DYNASTY: Stud WR's for later (1 Viewer)

[Raiders]

Who is going to be the best of this group?

Here's how I see it:

1 Braylon Edwards

2 Mark Clayton

3 Marques Colston

4 Chris Henry

5 Chad Jackson

6 Vincent Jackson

7 Troy Williamson

8 Greg Jennings

9 Reggie Williams

10 Reggie Brown

11 Santonio Holmes

12 Sinorice Moss

 

[a_rackowski]

1. Larry Fitzgerald

 

[fsufan]

1. Holt

 

[jurb26]

Is there a list you want us to rank or just give our #1?

 

[urbanhack]

Who's the best for the next few years

it depends on the next 13 weeks doesn't it?

 

[Raiders]

oops.

 

[code]

oops.

 

[King of the Jungle]

1 Braylon Edwards

2 Mark Clayton

3 Troy Williamson

4 Greg Jennings

5 Chris Henry

6 Vincent Jackson

7 Chad Jackson

8 Reggie Brown

9 Marques Colston

10 Santonio Holmes

11 Sinorice Moss

12 Reggie Williams

 

[Mister CIA]

Who is going to be the best of this group?Here's how I see it:1 Braylon Edwards 2 Mark Clayton 3 Marques Colston4 Chris Henry 5 Chad Jackson6 Vincent Jackson7 Troy Williamson 8 Greg Jennings 9 Reggie Williams 10 Reggie Brown 11 Santonio Holmes12 Sinorice Moss

I think the masses will disagree with Jennings at #8. And I think Vince Jackson at #6 is a bit high.

 

[a_rackowski]

1 Braylon Edwards2 Mark Clayton3 Troy Williamson4 Greg Jennings5 Chris Henry6 Vincent Jackson7 Chad Jackson8 Reggie Brown9 Marques Colston10 Santonio Holmes11 Sinorice Moss12 Reggie Williams

1)braylon edwards2)greg Jennings3)troy Williamson4)Marques Colston5)Vince Jackson6)Mark Clayton7)Chad Jackson8)Sinorice Moss9)Santonio Holmes10)Reggie WIlliams11)reggie Brown12)Chris Henry - Not going to last long in this league

 

[a_rackowski]

Who is going to be the best of this group?Here's how I see it:1 Braylon Edwards 2 Mark Clayton 3 Marques Colston4 Chris Henry 5 Chad Jackson6 Vincent Jackson7 Troy Williamson 8 Greg Jennings 9 Reggie Williams 10 Reggie Brown 11 Santonio Holmes12 Sinorice Moss

I think the masses will disagree with Jennings at #8. And I think Vince Jackson at #6 is a bit high.

I like vince jackson. SD isnt going anywhere. Young excellent QB. Great Running game. McCardell is getting older, Parker is coming up on FA, I really think that Vince Jackson is going to get his chance and will come up huge when he does.

 

[Jack Ham & Eggs]

I'd drop Chris Henry way down the list. There's no way that guy will be able to stay in the NFL more than another 1-2 years. He makes Koren Robinson look like the Reverend Billy Graham.

 

[zamboni]

I'd drop Chris Henry way down the list. There's no way that guy will be able to stay in the NFL more than another 1-2 years. He makes Koren Robinson look like the Reverend Billy Graham.

Even if he sticks around, I think the bigger issue is having two stud WRs ahead of him that will likely be with the team for some time. Perhaps Holt/Bruce, part deux.

 

[Mister CIA]

Who is going to be the best of this group?

Here's how I see it:

1 Braylon Edwards

2 Mark Clayton

3 Marques Colston

4 Chris Henry

5 Chad Jackson

6 Vincent Jackson

7 Troy Williamson

8 Greg Jennings

9 Reggie Williams

10 Reggie Brown

11 Santonio Holmes

12 Sinorice Moss

I think the masses will disagree with Jennings at #8. And I think Vince Jackson at #6 is a bit high.

I like vince jackson. SD isnt going anywhere. Young excellent QB. Great Running game. McCardell is getting older, Parker is coming up on FA, I really think that Vince Jackson is going to get his chance and will come up huge when he does.

