jdoggydogg said:
BILLIEVE said:
I went with Romo, and they had pretty similar stats in my scoring format.

What kind of scoring could you possibly have in your league? Garrard had 199 yards passing and 19 rushing and had 2 TDs passing and 1 TD rushing. Romo had 257 yards passing and 13 rushing and only had 1 passing TD. They both had 1 INT, so unless you have some ridiculous bonus for 200+ yards passing, I just see no way for Romo to have come close. In one league, which doesn't do decimals, i.e. 1 pt for 25 passing and 0 for 24, and is only 4 points per passing TD, Romo had 14 and Garrard had 21. In another with decimal and 6 pt passing TDs, Romo had 19.1 and Garrard had 28.9. In both cases Garrard had about 50% more points which is pretty significant in my book.Now, Romo didn't suck out, but it wasn't a wash like the decision I had between Romo and Derek Anderson, who both finished with exactly 14 points.ETA: In TD only leagues, like BILLIEVE's, Garrard did pummel Romo this week.