Andrew74
Footballguy
I am the commish in a 12 team dynasty league that I run at work. We had an owner leave the league back in February/March. We had two people who wanted in that were equal in talent on paper, so I flipped a coin to pick the owner (prospect A).
Fast forward to today and the owner who took over is leaving the company. He tells me today that he is dropping out of the league. So I go back to the second guy (Prospect B) and he still wants in the league. Problem solved.
During the two months or so that Prospect A was in the league, I made a trade with him. I am one of the few that is an active trader. The trade involved me getting Jamaal Charles and he Andre Johnson. I have been working on trading Charles to another owner (Owner B) since then.
After I send an email to the league saying Prospect B is taking over, Owner B sends a reply to all that all trades Prospect A made should be voided; mine being the only trade he made. Then a second owner responds to that message saying at least Prospect B should be able to review the trade to accept or reject it. Prospect B responds that he would like that.
So what should happen here? The rules don't address this. There is a 24 hour period after a trade that owners can object; no one objected to this trade.
For disclosure, here was the trade.
Me (Commish) gave - AJ, 1.05, 2.11
Prospect A gave - JC, 1.03, 2.03
His team still has Mendenhall, McFadden, Spiller. His best WR after AJ is either Benn or MSW.
Fast forward to today and the owner who took over is leaving the company. He tells me today that he is dropping out of the league. So I go back to the second guy (Prospect B) and he still wants in the league. Problem solved.
During the two months or so that Prospect A was in the league, I made a trade with him. I am one of the few that is an active trader. The trade involved me getting Jamaal Charles and he Andre Johnson. I have been working on trading Charles to another owner (Owner B) since then.
After I send an email to the league saying Prospect B is taking over, Owner B sends a reply to all that all trades Prospect A made should be voided; mine being the only trade he made. Then a second owner responds to that message saying at least Prospect B should be able to review the trade to accept or reject it. Prospect B responds that he would like that.
So what should happen here? The rules don't address this. There is a 24 hour period after a trade that owners can object; no one objected to this trade.
For disclosure, here was the trade.
Me (Commish) gave - AJ, 1.05, 2.11
Prospect A gave - JC, 1.03, 2.03
His team still has Mendenhall, McFadden, Spiller. His best WR after AJ is either Benn or MSW.