I don't dislike him, but I'd rank him around #8 on this list.Tier 1

Braylon Edwards

Tier 2

Mark Clayton

Marques Colston

Chris Henry

Greg Jennings

Tier 3

Chad Jackson

Vincent Jackson

Troy Williamson

Tier 3.5

Reggie Brown

Brandon Marshall

Bernard Berrian

Tier 4

Reggie Williams

Santonio Holmes

Sinorice Moss

 

[baronson]

1 Marques Colston

2 Troy Williamson

3 Sinorice Moss

4 Vincent Jackson

5 Chad Jackson

6 Braylon Edwards*

7 Mark Clayton*

8 Reggie Brown

9 Greg Jennings*

10 Reggie Williams

11 Santonio Holmes

12 Chris Henry

* - might be higher, but right now their QB situation has them with a limited outlook, in my mind.

colston will be an animal

 

[King of the Jungle]

1 Marques Colston2 Troy Williamson3 Sinorice Moss4 Vincent Jackson5 Chad Jackson6 Braylon Edwards*7 Mark Clayton*8 Reggie Brown9 Greg Jennings*10 Reggie Williams11 Santonio Holmes12 Chris Henry* - might be higher, but right now their QB situation has them with a limited outlook, in my mind.colston will be an animal

Let me guess, Colston owner? What have you seen from Braylon, Clayton, and Jennings that you do not like? What have you seen from Sin Moss that you do?

 

[stevegamer]

1 Braylon Edwards

2 Mark Clayton

3 Vincent Jackson

4 Greg Jennings

5 Chad Jackson

6 Reggie Brown

7 Troy Williamson

8 Marques Colston

9 Reggie Williams

10 Santonio Holmes

11 Sinorice Moss

13 Chris Henry

 

[mlichty]

1 Braylon Edwards 2 Mark Clayton 3 Vincent Jackson4 Greg Jennings 5 Chad Jackson6 Reggie Brown 7 Troy Williamson 8 Marques Colston9 Reggie Williams 10 Santonio Holmes11 Sinorice Moss13 Chris Henry

Does Bryant Johnson go somewhere in this list?I know he is currently #3 behind a couple of Studs but will he either start in ARI or move to another team and be the #1 within a couple of years?

 

[-OZ-]

Who is going to be the best of this group?

Here's how I see it:

1 Braylon Edwards

2 Mark Clayton

3 Marques Colston

4 Chris Henry

5 Chad Jackson

6 Vincent Jackson

7 Troy Williamson

8 Greg Jennings

9 Reggie Williams

10 Reggie Brown

11 Santonio Holmes

12 Sinorice Moss

Tier 1 Braylon Edwards

Tier 2

Greg Jennings

Mark Clayton

Marques Colston

Reggie Brown

Troy Williamson

Tier 3

Chris Henry

Reggie Williams

Chad Jackson

Vincent Jackson

Brandon Marshall

Tier 4

Santonio Holmes

Sinorice Moss

Bernard Berrian

 

[-OZ-]

1 Marques Colston

2 Troy Williamson

3 Sinorice Moss

4 Vincent Jackson

5 Chad Jackson

6 Braylon Edwards*

7 Mark Clayton*

8 Reggie Brown

9 Greg Jennings*

10 Reggie Williams

11 Santonio Holmes

12 Chris Henry

* - might be higher, but right now their QB situation has them with a limited outlook, in my mind.

You have that much more confidence in Travaris Jackson and Rivers than Frye?

