Free Agent Preview: Wide Receivers (1 Viewer)

[Jason Wood]

Another free agent preview on the blog today...this time for the Wide Receiver Position.

2008 NFL Free Agency Preview: Wide Receivers

Filed under: Free Agency, NFL, Footballguys, News, WR — Jason Wood @ 10:39 pm Edit This

Wide receivers are the divas of the NFL; the graceful playmakers who fantasy owners and NFL fans covet. While many coaches would argue that WR isn’t one of the positions you build a championship team around, few would argue that having elite receivers can help turn an average offense into an explosive one.

This year’s free agent crop of wide receivers is clearly above average, with quite a few potential starters available for the right price.

The Top Wide Receivers on the Market

1. Randy Moss (6′4″, 210 pounds, 30 years old) – If it seems incomprehensible that the league’s premier receiver, coming off a record-setting 23 TD season could be a free agent; remember that Moss isn’t typical in any way. Moss gave up a $10mm salary in order to play for the Patriots and resurrect his career and reputation. He played for a $3mm deal (plus $2mm in earned incentives); but wasn’t franchised by the Patriots. Before fans out there get too excited, remember that he likely already signed a long-term deal with the Patriots that will be announced on February 29th.

2. Bernard Berrian (6′1″, 185 pounds, 27 years old) — The offensively starved Bears could be without their top two pass catchers next season; particularly after opting not to tag Berrian. Although Berrian has yet to notch a 1,000-yard season, he started 29 games over the last two seasons, scored 11 TDs and 122 receptions. Berrian has the ability to stretch the defense, and would provide some team a possible WR1 or an elite WR2.

3. Bryant Johnson (6′3″, 213 pounds, 26 years old) – What’s all the fuss over a receiver who never caught more than 49 passes or 740 yards? Well, Johnson isn’t your typical part timer. He was a 1st round pick with excellent size; and he’s spent most of his career playing behind Anquan Boldin and Larry Fitzgerald. When he’s been given a chance to start, Johnson has performed at a high level and could easily be a 1,000-yard receiver as a focal point in the right system. On top of that, he’s only 26 years old despite being in the league for five seasons already.

4. D.J. Hackett (6′2″, 208 pounds, 26 years old) — Hackett hasn’t done enough to warrant a big free agent contract from anyone other than the Seahawks, his incumbent team. When healthy, Hackett has looked the part of a #1 option in the West Coast offense. Unfortunately, he hasn’t stayed healthy. The most likely scenario is for Hackett to re-sign with Seattle; but other teams will test the waters.

5. Donte Stallworth (6′0″, 200 pounds, 27 years old) — Hard to believe Donte Stallworth is only 27 years old, but such is the case for the speedy receiver that’s about to land on his fourth team in seven seasons. After four decent but inconsistent seasons in New Orleans, Stallworth was traded to the Eagles in 2006 and signed by New England in 2007. Unfortunately for Stallworth, the Patriots declined their option on Stallworth (further proof that they’ve already secretly re-signed Randy Moss). Expect Stallworth to want the security of a multi-year deal; and given his age and speed attributes, he’ll get it.

6. Andre’ Davis (6′1″, 195 pounds, 28 years old) — Davis has bounced around the league (Cleveland to New England to Buffalo to Houston) and never started more than 8 games. However, he played surprisingly well during Andre Johnson’s stint on the injured list and has earned a chance to latch on as a contributor somewhere.

7. Ernest Wilford (6′4″, 218 pounds, 29 years old) – Wilford’s numbers don’t jump out at you (45 receptions, 518 yards, 3 TDs) but he was the Jaguars most consistent receiver and his numbers were stymied by an extremely conservative game plan. It’s unclear whether Wilford would flourish in a more pass-happy attack or be exposed by it; yet with his size and experience, don’t be surprised if some team invests in him with an eye toward finding out.

8. Jerry Porter (6′2″, 220 pounds, 29 years old) – Porter seemed destined to be the latest Raider stuck in Al Davis’ dog house after being a complete non-factor in 2006. But under new coach Lane Kiffin, he worked his way back to prominence and started all 16 games, netting 705 yards and 6 TDs. Porter has an opt-out clause in his contract, and will try to earn a multi-year deal with a contender.

