IDP dynasty rankings - S (1 Viewer)

[onionsack]

1. Laron Landry WAS

2. Eric Berry KC

3. Tyvon Branch OAK

4. Yeremiah Bell MIA

5. T.J. Ward CLE

6. Patrick Chung NE

7. Roman Harper NO

8. Antoine Bethea IND

9. Quintin Mikell STL

10. Morgan Burnett GB

11. Louis Delmas DET

12. Troy Polamalu PIT

13. Adrian Wilson ARI

14. Eric Weddle SD

15. Kerry Rhodes ARI

16. Earl Thomas SEA

17. Oshiomogho Atogwe WAS

18. Donte Whitner SF

19. William Moore ATL

20. Chris Hope TEN

21. Kenny Phillips NYG

22. George Wilson BUF

23. Bob Sanders SD

24. Dawan Landry JAX

25. Jaiquawn Jarrett PHI

26. Tom Zbikowski BAL

27. Jairus Byrd BUF

28. Dashon Goldson SF

29. Michael Griffin TEN

30. Kam Chancellor SEA

31. Glover Quin HOU

32. Antrel Rolle NYG

33. Brian Dawkins DEN

34. Amari Spievey DET

35. Bernard Pollard BAL

36. Nate Allen PHI

37. Michael Mitchell OAK

38. Michael Huff OAK

39. Charles Godfrey CAR

40. Ed Reed BAL

41. Craig Dahl STL

42. Sean Jones TB

43. Nick Collins GB

44. Rahim Moore DEN

45. Major Wright CHI

46. Chris Harris CHI

47. Melvin Bullitt IND

48. Jim Leonhard NYJ

49. Malcolm Jenkins NO

50. Thomas DeCoud ATL

51. Kurt Coleman PHI

52. Quinton Carter DEN

53. Kendrick Lewis KC

54. Steve Gregory SD

55. Sherrod Martin CAR

56. Danieal Manning HOU

57. Sergio Brown NE

58. Cody Grimm TB

59. Courtney Greene JAX

60. Tyrell Johnson MIN

61. Chris Conte CHI

62. Gerald Sensabaugh DAL

63. Abram Elam DAL

64. Jamarca Sanford MIN

65. Reggie Nelson CIN

66. Usama Young CLE

67. Chris Crocker CIN

68. Darrell Stuckey SD

69. Husain Abdullah MIN

70. Reggie Smith SF

71. Chad Jones NYG

72. Haruki Nakamura BAL

73. Charlie Peprah GB

74. Erik Coleman DET

75. Taylor Mays CIN

76. Ryan Clark PIT

77. Reshad Jones MIA

78. Brodney Pool NYJ

79. Tanard Jackson TB

80. Rashad Johnson ARI

81. Da’Norris Searcy BUF

82. Sean Considine CAR

83. Madieu Williams SF

84. Josh Barrett NE

85. Atari Bigby SEA

86. Darian Stewart STL

87. Reshard Langford KC

88. Anthony Smith TEN

89. Barry Church DAL

90. Dominique Barber HOU

91. Jordan Babineaux TEN

92. Sabby Piscitelli KC

93. Gibril Wilson CIN

94. Jarrad Page PHI

95. Jon McGraw KC

96. Mike Adams CLE

97. James Sanders ATL

98. Kareem Moore WAS

99. David Bruton DEN

100. Reed Doughty WAS

101. Bryan Scott BUF

102. Eric Smith NYJ

103. Larry Asante TB

104. Joe Lefeged IND

105. Hamza Abdullah ARI

106. Shann Schillinger ATL

107. Tyler Sash NYG

108. Chris Prosinski JAX

109. John Wendling DET

110. Hiram Eugene OAK

111. Danny McCray DAL

112. Corey Lynch TB

113. Chris Clemons MIA

114. Robert Sands CIN

115. Troy Nolan HOU

116. Mistral Raymond MIN

117. Mark Legree SEA

118. Donald Washington KC

119. Dwight Lowery JAX

120. Ryan Mundy PIT

121. Anthony Levine GB

122. Pierson Prioleau NO

123. Paul Oliver NO

124. Emanuel Cook NYJ

125. Jonathan Amaya NO

126. Chinedum Ndukwe FA

127. Isa Abdul-Quddus NO

128. James Butler STL

129. Jermale Hines STL

130. Will Allen PIT

131. DeAndre McDaniel IND

132. M.D. Jennings GB

133. Dejon Gomes WAS

134. Akwasi Owusu-Ansah DAL

135. Brandon Meriweather FA

136. Vincent Fuller FA

137. Ahmad Black FA

138. Shiloh Keo FA

139. Jonathan Nelson STL

140. Tyrone Culver MIA

 

[SlevinKelevra]

Shouldn't AGE be a factor in Dynasty Rankings ?

