FFers better than NFL GMs? (1 Viewer)

[JayMan]

Looking at many threads... there is always the "How could that guy be drafted in the first round and not be in the league 3 years after"... ala Tim Couch, Ryan Leaf, Blair Thomas, Akili Smith, Curtis Enis, etc.

But, are we better off, [DYNASTY] FFers when going for our first round rookie draft?...

Looking at the last two years in my main $ league... and, more importantly, predicting this year's draft, any bust(s) that come to mind?...

How about your leagues... or the Zealots leagues ADP... is the success rate better than for the actual NFL draft?



(ranks are my personal choices - in regards to the pick number, the stats so far and available players at that moment... why KJones gets a 6 while Mark Clayton gets a 7)

'04:

1.01: Steven Jackson... 8

1.02: Kevin Jones... 6

1.03: Larry Fitzgerald... 10

1.04: Roy Williams... 6

1.05: Tatum Bell... 7

1.06: Julius Jones... 7

1.07: Kellen Winslow Jr. ... 1

1.08: Reggie Williams... 1

1.09: Lee Evans... 8

1.10: Michael Clayton... 7

1.11: Rashaun Woods... 1

1.12: Chris Perry... 6

'05:

1.01: Ronnie Brown... 8

1.02: Carnell Williams... 8

1.03: Cedric Benson... 4

1.04: Braylon Edwards... 5

1.05: Mike Williams... 3

1.06: JJ Arrington... 1

1.07: Troy Williamson... 3

1.08: Ryan Moats... 6

1.09: Frank Gore... 7

1.10: Mark Clayton... 7

1.11: Matt Jones... 5

1.12: Reggie Brown... 6

'06 - prediction:

1.01: Reggie Bush

1.02: Lendale White

1.03: Deangelo Williams

1.04: Laurence Maroney

1.05: Vernon Davis

1.06: Chad Jackson

1.07: Matt Leinart

1.08: Santonio Holmes

1.09: Vince Young

1.10: Joseph Addai

1.11: Jay Cutler

1.12: Sinorice Moss

I'd say a 50 to 60% success ratio... not that good it seems!

Who will be the 6 busts this year?

Your thoughts, your input...