9. Justin Gage (6′4″, 212 pounds, 26 years old) — The Titans were desperate for one of their young WR cadre to break out of the pack and establish himself as a potential long-term starter. Few would’ve guessed that receiver would be Justin Gage. After four uneventful years in Chicago, Gage worked his way up the depth chart in Tennesse and finished the year with 55 catches, 750 yards and 2 TDs. The Titans have already begun negotiations on a new contract; so don’t expect Gage to go elsewhere.

10. Muhsin Muhammad (6′2″, 215 pounds, 34 years old) — Muhammad has 12 seasons under his belt and will assuredly find interest from a number of teams looking for a veteran presence to put them over the top. His three seasons in Chicago fell short of expectations, but he’s a sure handed, smart, reliable player that will garner significant interest.

11. Marty Booker (6′0″, 210 pounds, 31 years old) — Booker was part of the mass exodus under new Dolphins Team President Bill Parcells; but he can still contribute. While not a WR1 (was he ever really?), Booker has caught 50 or more passes six of the last seven seasons; despite a revolving stable of quarterbacks and offensive schemes.

12. David Patten (5′10″, 190 pounds, 33 years old) – Patten is a tried and true journeyman. Five teams in eleven years, with varying degrees of success. Working in Patten’s favor is his resurgent 2007 season (54 receptions, 792 yards and 3 TDs in only five starts) although teams will find it hard to look past his terrible showing in Washington or his suboptimal age and height.

The (Near) Complete List

Player Name Status 2007 Team 2008 Team

Bryant Johnson UFA ARZ

Devard Darling UFA BAL

Sam Aiken UFA BUF

Keary Colbert UFA CAR

Drew Carter UFA CAR

Bernard Berrian UFA CHI

Antonio Chatman UFA CIN

Marcus Robinson UFA DET

Troy Walters UFA DET

Andre Davis UFA HOU

Aaron Moorehead UFA IND

Ernest Wilford UFA JAX

Eddie Drummond UFA KC

Samie Parker UFA KC

Robert Ferguson UFA MIN

Donte Stallworth UFA NE

Jabar Gaffney UFA NE

Randy Moss UFA NE

Troy Brown UFA NE

David Patten UFA NO

Devery Henderson UFA NO

Terrance Copper UFA NO

Tim Carter UFA CLE

Doug Gabriel UFA OAK

Jerry Porter UFA OAK

Tim Dwight UFA OAK

D.J. Hackett UFA SEA

Bryan Gilmore UFA SF

Michael Lewis UFA SF

Eric Moulds UFA TEN

Justin Gage UFA TEN

Keenan McCardell UFA WAS

Reche Caldwell UFA WAS

Ahmad Merritt RFA ARZ

Jerheme Urban RFA ARZ

Rashied Davis RFA CHI

Tab Perry RFA CIN

Jerome Mathis RFA HOU

Chris Davis RFA MIA

Chris McFoy RFA OAK

Nate Washington RFA PIT

Malcom Floyd RFA SD

B.J. Johnson RFA TB

Chad Lucas RFA TB

Mark Jones RFA TB

Paris Warren RFA TB

Jamin Elliott Released ATL

Peerless Price Released BUF

Muhsin Muhammad Released CHI

Carlton Brewster Released DEN

Marty Booker Released MIA

 

[Jason Wood]

Bump...no thoughts on the WR free agency picture?!?!?

 

[Beaumont]

Bump...no thoughts on the WR free agency picture?!?!?

Great article. I think the FA crop is pretty poor past Moss. I think there will be a few relatively mediocre players that hit paydirt (Andre Davis?) due to the overall blechness of this class ...http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...p;#entry8219113

 

[gman8343]

Great list and breakdown, Jason.

The guy who intrigues me is Bryant Johnson, who I think could be under the radar in many leagues. If he lands in the right spot, he could become a nice possession reciever and has the size to be a decent red zone target. I was a bit surprised you ranked him above Stallworth and Hackett - I hope you're right on his talent and potential.

 

[Jason Wood]

Great list and breakdown, Jason.The guy who intrigues me is Bryant Johnson, who I think could be under the radar in many leagues. If he lands in the right spot, he could become a nice possession receiver and has the size to be a decent red zone target. I was a bit surprised you ranked him above Stallworth and Hackett - I hope you're right on his talent and potential.

