What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Had DHS called on me (1 Viewer)

snellman

Footballguy
I have 5 children (19,18,17,11, and 6). The 2 oldest are mine from previous marriage, the next 2 are wife's and the youngest is ours together. A week ago the 11 and 6 yr old were playing xbox and arguing like brothers do when the youngest one started crying pretty loud so I went to see what was going on. The 6 year old said that the 11 yr old punched him. At first the 11 yr old denied it but after more questioning he admitted to it and said he punched him because "he wasn't playing the game right, was annoying me, and wasn't listening to me." I punched the 11 yr old in the arm, asked him how it felt and if he would like me to punch him every time he didn't listen.

The 11 yr old bruises easily (you should see his legs in the summer, they are always black and blue) so we notice a bruise there later that night. Not a big deal or so I thought. Today, DHS calls and says they are investigating possible abuse that was reported by the school and want to know if they can talk to us. They have already talked to the 11 yr old and have to talk to the rest of the family. I say that is fine, I have nothing to hide. One of the questions they ask is how we discipline our children. We tell them that time outs, grounding and spanking. The person then proceeds to tell me that spanking is legal in the state of Iowa as long it is not done with foreign objects and does not injure. Needless to say, I was very :confused: because I did not know there was such a law.

My parents and grand parents could have been in huge trouble back in the day because I had the belt and yard stick used on me more than once. I understand that they are doing their job, but now I understand why our society is turning out the way it is.

 
It's probably not wise to post admissions to a potential crime on the internet.

 
You can raise perfectly well mannered, disciplined, respectful children without ever spanking them. Seriously. Spoil the rod and spoil the child is bull####. I know that may not sit well with the "that's not how I was raised up" crowd but it's the truth.

 
Forget the law, I am confused about why you punched your kid.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
You can raise perfectly well mannered, disciplined, respectful children without ever spanking them. Seriously. Spoil the rod and spoil the child is bull####. I know that may not sit well with the "that's not how I was raised up" crowd but it's the truth.
Yea, a spoiled rod will not help anyone in the end.

 
When they visit, be honest with what happened. They will be looking for signs of abuse and whether it's something that occurs regularly or a reason to feel that the child is at harm. Make it very clear that abuse is not something that happens in the home and you can see how the situation would be seen that way. They will likely schedule future visits and want contacts that are close to you that they can interview to see if there is any reason to investigate.

It really sucks to be called out as a possible bad parent. IMO, if everything went down exactly as described you should be in the clear. However, things are different from case to case and also very dependant on whom is working your case. I wish you the best of luck. In the meantime, try to find another way of getting the point across other than reciprocating the action.

 
You can raise perfectly well mannered, disciplined, respectful children without ever spanking them. Seriously. Spoil the rod and spoil the child is bull####. I know that may not sit well with the "that's not how I was raised up" crowd but it's the truth.
Yea, a spoiled rod will not help anyone in the end.
don't tell my wife that
LOL - I'm multi-tasking..Gimmee a break here. Spare the rod and spoil the child. I never say that so no wonder I messed it up..

 
We should unlock the "how many 11 year olds have you punched today" poll. That one was a hoot.

 
If you are worried about DHS always down your throat just take your anger out on your wife

Problem solved

 
How unfortunate that your 11 year old child bruises when you punch him.

Should be easy to explain. Next time you are punching your kid use a phone book.

 
I have 5 children (19,18,17,11, and 6). The 2 oldest are mine from previous marriage, the next 2 are wife's and the youngest is ours together. A week ago the 11 and 6 yr old were playing xbox and arguing like brothers do when the youngest one started crying pretty loud so I went to see what was going on. The 6 year old said that the 11 yr old punched him. At first the 11 yr old denied it but after more questioning he admitted to it and said he punched him because "he wasn't playing the game right, was annoying me, and wasn't listening to me." I punched the 11 yr old in the arm, asked him how it felt and if he would like me to punch him every time he didn't listen.

The 11 yr old bruises easily (you should see his legs in the summer, they are always black and blue) so we notice a bruise there later that night. Not a big deal or so I thought. Today, DHS calls and says they are investigating possible abuse that was reported by the school and want to know if they can talk to us. They have already talked to the 11 yr old and have to talk to the rest of the family. I say that is fine, I have nothing to hide. One of the questions they ask is how we discipline our children. We tell them that time outs, grounding and spanking. The person then proceeds to tell me that spanking is legal in the state of Iowa as long it is not done with foreign objects and does not injure. Needless to say, I was very :confused: because I did not know there was such a law.

My parents and grand parents could have been in huge trouble back in the day because I had the belt and yard stick used on me more than once. I understand that they are doing their job, but now I understand why our society is turning out the way it is.
Hey, Richard Cranium, you are the adult, and violence is never the answer. For your children's sake, get help.

 
Good lord....some things are too distasteful for humor. Child abuse is one of those things.
I dont think a shot in the arm is "child abuse"

If he winds up and causes seriously grief/harm, ok... but some ppl bruise just by breathing on them
Debatable but I'm talking about some of the comments that follow. If an adult punched my son in the arm and bruised him, I'd not be very happy.

 
Holy crap just realized the kid he punched wasnt even his own son.
Yikes. An adult punching the stepkid as retribution for acts towards the biological kid. Those are the type of facts that can potentially raise red flags at the Child Protective Services agencies.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top