Is this too over the Top.... (1 Viewer)

[KellysHeroes]

Scoring System

Player Stats from last year

Offenese

1pt every 25 yds passing, 1 pt every 10 yd rushing & receving

.2 per pass Comp, -1 sack, -2 int w/ an Additional -1 after the 2nd. Addational -2 if returned for TD

.2 Ru Att, 1 PPR for WR & TE, .5 PPR for RBs.

-1 fumble w/ addational -1 if lost. Addational -1 on 2nd fumble and additional -1 on Lost

FGs 3 pts 0 - 30 yds. additional .1 per yd after 30 yds.

Bonus PTs

All Players

3 pts 300 yds passing, 3 pts 100 yds rushing

2 pts 25 pass comp, 2 pts 25 ru att

RBs: 2 pts 150 yd Rushing + receiving

WRs: 3 pts 100 yds receving, 2 pts 150 yds, 3 pts 7 rec.

TEs: 3 pts 75 yds receiving, 2 pts 100yds, 3 pts 5 rec

FG: 2 pts after the 3rd FG

IDPs

4 INT, 2 Forced Fumble, 2 Fumble Recovery, 3 Sack w/ addaitional .2 per 1 yd of sack, 3 BLK kick, 3 safety

2 pt solos, 1 pt assist, 1 pt pass Def

Bonus PTs

All IDPs

Additional 2 pts on 2nd INT, Forced Fumble, Fumble Recovery & or Sack

additional 1 pt on 3rd Pass def

DT / DE: additional 3 pts on 4th solo, additional 1 pt on 2nd assist

LB / CB / S: additional 3 pts on 6th solo, additional 1 pt on 4th assist

All TDs: 6 pts for 0 - 39 yds, 9 pts for 40 or more yds

Top 30 is made up of 6 QBs, 9 RBs, 8 WRs, & 7 LBs

Top 60 is made up of 13 QBs, 16 RBs, 15 WRs, 15 LBs, & 1DB

 

[KellysHeroes]

5 too 5 right now.. not too bad

 

[Birdie048]

Top 30 is made up of 6 QBs, 9 RBs, 8 WRs, & 7 LBsTop 60 is made up of 13 QBs, 16 RBs, 15 WRs, 15 LBs, & 1DB

I realize you are looking for position balance, but there are too many "bonuses" to keep track of for each position and they are all over the place. Top 60 is too QB heavy. I prefer a more RB, WR & LB weighted value. No drafting struggles with all positions being equal. Not a bad system, but I voted no.

 

[KellysHeroes]

I guess only certain Fantasy players like high scoring

 

[Zoomanji]

I like it.

Scores in my non-IDP (QB,2-RB,3-WR, TE, K, DEF) avergage 270 pts per week

 

[cstu]

I guess only certain Fantasy players like high scoring

No, I just don't like bonuses for reaching arbitrary yardage and don't see that as reflecting actual player performance.

 

[KellysHeroes]

had a feeling that the "Over the Top" option would pull away...

 

[Mystery Achiever]

i don't care about high scoring or not, but i agree with cstu and birdie that it is too much to keep track of; I played in a league with a lot of similar bonuses this past season and didn't care for it.

 

[stevegamer]

I also thing the sheer number of bonus breakpoints are an issue.

 

[KellysHeroes]

19 too 15

so there some who like the high scoring like I do

thanks all

 

[benbadman]

I hope your league uses a website to calculate that!! Also, a complicated scoring system like this makes it rather hard to follow your game in real time, doing the math in your head (well I got 100 yards and a TD, so thats 5+6 points, etc).

Really for the FG, .1 per yard.. that's kinda, meh. I see how it works, and my league does 1-39yd=3, 40-49=4, 50+ = 5. I dont know..

Sometimes having cutoffs and threshholds makes for scoring nuances that win and lose games, which, to me at least, would be preferable to an absolutist scoring system where its hard to get screwed, or conversely divinely benefit, from a scoring rule plateau.

Scoring System

Player Stats from last year

Offenese

1pt every 25 yds passing, 1 pt every 10 yd rushing & receving

.2 per pass Comp, -1 sack, -2 int w/ an Additional -1 after the 2nd. Addational -2 if returned for TD

.2 Ru Att, 1 PPR for WR & TE, .5 PPR for RBs.

-1 fumble w/ addational -1 if lost. Addational -1 on 2nd fumble and additional -1 on Lost

FGs 3 pts 0 - 30 yds. additional .1 per yd after 30 yds.

Bonus PTs

All Players

3 pts 300 yds passing, 3 pts 100 yds rushing

2 pts 25 pass comp, 2 pts 25 ru att

RBs: 2 pts 150 yd Rushing + receiving

WRs: 3 pts 100 yds receving, 2 pts 150 yds, 3 pts 7 rec.

TEs: 3 pts 75 yds receiving, 2 pts 100yds, 3 pts 5 rec

FG: 2 pts after the 3rd FG

IDPs

4 INT, 2 Forced Fumble, 2 Fumble Recovery, 3 Sack w/ addaitional .2 per 1 yd of sack, 3 BLK kick, 3 safety

2 pt solos, 1 pt assist, 1 pt pass Def

Bonus PTs

All IDPs

Additional 2 pts on 2nd INT, Forced Fumble, Fumble Recovery & or Sack

additional 1 pt on 3rd Pass def

DT / DE: additional 3 pts on 4th solo, additional 1 pt on 2nd assist

LB / CB / S: additional 3 pts on 6th solo, additional 1 pt on 4th assist

All TDs: 6 pts for 0 - 39 yds, 9 pts for 40 or more yds

Top 30 is made up of 6 QBs, 9 RBs, 8 WRs, & 7 LBs

Top 60 is made up of 13 QBs, 16 RBs, 15 WRs, 15 LBs, & 1DB

 

[benbadman]

I hope your league uses a website to calculate that!! Also, a complicated scoring system like this makes it rather hard to follow your game in real time, doing the math in your head (well I got 100 yards and a TD, so thats 5+6 points, etc).

Really for the FG, .1 per yard.. that's kinda, meh. I see how it works, and my league does 1-39yd=3, 40-49=4, 50+ = 5. I dont know..

Sometimes having cutoffs and threshholds makes for scoring nuances that win and lose games, which, to me at least, would be preferable to an absolutist scoring system where its hard to get screwed, or conversely divinely benefit, from a scoring rule plateau.

 

[KellysHeroes]

Its uses MFL

 

[Pictus Cat]

I prefer Forced Fumbles to be equal to INT and safeties 6.

I put scoring systems into to two categories. Magazine and not. This is not. You can't go get a magazine and not adjust for scoring. Some people will still try though. I play both types of leagues. I don't use magazine rankings.

 

[KellysHeroes]

The Forced Fumble and Recovery equals an INT..

and the saftey does equal 6; Sack (3) + Safety (3) = 6

 

[Pictus Cat]

The Forced Fumble and Recovery equals an INT..and the saftey does equal 6; Sack (3) + Safety (3) = 6

My leagues didn't add sack and safety. System looks good to me.

 

[KellysHeroes]

My leagues didn't add sack and safety. System looks good to me.

Really; wow I thought that was a standard thing since the NFL records Safeties as Sacks..Actually; every IDP league I played..A sack also counts as a Solo as well..So in this league; you would get Solo (2) + Safety (3) + Sack (2) = 8 + the bonus yardage points