They're fairly tightly grouped but Stallworth is older and been on a bunch of teams, and it's tough for a rational GM to look at the fact the Eagles and Patriots chose not to keep him after one season and then think THEY should. To me, Johnson not only has the pedigree, but he played behind two uber stud receivers and I think WILL get starters money and years from someone. Hackett I need to be sold on; the Seahawks receiving corps was among the worst last year (most drops, among the worst in YAC) and he just can't stay healthy.

 

[jeter23]

Assuming Moss goes back to NE, this is a really ugly group. Even though none of these guys would be a #1 on a playoff team IMO, a couple of these guys will really get overpaid based on the many teams that need WR help and how many teams have money to spend. If I heard correctly, there are 10 teams that are more than 30 million under the cap.

 

[Guinis72]

As a Skins fan, I'd love to see them try to bring in Hackett to pair with S Moss. He has way more talent than any of their WR2's and will be able to help teach Zorn's offense.

Andre Davis was a feel good story for HOU this year after they signed him off the street. I could see both being happy about signing a 2-3 yr deal to go along with Walter and Jacoby.

I've been keeping an eye on Malcom Floyd over the last couple years and think he may be an interesting sleeper if he ends up in a good situation.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

As always, Woodrow skillfully sets the scene...

I can see why the Vikes would be going hard after Berrian. He's at his best with a QB who can outthrow the deep safety's range, because Berrian seems to effortlessly run under the deep ball - Tarvaris has considerable arm strength and Berrian would allow Rice the chance to do some damage over the middle. Teams that ask Berrian to be a true #1 might be disappointed. He's got the willingness to go over the middle and do the dirty work, but he won't hold up long in that role.

I agree that a team will make Johnson a starter - he's a big WR with better than average physical tools for a guy his size. The Cards might have reached for him - but he's got NFL starter ability.

Some team should be willing to take a chance on Hackett. He did get injured twice last year and missed significant time, but he is the closest to a true #1 of anyone not named Moss in this group. He can get deep, he's got the size and courage to make big plays in the air, and he's got the my ball mentality. He will outperform what should be a modest contract, even if he gets injured as frequently as he did last year.

Davis really opened my eyes last year. His deep ball tracking and high wire act put on a show, and any team should be happy to add him as a #3 that can make the big play, and maybe outperform the #2 before it's all said and done. Berrian, Johnson, and Hackett are getting more attention, but Davis could be the best performer of the FAs not named Moss when the dust settles.

The last guy that stands out to me is Wilford. I dont think he'll ever be consistent enough to be a starter, but his size and ability to make the tough catch (especially in the red zone) will make him a welcome addition to just about any passing attack. He's another one that a team may sign to play a narrow role, but he'll earn more opportunity during his stint. If he can settle down and make the routine plays with ease, he could be the surprise of this FA class.

 

[Max Power]

"Berrian is believed to be seeking a whopper of a contract: more than $20million over the first three years of a deal"

That is a lot of cash for a one trick pony.

 

[Max Power]

Fun read from ROTO:

0. Randy Moss, Patriots - Since everyone in the league seems to agree he's not actually available, let's not waste too much time here.

Prediction: Patriots, three years, $25 million.

1. D.J. Hackett, Seahawks - He doesn't have the production of players below, but Hackett is the only potential "number one" receiver available. In seven full games in 2007, he topped 100 yards three times with four touchdowns. He'll come cheaply and fits well in a West Coast offense. He can go deep and be a physical receiver over the middle; the main concern is durability.

And if you think I'm letting my man-love for Hackett blind me, Scout.com also calls him and Bernard Berrian the top two free agent wideouts. So there! Any West Coast team like the Vikings, Eagles, and Redskins should go hard after him. Seattle will also do their best to keep him.

Prediction: Redskins, $13 million guaranteed.

2. Bernard Berrian, Bears - Berrian hits home runs. He may not be a complete receiver, but he's the best deep threat by far available and should get the biggest contract at his position. Berrian is a solid number two with potential for a string of 1,000-yard seasons.

I see him as a vertical threat that would best fit outside of a West Coast system, although Washington, Denver, and Tampa are rumored to be interested. Buffalo, Tennessee, San Francisco, Oakland, and Miami all make some sense. I don't think the Bears will pay him enough.

The Raiders love speed and Berrian grew up near there, so we'll have him replace Jerry Porter. They are usually good for a surprise or three.

