I decided to cut and paste the info that will be used in the Team Report Section of the site. It was written a couple of weeks ago but not too much has changed since then...
This will help to make my Grades a little more obvious...
Arizona Cardinals
Projected Starters: LT Oliver Ross, LG Reggie Wells, C Al Johnson, RG Deuce Lutui, RT Levi Brown [r]
Key Backups: Mike Gandy, Milford Brown, Nick Leckey, Elton Brown, Brandon Gorin
Key Additions: C Al Johnson (Cowboys); OT Mike Gandy (Bills), OT Levi Brown [r], Russ Grimm (new offensive line coach)
Key Losses: C Alex Stepanovich(Bengals); OT Leonard Davis (Cowboys), G Chris Liwienski (Dolphins)
Over the past fifteen seasons, the Cardinals offensive line has never been able to elevate their play and develop into a strong unit. The tide may finally be turning with this group of guys. To start with, new OL coach Russ Grimm (formerly with the Steelers) is overseeing the unit. He is regarded as one of the finest offensive line coaches in the NFL today and he does have some talent on this roster to build around. At this time it appears that Oliver Ross will slot into the left tackle position. Ross played under Grimm with the Steelers and both are excited to be re-united. Reggie Wells had a very good 2006 season at right tackle but at this point it appears he may be destined to start at left guard, bringing stability to the left side of the ball. At center, newcomer Al Johnson, a free agent pickup from the Cowboys should earn the starting nod over Nick Leckey. 2nd-year player Deuce Lutui played well when called upon last season and should start at right guard while 1st round pick, Levi Brown from Penn State should slot into the starting right tackle position. The wildcard here is veteran Mike Gandy who can play inside at guard as well as outside at tackle. He could earn a starting job with a great camp. With decent depth including Milford Brown and Elton Brown, this group is headed in the right direction. Grimm will get a decent season out of this group and could be considered a team strength by 2008.
Atlanta Falcons
Projected Starters: LT Wayne Gandy, LG Justin Blaylock [r], C Todd McClure, RG Kynan Forney, RT Todd Weiner
Key Backups: Tyson Clabo P.J. Alexander, Toniu Fonoti, Frank Omiyale, Doug Datish
Key Additions: OG Justin Blaylock [r], OG Toniu Fonoti (Dolphins), C Doug Datish [r]
Key Losses: LG Matt Lehr (Buccaneers)
The Falcons have been one of the better offensive lines over the past several seasons. There isn’t a ton of individual talent here but good coaching and schemes in the past have allowed this group to shine. Alex Gibbs, considered one of the brightest OL coaches in the game today has moved on so there is a state of flux here in Atlanta. Wayne Gandy is now 36 years old and entering his 14th season. He was a great lineman at one time but he began to show his age last year and it’s only downhill from this point. He should have another season or two as a decent starting option for the club before heading out to pasture. The club lost starting guard Matt Lehr to the Buccaneers but filled the spot in a great way with the selected of big lineman, Justin Blaylock from Texas. He should slot in as a starter right out of the gate and become a rock for the club at left guard for the next decade. The other starters Todd McClure (an underrated center), Kynan Forney (a six-year starter) and Todd Weiner (a five-year starter) aren’t spectacular but are experienced and get the job done. Overall this is a pretty good unit. If Blaylock can slot in without missing a beat and Gandy’s tank hasn’t emptied out, this will be another solid season for this unit.
Baltimore Ravens
Projected Starters: LT Jonathon Ogden, LG Ben Grubbs [r], C Mike Flynn, RG Chris Chester, RT Adam Terry
Key Backups: Jason Brown, Brian Rimpf, Keydrick Vincent, Ikechuku Ndukwe, Marshall Yando [r]
Key Additions: OG Ben Grubbs [r], Marshall Yando [r]
Key Losses: OG Edwin Mulitalo (Lions), OT Tony Pashos (Jaguars)
You can hear the collective sign from Raven players, coaches and fans. Star LT Jonathon Ogden has agreed to come back for at least one more season. While not the player he once was, he is still one of the best tackles in the NFL and he brings stability to this unit which is in a state of transition. Aside from Ogden and center Mike Flynn who is one of the finer centers today, this group has been completely revamped from the past couple of years. However that is not necessarily a negative thing as the guys coming in have incredible athleticism and upside. At this point it appears that Adam Terry will start at right tackle. He filled in admirably for Ogden at the end of last season and he is a big, strong, talented kid who is the future left tackle for the team. Chris Chester started four games as a rookie last year and looked good. He may be the future center for the Ravens but should start at right guard this year. He has incredible athletic ability. Finally it appears that rookie Ben Grubbs from Auburn (a 1st round pick) should get the nod at left guard. He is tenacious with good power and athleticism and can dominate a football game. Other lineman such as Jason Brown and Keydrick Vincent provide excellent depth off of the bench. While it may take some time for this group to become cohesive, the talent here is staggering and this could be one of the best units in the NFL by season end. Great job of drafting lineman by the Ravens over the past few seasons give this unit a bright, long-term outlook.
