Javon Walker & Marvin Harrison? (1 Viewer)

[theJCdude]

I been offered to trade Cedric Benson for either Harrison or Walker? What would you do? I really don't plan on ever starting Benson, and think this might be my only shot to get rid of him.

Thoughts?

 

[jamil]

they have polls in AC now? cool.

 

[MDSkinner]

This seems easy to me. Harrison by a long shot, if for no other reason than at the very least he has his starting QB throwing to him.

 

[SSOG]

This seems easy to me. Harrison by a long shot, if for no other reason than at the very least he has his starting QB throwing to him.

Cutler's healthy and playing this week.Anyway, the answer depends on a lot of things. Dynasty or redraft (Dynasty favors Walker, redraft favors Harrison)? Are you desperately scrambling for the playoffs (which favors Harrison), or are you a near-lock to get in and looking to solidify your roster once there (which favors Walker)?

 

[EdwardCat]

This seems easy to me. Harrison by a long shot, if for no other reason than at the very least he has his starting QB throwing to him.

The only QB harrison has throwing to him is in pre-game warm-ups. All signs point to Harrison being worthless this year. A guy does not miss 3 straight games with a ####### knee bruise.