Henry v Young (1 Viewer)

[gump]

Assume you are in a REDRAFT STANDARD SCORING league.

You can only keep 1 of the 2. You have to drop one tommorrow. And you will not be able to pick up the one you drop later.

Young - may be starter for at least weeks 9-16, looks good in brief time so far

Henry - obviously the better player, may play 1 month or longer, Young may end up in RBBC anyway

Is the answer of Young as obvious as it seems?

 

[thayman]

Depends on your team. If you need to make a push for the playoffs, then Henry's play over the next month can help. If you have a deep enough team, and are doing well, Young could be a very nice bonus come playoff time.

 

[spurs44]

Assume you are in a REDRAFT STANDARD SCORING league.You can only keep 1 of the 2. You have to drop one tommorrow. And you will not be able to pick up the one you drop later.Young - may be starter for at least weeks 9-16, looks good in brief time so farHenry - obviously the better player, may play 1 month or longer, Young may end up in RBBC anywayIs the answer of Young as obvious as it seems?

I understand and appreciate your poll but I think it's a bit premature to think that Young is going to replace Henry if he's suspended. It's more than likely a rbbc which I think will include Bell because of his experience. I think it would take at least a few weeks before any of the rb's win the pole position if at all.

 

[BeachBums]

I didn't own Henry in either of my leagues, but picked up Young in both. I think Young's value at this point is in trades to the Henry owner and anyone else (everyone) hurting at RB. Dealt Young and D. Bowe in one league for 85 and am trying to package Young in the other to the Henry owner for Brady.

 

[hellz_fireflies]

Depends on your team. If you need to make a push for the playoffs, then Henry's play over the next month can help. If you have a deep enough team, and are doing well, Young could be a very nice bonus come playoff time.

would of said same.

 

[taco breath]

young

 

[gump]

This shows how divided opinions are on this...although a small sample.

I think this is a toss up...too many unknowns.

 

[taco breath]

This shows how divided opinions are on this...although a small sample.I think this is a toss up...too many unknowns.

is this a team management question?

 

[gump]

This shows how divided opinions are on this...although a small sample.I think this is a toss up...too many unknowns.

is this a team management question?

It's a simple question of which back people value more going forward for '07 in this wild situation.I can't guage...and there is no consensus.

 

[taco breath]

This shows how divided opinions are on this...although a small sample.I think this is a toss up...too many unknowns.

is this a team management question?

It's a simple question of which back people value more going forward for '07 in this wild situation.I can't guage...and there is no consensus.

TAKE IT TO THE ASSITANT COACH FORUM!!!

 

[gump]

This shows how divided opinions are on this...although a small sample.I think this is a toss up...too many unknowns.

is this a team management question?

It's a simple question of which back people value more going forward for '07 in this wild situation.I can't guage...and there is no consensus.

TAKE IT TO THE ASSITANT COACH FORUM!!!

? What's the difference between this question and the thread about Pittman v Graham?Both threads were designed to discuss and weigh the information and situation to decide which back is more valuable...