Joe Mixon for Najee Harris trade (1 Viewer)

[Mass Marauder]

Standard Yahoo league, QB,RB, 2WR, Flex, K, D

I have Taylor and Harris, trade partner has Gibson an Mixon.  He was BUMMED that I picked Harris 1 pick ahead of Mixon, and wants to trade them.  All the analysis says this is a pretty even trade, with maybe some edge to Mixon.  I'm intrigued by Harris's upside this year, but worried about his O line.  And he's a rookie, so who knows what's going to happen.  

 

[Gally]

You picked Harris over Mixon.  Why would you move him for Mixon now?  You could have had Mixon if you wanted him.  Stick with your initial decision.  You haven't even seen him play yet.  Mixon is also a bigger injury risk (his mysterious foot injury still lingers in my mind because it was so strange).  

If the guy wants Harris that bad see if he will throw something else into the deal.  I wouldn't do it straight up mainly because you picked Harris over Mixon to begin with.  

 

[titusbramble]

I'd take Najee over Mixon pretty comfortably. I'm not convinced by Mixon at all (sucks that I've got a piece of him in one league which is one more than I wanted, and it's in my only Gus league so can't really trade him away now) and Harris is surely going to get more usage

 

[wlwiles]

I took Najee over Mixon myself, twice.  Like @Gally said, stick with your choice.  

 

[jawhoo]

You picked Harris over Mixon.  Why would you move him for Mixon now?  You could have had Mixon if you wanted him.  Stick with your initial decision.  You haven't even seen him play yet.  Mixon is also a bigger injury risk (his mysterious foot injury still lingers in my mind because it was so strange).  

If the guy wants Harris that bad see if he will throw something else into the deal.  I wouldn't do it straight up mainly because you picked Harris over Mixon to begin with.  

+1 to this.  Why would you make this trade straight up, you obviously like Harris more? That said, I personally don't think Mixon is a step down from Harris, in a redraft league if the other owner is willing to sweeten the pot a bit (trading you up a tier at TE, or low WR2 for high WR3, something like that) I'd do it.

 

[j0nese]

yeah no idea why you would just give away harris when you picked him over mixon.  I would send a message saying you took harris cuz you wanted him & if he is interested make an offer.  but you arent interested in straight up trade of the 2

 

[Goooals]

Agree with everyone else here. If he wants Harris that bad, he needs to sweeten the pot and upgrade you somewhere else to even consider it. Maybe he has Mark Andrews and you have Fant. 

Please see mine:

https://forums.footballguys.com/topic/799941-non-ppr-wdis-d-harris-or-m-davis/