Go cats RB (1 Viewer)

[gocats]

RB’s:

1. LJ

2. SA

3. LT

4. Portis

5. Tiki Barber

6. Jordan

7. Reggie Bush

8. Jackson

9. Brown

10. Caddy

11. Rudi

12. Parker

13. TJ

14. Droughns

15. Davis

16. McGahee

17. E. James

18. Cmart

19. Dunn

20. Westbrook

21. F. Taylor

22. D.Williams

23. JJ

24. C. Taylor

25. Dillon

26. Dayne

27. Foster

28. Kevin Jones

29. J. Lewis

30. D. Rhodes

31. Chris Brown

32. L. White

Editted thanks for the help on the corrections

 

[Finatic]

You have Dillon listed twice.(20 and 25)........

 

[aposulli]

You have Dillon twice and you're missing James

 

[gocats]

Sorry guys give me a second, pasting these from excel

 

[KnowledgeReignsSupreme]

You have Dillon listed twice.(20 and 25)........

He's that good.

 

[TLEF316]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

 

[gocats]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

Bush = 1350 yds 7 tds 400 rec 2 Tds James = 1050 5 Tds 200 rec 1 Td

 

[ThisGuy]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

Bush = 1350 yds 7 tds 400 rec 2 Tds James = 1050 5 Tds 200 rec 1 Td

Did Edge get hurt?

 

[-OZ-]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

Bush = 1350 yds 7 tds 400 rec 2 Tds James = 1050 5 Tds 200 rec 1 Td

Predicting an injury for Edge, or expect Green to unerutilize the RB they paid a lot of $ to?

 

[gocats]

Reasons for his low ranking:

o One of the worst offensive lines in the league

o there isn't going to be a lot of 2nd half rushing yards/touchdowns for Edge, which is what he really capitalized on last year.

o He will struggle getting touches with Boldin and Fitz to throw too, not to mention Pope and Johnson.

o Misses an average of 3 games per season with injury last 5 years

 

[helix]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

Bush = 1350 yds 7 tds 400 rec 2 Tds James = 1050 5 Tds 200 rec 1 Td

I think you have the 2 reversed.

There is no way the Saints will give Bush enough carries to see 1400 yards. 1K would be a nice 1st season. I also smell a holdout which will hurt his progression.

 

[Roc Pile]

didnt check the stats but arent the only games edge has missed since coming back from knee surgery are the week 17 games... when the clinched

 

[TLEF316]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

Bush = 1350 yds 7 tds 400 rec 2 Tds James = 1050 5 Tds 200 rec 1 Td

credibilityedge could score 5 Td's with me at left guard

 

[KnowledgeReignsSupreme]

didnt check the stats but arent the only games edge has missed since coming back from knee surgery are the week 17 games... when the clinched

He was out with a back injury for like three games two years post ACL also.

 

[FunkyPlutos]

I think Deuce will outscore Bush.

 

[Ned]

I think Deuce will outscore Bush.

 

[MLBrandow]

I'd bump DeAngelo williams up into the top 10 or 12...

 

[MagicMan]

Too horrible to even critique.

 

[Pickle Rody]

RB’s:

1. LJ

2. SA

3. LT

4. Portis

5. Tiki Barber

6. Jordan

7. Reggie Bush

8. Jackson

9. Brown

10. Caddy

11. Rudi

12. Parker

13. TJ

14. Droughns

15. Davis

16. McGahee

17. E. James

18. Cmart

19. Dunn

20. Westbrook

21. F. Taylor

22. D.Williams

23. JJ

24. C. Taylor

25. Dillon

26. Dayne

27. Foster

28. Kevin Jones

29. D. Rhodes

30. Chris Brown

31. Deuce McCallister 

Editted thanks for the help on the corrections

I'm not so sure about this ranking list......NO WAY Bush makes it up to 7th this year. Drop him to 17th. Bump Jackson, Brown & Caddy up one each.