Prediction: Raiders, $14 million guaranteed

3. Jerry Porter, Raiders - Quietly enjoyed a nice comeback season, making a lot of tough grabs on a terrible offense. He can start, but isn't fast in the open field and has some off-field baggage. He could be one of the most dominant slot receivers in the league, but his contract will pay him to be a red zone beast and starter. Tampa and Minnesota both could use a physical threat and are desperate for receiver help.

Prediction: Vikings, $10 guaranteed

4. Donte Stallworth, Patriots - Nikko's alter ego has great after-catch ability, but three teams have given up on him in two years. He's a piece to the puzzle, but not the corner piece. Tennessee could use a weapon for Vince Young and showed strong interest in Stallworth last season.

Prediction: Titans, $ 9 million guaranteed

5. Bryant Johnson, Cardinals - Former first-round pick can step out of his teammates' shadows, but would best be used as a number three. His speed is overrated, but his ability to make tough grabs in traffic shined in 2006. He hasn't been able to put together consistent seasons, but he's talented enough to help a roster. He's on the borderline between a starter and a third receiver.

Prediction: Bears, $8 million guaranteed

6. Ernest Wilford, Jaguars - Rugged third receiver can block well and be a red zone factor. He won't blow anyone away with big plays, but he can improve a thin rotation. Buffalo could use some toughness and depth at the position.

Prediction: Bills, $7 million guaranteed

7. Marty Booker, Dolphins - Younger than you think (31), and always stuck with terrible quarterbacks. Booker is an intelligent veteran who can fit right in with a complex offense. New England, Tennessee, Dallas, and Minnesota are possibilities.

Prediction: Cowboys, $6 million guaranteed

8. Devery Henderson, Saints - Blinding speed has teased two Saints staffs who learned he has hands of concrete.

Prediction: Broncos, $3 million guaranteed

9. Muhsin Muhammad, Bears - If Chicago doesn't want him, no one should.

Prediction: Panthers, $4 million guaranteed

10. Jabar Gaffney, Patriots - They don't pay you big bucks for blocking, which means Gaffney is unlikely to get great interest around the league. Some Patriot-like teams (Jets, Browns, Dolphins) could look at him as a role player, but we'll keep him in New England.

Prediction: Patriots, $2 million

11. Nate Washington, Steelers (Restricted) - The Steelers better put a second-round tender on Washington, because he has excellent physical skills and they have spent a lot of time developing him.

Prediction: Steelers, Second-round tender

12. Andre Davis, Texans - Revived his career with great special teams play and surprisingly solid run as a starter while Andre Johnson was hurt.

Prediction: Bucs, $4 million guaranteed

13. Justin Gage, Titans - Enjoyed the best stretch of a lackluster career with Tennessee, but has more value to the Titans than other teams.

Prediction: Titans, $5 million guaranteed

The Best of the Rest

Keary Colbert, Panthers - The spark went out in Carolina, but Colbert's great rookie season is proof there is talent in there somewhere.

David Patten, Saints - The product of a great system.

Drew Carter, Panthers - He can run straight lines real fast, but the NFL requires subtler skills.

Kelley Washington, Patriots - Special teams dynamo is likely to leave the Patriots.

Reche Caldwell, Redskins - New England's leading receiver in 2006, which feels like a long time ago.

Eric Moulds, Titans - Great career dwindling to an end.

Samie Parker, Chiefs - Had years of opportunity in Kansas City, but never took advantage.

The Rest

Tim Carter, Terrance Copper, Doug Gabriel, Az-Zahir Hakim, Jerome Mathis, Marcus Robinson, Devard Darling, Robert Ferguson, Tab Perry, Sam Aiken, Aaron Moorehead

Possible releases

Darrell Jackson, 49ers - Not sure how he fits in a Mike Martz system. That draft day trade isn't looking like a steal anymore.

Isaac Bruce, Rams - Probably will remain in St. Louis because he's shown he can still play. If not, Martz would bring him to San Francisco.

Joe Horn, Falcons - I'd guess his career is over.

Troy Williamson, Vikings - He's allowed to seek a trade, but look for the Vikings to eventually release him.

Brandon Lloyd, Redskins - Will have more time to work on aspiring rap career.

Terry Glenn, Cowboys - Status of his knee has clouded Glenn's future.

Trade Candidates

Javon Walker, Broncos - The Bucs have already shown interest. Walker's price tag will depend on the results of his physical. Rumors have swirled that his knee may require microfracture surgery. A release is more likely.

Chad Johnson, Bengals - Marvin Lewis says he's holding on to Ocho Cinco, but a draft pick bounty could change his mind.

