John Madden (1 Viewer)

[Pat Patriot]

I think Greg Jennings is better than Stallworth as well.

Me too. Stallworth drops too many passes and he is constantly injured. I cannot believe he is not injured yet this season. He has only played 1/3 of his career completely (2 out of 6 seasons where he played 16 games).

You realize this is the NFL right? Do you know how many guys, especially those at the skill positions, that play 16 games in a season?Boldin 2 of 5 yearsHoush 2 of 6 yearsTO 5 of 12 yearsSantana Moss 2 of 7 yearsAndre Johnson 3 of 5 yearsI'm sure there are many others with similar histories.

 

[nashua55]

Take away Brady, and Stallworth is garbage. There, it had to be said. He underperformed in PHI, and he underperformed in NO. I could name about 30 non-#1 wrs thatd put up his stats or better in his current situation.

He was a free agent, PHI didn't "let him go." The only edge Wayne has on Stallworth is hands. But speed, and routes, Stallworth is better.Stallworth would be a #1 WR for any other team, as would Wayne. He played lights out in PHI before injury, had comparable numbers (when healthy) to what Wayne has put up this season. Wayne has Manning throwing to him, Stallworth has had Aaron Brooks and Donovan McNabb (not a pretty passer). You can knock him all you want, but he is one of the elite WR talents in the league. And BTW, this has been my stand since well before Stallworth was a Patriot - he is a great WR, but has been limited by injuries. You could ask any professional NFL scout and they would agree with me. Funny - he underperformed in PHI? Are you CRAZY??????????

I live in the philly area and watch all the Eagles games, for you to say D. Stallworth was light out for Philly sounds crazy to me. He was good at times, but lets be realistic, he only had 38 catches in 12 games. Not my definition of "Lights Out"

 

[nashua55]

Take away Brady, and Stallworth is garbage. There, it had to be said. He underperformed in PHI, and he underperformed in NO. I could name about 30 non-#1 wrs thatd put up his stats or better in his current situation.

Funny - he underperformed in PHI? Are you CRAZY??????????

Stallworth was EXCELLENT for Philly last year. He was an excellent deep threat. The fact that he was playing with a QB that couldnt really throw the deep ball cut down on his stats. I know watching every game there werent many drops and after missing 4 games early in the year, he didnt miss any others inlcuding 2 playoff games. He scored a TD in each playoff game.

I know you are going to laugh, but in reality Donnie Mac actually can throw a pretty good deep ball. He has problems hitting recievers in stride with intermediate patterns, and cant throw a pass with some touch.

 

[Da Guru]

Did anyone catch Madden saying that Stallworth is the best No.2 WR in the NFL during last night's game? I must have missed it or something, but according to Skip Bayless right now, he did.So I guess Stallworth is better than Wayne when Harrison is healthy?or better than Houshmandzadeh?or better than Santonio Holmes?or better than Anquan Boldin?Please forgive me... but wow. What an insane comment, if he said this. We can't always believe Skip Bayless either though.

TJ is the #1 in Cinci.