What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

List of players who left the year before their team won the SB... (1 Viewer)

SuperJohn96

SuperJohn96

RPS World Champion
YEAR GAME NFL2008 XLIII PIT/ARI2007 XLII NYG2006 XLI IND2005 XL PIT2004 XXXIX NEP2003 XXXVIII NEP2002 XXXVII TBB2001 XXXVI NEP2000 XXXV BAL1999 XXXIV STL1998 XXXIII DEN1997 XXXII DEN1996 XXXI GBP1995 XXX DAL1994 XXIX SFO1993 XXVIII DAL1992 XXVII DAL1991 XXVI WAS1990 XXV NYGIt could be via Free Agency, Retiring, being Traded or just cut.Obvious one is Tiki Barber leaving before the Giants won SB XLII...

As for the PIT/ARI Super Bowl:

Calvin Pace left the Cardinals for the Jets

Clark Haggans left the Steelers for the Cardinals

 
Last edited by a moderator:
SuperJohn96 said:
Code: 
YEAR   GAME	 NFL2008   XLIII	PIT/ARI2007   XLII	 NYG2006   XLI	  IND2005   XL	   PIT2004   XXXIX	NEP2003   XXXVIII  NEP2002   XXXVII   TBB2001   XXXVI	NEP2000   XXXV	 BAL1999   XXXIV	STL1998   XXXIII   DEN1997   XXXII	DEN1996   XXXI	 GBP1995   XXX	  DAL1994   XXIX	 SFO1993   XXVIII   DAL1992   XXVII	DAL1991   XXVI	 WAS1990   XXV	  NYG
It could be via Free Agency, Retiring, being Traded or just cut.Obvious one is Tiki Barber leaving before the Giants won SB XLII...As for the PIT/ARI Super Bowl:Calvin Pace left the Cardinals for the JetsClark Haggans left the Steelers for the Cardinals
Click to expand...
Edgerrin James - Colts
 
NFL rosters don't stay the same year after year. There always will be many players not on a team one year that were on it the previous year.

Alvin Harper left Dallas before their 3rd Super Bowl win in the 90's.

 
Here's a few from last year's New York Giants

Tiki Barber Retired

Tim Carter Cleveland

Jay Feely Miami

Luke Petitgout Tampa

Carlos Emmons Retired

Lavar Arrington Released and not played since ( not sure if he's officially retired )

Bob Whitfield Retired

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The Man With No Name said:
NFL rosters don't stay the same year after year. There always will be many players not on a team one year that were on it the previous year.

Alvin Harper left Dallas before their 3rd Super Bowl win in the 90's.
Click to expand...
Well that goes without saying.I'm not surprised, I am just curious on who JUUUUST missed out on being on a championship team.

 
Lawyer Milloy certainly comes to mind... cut just before the start of the regular season; Pats go on to win the Super Bowl without him.

 
John Jurkovic - a huge fan favorite in Green Bay, who unfortunately left for Jacksonville after the 1995 season. His life has since spiraled down the tubes, as he finds himself in a deplorable position on Chicago sports radio pretending to be a Bear fan.

 
CletiusMaximus said:
John Jurkovic - a huge fan favorite in Green Bay, who unfortunately left for Jacksonville after the 1995 season. His life has since spiraled down the tubes, as he finds himself in a deplorable position on Chicago sports radio pretending to be a Bear fan.
Click to expand...
:goodposting: IIRC he grew up in Calumet City. Not sure how that makes him a "pretend" fan. And exactly how has his life "spiraled down the tubes"? He's very entertaining on the radio.

 
SuperJohn96 said:
The Man With No Name said:
NFL rosters don't stay the same year after year. There always will be many players not on a team one year that were on it the previous year.

Alvin Harper left Dallas before their 3rd Super Bowl win in the 90's.
Click to expand...
Well that goes without saying.I'm not surprised, I am just curious on who JUUUUST missed out on being on a championship team.
Click to expand...
OK. Super Bowl XXIX Champion San Francisco was missing the following players from the previous season:WR Stanley Beach