Bump Edge up to 10th. Drop Rudi, FWP, TJ, Droughns, Davis & Mcgahee one each. Fact is: each of these guys could finish anywhere from 11th to 16th IMO.

Edge will easily be top ten this year. I happen to like both Droughns and McGahee this year, but neither has a better year than Edge, sans injury.

I don't care much for the remainder of the list as any one of them has a chance to finish top 20. McAllister should be top fifteen also. Slip him in at 15 and drop Davis, McGahee and the rest of the bunch down another notch. While you are at it swap spots for the Taylor’s. Fred is not going to have a better year than Chester.

It will look like this:

1. LJ

2. SA

3. LT

4. Portis

5. Tiki Barber

6. Jordan

7. Jackson

8. Brown

9. Caddy

10. E. James

11. Rudi

12. Parker

13. T. Jones

14. Droughns

15. McAllister

16. Davis

17. McGahee

18. Reggie Bush

19. CMart

20. Dunn

21. Westbrook

22. C. Taylor

23. D. Williams

24. J. Jones

25. F. Taylor

26. Dillon

27. Dayne

28. Foster

29. K. Jones

30. D. Rhodes

31. Chris Brown

This is a more realistic list......BTW, top three are interchangable IMO.

Ruffrodys

 

[Blackjacks]

RB’s:

1. LJ

2. SA

3. LT

4. Portis

5. Tiki Barber

6. Jordan

7. Reggie Bush

8. Jackson

9. Brown

10. Caddy

11. Rudi

12. Parker

13. TJ

14. Droughns

15. Davis

16. McGahee

17. E. James

18. Cmart

19. Dunn

20. Westbrook

21. F. Taylor

22. D.Williams

23. JJ

24. C. Taylor

25. Dillon

26. Dayne

27. Foster

28. Kevin Jones

29. D. Rhodes

30. Chris Brown

31. Deuce McCallister

Editted thanks for the help on the corrections

I'm not so sure about this ranking list......NO WAY Bush makes it up to 7th this year. Drop him to 17th. Bump Jackson, Brown & Caddy up one each.

Bump Edge up to 10th. Drop Rudi, FWP, TJ, Droughns, Davis & Mcgahee one each. Fact is: each of these guys could finish anywhere from 11th to 16th IMO.

Edge will easily be top ten this year. I happen to like both Droughns and McGahee this year, but neither has a better year than Edge, sans injury.

I don't care much for the remainder of the list as any one of them has a chance to finish top 20. McAllister should be top fifteen also. Slip him in at 15 and drop Davis, McGahee and the rest of the bunch down another notch. While you are at it swap spots for the Taylor’s. Fred is not going to have a better year than Chester.

It will look like this:

1. LJ

2. SA

3. LT

4. Portis

5. Tiki Barber

6. Jordan

7. Jackson

8. Brown

9. Caddy

10. E. James

11. Rudi

12. Parker

13. T. Jones

14. Droughns

15. McAllister

16. Davis

17. McGahee

18. Reggie Brown

19. CMart

20. Dunn

21. Westbrook

22. C. Taylor

23. D. Williams

24. J. Jones

25. F. Taylor

26. Dillon

27. Dayne

28. Foster

29. K. Jones

30. D. Rhodes

31. Chris Brown

This is a more realistic list......BTW, top three are interchangable IMO.

Ruffrodys

So let me get this right, your correcting him and then you put a wr @ #18. Good job, let the guy have his rankings. You can't really tell someone their rankings are wrong. I also believe Edge finishes near 15 to 17 this year. It's not that crazy of a thought. Arizona's line is just that bad.