Buffalo Bills
Projected Starters: LT Jason Peters, LG Derrick Dockery, C Melvin Fowler, RG Duke Preston, RT Langston Walker
Key Backups: Terrance Pennington, Jason Whittle, Brad Butler, Kirk Chambers
Key Additions: OG Derrick Dockery (Redskins), G/T Langston Walker (Raiders), C/OG Jason Whittle (Vikings)
Key Losses: OG Tutan Reyes (released), OG Chris Villarrial (released), OT Mike Gandy (Cardinals)
The Bills were only average at best last season but there is hope for this season as the club brought in three free agent players who should help strengthen this group. Leading the way is 3rd year starter Jason Peters who may be one of the most athletic linemen in the NFL. He is become a great cornerstone at left tackle and he is still improving. Center Melvin Fowler started all sixteen games a year ago and did a decent job. Duke Preston is an aggressive, tough interior lineman who started eight games a year ago. He should start at right guard. Newcomer Derrick Dockery has the natural ability to become one of the finer guards in the NFL. He has incredible size, surprising agility and at 26 years old is still improving. The Bills paid a ton to get him via free agency but he’s worth it. Finally expect huge Langston Walker to start at the right tackle spot. He started all sixteen games for the Raiders last year but was only adequate. At 345 pounds, he is a huge man but doesn’t have the athleticism or tenacity to dominate the way his size and talent indicates should be possible. Looking at the starting unit, it seems that Walker is the key to the possible success in 2007. If he can play well, the unit has the talent to have a pretty strong season. With the addition of Dockery and the continued growth of Peters, this will be the best offensive line performance by the Bills in a while.
Carolina Panthers
Projected Starters: LT Travelle Wharton, LG Mike Wahle, C Geoff Hangartner, RG Evan Mathis, RT Jordan Gross
Key Backups: Ryan Kalil [r], Jeremy Bridges, Justin Hartwig, Will Montgomery
Key Additions: C Ryan Kalil [r]
Key Losses: none
This is a tough year to project the Panthers fortunes when it comes to the offensive line. The good thing is the starting five lineman return from last year although Wharton was hurt in game one and missed the entire season. When healthy, Wharton had a very good 2005 season and should return to that level. On the other side, Gross hasn’t missed a game in his four seasons and is a good right tackle. He has never become the dominant lineman the club anticipated though when he was drafted. At center Geoff Hangartner started fifteen games a year ago when Justin Hartwig went down with injury and did a good job. He’ll battle veteran Justin Hartwig and rookie Ryan Kalil for the starting position. Kalil has great potential and phenomenal technique coming out of college. Evan Mathis was a first year starter in 2006 and did a pretty good job. He has good athletic ability and should continue to grow as a player. Mike Wahle is a long-time starter in the NFL and is going into his third season with the Panthers. He is a good, reliable lineman who still has several years left as a starter. The question mark this season is the Panthers shift to a zone-blocking scheme. At this point it is unknown how well this unit will adapt to the change but the starting five does appear to be well suited for this type of blocking scheme thanks to the athleticism and quickness along the group Look for an improvement for this unit in 2007.
Chicago Bears
Projected Starters: LT John Tait, LG Ruben Brown, C Olin Kreutz, RG Roberto Garza, RT Fred Miller
Key Backups: John St. Clair, Terrence Metcalf, Josh Beekman [r]
Key Additions: Josh Beekman [r]
Key Losses: none
The Bears offensive line was outstanding in 2006 and with the starting five all returning you can expect more of the same this season. Olin Kreutz is one of the best centers in the NFL and has missed just one game over six years. Roberto Garza stepped into the starting role at right guard and played extremely well. Fred Miller is a 12-year vet who has missed just two games in nine seasons and both John Tait and Ruben Brown are veteran players who are excellent blockers. With good depth in Terrence Metcalf and John St. Clair and a good rookie prospect in Josh Beekman who can play both center and guard, this will be another outstanding season for the Bears offensive line.
Cincinnati Bengals
Projected Starters: LT Levi Jones, LG Andrew Whitworth, C Eric Ghiaciuc, RG Bobbie Williams, RT Willie Anderson
Key Backups: Scott Kooistra, Stacy Andrews, Alex Stepanovich, Ben Wilkerson, Dan Santucci [r]
Key Additions: C Alex Stepanovich (Cardinals), OG Dan Santucci [r]
Key Losses: OG Eric Steinbach (Browns), C Rich Braham (retired)
The Bengals offensive line was one of the best in the NFL going into last season but has had some change to deal with since then. First of all, long-time center Rich Braham has retired so 3rd-year pro Eric Ghiaciuc, who started thirteen games last year will get the nod as the starting center. Of more concern is the loss of left guard Eric Steinbach to the Browns. Steinbach is one of the top guards in football and it will be difficult to replace him. It appears the job will go to 2nd-year player Andrew Whitworth who started 13 games as a rookie at both guard and tackle last year. He has a ton of talent and if he can make the transition to the interior of the offensive line, he should have a great career. The other positions are in great shape with three excellent veteran players. Levi Jones missed eleven games with injury last year and his absence hurt the club. He is a very good left tackle. Right tackle is 12th year starter Willie Anderson who is an incredible talent. Bobbie Williams isn’t flashy at right guard but he is very effective. As far as depth goes, young players such as Stacy Andrews and Ben Wilkerson are unproven but have talent. The loss of Braham and Steinbach hurts but this is still a very strong unit going forward.
Cleveland Browns
Projected Starters: LT Joe Thomas, LG Seth McKinney, C Hank Fraley, RG Eric Steinbach, RT Ryan Tucker
Key Backups: Kevin Shaffer, Lennie Friedman, Kelly Butler, Nat Dorsey
Key Additions: OG Eric Steinbach (Bengals), OG/C Seth McKinney (Dolphins), OT Joe Thomas [r], Steve Marshall (OL Coach)
Key Losses: Joe Andruzzi (released)
This unit has been completely overhauled over the past couple of years and deservedly so as it was putrid. However the pieces are starting to fit together and the future looks promising for the first time. Two huge additions are offering that promise going forward. The first addition is the free agent acquisition of Eric Steinbach from the Bengals. He is one of the best linemen in football and he is a massive upgrade for the team. Secondly, the Browns used the 3rd pick in the draft to select talented left tackle Joe Thomas who appears ready to immediately step in and become the cornerstone of the unit for the next fifteen years. He’s that good. Hank Fraley brought experience and leadership to the middle of the line last year, Seth McKinney is a dependable veteran guard and Ryan Tucker is a good right tackle if he can stay healthy. Kevin Shaffer and Lennie Friedman provide great veteran depth if they’re needed although Shaffer is asking for a trade because Joe Thomas was taken in the draft. The Browns offensive line is shooting up the ranks. Expect an improvement in 2007 and great things by 2008.