 

[QB11]

1 Chad Jackson - seems like he's got speed, size, skills + Brady

2 Braylon Edwards - same as above, but less at QB

3 Reggie Brown - looks solid so far + McNabb

4 Greg Jennings - looks alot like former-great #84 for GB

5 Mark Clayton - talented WR, will emerge in 2007 IF he has QB

6 Marques Colston - Looks like young Moose Muhammad. Brees favorite

7 Reggie Williams - looking better; can be Leftwich's go-to WR

8 Troy Williamson - fast fast & faster, but needs to catch first

9 Santonio Holmes - needs to grow-up

10 Chris Henry - will have too many suspensions

11 Sinorice Moss - works-in-progress, but has the speed and skills

12 Vincent Jackson - there's a reason he's not playing

 

[Stealthycat]

Jennings

Colston

all the others in no particular order

 

[Dinsy Ejotuz]

Henry

Edwards

Jennings

Colston

Clayton

Henry's dumb, but you guys are underestimating the benefit of seeing his bud Thurman run out of the league will have. When Odell is broke/in jail/in rehab (pick two) I bet Henry sees the light. Especially since he'll get a good taste of it himself when he watches from home for four week this year.

Or not. Time will tell.

Either way, he and Edwards are head and shoulders above the rest of the guys on this list in terms of raw physical ability.

 

[JayMan]

The simple fact that everyone's list is different leads me to believe that we don't have a clue who will become a stud...

The only constant seems to be Braylon Edwards at the top... I'd have to agree with that...

Other than this, it seems that most "high place" votes comes from guys that own these players and hope that they become studs... only to think that Marques Colston wasn't even in the equation a month ago says alot in my opinion...

I know he's not on that list (nor should he be) but I think the next uberstud (Fitz / Holt type) is Calvin Johnson... get him if you can in your next year's draft...

 

[kupcho1]

I know he's not on that list (nor should he be) but I think the next uberstud (Fitz / Holt type) is Calvin Johnson... get him if you can in your next year's draft...

That's damn good advice. Now shut the hell up about it.

 

[JayMan]

I know he's not on that list (nor should he be) but I think the next uberstud (Fitz / Holt type) is Calvin Johnson... get him if you can in your next year's draft...

That's damn good advice. Now shut the hell up about it.

I probably won't be having a high pick next year... and even if we want the other owners in our [DYNASTY] leagues to know nothing about Calvin... I'm guessing they will

(I can already imagine the highlight films on ESPN when he's drafted)...

 

[baronson]

1 Marques Colston2 Troy Williamson3 Sinorice Moss4 Vincent Jackson5 Chad Jackson6 Braylon Edwards*7 Mark Clayton*8 Reggie Brown9 Greg Jennings*10 Reggie Williams11 Santonio Holmes12 Chris Henry* - might be higher, but right now their QB situation has them with a limited outlook, in my mind.colston will be an animal

Let me guess, Colston owner? What have you seen from Braylon, Clayton, and Jennings that you do not like? What have you seen from Sin Moss that you do?

yes, Colston owner, which means i've paid special attention to the fact that his hands are soft like a kitten, and his body control makes Jessica Simpson look clumsy. ok, bad example like my asterisk clearly indicates, i think Braylon, Clayton, and Jennings are limited because their QB situation is a huge question mark going forward. i think its hard for you or anyone else to argue otherwise.as a Giants fan, i can tell you that what few plays Sinorice has been in on, make him look like Tron. the dude can turn on a dime, appears in limited opportunities to have very good hands. unfortunately, he was hurt much of preseason, so anyone not working out with the Giants during the week is only left to speculate. what i do know is that Toomer's clock is winding down, and Tim Carter isn't the answer. Sinorice will be starting as early as next year, latest 2008. Eli will have his act completely together, and Plax will be blowing up. Call Moss the Reggie Wayne to Peyton's Harrison, if you will.basically, i think Sinorice has every opportunity to excel, and i've seen nothing from his skillset thus far to lead me to believe he won't.

 

[Men-in-Cleats]

Why isn't Matt Jones on this list? He's hasn't proven himself much more than most of the guys on this list and should be pretty high on this list for most people. Is it just because he wasn't on the originial list?

 

[Mister CIA]

Why isn't Matt Jones on this list? He's hasn't proven himself much more than most of the guys on this list and should be pretty high on this list for most people. Is it just because he wasn't on the originial list?

I think it's because we collectively, and readily, accept MaJones as a fantasy fixture; and, as this thread indicates, Braylon Edwards belongs in the Club too.The rest are still auditioning.