Recap on the team I drafted from the "1" spot. Basic strategy for my draft position was take a top 3 RB with the first pick. On the first turn I planned on going RB/WR or possibly WR/WR if none of my preferred RB1/2 types didn't make it to the turn. Round 4/5 turn was for a TE like Witten/Davis/Hernandez if they happen to fall, I know this was only about 50/50 though. Otherwise probably another RB/WR combo. For the 6/7 turn I planned on taking a QB like Romo or M.Ryan, then if I didn't have a TE yet, hoping the Pettigrew would be there for me. Next few picks, draft the best available players, find value, and make sure I have enough flex starters along with a couple high-upside players.
As far as grading goes, I think everyone is a little biased for their teams because they are taking players that they like. I will try to be objective as possible. I did take some players that I may not love, but on the turn (22 picks in-between my selections) especially with a skilled drafter in front of my turn picks, I had to make some tough decisions to get what I thought would be the best possible team.
QB
D.Brees 2.12
M.Flynn 14.12
M.Sanchez 16.12
My whole draft strategy got thrown out the window on this first turn of the draft. I never take a QB this early, ever! However with Brees sitting there, I had to take him. I don't think he should be there at pick 24, especially with Rodgers/Brady being drafted in the first round. Even with 80% of last years points he would have been a top 5 QB. My projections keep him in the top 3 this year, even with all of the team/coaching issues. He's a plug-in QB no matter what the match-up. Flynn and Sanchez both have some question marks but as a one week fill-in for Brees' week 6 bye they have Indy and NE match-ups so one of them should still have their job and be good for 1 week. Sorry, that was way too long-winded. This Brees pick hopefully won't screw my draft up. If Fitz was available instead of getting picked at 2.11, I would have gone WR/WR.
RB
A.Foster 1.1
F.Gore 4.12
M.Turner 5.1
R.Williams 10.12
D.Wilson 11.1
M.Tolbert 18.12
Hard to complain about having Foster on your roster. Barring injury he will put up top 5 numbers, and has a decent chance to be the number one RB. at the 4/5 turn there were only a few RB's I would feel comfortable with, both for a RB2 and probable flex starter. I think Turner has another year in him, Gore has some question marks, but still seems like he should have been drafted sooner. Every other RB at that turn had some question marks so I was comfortable with these two here, Austin was drafted at 4.11, if he was there for me I probably would have taken Austin and then Turner. My next two RB's are a couple of my favorite picks of this draft. I don't think Williams or Wilson should have been available at the 10/11 turn but I got them both. More than likely Wells and Bradshaw will both miss at least a few games this year so there's a good chance I'll be able to have extra RB starts available, and if Bradshaw misses any significant time, I think Wilson puts up easy RB2 numbers. I wasn't able to snag any handcuffs for my top RB's. They are being drafted a little too early for my liking, especially Tate, although if he made it to the 8/9 turn I would have snagged him (8.9 well below current ADP).
WR's
W.Welker 3.1
T.Smith 7.1
S.Holmes 9.1
J.Blackmon 13.1
B.Hartline 17.1
J.Morgan 20.12 (thought I had H.Douglas pre-drafted in front of Morgan?)
Lots of good options at 3.1, most of the 3rd round WR are all excellent receivers, although even the majority of them have some issues/question marks. I felt Welker has the highest floor so with Foster and Brees already I didn't want to gamble with this pick. After skipping WR all the way to the 6/7 turn, I was very happy to get T.Smith, one of my middle round targets. I really wanted Austin on the 4/5 turn, happy this worked out though because he was the last guy I felt comfortable with for my WR2. Holmes in the 9th was a good pick for me, still like the talent and he's the play-maker there. Besides Keller, if Holmes attitude is right he could have a huge bounce-back yr. Blackmon is interesting to me, figured he'd be gone before I felt he was good value, I think the holdout helped him fall to me this late. Even missing some camp, I figure he will start a little slow, but by the time I have by weeks and late season push I feel he should be a good option to plug into the lineup. Possible boom/bust guy but at 13.1 I'll take him. Hartline is listed #1 for Miami, I think their passing game stinks but he is a starting WR in the 17th round...Morgan could be a starter, could be a drop...actually thought I had Douglas though which is an injury away from possibly putting up decent numbers in that Atl offense.
TE
T.Gonzo 6.12
J.Tamme 8.12
E.Dickson 12.12
Missed my target Pettigrew by 1 pick. I'm not that excited by Gonzo, but think he'll be ok. I almost took Tamme there, and seeing how he was still available at the next turn, I had to take him even with the same bye week as Gonzo. Figure they might both be in the line-up now. Because of this I had to get a 3rd TE, if he can put it together Dickson can become a player. I don't have a top 5 guy, but could possibly have 2 top 12 guys...not an advantage here at all, hoping not to get killed on TE points.
K and Def
S.Gos 19.01
SF def 15.1
Top picks by many experts so I feel I'll be at an advantage here. On the turn I was able to snag them before the runs, when picking SF def I liked them better than other back-up players available so it made a lot of sense, could average 2-4 points more than def12 this year.
Overall if a couple of things fall right, this team could win the league or it could miss the playoffs. Actually very dependent on what happens with my RBs. Of course have Foster is huge, then health with Gore, Turner still burnin'? Then Williams/Wilson are the wildcards.. Blackmon could be huge for my WR's or be a bust. I feel I have plenty of starters, plus lots of players that are worthy for flex-starts. Team could be good.
