KEEPER QUESTION (1 Viewer)

[Wrigley]

5X5 12 team roto league

We have an odd set of keeper rules. Keeper values are based on when a player is taken in last years draft.

1st: $5

2-4: $4

5-10: $3

11-20: $2

21+Waiver pickups: $1

All players retain their value for the following draft(dropped players still hold their keeper value)

Each year a player is kept, his keeper value increases by $2

I've just started looking this over, and am having a hard time

Beckett: 6

C Lee: 5

V Mart: 5

Youkills: 5

Werth: 5

Kendrick: 5

Victorino: 4

N Cruz: 4

M Young: 4

Figgins: 4

C Pena: 4

R Davis: 3

Span: 3

A Ramirez(CHI): 3

B Anderson: 3

Drew: 2

T Hudson: 2

Masterson: 2

Bard: 2

Pettitte: 2

Swisher: 1

C Ruiz: 1

M Gonzalez: 1

Gregerson: 1

Kuo: 1

Myers: 1

Leaning: Youk(5)Lee(5)Cruz(4)Davis(3)Swisher(1)

What says the BF?

 

[Eephus]

Which Drew brother?

 

[Captain Hook]

Wrigs - you know where to get better answers

Only five keepers? "salary" doesn't matter? cap?

I wouldn't keep Rajai Davis but make sure he is in the starting lineup (which would mean Bautista is moving back to 3B? Encarnacion?)

 

[Wrigley]

Wrigs - you know where to get better answers Only five keepers? "salary" doesn't matter? cap?I wouldn't keep Rajai Davis but make sure he is in the starting lineup (which would mean Bautista is moving back to 3B? Encarnacion?)

No salary per sePlayers are given a "keeper" value based on where they were drafted the previous year.Oh, and the Drew is JDand I'll be over there soon.

 

[dparker713]

Wrigs - you know where to get better answers Only five keepers? "salary" doesn't matter? cap?I wouldn't keep Rajai Davis but make sure he is in the starting lineup (which would mean Bautista is moving back to 3B? Encarnacion?)

No salary per sePlayers are given a "keeper" value based on where they were drafted the previous year.Oh, and the Drew is JDand I'll be over there soon.

This makes no sense. Why have keeper values if you have no budget and you do a draft, not an auction? Also, having what are your lineup and roster settings?

 

[Wrigley]

Wrigs - you know where to get better answers Only five keepers? "salary" doesn't matter? cap?I wouldn't keep Rajai Davis but make sure he is in the starting lineup (which would mean Bautista is moving back to 3B? Encarnacion?)

No salary per sePlayers are given a "keeper" value based on where they were drafted the previous year.Oh, and the Drew is JDand I'll be over there soon.

This makes no sense. Why have keeper values if you have no budget and you do a draft, not an auction? Also, having what are your lineup and roster settings?

Keeper values increase each year a player is kept.....making it impossible to keep the elite players for more than couple years.25 man rosters, playing 4 outfielders with and a pitching staff of 7 with daily transactions.This is our 10th year doing it this way(with little tweaks here and there)I can pm you a copy of our league constitution if you'd like

 

[dparker713]

Wrigs - you know where to get better answers Only five keepers? "salary" doesn't matter? cap?I wouldn't keep Rajai Davis but make sure he is in the starting lineup (which would mean Bautista is moving back to 3B? Encarnacion?)

No salary per sePlayers are given a "keeper" value based on where they were drafted the previous year.Oh, and the Drew is JDand I'll be over there soon.

This makes no sense. Why have keeper values if you have no budget and you do a draft, not an auction? Also, having what are your lineup and roster settings?

Keeper values increase each year a player is kept.....making it impossible to keep the elite players for more than couple years.25 man rosters, playing 4 outfielders with and a pitching staff of 7 with daily transactions.This is our 10th year doing it this way(with little tweaks here and there)I can pm you a copy of our league constitution if you'd like

So, you have a keeper budget then? What is it?

 

[Notorious T.R.E.]

Secret cap makes this question tricky.

 

[Wrigley]

oh crap

It was in the original post, but I must have deleted it

We get $18 to spend on our keepers.

 

[Notorious T.R.E.]

Youk 5

Werth 5

Cruz 4

Anderson 3

Swisher 1

Another option I considered:

Youk 5

Werth 5

VMart 5

Swisher 1

Kuo/Myers 1

I'm a little torn between VMART and Cruz; VMART helps the AVG. Especially considering that Werth and Swish could end up AVG drags. However, I'm also a big Brett Anderson fan so I lean towards the first scenario for the pitching bump.

 

[ttiger72]

Youk 5Werth 5Cruz 4Anderson 3Swisher 1Another option I considered:Youk 5Werth 5VMart 5Swisher 1Kuo/Myers 1I'm a little torn between VMART and Cruz; VMART helps the AVG. Especially considering that Werth and Swish could end up AVG drags. However, I'm also a big Brett Anderson fan so I lean towards the first scenario for the pitching bump.

I like Anderson too. Great defense + great park + groundballz + not a heavy workload from last year. I guess the elbow thing is a double-edged sword...I like Tre's scenarios. But I'd def. pass on Lee.

 

[the moops]

Youk 5Werth 5Cruz 4Anderson 3Swisher 1

I would swap Werth for V Mart.

 

[dparker713]

Youk 5Werth 5Cruz 4Anderson 3Swisher 1Another option I considered:Youk 5Werth 5VMart 5Swisher 1Kuo/Myers 1I'm a little torn between VMART and Cruz; VMART helps the AVG. Especially considering that Werth and Swish could end up AVG drags. However, I'm also a big Brett Anderson fan so I lean towards the first scenario for the pitching bump.

If its a 1 cathcer league I wouldn't keep VMart. I'd do your second scenario with Lee instead of VMart and Myers, not Kuo.

 

[rodg12]

I'd go...

Youk (5)

Lee (5)

Cruz (4)

Anderson (3)

Swisher (1)