 

[Shane Falco]

Shouldn't AGE be a factor in Dynasty Rankings ?

It appeared that he factored that in with DE rankings

 

[JoeSteeler]

 

[onionsack]

Shouldn't AGE be a factor in Dynasty Rankings ?

Absolutely. I think one of the biggest mistakes owners make in dynasty leagues is to not take it into proper account. Is there someone specific you think is over-rated or underrated because of age? In general I tend not to give it *too* much weight with the defensive backs, since it's so easy to find serviceable starters for dirt cheap every year.

 

[Tick]

What scoring system?

Polamalu and Adrian Wilson seem quite high to me. Then I look at the list and remember that redraft and dynasty rankings should be pretty much identical for safeties - we have no idea which of the backups are going to luck their way into a starting lineup.

 

[JOBOOZOSO]

Everywhere I look, Danieal Manning is being ignored. What am I missing? The guy produces when he plays.

 

[Crippler]

Any list with Berry not 1 is completely wrong.

Branch and Bell are both mediocre players playing in good fantasy spots. Berry is a stud pure and simple

 

[onionsack]

Any list with Berry not 1 is completely wrong. Branch and Bell are both mediocre players playing in good fantasy spots. Berry is a stud pure and simple

You're probably right, and I confess I don't spend a lot of time quibbling about who's number 1 and who's number 4 since that's not really the area of the rankings that interests me. I do think you somewhat underestimate Branch and Bell's abilities, but as a Michael Mitchell owner, I'm hoping you've got at least Branch pegged correctly.

 

[Hoss Style]

I like George Wilson a bit more than you do. We'll see what he does this year.

Thanks for posting these. Always fun to compare.

 

[ninerfanatic492000]

this may not exactly be a dynasty question(unless peyton is infact done), but whats the prognosis on melvin bullitt now that the colts are on track to quite possibly be ran on more than any team in history till peyton is back in full strength? is he good enuff/durable or in the right situation to take advantage?

 

[onionsack]

Rankings updated in first post. Thanks in advance for pointing out any errors or omissions!

 

[jimbodan]

After week 1 what are your thoughts on Kam Chancellor? Was it just an aberration or do you think it has a chance of becoming the norm? Do you think Hawthorne's return will cut into his production?

 

[cr8f]

After week 1 what are your thoughts on Kam Chancellor? Was it just an aberration or do you think it has a chance of becoming the norm? Do you think Hawthorne's return will cut into his production?

Norton(No it was Jene) I think predicted he would be top 10 this year. I think he's good against the run.

 

[matttyl]

Rankings updated in first post. Thanks in advance for pointing out any errors or omissions!

Berry still #2 with a torn ACL?

 

[onionsack]

Rankings updated in first post. Thanks in advance for pointing out any errors or omissions!

Berry still #2 with a torn ACL?

The rankings were made before the injury, but yeah, in a dynasty league I'd basically still trade any other safety in the league for him straight up. The injury occurred early enough in the season that he should be fully healed by next year.

 

[matttyl]

Rankings updated in first post. Thanks in advance for pointing out any errors or omissions!

Berry still #2 with a torn ACL?

The rankings were made before the injury, but yeah, in a dynasty league I'd basically still trade any other safety in the league for him straight up. The injury occurred early enough in the season that he should be fully healed by next year.

I'm in a dynasty league, and I'm thinking I'd get laughed at if I offered him straight up for a Delmas or something right now.

 

[onionsack]

Rankings updated in first post. Thanks in advance for pointing out any errors or omissions!

Berry still #2 with a torn ACL?

The rankings were made before the injury, but yeah, in a dynasty league I'd basically still trade any other safety in the league for him straight up. The injury occurred early enough in the season that he should be fully healed by next year.

I'm in a dynasty league, and I'm thinking I'd get laughed at if I offered him straight up for a Delmas or something right now.

Delmas is young and talented and healthy and in a good situation. I might keep him. But if I'm holding, say, Yeremiah Bell, I'd make the offer in a heartbeat.

 

[Tick]

Rankings updated in first post. Thanks in advance for pointing out any errors or omissions!

Berry still #2 with a torn ACL?

The rankings were made before the injury, but yeah, in a dynasty league I'd basically still trade any other safety in the league for him straight up. The injury occurred early enough in the season that he should be fully healed by next year.

I'm in a dynasty league, and I'm thinking I'd get laughed at if I offered him straight up for a Delmas or something right now.

I'm planning to offer similar players for him over the next week or so.

 

[Shane Falco]

Any opinion change on some higher ranked guys that have been pretty slow?

Delmas

Ward (was addressed in another thread)

W. Moore

Hope (has missed time)

Godfrey (one of my favorites, maybe the loss of all the LBs will help him)