Dallas Cowboys
Projected Starters: LT Flozell Adams, LG Kyle Kosier, C Andre Gurode, RG Marco Rivera, RT Leonard Davis
Key Backups: Marc Colombo, Doug Free [r], James Marten [r], Joe Berger, Pat McQuistan, Jim Molinaro
Key Additions: OT Leonard Davis (Cardinals), OT Jim Molinaro (Redskins), OT James Marten [r], OT Doug Free [r]
Key Losses: C Al Johnson (Cardinals), OG Marco Rivera (likely), OT Jason Fabini (Washington)
There is no question the Cowboys have the largest tandem at tackle in the NFL today. Flozell Adams and Leonard Davis are huge men. At over 700 pounds between them, they block out the sun but can they dominate a football game. That hasn’t proven true consistently for either player although Adams has had more glimpses of greatness throughout his career. After a few disappointing seasons, Adams had a much better 2006 season. He is a dominant run blocker when he’s on the top of his game. Davis is durable and dependable but hasn’t become a dominating tackle in the NFL. Still he is a big upgrade for the Cowboys at right tackle and he’ll make this unit better. Marco Rivera is a good veteran guard but is coming off injury and may not be back with the club. If he doesn’t return an open competition will take place at training camp. Kyle Kosier is able to slot in anywhere along the offensive line but should start at guard and Andre Gurode has become a dependable center. The Cowboys draft Doug Free from Northern Illinois and he offers promise for the future with good athleticism. He may slot into guard as the club also drafted James Marten who is best suited as a tackle. This is a good unit but not a great one. If Rivera doesn’t return there is a possible weak link at right guard unless somebody such as Joe Berger or E.J. Whitley can surprise and that will hurt this unit’s overall performance.
Denver Broncos
Projected Starters: LT Matt Lepsis, LG Ben Hamilton, C Tom Nalen, RG Montrae Holland, RT Erik Pears
Key Backups: Chris Kuper, Greg Eslinger, Adam Meadows, Ryan Harris [r]
Key Additions: OG Montrae Holland (Saints), OT Ryan Harris [r]
Key Losses: OT George Foster (Lions-trade), G Cooper Carlisle
The Broncos offensive line has gone through some changes this season but the scheme and players returning should keep this unit functioning well. Out this season our former starters George Foster and Cooper Carlisle although both struggled last season. In for those players this season is Montrae Holland at right guard and Erik Pears at right tackle if he beats out veteran Adam Meadows in training camp. Pears started ten games for the club last year and held his own. He may be best suited at left tackle but he should be able to beat out Meadows to start this year. Holland is an intriguing signing and could be an upgrade for the team. He has 30 career starts and appears to be well-suited to this scheme. Veteran Matt Lepsis was injured for the first time in his career last season and the team missed his experience. Left guard Ben Hamilton is undersized at only 283 pounds but has superlative technique and gets the job done. Center Tom Nalen is the leader of this group and is still playing at a high level despite being 36 years old. The Broncos are blessed with young, talented backups including Chris Kuper, Greg Eslinger and rookie Ryan Harris so the future is bright. It isn’t a guarantee but the players jumping into a starting role may be more talented than those that left. It may take awhile to come together as a group for the promise is there for another strong season.
Detroit Lions
Projected Starters: LT Jeff Backus, LG Damien Woody, C Dominic Raiola, RG Edwin Mulitalo, RT George Foster
Key Backups: Jonathon Scott, Manuel Ramirez, Rex Tucker
Key Additions: OG Edwin Mulitalo (Ravens), George Foster (Broncos-trade), Manuel Ramirez [r]
Key Losses: OG Rick DeMulling (Colts)
The Lions completely overhauled their offensive line this season which was a good idea considering how poorly it performed in 2006. However it remains to be seen whether the three veteran players brought in will be able to come together on the field and help this unit improve. George Foster was a promising tackle for the Broncos a few years ago but fell apart over the past couple of years which led to his departure. Still he should be an upgrade for the Lions and his upside is considerable. He may be pushed by 2nd-year tackle Jonathon Scott who struggled as a rookie but is big and athletic. The Lions will start two new guards in 2007 with the arrival of Zach Piller from the Titans and Edwin Mulitalo of the Ravens. Piller is a good starting lineman when healthy but has missed two of the past three seasons due to injury. Mulitalo was a good player a few years back but poor conditioning and work ethic have eroded his play on the field. If committed he is a dependable guard. Jeff Backus is a great left tackle surrounded by questionable talent. This could be a better season for the Lions offensive line or it could be a disappointing one. It all depends on Piller’s health, Foster’s commitment and Mulitalo’s conditioning. At least there is some promise for 2007 unlike years past.
