James Hall or Robert Mathis (1 Viewer)

[eddy13]

Woudl you guys consider James Hall better than Robert Mathis

 

[eddy13]

anyone

 

[Portis 26]

About the same really. Indy's D looks to have taken a step backwards, so maybe I'd go for Hall. But Hall's hurt so that might lead me back to Mathis.

 

[eddy13]

James Hall I heard on Kffl that hes fine and practicing.... Also Indy d got better with Simon

 

[grady]

Personally, I would go with Hall. He is the more complete DE. Mathis is just a pass rusher.Mathis might put up the double digit sacks but only Hall has the realistic shot to put up 50+ tackles.

 

[ffchamp1]

Personally, I would go with Hall. He is the more complete DE. Mathis is just a pass rusher.

Mathis might put up the double digit sacks but only Hall has the realistic shot to put up 50+ tackles.

Gotta agree with Grady on this. With Hall you know that you will get 50+ tackles. The Colts DEF (LB's not withstanding) improved tremendously this offseason with a healthy Sanders, a better than expected CB in Jackson and the recent addition of Simon. Mathis may get double digit sacks playing opposite Freeney, however, don't expect alot of tackles as the ends in this system just don't get them.Tom