 

[thayman]

RB’s:

1. LJ

2. SA

3. LT

4. Portis

5. Tiki Barber

6. Jordan

7. Reggie Bush

8. Jackson

9. Brown

10. Caddy

11. Rudi

12. Parker

13. TJ

14. Droughns

15. Davis

16. McGahee

17. E. James

18. Cmart

19. Dunn

20. Westbrook

21. F. Taylor

22. D.Williams

23. JJ

24. C. Taylor

25. Dillon

26. Dayne

27. Foster

28. Kevin Jones

29. D. Rhodes

30. Chris Brown

31. Deuce McCallister 

Editted thanks for the help on the corrections

I'm not so sure about this ranking list......NO WAY Bush makes it up to 7th this year. Drop him to 17th. Bump Jackson, Brown & Caddy up one each.

Bump Edge up to 10th. Drop Rudi, FWP, TJ, Droughns, Davis & Mcgahee one each. Fact is: each of these guys could finish anywhere from 11th to 16th IMO.

Edge will easily be top ten this year. I happen to like both Droughns and McGahee this year, but neither has a better year than Edge, sans injury.

I don't care much for the remainder of the list as any one of them has a chance to finish top 20. McAllister should be top fifteen also. Slip him in at 15 and drop Davis, McGahee and the rest of the bunch down another notch. While you are at it swap spots for the Taylor’s. Fred is not going to have a better year than Chester.

It will look like this:

1. LJ

2. SA

3. LT

4. Portis

5. Tiki Barber

6. Jordan

7. Jackson

8. Brown

9. Caddy

10. E. James

11. Rudi

12. Parker

13. T. Jones

14. Droughns

15. McAllister

16. Davis

17. McGahee

18. Reggie Brown

19. CMart

20. Dunn

21. Westbrook

22. C. Taylor

23. D. Williams

24. J. Jones

25. F. Taylor

26. Dillon

27. Dayne

28. Foster

29. K. Jones

30. D. Rhodes

31. Chris Brown

This is a more realistic list......BTW, top three are interchangable IMO.

Ruffrodys

So let me get this right, your correcting him and then you put a wr @ #18. Good job, let the guy have his rankings. You can't really tell someone their rankings are wrong. I also believe Edge finishes near 15 to 17 this year. It's not that crazy of a thought. Arizona's line is just that bad.

 

[Pickle Rody]

So let me get this right, your correcting him and then you put a wr @ #18. Good job, let the guy have his rankings. You can't really tell someone their rankings are wrong. I also believe Edge finishes near 15 to 17 this year. It's not that crazy of a thought. Arizona's line is just that bad.

good catch , I'll correct that. I wasn't telling him his rankings were wrong, just giving my opinion. Kind of what I thought he was looking for, although GoCats didn't ask for it. If he did not care what other people thought he would not have posted his rankings.

 

[Blackjacks]

I will make a sigbet with anyone that wants to that Deuce isn't in the top 15 rb's this year.

 

[DoctorDetroit]

Just awful.

 

[kevthegrad]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

Bush = 1350 yds 7 tds 400 rec 2 Tds James = 1050 5 Tds 200 rec 1 Td

They aren't just going to sit McAllister. He's going to see 700 yrds at best this year, likely 500. With McAllister healthy he doesn't see the touches you're suggesting. He's going to be eased in. This isn't Shaun Alexander taking hte job from a tired Ricky Watters. McAllister is pretty young all things said.

 

[Slider]

I'll be in the minority here that thinks LJ, with and aging line and new coaches, is about 7.

 

[fsufan]

im no expert, but those are awful. Edge at 17, bush at 7. No chance

Bush = 1350 yds 7 tds 400 rec 2 Tds James = 1050 5 Tds 200 rec 1 Td

 

[joffer]

other than Bush and Dayne, I like it.

 

[DoubleG]

Jamal Lewis down?

I mean, I realize he had an off year, but he's the starting RB on a team that loves to run.

 

[Baracuda]

I'll be in the minority here that thinks LJ, with and aging line and new coaches, is about 7.

Slider, I fear this as well. I think LJ takes a step back this year, and thus, is modestly overvalued.

 

[Ron_Mexico]

This is the worst ranking list I have ever seen.