Roy Williams, Lions - Detroit appears to be tired of waiting for Williams to "get it" although he'd have no shortage of suitors if available.

 

[Brutis]

My top 5 FA Wr's:

1. Bryant Johnson

2. Donte Stallworth

3. DJ Hackett

4. Bernard Berrian

5. Jerry Porter

 

[Chadstroma]

I really think Berrian is getting way too much love.

 

[Jason Wood]

I really think Berrian is getting way too much love.

I'm not 100% sold on Berrian, but I do think he'll get the biggest contract outside of Moss in this free agent pool. I think teams will look at his obvious physical gifts and consider the less-than-ideal conditions of playing in Chicago (both b/c of the weather conditions and the QB situation) and project him as a high upside WR2.

 

[Max Power]

I really think Berrian is getting way too much love.

I'm not 100% sold on Berrian, but I do think he'll get the biggest contract outside of Moss in this free agent pool. I think teams will look at his obvious physical gifts and consider the less-than-ideal conditions of playing in Chicago (both b/c of the weather conditions and the QB situation) and project him as a high upside WR2.

very true, but he wants to be paid like a top 10-15 guy

 

[Jason Wood]

I really think Berrian is getting way too much love.

I'm not 100% sold on Berrian, but I do think he'll get the biggest contract outside of Moss in this free agent pool. I think teams will look at his obvious physical gifts and consider the less-than-ideal conditions of playing in Chicago (both b/c of the weather conditions and the QB situation) and project him as a high upside WR2.

very true, but he wants to be paid like a top 10-15 guy

Yeah...but so have a lot of other guys. Remember when Plaxico Burress left Pittsburgh and visited New York right away; only to leave and visit a bunch of other teams. The Giants held steady and got him for a song (in retrospect). I don't think Berrian has done ENOUGH that teams will look to break the bank.The one thing I think the Roto article forgets, is that the reported contracts by and large are going to seem enormous. With the rapid escalation of the salary cap and so many teams with $20, $30 even $40mm under the cap; the 2008 contracts are going to seem monstrous in some cases when, in reality, it's just the new going rate.

 

[Weiner Dog]

If I'm a GM and I need a deep threat to stretch the field, I would look in the mirror and say, "Why should I pay big $$$ for Berrian when I can get the poor-man's version of him with Stallworth at 1/2 the cost?!?!"

 

[Jason Wood]

If I'm a GM and I need a deep threat to stretch the field, I would look in the mirror and say, "Why should I pay big $$$ for Berrian when I can get the poor-man's version of him with Stallworth at 1/2 the cost?!?!"

Well, presumably a GM would consider Berrian more than a deep threat. You wouldn't pay Berrian that kind of scratch if you thought he was one-dimensional.

 

[Weiner Dog]

If I'm a GM and I need a deep threat to stretch the field, I would look in the mirror and say, "Why should I pay big $$$ for Berrian when I can get the poor-man's version of him with Stallworth at 1/2 the cost?!?!"

Well, presumably a GM would consider Berrian more than a deep threat. You wouldn't pay Berrian that kind of scratch if you thought he was one-dimensional.

True. However, Berrian has not shown he's more than a deep threat.

 

[Couch Potato]

The guy whose 2008 season I'm really interested to see is Bryant Johnson. Drafted ahead of Boldin (1st and 2nd rounders in 2003) but clearly not measuring up to his teammate from day 1, then falling to WR3 with Fitz coming along in 2004, he's never lived up to his draft slot.

It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later, but now after 5 years in the league it's possible that Johnson has matured as a receiver enough to come out of the shadow of Boldin/Fitz and really shine somewhere else.

Or he may just be a guy who will always be OK but never a team's WR1 or even a solid WR2. I'm curious to find out how he does now with a new opportunity and some experience under his belt.

 

[Jason Wood]

The guy whose 2008 season I'm really interested to see is Bryant Johnson. Drafted ahead of Boldin (1st and 2nd rounders in 2003) but clearly not measuring up to his teammate from day 1, then falling to WR3 with Fitz coming along in 2004, he's never lived up to his draft slot. It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later, but now after 5 years in the league it's possible that Johnson has matured as a receiver enough to come out of the shadow of Boldin/Fitz and really shine somewhere else. Or he may just be a guy who will always be OK but never a team's WR1 or even a solid WR2. I'm curious to find out how he does now with a new opportunity and some experience under his belt.

