Captain_Apocalypse said:
Yeah, pretty sure he didn't coach Ahman in GB, coached him in seattle, where I'm pretty sure he underpreformed and then they traded him to GB in part for Hass. Have to say though that I don't rememeber Holmgren ever really using a comittee approach. Seems like he has a philosophy of getting one guy into the rhythm of the game. (mostly). Anyway, I don't see much difference between Jones and Dorsey Leavens, whom Holmgren did coach into a pretty good fantasy back in GB. Thing is now he has a glut of weapons in the backfield so I fully expect him to try them all out. Sad thing is I really liked the way Weaver was working out and now they have Duckett too. Terrible. We'll just have to keep an eye on things in the preseason.
Dorsey Levens wasn't that successful. Two years with 1000+ yards. Above 4 yards per carry only 2 years. I think it's rather unfair to compare the successes had by a RB 10 years ago and try to make an accurate assumption of what kind of success a similar RB would have with that same coach. How many of you actually think Holmgren does the exact same thing with the same style of players that he did 10 years ago? The game has changed, I'm sure his coaching philosphy has changed...
unpossible said:
Garts said:
He was traded out of Seattle because he fumbled all the time.
3 fumbles in 2 years.
Just saying
But that really IS the reason why he was traded. Holmgren couldn't trust him to carry the ball. 3 fumbles in 2 years is an unfair statistic. 3 fumbles in
60 carries. That's 1 fumble every 20 carries. Give a guy 250-300 carries and that average has him fumbling 12.5-15 times in a season. Granted, the most he ever did was 7, but I remember that year and that was ridiculous! Imagine one fumble every other game... not real trustworththyI do not like Julius Jones. Enough time has gone by to successfully label him a bust. He's 27 years old, he's got maybe 3 years of shelf life left before he goes to Ron Dayne-type duty. His YPC is 0.1 greater than Cedric Benson. He has to compete with TJ Duckett and Maurice Morris (who has made a good case for himself).
Let's assume Jones wins the #1 spot, which I really doubt he will, but I will play along. He still will lose carries to Duckett at the goal line and be in an EXACT situation that he was in DAL if not worse. This will truly be a RBBC with Jones and Morris each getting roughly 12 carries and Duckett about 6-8. Morris is just 2 years older than Jones, but more proven with a career 4.3 ypc, ran for 4.5 last season
Bottom Line- unless an injury occurs to both Duckett and Morris, Jones is not worth owning or even considering owning. In fact, I think Morris is still the RB to own in SEA, followed second by Duckett if he gets goal line carries, and THEN Jones