[Dynasty] Rookie #9 (1 Viewer)

[jeter23]

1. Reggie Bush

2. DeAngelo Williams

3. LenDale White

4. Laurence Maroney

5. Vince Young

6. Matt Leinart

7. Brian Calhoun

8. Santonio Holmes

Who is #9? Please discuss who you voted for and why.

 

[wannabee]

Went Cutler. As a non-IDPer, I see a big dropoff at the other positions. Cutler is the only one that is definitely the top at his position.

 

[anakin]

Went Davis as a great TE prospect in a TE required lineup will be very handy instead of starting a D Jolley or M Pollard.

 

[Destroyer]

I nominate Jerome Harrison and Jerious Norwood for the next "ballot".

 

[jeter23]

I nominate Jerome Harrison and Jerious Norwood for the next "ballot".

That's fine, but "other" wasn't drawing many votes the past few polls.

 

[Destroyer]

I nominate Jerome Harrison and Jerious Norwood for the next "ballot".

That's fine, but "other" wasn't drawing many votes the past few polls.

Didn't vote "other" because there were players I had ranked higher already listed.I just think a couple more names could be added as choices. Just my 2 cents.

 

[jeter23]

I nominate Jerome Harrison and Jerious Norwood for the next "ballot".

That's fine, but "other" wasn't drawing many votes the past few polls.

Didn't vote "other" because there were players I had ranked higher already listed.I just think a couple more names could be added as choices. Just my 2 cents.

No problem. I can add some more.

 

[jburns]

i think at this pt you should take the defensive players off completely.

i'm not an idp player but i think with idp's and non idp's voting, it will be tough for a defensive player to be chosen in this format, therefore causing defensive players to be ranked lower than they would be in an idp league.

therefore this won't be much of a help to either format.

just my 2cents.

 

[Baracuda]

Addai is a RB and a good prospect. He should be drafted ahead of a TE considered by some to be similar to Ben Watson. At this point in the draft, I wouldn't take a TE with a decent RB prospect on the board.

 

[Destroyer]

i think at this pt you should take the defensive players off completely.

i'm not an idp player but i think with idp's and non idp's voting, it will be tough for a defensive player to be chosen in this format, therefore causing defensive players to be ranked lower than they would be in an idp league.

therefore this won't be much of a help to either format.

just my 2cents.

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Deep class for TE.

Have to like Addai over Cutler here, although this is where things do get interesting.

 

[anakin]

Addai is a RB and a good prospect. He should be drafted ahead of a TE considered by some to be similar to Ben Watson. At this point in the draft, I wouldn't take a TE with a decent RB prospect on the board.

So you are saying it is better to get a RB who might pan out versus a TE who has a lot of skills and who would do well in a good passing situation.

 

[jeter23]

i think at this pt you should take the defensive players off completely.

i'm not an idp player but i think with idp's and non idp's voting, it will be tough for a defensive player to be chosen in this format, therefore causing defensive players to be ranked lower than they would be in an idp league.

therefore this won't be much of a help to either format.

just my 2cents.

I don't play IDP myself, but I included them because they were requested. I do think they can be included without the rankings being skewed. Whatever the majority wants is what we can do with this. IDP or no IDP?

 

[jeff_eaglz]

Addai is a RB and a good prospect. He should be drafted ahead of a TE considered by some to be similar to Ben Watson. At this point in the draft, I wouldn't take a TE with a decent RB prospect on the board.

So you are saying it is better to get a RB who might pan out versus a TE who has a lot of skills and who would do well in a good passing situation.

Considering the relative ease in getting a quality TE vs. a quality RB, I'd be more inclined to gamble more on the RB.For example, if I was "on the clock" with Addai on the board and the #1 TE, I'd go Addai and grab a Top 10 TE prospect later in the draft.

RBs present higher upside than TEs.

 

[Destroyer]

i think at this pt you should take the defensive players off completely.

i'm not an idp player but i think with idp's and non idp's voting, it will be tough for a defensive player to be chosen in this format, therefore causing defensive players to be ranked lower than they would be in an idp league.

therefore this won't be much of a help to either format.

just my 2cents.

I don't play IDP myself, but I included them because they were requested. I do think they can be included without the rankings being skewed. Whatever the majority wants is what we can do with this. IDP or no IDP?

No IDP

 

[ConstruxBoy]

I vote no IDP because I think in an IDP league Hawk should already be gone.

 

[Spike]

Include IDP.

Seriously, I would be curious as to how many non-IDP dynasty leagues there are these days.

 

[coolnerd]

Include IDP.

Seriously, I would be curious as to how many non-IDP dynasty leagues there are these days.

As someone who plays in both...Non IDPs even in dynasty still outnumber IDP by quite a bit. In redrafts it is not even worth discussion.

 

[wannabee]

Include IDP.

Seriously, I would be curious as to how many non-IDP dynasty leagues there are these days.

just a guess, with all leagues, 85% non-IDP, 15% IDP. I think this is even generous to the IDPers.

 

[BigTex]

i think at this pt you should take the defensive players off completely.

i'm not an idp player but i think with idp's and non idp's voting, it will be tough for a defensive player to be chosen in this format, therefore causing defensive players to be ranked lower than they would be in an idp league.

therefore this won't be much of a help to either format.

just my 2cents.

 

[jeter23]

There will be no IDP from this point. I don't play IDP, so maybe someone else would be interested in running polls on the IDP forum.