I like him a lot, too. One of the things that sets him apart from the other FAs is his versatility. The guy has good size, can run a nice crossing route, can get deep on most DBs and has improved his concentration after lapses early in his career. On top of it all, he's only 26 years old; you don't find many guys with five years into the league that are only 26. He's one of the few FAs I could see earning every penny of a 5-year deal.

 

[Chadstroma]

If I'm a GM and I need a deep threat to stretch the field, I would look in the mirror and say, "Why should I pay big $$$ for Berrian when I can get the poor-man's version of him with Stallworth at 1/2 the cost?!?!"

Well, presumably a GM would consider Berrian more than a deep threat. You wouldn't pay Berrian that kind of scratch if you thought he was one-dimensional.

True. However, Berrian has not shown he's more than a deep threat.

I watched most of the Bear's games last year and either that is all that he is or that is the only way the Bear's tried to use him. He really seemed to me a guy that has speed but has not developed into an all around WR. I understand Jason's position of not being sold on him but expecting some team to cough up a good chunk of cash for him. I hope that that team will not be my Raider's but with their love of speed, I think that is a real possibility.

 

[Weiner Dog]

The guy whose 2008 season I'm really interested to see is Bryant Johnson. Drafted ahead of Boldin (1st and 2nd rounders in 2003) but clearly not measuring up to his teammate from day 1, then falling to WR3 with Fitz coming along in 2004, he's never lived up to his draft slot. It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later, but now after 5 years in the league it's possible that Johnson has matured as a receiver enough to come out of the shadow of Boldin/Fitz and really shine somewhere else. Or he may just be a guy who will always be OK but never a team's WR1 or even a solid WR2. I'm curious to find out how he does now with a new opportunity and some experience under his belt.

I agree this will be interesting, but I surely hope an NFL team does not pin their '08 hopes on experimenting with BJ as a #1. Hopefully, he's brought to a team with a young WR corp where he can be the #2 guy. Off the top of my head...MIABALTCLE and MIN could be options as well, but I don't think he would complement Edwards and Rice as a #2.

 

[Jason Wood]

The guy whose 2008 season I'm really interested to see is Bryant Johnson. Drafted ahead of Boldin (1st and 2nd rounders in 2003) but clearly not measuring up to his teammate from day 1, then falling to WR3 with Fitz coming along in 2004, he's never lived up to his draft slot. It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later, but now after 5 years in the league it's possible that Johnson has matured as a receiver enough to come out of the shadow of Boldin/Fitz and really shine somewhere else. Or he may just be a guy who will always be OK but never a team's WR1 or even a solid WR2. I'm curious to find out how he does now with a new opportunity and some experience under his belt.

I agree this will be interesting, but I surely hope an NFL team does not pin their '08 hopes on experimenting with BJ as a #1. Hopefully, he's brought to a team with a young WR corp where he can be the #2 guy. Off the top of my head...MIABALTCLE and MIN could be options as well, but I don't think he would complement Edwards and Rice as a #2.

I've said for two seasons that the Eagles should go after him. McNabb wants weapons, the Eagles don't want to break the bank on them. Johnson is accustomed to the West Coast offense; is young, and won't come with the price tag that Berrian is seeking. I would if the Eagles surprise me and bring him in; but somehow I doubt it will happen

 

[Weiner Dog]

The guy whose 2008 season I'm really interested to see is Bryant Johnson. Drafted ahead of Boldin (1st and 2nd rounders in 2003) but clearly not measuring up to his teammate from day 1, then falling to WR3 with Fitz coming along in 2004, he's never lived up to his draft slot. It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later, but now after 5 years in the league it's possible that Johnson has matured as a receiver enough to come out of the shadow of Boldin/Fitz and really shine somewhere else. Or he may just be a guy who will always be OK but never a team's WR1 or even a solid WR2. I'm curious to find out how he does now with a new opportunity and some experience under his belt.

I agree this will be interesting, but I surely hope an NFL team does not pin their '08 hopes on experimenting with BJ as a #1. Hopefully, he's brought to a team with a young WR corp where he can be the #2 guy. Off the top of my head...MIABALTCLE and MIN could be options as well, but I don't think he would complement Edwards and Rice as a #2.