Green Bay Packers
Projected Starters: LT Chad Clifton, LG Daryn Colledge, C Scott Wells, RG Jason Spitz, RT Mark Tauscher
Key Backups: Tony Moll, Junius Coston, Kevin Barry, Allen Barbre [r]
Key Additions: T/G Allen Barbre [r]
Key Losses: none
The Packers brass deserves big props for their 2006 draft that saw them bring aboard three talented players, all of whom started a number of games. What appeared to be a weakness going into 2006 is now fast becoming a strength in 2007. 2nd-year player Jason Spitz started thirteen games last season and had an exceptional rookie campaign. He surprised everybody with his poised play and tremendous technique. Daryn Colledge was also a rookie who stepped in a year ago and improved as the season wore on. He and Spitz are the future of this group. Left tackle Chad Clifton does well in all aspects of the game although he could be more explosive at the point of attack. Tauscher has been a starter since the 2000 season and has both heart and aggression that helps make up for marginal athletic ability. Wells, a fourth-year player came into his own at center a year ago and became a strong starter. What a difference a season can make. It was clear the talent was there for this unit to become a really good group but nobody expected the young players to develop so quickly. Expect more improvement and a good season in 2007.
Houston Texans
Projected Starters: LT Ephraim Salaam, LG Chester Pitts, C Mike Flanagan, RG Fred Weary, RT Eric Winston
Key Backups: Charles Spencer (serious knee injury could derail promising career), Jordan Black, Steve McKinney, Brandon Frye [r]
Key Additions: OT Jordan Black (Chiefs), OT Brandon Frye [r], OG Casey Studdard [r]
Key Losses: OG Zach Wiegert (released)
The Texans offensive line looked improved at times last season but more work needs to be done. Promising 2nd-year player Charles Spencer is still fighting his knee injury that could derail his career before it got going. Winston started 7 games as a rookie a year ago and had some really good moments. He has incredible natural ability and athleticism and he should develop into a great tackle. Chester Pitts has started every game for the Texans over the past five seasons and continues to improve. Pitts will always be a liability in pass protection but he is a mauler in the rushing attack. Fred Weary started 12 games a year ago and played well. Flanagan played well last year but missed seven games due to injury. Steve McKinney filled in during his absence and both are capable centers. There is a big question mark at left tackle right now. It appears that veteran Ephraim Salaam will get the nod but he is a stop-gap solution. Free agent signing Jordan Black will also be in the running to start at tackle. With a healthy Spencer, I would have liked this unit to surprise with a very strong season but the question mark at left tackle cannot be overlooked. If that position is stabilized, the rest of the starting group is talented enough to have a productive season.
Indianapolis Colts
Projected Starters: LT Tarik Glenn, LG Ryan Lilja, C Jeff Saturday, RG Jake Scott, RT Ryan Diem
Key Backups: Tony Ugoh [r], Dylan Gandy, Charlie Johnson, Rick DeMulling
Key Additions: OG Rick DeMulling (Lions), OT Tony Ugoh [r]
Key Losses: none
This starting unit features a couple of great linemen in left tackle Tarik Glenn and center Jeff Saturday. Both are near the top of their positions in the NFL. The other three linemen aren’t overly talented, but play with heart, brains and have become part of a very good offensive line. Among the more cohesive units in football, this group continues to grow each season. Having Peyton Manning under center certainly helps but this unit is making big strides in run blocking over the past couple of seasons. Backup guard Dylan Gandy started eleven games for Lilja a year ago and may compete for the starting position this year. He also backs up Saturday at center. The Colts drafted talented tackle Tony Ugoh in this year’s draft and he has the talent to become a star down the road. Finally Rick DeMulling was brought back to the fold after a couple of seasons in Detroit and he brings great experience to a backup role. Expect more of the same for this offensive line in 2007.
Jacksonville Jaguars
Projected Starters: LT Khalif Barnes, LG Vince Manuwai, C Brad Meester, RG Chris Naeole, RT Maurice Williams
Key Backups: Stockar McDougle, Tony Pashos, Dennis Norman, Uche Nwaneri [r]
Key Additions: OT Tony Pashos (Ravens), OG Uche Nwaneri [r]
Key Losses: none
There is a lot of talent on offensive line for the Jaguars but some questions that still need to be answered. Khalif Barnes, a 3rd-year pro has become a fixture at left tackle and should continue to improve. There will be a battle at right tackle between incumbent starter Maurice Williams and free agent acquisition Tony Pashos. The club has been a little disappointed in Maurice Williams as of late and Pashos will be given every opportunity to win the job. Right now it is 50/50 as to who will emerge as the starting right tackle but Williams is the more talented of the two. Vince Manuwai is a very good guard who has missed only two starts over the past four seasons. He is very dependable at left guard. Chris Naeole starts at the other guard position. He isn’t flashy but has only missed two games in the last nine years and is also a dependable player. Finally at center, Brad Meester is a great player who is the leader of this group. The depth in Jacksonville is very good with a good veteran base to draw from. The Jaguars have the makings of a tremendous line and were one of the better run blocking units last season. Expect more of the same from this group in 2007.
Kansas City Chiefs
Projected Starters: LT Damion McIntosh, LG Brian Waters, C Casey Wiegmann, RG John Welbourn, RT Chris Terry
Key Backups: Rudy Niswanger, Kevin Sampson, Tre Stallings, Chris Bober, Herbert Taylor [r]
Key Additions: OT Damion McIntosh (Dolphins), OT Herbert Taylor [r]
Key Losses: OT Jordan Black (Texans), Kyle Turley (released), OG Will Shields (retired)
How the mighty have fallen. Once the class of the entire NFL, this unit now looks like an average group at best. At center Casey Wiegmann is getting long in the tooth but has started 95 straight games for the Chiefs and he’ll do a good job again in 2007. Of concern to the Chiefs though is speculation that he may choose to retire this season. Nothing has been decided as of yet but if he does, this unit may collapse. Brian Waters is an excellent left guard. If Wiegmann were to retire, Waters could slot into center. At right tackle it appears that Chris Terry will start. He has 80 career starts in the NFL but is just an adequate starting lineman who is in some trouble after failing to appear at a court hearing near the end of April. The Chiefs paid big bucks to sign Damion McIntosh. He does solidify the left side of the line but he isn’t an elite lineman despite being paid as such. He’ll do a good job but won’t dominate football games. At right guard, there will be a battle between veteran John Welbourn and Chris Bober. Training camp will determine who wins that battle. Two interesting young guards are Tre Stallings and Rudy Niswanger who have talent as well as size and could compete at right guard as well. Also 4th year tackle Kevin Sampson may get an opportunity at right tackle if Terry falters. This unit is not nearly as strong as it was a couple of seasons ago. Best case prognosis is middle of the pack and if Wiegmann retires, this could turn into a disaster.