For the purpose of grading
QB's - A-
RB's - now B, possibly A later
WR's - B
TE's - B-
K and def - A
Overall - B to B+
I would actually like a couple other opinions on this team...thanks again, it was a good draft!
As far as grading goes, I think everyone is a little biased for their teams because they are taking players that they like. I will try to be objective as possible. I did take some players that I may not love, but on the turn (22 picks in-between my selections) especially with a skilled drafter in front of my turn picks, I had to make some tough decisions to get what I thought would be the best possible team.
QB
D.Brees 2.12
M.Flynn 14.12
M.Sanchez 16.12
My whole draft strategy got thrown out the window on this first turn of the draft. I never take a QB this early, ever! However with Brees sitting there, I had to take him. I don't think he should be there at pick 24, especially with Rodgers/Brady being drafted in the first round. Even with 80% of last years points he would have been a top 5 QB. My projections keep him in the top 3 this year, even with all of the team/coaching issues. He's a plug-in QB no matter what the match-up. Flynn and Sanchez both have some question marks but as a one week fill-in for Brees' week 6 bye they have Indy and NE match-ups so one of them should still have their job and be good for 1 week. Sorry, that was way too long-winded. This Brees pick hopefully won't screw my draft up. If Fitz was available instead of getting picked at 2.11, I would have gone WR/WR.
RB
A.Foster 1.1
F.Gore 4.12
M.Turner 5.1
R.Williams 10.12
D.Wilson 11.1
M.Tolbert 18.12
Hard to complain about having Foster on your roster. Barring injury he will put up top 5 numbers, and has a decent chance to be the number one RB. at the 4/5 turn there were only a few RB's I would feel comfortable with, both for a RB2 and probable flex starter. I think Turner has another year in him, Gore has some question marks, but still seems like he should have been drafted sooner. Every other RB at that turn had some question marks so I was comfortable with these two here, Austin was drafted at 4.11, if he was there for me I probably would have taken Austin and then Turner. My next two RB's are a couple of my favorite picks of this draft. I don't think Williams or Wilson should have been available at the 10/11 turn but I got them both. More than likely Wells and Bradshaw will both miss at least a few games this year so there's a good chance I'll be able to have extra RB starts available, and if Bradshaw misses any significant time, I think Wilson puts up easy RB2 numbers. I wasn't able to snag any handcuffs for my top RB's. They are being drafted a little too early for my liking, especially Tate, although if he made it to the 8/9 turn I would have snagged him (8.9 well below current ADP).
WR's
W.Welker 3.1
T.Smith 7.1
S.Holmes 9.1
J.Blackmon 13.1
B.Hartline 17.1
J.Morgan 20.12 (thought I had H.Douglas pre-drafted in front of Morgan?)
Lots of good options at 3.1, most of the 3rd round WR are all excellent receivers, although even the majority of them have some issues/question marks. I felt Welker has the highest floor so with Foster and Brees already I didn't want to gamble with this pick. After skipping WR all the way to the 6/7 turn, I was very happy to get T.Smith, one of my middle round targets. I really wanted Austin on the 4/5 turn, happy this worked out though because he was the last guy I felt comfortable with for my WR2. Holmes in the 9th was a good pick for me, still like the talent and he's the play-maker there. Besides Keller, if Holmes attitude is right he could have a huge bounce-back yr. Blackmon is interesting to me, figured he'd be gone before I felt he was good value, I think the holdout helped him fall to me this late. Even missing some camp, I figure he will start a little slow, but by the time I have by weeks and late season push I feel he should be a good option to plug into the lineup. Possible boom/bust guy but at 13.1 I'll take him. Hartline is listed #1 for Miami, I think their passing game stinks but he is a starting WR in the 17th round...Morgan could be a starter, could be a drop...actually thought I had Douglas though which is an injury away from possibly putting up decent numbers in that Atl offense.
TE
T.Gonzo 6.12
J.Tamme 8.12
E.Dickson 12.12
Missed my target Pettigrew by 1 pick. I'm not that excited by Gonzo, but think he'll be ok. I almost took Tamme there, and seeing how he was still available at the next turn, I had to take him even with the same bye week as Gonzo. Figure they might both be in the line-up now. Because of this I had to get a 3rd TE, if he can put it together Dickson can become a player. I don't have a top 5 guy, but could possibly have 2 top 12 guys...not an advantage here at all, hoping not to get killed on TE points.
K and Def
S.Gos 19.01
SF def 15.1
Top picks by many experts so I feel I'll be at an advantage here. On the turn I was able to snag them before the runs, when picking SF def I liked them better than other back-up players available so it made a lot of sense, could average 2-4 points more than def12 this year.
Overall if a couple of things fall right, this team could win the league or it could miss the playoffs. Actually very dependent on what happens with my RBs. Of course have Foster is huge, then health with Gore, Turner still burnin'? Then Williams/Wilson are the wildcards.. Blackmon could be huge for my WR's or be a bust. I feel I have plenty of starters, plus lots of players that are worthy for flex-starts. Team could be good.
For the purpose of grading
QB's - A-
RB's - now B, possibly A later
WR's - B
TE's - B-
K and def - A
Overall - B to B+
I would actually like a couple other opinions on this team...thanks again, it was a good draft!