I've said for two seasons that the Eagles should go after him. McNabb wants weapons, the Eagles don't want to break the bank on them. Johnson is accustomed to the West Coast offense; is young, and won't come with the price tag that Berrian is seeking. I would if the Eagles surprise me and bring him in; but somehow I doubt it will happen

Good call on the Eagles. Curtis and Brown are not youngsters, but they're also different receivers than BJ. Could be a good fit and (finally) a red-zone target for McNabb (...cough...cough...Kolb).

 

[Jason Wood]

The guy whose 2008 season I'm really interested to see is Bryant Johnson. Drafted ahead of Boldin (1st and 2nd rounders in 2003) but clearly not measuring up to his teammate from day 1, then falling to WR3 with Fitz coming along in 2004, he's never lived up to his draft slot. It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later, but now after 5 years in the league it's possible that Johnson has matured as a receiver enough to come out of the shadow of Boldin/Fitz and really shine somewhere else. Or he may just be a guy who will always be OK but never a team's WR1 or even a solid WR2. I'm curious to find out how he does now with a new opportunity and some experience under his belt.

I agree this will be interesting, but I surely hope an NFL team does not pin their '08 hopes on experimenting with BJ as a #1. Hopefully, he's brought to a team with a young WR corp where he can be the #2 guy. Off the top of my head...MIABALTCLE and MIN could be options as well, but I don't think he would complement Edwards and Rice as a #2.

I've said for two seasons that the Eagles should go after him. McNabb wants weapons, the Eagles don't want to break the bank on them. Johnson is accustomed to the West Coast offense; is young, and won't come with the price tag that Berrian is seeking. I would if the Eagles surprise me and bring him in; but somehow I doubt it will happen

Good call on the Eagles. Curtis and Brown are not youngsters, but they're also different receivers than BJ. Could be a good fit and (finally) a red-zone target for McNabb (...cough...cough...Kolb).

Curtis and Brown are 29 and 27, respectively, so it's not like they're age is a deciding factor relative to signing any of the available FAs (Johnson is the youngest at 26).But yes, I'm convinced he could help the team. The one concern would be if BJ was unwilling to even consider Philly, I doubt he would sign with a team that didn't have a clear opening at one of its starting positions.

 

[Couch Potato]

Jason, as a Philly fan maybe you can answer this one.

I was reading some Philly online paper or blog or something recently (I don't remember where), and it was suggested that the Eagles might want to bring Stallworth back. That kind of surprised me. I don't know if this was just the writer's opinion or whether someone in the team's organization has said something to that effect.

Did he leave there on good terms? IIRC, he went to PHI on a one-year deal and then moved on for a bigger paycheck, but I don't know the reasons the Eagles weren't that interested in keeping him, choosing to get Curtis instead. Now, with Curtis and Brown there, would Stallworth even be looked at by them?

 

[Jason Wood]

Jason, as a Philly fan maybe you can answer this one.I was reading some Philly online paper or blog or something recently (I don't remember where), and it was suggested that the Eagles might want to bring Stallworth back. That kind of surprised me. I don't know if this was just the writer's opinion or whether someone in the team's organization has said something to that effect. Did he leave there on good terms? IIRC, he went to PHI on a one-year deal and then moved on for a bigger paycheck, but I don't know the reasons the Eagles weren't that interested in keeping him, choosing to get Curtis instead. Now, with Curtis and Brown there, would Stallworth even be looked at by them?

I've read the reports and they, like most things right now, are pure speculation/conjecture on the part of the beat writer concerned. Stallworth is an interesting situation because the Eagles gambled on him and lost. They offered him a low-ball deal and told him it would be there for him after he went out and looked elsewhere. No other team was willing to bite, but he took the Pats deal instead.

 

[dmac37]

If I'm a GM and I need a deep threat to stretch the field, I would look in the mirror and say, "Why should I pay big $$$ for Berrian when I can get the poor-man's version of him with Stallworth at 1/2 the cost?!?!"

Well, presumably a GM would consider Berrian more than a deep threat. You wouldn't pay Berrian that kind of scratch if you thought he was one-dimensional.

True. However, Berrian has not shown he's more than a deep threat.

As a Berrian owner I gathered as much information and watched him whenever I could this past year. Pre season report was that he owned all the Bears top DB's, considered top DB's in the league at the time. Downside were the dropped balls, not nearly as bad as TO, but he must improve. He also developed into a great red zone target, made some spectacular TD catches, not just a deep threat. The Bears offense was a mess last year, he could really bust out in a real NFL offense.