Miami Dolphins
Projected Starters: LT Anthony Alabi, LG Rex Hadnot, C Samson Satele [r], RG L.J. Shelton, RT Vernon Carey
Key Backups: Joe Toledo, Chris Liwienski, Mike Rosenthal
Key Additions: OG Chris Liwienski (Cardinals), Mike Rosenthal, C Samson Satele[r]
Key Losses: OT Damion McIntosh (Chiefs), OG/C Seth McKinney (Browns), OG Toniu Fonoti (Falcons), OG Jeno James
It is really difficult to project the Dolphins starting five at this time. Hudson Houck is a talented coach but he can only do so much. Talk about a unit in a state of flux. It appears at this time that the starting unit will look like this although many combinations are still possible. It appeared likely that Red Hadnot would start at center and he still may but with the Dolphins drafting talented center Samson Satele from Hawaii in the second round, he’ll likely get a shot if he has a good training camp. Satele is quick and athletic and a natural center. That will allow Hadnot to slot into guard where he is experienced. He isn’t a great talent but he is gritty, plays hard and is improving. L.J. Shelton could slot in a left tackle but he’s always struggled there and his lack of quickness makes him a better fit at right guard. Vernon Carey has come into his own over at right tackle and he will continue to improve. He is the best lineman on the roster now. Finally at left tackle it appears right now that it is Anthony Alabi’s job to lose. He struggled in mini-camp but the club likes his ability. Joe Toledo is a talented 2nd-year kid whom the Dolphins like a great deal and could emerge as a starter. Finally both Chris Liwienski and Mike Rosenthal are veteran players who aren’t flashy but can do the job if called upon. There are simply too many question marks here to expect a great year.
Minnesota Vikings
Projected Starters: LT Bryant McKinnie, LG Steve Hutchinson, C Matt Birk, RG Artis Hicks, RT Marcus Johnson
Key Backups: Ryan Cook, Anthony Herrera
Key Additions: none
Key Losses: OG/C Jason Whittle (Bills), OT Mike Rosenthal (released)
Here is a unit with the talented to be great but didn’t manage to put it all together a year ago. Bryant McKinnie is a cornerstone at left tackle for the Vikings but his play on the field has never been able to match his incredible potential. He really should be a perennial Pro Bowler but until he produces on a consistent, dominant basis he’ll just be a good and not great player. Steve Hutchinson however is a star player. Hutchinson didn’t have his best season in his first year in Minnesota but still was very good and should return back to his dominant form this year. Matt Birk made the Pro Bowl again last year and deservedly so as he is an elite center. Artis Hicks was picked up last year and started fourteen games for the Vikings. He isn’t a great player but he dependable and is a powerful run blocker. Finally at right tackle it will be a battle between two young players. 3rd-year player Marcus Johnson started 10 games a season ago but was only adequate. He took too many holding penalties and is beat too often around the edge. Still he is young and improving and he may develop into a good starter. The other option is 2nd-year lineman Ryan Cook who is a center in a tackle’s body. He has good range and may beat out Johnson with a good camp. This has the makings of an elite unit if everyone plays up to their potential. Rookie RB Adrian Peterson will be happy he runs behind this unit.
New England Patriots
Projected Starters: LT Matt Light, LG Logan Mankins, C Dan Koppen, RG Steve Neal, RT Nick Kaczur
Key Backups: Wesley Britt, Billy Yates, Ryan O'Callaghan, Russ Hochstein
Key Additions: Corey Hilliard [r]
Key Losses: none
The Patriots offensive line has developed into one of the best groups in football. The addition of Logan Mankins two seasons ago really put this group over the top and this unit is one of the best in the NFL. They play very well as a unit, each is very intelligent and the scheme is an exceptional one. The best lineman is probably Matt Light who is not overpowering but athletic with sound technique. The guard position is in great shape with Mankins becoming a top-tier guard and Neal being a gritty, hard-nosed blocker. Dan Koppen is dependable at the center position and likely one of the best playing the position today. The only real question mark is at right tackle. Nick Kaczur is the weak link of this unit. He is an average starter at best and can be overpowered at the point of attack. He’ll be pushed by 2nd-year giant Ryan O’Callaghan who is 6’7, 330 pounds and played very well when given the opportunity a year ago. He isn’t the most mobile lineman but has good power and his upside is enormous. All in all this is a very good offensive line and it will be more of the same in 2007.
New Orleans Saints
Projected Starters: LT Jammal Brown, LG Jamar Nesbit, C Jeff Faine, RG Jahri Evans, RT Jon Stinchcomb
Key Backups: Jonathon Goodwin, Zach Strief, Andy Alleman [r]
Key Additions: OG Andy Alleman [r], OT Jermon Bushrod [r]
Key Losses: OG Montrae Holland (Broncos);
The Saints team surprised a season ago and that charge was led by the Saints offensive line that played much better than anticipated. Everybody knew that Jammal Brown was a very talented individual and last year he became dominant. He was simply incredible and is still coming into his own. He may be considered the best young lineman in the NFL today. Jeff Faine always had the talent to be a great center but simply could not stay healthy. However last year he was able to stay on the field and he had a very strong season. Jon Stinchcomb is another player who came into 2006 with a ton of talent but an inability to escape the injury bug. Last year however he was healthy and he was a pleasant surprise for the Saints. Jamar Nesbit is a veteran guard who brings experience and technique to the table. He isn’t a star but had a very good season in 2006 and should be reliable again this year. Finally Jahri Evans was a huge surprise as a first year starter a season ago. The Saints drafted Andy Alleman from Akron and in a season or two, he may turn out to be a very good player. This unit came together in a big way a season ago and the only thing that can derail them this year is if injury woes return to Faine and Stinchcomb.
