I am a fairly inexperienced dynasty player and have a little dilemma, or maybe not.
We are currently in the second year of our league and our rookie draft is approaching quickly.
Now that we are in the postseason, I am constantly tinkering and scheming to make my team better. To take it over the top. I am always targeting players to trade for and draft, and racking my brain...
Is there a time that this normally happens in dynasty leagues, and should dynasty players fight the urge to tinker with their teams when nothing might need to be done?
Is this a stupid question?
Not a stupid question IMO, but you may not like my answer. All teams can be improved, but I don't think that necessarily means that every owner should trade frequently.I think it depends on (1) how sharp and experienced the other owners are and (2) whether it's a fun league or a serious league (whether or not significant money is involved). If you are fairly inexperienced and the other owners are, too, then you probably don't lose much by trading a lot. And if it's a fun league, then you can build good experience (and develop trading skill) by trying to assess the strengths and weaknesses of your team and improving it through trades.
OTOH, if it's a "serious" league and some of the other owners are sharks, then you will be hurting your team by trading frequently because you will likely end up with a slightly lower quality team after most if not all trades. Some trades help both teams, but many trades are zero sum games where one team loses if the other team wins. And sharks will not make a trade unless it helps their team in some significant way, usually by increasing the quality of players in aggregate.
No offense intended but I think the FF corollary to "Sometimes it's better to be quiet and let others guess if you're not informed than open your mouth and prove it" is "Sometimes it's better to take a conservative approach and work through the draft and WW to improve your team, compared to trading frequently with sharks and demonstrating that you're not a good trader."
In dynasty leagues with active trading, the best traders end up with incredibly strong teams. Most of the other teams are weakened because the most astute shark has gotten the edge in many trades, with the net result that his team keeps getting stronger and stronger over time.
If it's a serious league and you're fairly inexperienced, the best thing you can do for the long-term benefit of your team is to identify the 3-4 most experienced and sharpest sharks in your league, and resolve never to trade with them. If you do trade with them, you will rarely improve your team. They know a lot more than you do, and you will be taken advantage of -- not every time, but most times.
Every astute owner is looking to identify the 2-3 weakest or most gullible owners in their league -- and then trade with them as much as possible. Sharks recognize other sharks and are very wary of trading with them, unless they can structure a trade that benefits both teams. As in most things, buyer beware!