 

[Couch Potato]

11. Marty Booker (6′0″, 210 pounds, 31 years old) — Booker was part of the mass exodus under new Dolphins Team President Bill Parcells; but he can still contribute. While not a WR1 (was he ever really?), Booker has caught 50 or more passes six of the last seven seasons; despite a revolving stable of quarterbacks and offensive schemes.

The (Near) Complete List

Player Name Status 2007 Team 2008 Team

Keenan McCardell UFA WAS

If Booker signs with DAL (and I'm reading this is a good possibility right now) and Glenn can't make it back with the knee, Marty could be the most productive of this FA group in PPR leagues (not counting Moss of course). I could see 60+ catches in that offense as a complement to TO.Re: MCcardell -- can a guy be a member of NFLPA and AARP at the same time? This guy was the oldest WR in the league last year, and he's now looking to play an 18th year. Wow.

 

[Sigmund Bloom]

It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later

I think that Fitzgerald's singular physical talent + Denny Green's history with him made him a slam dunk pick as the new franchise - I dont think Johnson's development (or lack thereof) played much into that decision.

 

[Couch Potato]

It's reasonable to say that ARI didn't feel they got what they were hoping for from a 1st round pick or they wouldn't have drafted Fitz a year later

I think that Fitzgerald's singular physical talent + Denny Green's history with him made him a slam dunk pick as the new franchise - I dont think Johnson's development (or lack thereof) played much into that decision.

That's a good point. He really was too good to pass up at the time, esp. with the Green connection. It sure killed what was left of Johnson's value though. :2003 Johnson drafter raising hand:

 

[Cecil Lammey]

The Broncos are looking to add a free agent receiver opposite Brandon Marshall. Currently they are considering Bernard Berrian and Bryant Johnson. Johnson may be the one they're after because they feel that he will come at a much cheaper price than Berrian.

 

[Bri]

Wilford gettin' out of dodge is a big deal. Jason alluded to his size, he's a good sized WR. I think he's the prize here.

Mathis won't be tenderred a contract, may even get released. He's a UFA anyday now.

Carter is CLE not NYG, Savage may offer him a cheap contract. He's got the goods but is always hurt. Broke into #3 role with them.

Comments on Gaffney Jason?

Hackett, Davis, and Johnson have all had their moments but are quite inconsistent. I can roll with the weak market= big money theory, but I don't think they land big deals. Personally I think Houston is silly if they let Andre walk. He was the perfect sub and that's not easy to find.

I like Nate Washington, I hope some team offers up the pick compensation for him and gives him a chance.

Devery Henderson will have some FFers overvaluing him, counting the days til that happens

Amazing that the last so many years the cream of the WR FA class is 700 yard guys. Odd stat.

 

[Ron_Mexico]

It's definitely a great year to be a UFA WR.

This list is loaded with "has beens" and "never will be's".

 

[Kiddnets]

If Jets deal Lav Coles as the rumor mill states I can see them going after Bryant Johnson to team with Cotchery - has the height and will not need to break the bank.

As a JEt fan - trade Coles for a late 2nd rder, sign Bryant, draft a speed WR in the 3rd or 4th rd to stretch he field and I would be happy

 

[redman]

Jason, as a Philly fan maybe you can answer this one.I was reading some Philly online paper or blog or something recently (I don't remember where), and it was suggested that the Eagles might want to bring Stallworth back. That kind of surprised me. I don't know if this was just the writer's opinion or whether someone in the team's organization has said something to that effect. Did he leave there on good terms? IIRC, he went to PHI on a one-year deal and then moved on for a bigger paycheck, but I don't know the reasons the Eagles weren't that interested in keeping him, choosing to get Curtis instead. Now, with Curtis and Brown there, would Stallworth even be looked at by them?

I've read the reports and they, like most things right now, are pure speculation/conjecture on the part of the beat writer concerned. Stallworth is an interesting situation because the Eagles gambled on him and lost. They offered him a low-ball deal and told him it would be there for him after he went out and looked elsewhere. No other team was willing to bite, but he took the Pats deal instead.

I, too, think Stallworth to the Eagles makes loads of sense, but I have no feel for the personal dynamics there (bad blood?).

 

[FUBAR]

It's definitely a great year to be a UFA WR.This list is loaded with "has beens" and "never will be's".

and there aren't top-notch WRs in the draft to fall back to.