New York Giants
Projected Starters: LT David Diehl, LG Gray Ruegamer, C Shaun O’Hara, RG Chris Snee, RT Kareem McKenzie
Key Backups: Guy Whimper, Rich Seubert Adam Koets
Key Additions: OT Adam Koets [r]
Key Losses: OT Luke Petitgout (Buccaneers)
The Giants lost long-time starter at left tackle Luke Petitgout to the Buccaneers. He was a leader of the unit and he’ll be missed. However he had been fighting injury problems over the past couple of seasons and hadn’t been as effective as in years past. It appears that David Diehl will move from left guard to start at the left tackle position and he has the ability to make that transition. The team did draft Adam Koets from Oregon State and his upside is considerable. However it is doubtful he’ll be ready to start in 2007. Kareem McKenzie is a fixture at right tackle. He is a big man who plays with a chip on his shoulder on every play. He punishes the defender across from him and is an aggressive run blocker. His pass blocking isn’t tremendous but he gets the job done. Chris Snee is an underrated guard who is one of the best run blockers in football. He is aggressive and never quits on a play. Shaun O’Hara is the leader of the group and is an above-average player. Finally it appears that Gray Ruegamer, a veteran with only 17 career starts slides into left tackle although he’ll be pushed in camp by several players. It’s one thing to let a player like Petitgout leave because there is someone ready to take over but that wasn’t the case in New York. Diehl will cover the spot well but he was a force at guard and nobody is going to replace what he brought to the table. Expect a bit of a drop off in 2007.
New York Jets
Projected Starters: LT D'Brickashaw Ferguson, LG Pete Kendall, C Nick Mangold, RG Brandon Jones, RT Adrian Jones
Key Backups: Adrian Clarke, Wade Smith, Anthony Clement, Jacob Bender
Key Additions: OT Jacob Bender [r]
Key Losses: C Trey Teague (released)
The New York Jets were in a transition period last year with two rookies in the starting group. D’Brickashaw Ferguson started all sixteen games but struggled during his rookie campaign. He even struggled in pass protection which was his strength coming out of school. He must play better this season but being so young, he'll likely improve significantly in 2007. Fellow rookie in 2006, center Nick Mangold also stepped in and played in all sixteen games. However he stepped in like a seasoned vet and established himself as one of the best young centers in the game. Adrian Jones didn’t start a game last season but should step back into the right tackle spot this season unless veteran Anthony Clement has a tremendous camp. Brandon Moore has been a dependable right guard for years. He is athletic and plays with passion. Pete Kendall is the grizzled, old-beard of the group entering his 12th season but he is still a good starter at guard and brings experience and leadership to the table. There is pretty good depth here and the team drafted a project tackle in Jacob Bender who dominated 1-AA and has incredible athleticism. This unit should continue to improve throughout the year.
Oakland Raiders
Projected Starters: LT Robert Gallery, LG Paul McQuistan, C Jake Grove, RG Cooper Carlisle, RT Cornell Green
Key Backups: Jeremy Newberry, Chad Slaughter, Kevin Boothe, Mario Henderson [r]
Key Additions: C Jeremy Newberry (49ers), OG Cornell Green (Buccaneers), OG Cooper Carlisle, OT Mario Henderson [r]
Key Losses: OT Langston Walker (Bills)
The Raiders offense was horrendous last year and the offensive line was as much to blame as the rest of the offensive unit. Robert Gallery at left tackle continues to be an enigma. He has the athleticism and talent to dominate defenses but he continues to be average at best. He only played in ten games last season, allowed one sack per game, took too many penalties and struggled in the running game. He must do better going forward. Paul McQuistan had his moments last year in his six starts but he is still raw. He is tenacious and plays with a ton of heart and will get better with experience. 4th year center Jake Grove is talented but also struggled last year and will have to have a good training camp to hold off veteran, free agent Jeremy Newberry. Cooper Carlisle was brought in from Denver and hopefully he’ll bring confidence to the group. He isn’t a great player but should help stabilize the right side. At this point right tackle is unclear. Cornell Green is in the running as is rookie tackle Mario Henderson from Florida State. This will be another painful year for this unit but if the young talent can develop, there is hope for the future.
Philadelphia Eagles
Projected Starters: LT William Thomas, LG Todd Herremans, C Jamaal Jackson, RG Shawn Andrews, RT Jon Runyan
Key Backups: Winston Justice, Max Jean-Gilles, Scott Young
Key Additions: none
Key Losses: none
The Eagles will likely be starting the same five linemen as a year ago and this is an above-average group. William Thomas is heading into his 10th season for the Eagles and he is still performing at a high level at left tackle. When the time comes, 2nd-year Winston Justice will step in and the Eagles won’t miss a beat but that won’t happen for awhile. Shawn Andrews played all sixteen games once again in 2006 and improved significantly over his prior season. His weight is under control and he is becoming a terrific player. He made the Pro Bowl last season and deservedly so. On the other side, Todd Herremans started all sixteen games and played well. He isn’t an elite blocker but he fits in nicely and should start again. Pushing him may be talented 2nd-year player Max Jean-Gilles who has impressed coaches on the practice field. Jamaal Jackson won the starting center job and did a great job in his first full season as the starter. Finally Jon Runyan, who hasn’t missed a start in ten straight seasons, will get the nod at right tackle. Expect another great season from this group in 2007.
