennett first. D.Thomas was several spots down everyone's lists 'till he had a great combine (always scares me a little). Sweed and J.Charles both have a coulpe years 'till they get an opportunity (barring injury of course) to be starters. I'd go Hardy here w/o hesitation.

 

[KoolKat]

I voted Flacco, because I am not sold on any of the WRs. I think it is a crapshoot, so it would be best to wait till the 2nd round to snag one. However, I am sold on Flacco. I hear alot of people talk about his mobility, but take a lookat this:

 

[Mr. Peterson]

I was almost ready to give the #10 spot to Hardy since he was so far ahead of Thomas and everyone else in the last poll.

Kinda suprised Thomas is beating Hardy in this one so far.

 

[houndirish]

I voted OTHER for Brohm. I think all the receivers have question marks. I don't like Flacco. The falloff at RB is quite considerable compared to those taken (I'd even argue that some of those already gone went too early).

I'll accept that Brohm likely has as many questions as the other players mentioned but I think he definitely deserves to be mentioned as a poll choice.

 

[Crippler]

I voted Flacco, because I am not sold on any of the WRs. I think it is a crapshoot, so it would be best to wait till the 2nd round to snag one. However, I am sold on Flacco. I hear alot of people talk about his mobility, but take a lookat this:

And my league is where you must start 1 but can start 2 QB's each week. Love Flacco slightly over Ryan and Henne and by quite a bit over Brohm in the end for the other vote. Brohm may not see the field in Green Bay ever.

 

[Mr. Peterson]

I voted Flacco, because I am not sold on any of the WRs. I think it is a crapshoot, so it would be best to wait till the 2nd round to snag one. However, I am sold on Flacco. I hear alot of people talk about his mobility, but take a lookat this:

Brohm will be a backup until he leaves GB. And I like the guy.

 

[Kleck]

It's a little early for me to think about Brohm, but Rodgers will be a FA heading into '09.

 

[Mr. Peterson]

This one's close. Might have to go to a run-off.

 

[Burning Sensation]

This one's close. Might have to go to a run-off.

Or a tie for 10, and then just start the next poll at 12.

 

[Mr. Peterson]

This one's close. Might have to go to a run-off.

Or a tie for 10, and then just start the next poll at 12.

Thw two WR's are tied at 39 right now. Should I do a run-off or just make it a tie?

 

[Tecmo]

this is a tie