Pittsburgh Steelers
Projected Starters: LT Marvel Smith, LG Alan Faneca, C Sean Mahan, RG Kendall Simmons, RT Max Starks
Key Backups: Chris Kemoeatu, Willie Colon, Cameron Stephenson [r], Chukky Okobi,
Key Additions: OG/C Sean Mahan (Buccaneers), OG Cameron Stephenson[r]
Key Losses: C Jeff Hartings
The Steelers lost center Jeff Hartings to retirement this season and there will be a battle to determine the new starter. At this point it appears that free agent pickup Sean Mahan will battle starting right guard Kendall Simmons for the center job. The player who doesn’t emerge as the center will start at right guard. Of some concern is starting left guard Alan Faneca’s unhappiness in regards to his current contract. He skipped the first day of mini-camp and may miss more sessions as well. This will likely work out in time but the Steelers can’t afford to lose two gifted members of last season’s starting unit. Faneca has missed only one start in the past seven years and has been a Pro Bowler in six straight seasons. At right tackle, Max Starks has settled in as the man. He isn’t a dominant player yet but his upside is huge and he’s improving. He’s started 30 of the past 32 games. Chris Kemoeatu looks like a great fit in this offense but he has yet to put the pieces together and he isn’t ready to start. Willie Colon looked good in his two starts a year ago and he continues to grow as a player. The Steelers offensive line can continue on without Jeff Hartings and still be great but they need a happy Faneca going forward.
San Diego Chargers
Projected Starters: LT Marcus McNeill, LG Kris Dielman, C Nick Hardwick, RG Mike Goff, RT Shane Olivea
Key Backups: Scott Mruczkowski, Roman Oben, Corey Withrow
Key Additions: none
Key Losses: none
Heading into the preseason a year ago, rookie Marcus McNeil was a big question mark. His back was considered troublesome, he was getting beat in camp and he had no pro experience. Once week one began though none of that mattered as he had a sensational rookie season and was the NFL’s best rookie offensive tackle. He didn’t make the Pro Bowl but probably should have. Right guard Mike Goff is your stereotypical mucker. He is aggressive, plays hard and that overcomes his marginal athleticism. He is much better than most realize. Kris Dielman was almost lost to the Seattle Seahawks in free agency but the Chargers had the rights to match the offer and they did so. Dielman is an improving guard who is coming into his own. Not sure he is worth the money he received but it was important for the group to stay together. Nick Hardwick is another young player getting better each season. A couple of years ago the Chargers offensive line struggled with these young players learning their craft but it has all come together now. Shane Olivea is probably the weakest link along the line but he is a decent tackle and doesn’t hurt the offensive production. With veteran backups in place, expect another strong season from this group in 2007.
San Francisco 49ers
Projected Starters: LT Jonas Jennings, LG Larry Allen, C Eric Heitmann, RG Justin Smiley, RT Kwame Harris
Key Backups: Adam Snyder, David Baas, Joe Staley [r]
Key Additions: OT Joe Staley [r]
Key Losses: C Jeremy Newberry (Raiders)
The 49ers offensive line played very well at times last season but there is still potential for a couple of big moves this season. The club isn’t overly happy with right tackle Kwame Harris and right guard Justin Smiley, haven’t offered to extend their contracts (expired after this season) and they could be replaced as early as this season with rookie Joe Staley from Central Michigan slotting in at tackle and David Baas or even tackle Adam Snyder sliding inside to right guard. For now though, Harris and Smiley are still on the roster and will probably start if still on the club. However if Staley has a great training camp, he may emerge as the victor and start whether or not Harris is around. Eric Heitmann is turning out to be a very good center and he’s developing into the leader of the group. Left guard Larry Allen did make the Pro Bowl is his first season in San Francisco but he’s 36-years old this season and beginning to show his age. Jonas Jennings missed a few games but was dominant when on the field. His durability is the only thing keeping him from being a Pro Bowl caliber player. The club has good depth and it should be another strong season for this group if the question marks along the right side don’t disrupt the club.
Seattle Seahawks
Projected Starters: LT Walter Jones, LG Rob Sims, C Chris Spencer, RG Chris Gray, RT Sean Locklear
Key Backups: Floyd ‘Porkchop’ Womack, Tom Ashworth, Ray Willis, Mansfield Wrotto[r]
Key Additions: OG Mansfield Wrotto[r]
Key Losses: Robbie Tobeck (retired)
Walter Jones is still an elite tackle but he gave up ten sacks a year ago (a career high) and is beginning to show his age. He’s still a great luxury to have at left tackle though. Chris Gray is back for a fifteenth season in the NFL but is now at best an average lineman. 2nd-year player Rob Sims started three games for the club as a rookie and should earn the starting nod ahead of veteran Floyd ‘Porkchop’ Womack. Chris Spencer is a 3rd-year center that started thirteen games last year and has tremendous upside. He is athletic, hard-working and has good technique. Sean Locklear will likely get the nod once again at tackle but he’s only an average starter who can get beat in passing situations. Tom Ashworth was brought in last year to compete for a starting position but he disappointed and is now only a depth player. Womack has talent but has only 32 starts in six years and has durability issues. This isn’t the strength that it was a couple of seasons ago. Jones presence still gives confidence and both Sims and Spencer offer hope for the future but this group will not be elite in 2007.
St. Louis Rams
Projected Starters: LT Orlando Pace, LG Mark Setterstrom, C Andy McCollum, RG Richie Incognito, RT Alex Barron
Key Backups: Claude Terrell, Adam Goldberg, Todd Steussie
Key Additions: C Dustin Fry [r]
Key Losses: Adam Timmerman (released)
Left tackle Orlando Pace had a forgettable 2006 season. He missed eight games due to injury and he’ll be looking for a bounce back performance this year. He is now entering his 11th season and will be turning 32 years old this season. He has had just one holding penalty in the last seven years. Alex Barron is a young player who has 27 starts in the last two years. He has played well but needs to improve to take the next step in his development. Inexcusable is the 22 false start penalties over the past two seasons. He has great athleticism and could become an elite player with hard work. As a first-year starter last year, Richie Incognito surprised with a very good performance. He is tenacious and loves to get after defenders and it appears that his problems are now behind him. Andy McCollum is 37 years old but back for another season as the starting center. He played in only one game last year though and he’ll have to show he’s healthy to see the field this year. Perhaps his future replacement was drafted this season in Dustin Fry who has great size and tenacity. He is more of a brawler than a technician. This unit is kind of in transition between the old and the new but it appeared to work last season and should again this year. With a healthy Pace, expect a good season from this unit in 2007.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Projected Starters: LT Luke Petitgout, LG Arron Sears [r], C John Wade, RG Davin Joseph, RT Jeremy Trueblood
Key Backups: Dan Buenning, Jeb Terry, Matt Lehr, Anthony Davis
Key Additions: OG Matt Lehr (Falcons), OT Luke Petitgout (Giants), OG Arron Sears [r]
Key Losses: OG Sean Mahan (Steelers), OT Kenyatta Walker (released)
The good news for the Buccaneers is there is a ton of talent to pick a starting five from this season. The bad news is having to pick five starters from this group. It’s going to be tough at left guard to determine between Anthony Davis, Dan Buenning and rookie Arron Sears who should get to start. Even veteran Matt Lehr may be in the mix to start at guard for this team. Sears was a tackle in school but should turn out to be a tremendous guard in the NFL with his size, smarts and toughness. He will be given every opportunity to win the starting job but no matter who they go with at left guard, the Buccaneers will be in good shape. Jeremy Trueblood started thirteen games at tackle last year and did very well as a rookie. He is a talented kid who should continue to improve this year and is a lock to start at right tackle. Davin Joseph had a strong rookie campaign in 2006 and has the size, ability and toughness to be one of the best guards in the NFL. He should be even better this season. Luke Petitgout was brought in for leadership and to stabilize the left side of the line. He’ll start at left tackle and do just that. Anthony Davis started sixteen games for the Buccaneers and they won’t lose much if they have to slot him in at tackle or even guard. Center John Wade isn’t flashy but he gets the job done. With tons of depth and young talent, this is one of the best looking young units in the entire NFL. By 2008, this group may be considered one of the best in football.
Tennessee Titans
Projected Starters: LT Michael Roos, LG Jacob Bell, C Kevin Mawae, RG Benji Olson, RT David Stewart
Key Backups: Seth Wand, Justin Geisinger, Daniel Loper, Leroy Harris [r]
Key Additions: C/OG Leroy Harris [r], T Mike Otto [r]
Key Losses: OG Zach Piller (Lions)
Considering the youth at tackle last season, the Titans offensive line did extremely well last season and should be even better this year. It all starts up the middle with veteran Kevin Mawae bringing experience and leadership to the team. He’s 36-years old now but isn’t showing his age yet and could have another couple of good seasons in him. The club may have drafted his future replacement this season in Leroy Harris from NC State. Harris is smart and tough and gets to learn from Mawae while learning his craft. Benji Olson has missed just two starts in eight seasons and is as consistent as they come. Jacob Bell started fifteen games last season and had a tremendous year. He now looks like a fixture at left guard. Both young tackles, David Stewart and Michael Roos were exceptional and are still improving. They give the Titans perhaps the best young bookends in all of the NFL. The Titans offensive line appears to be in great shape and it should be another strong effort this season.
Washington Redskins
Projected Starters: LT Chris Samuels, LG Taylor Whitley C Casey Rabach, RG Randy Thomas, RT Jon Jansen
Key Backups: William Whitticker, Jason Fabini
Key Additions: OT Jason Fabini (Cowboys)
Key Losses: OG Derrick Dockery (Bills), OT Jim Molinaro (Cowboys)
Four of the five starting linemen are written in stone and have been playing together for years. Chris Samuels played in all sixteen games for the third consecutive season and is a great left tackle. He made the Pro Bowl each of the past two seasons and should be considered one of the finest tackles in the game today. Jon Jansen isn’t as talented as Samuels but has good size and smarts and is very good right tackle. At right guard Randy Thomas has started 61 of the past 64 games and is an aggressive, athletic guard that doesn’t get as much appreciation as he should. Center Casey Rabach has started 32 straight games for the Redskins and is a dependable player. It is at left guard that the question marks begin. Derrick Dockery left via free agency and there is a big hole at left guard with no obvious replacement on the team. Taylor Whitley is a natural guard that may slot in as is William Whitticker. There is even a chance that free agent acquisition Jason Fabini will move over from tackle to guard. No matter who starts at left guard, this is a good overall unit. If the left guard position is filled well, this unit should be very strong again this season.
All the teams are graded and then ranked 1st to 32nd based on the criteria I set forth above. When you see the entire table plus read the write-up for each of the 32 teams, I am hopeful that the reasoning will be clear and accurate. I'm always interested in hearing other opinions on offensive lines however so once the article is posted to the site later on, feel free to break it down and tell me what I'm on my game and when I'm not.
This is a great post 
That "opener" was hysterical. I felt like I was in third grade or something...