QB Steve Bono

TE John Brandes

PK Mike Cofer

LB Keith DeLong

DE Kevin Fagan

LB Brett Faryniarz

G Roy Foster

CB Don Griffin

CB Adrian Hardy

LB John Johnson

LB Darin Jordan

LB Larry Kelm

DL Matt LeBounty

RB Amp Lee

CB Michael McGruder

G Guy McIntyre

QB Bill Musgrave

FB Tom Rathman

DE Larry Roberts

LB Bill Romanowski

S Damien Russell

DL Artie Smith

WR Odessa Turner

TE Wesley Walls

LB Mike Walker

DT Ted Washington

TE Jamie Williams

DL Karl Wilson

 
Here are, by my reckoning, the top three players in Year N-1 who did not play for that team in Year N for each team that made a Super Bowl in Year N:

Tiki Barber NYG 2007

Will Demps NYG 2007

Carlos Emmons NYG 2007

Artrell Hawkins NWE 2007

Reche Caldwell NWE 2007

Corey Dillon NWE 2007

Edgerrin James IND 2006

David Thornton IND 2006

Corey Simon IND 2006

Michael Green CHI 2006

Bobby Wade CHI 2006

Kyle Orton CHI 2006

Ken Lucas SEA 2005

Cedric Woodard SEA 2005

Chike Okeafor SEA 2005

Plaxico Burress PIT 2005

Oliver Ross PIT 2005

Keydrick Vincent PIT 2005

Troy Vincent PHI 2004

N.D. Kalu PHI 2004

Duce Staley PHI 2004

Bobby Hamilton NWE 2004

Ted Washington NWE 2004

Damien Woody NWE 2004

Lawyer Milloy NWE 2003

Kenyatta Jones NWE 2003

Otis Smith NWE 2003

Mark Fields CAR 2003

Hannibal Navies CAR 2003

Emmanuel McDaniel CAR 2003

Warrick Dunn TAM 2002

Jerry Wunsch TAM 2002

Jamie Duncan TAM 2002

Grady Jackson OAK 2002

Greg Biekert OAK 2002

William Thomas OAK 2002

Chad Eaton NWE 2001

Chris Slade NWE 2001

Bruce Armstrong NWE 2001

Trent Green STL 2001

Mike Jones STL 2001

Ray Agnew STL 2001

Roman Oben NYG 2000

Scott Gragg NYG 2000

Corey Widmer NYG 2000

DeRon Jenkins BAL 2000

Everett Lindsay BAL 2000

Errict Rhett BAL 2000

Mike D. Jones STL 1999

Tony Banks STL 1999

Eric Hill STL 1999

Gary Walker TEN 1999

Lonnie Marts TEN 1999

Darryll Lewis TEN 1999

Gary Zimmerman DEN 1998

Allen Aldridge DEN 1998

Brian Habib DEN 1998

Bert Emanuel ATL 1998

Dan Owens ATL 1998

Matt Willig ATL 1998

Anthony Miller DEN 1997

Broderick Thompson DEN 1997

Dan Williams DEN 1997

Sean Jones GNB 1997

Edgar Bennett GNB 1997

Keith Jackson GNB 1997

Vincent Brown NWE 1996

Myron Guyton NWE 1996

Reggie E. White NWE 1996

Harry Galbreath GNB 1996

George Teague GNB 1996

John Jurkovic GNB 1996

Mark Stepnoski DAL 1995

Alvin Harper DAL 1995

James Washington DAL 1995

Eric Green PIT 1995

Duval Love PIT 1995

Gerald Williams PIT 1995

Guy McIntyre SFO 1994

Bill Romanowski SFO 1994

John Johnson SFO 1994

Anthony Miller SDG 1994

Mike Zandofsky SDG 1994

Donald Frank SDG 1994

Vinson Smith DAL 1993

Kelvin Martin DAL 1993

Issiac Holt DAL 1993

Will Wolford BUF 1993

James Lofton BUF 1993

Shane Conlan BUF 1993

Leon Seals BUF 1992

Leonard Smith BUF 1992

Hal Garner BUF 1992

Jack Del Rio DAL 1992

Manny Hendrix DAL 1992

Robert Awalt DAL 1992

Darryl Grant WAS 1991

Todd Bowles WAS 1991

Greg Manusky WAS 1991

John Hagy BUF 1991

Don Smith BUF 1991

Jamie Mueller BUF 1991

Fred Smerlas BUF 1990

Art Still BUF 1990

Joe Devlin BUF 1990

Terry Kinard NYG 1990

Zeke Mowatt NYG 1990

Damian Johnson NYG 1990

Jim Ryan DEN 1989

Bill Bryan DEN 1989

Mike Harden DEN 1989

Randy Cross SFO 1989

Riki Ellison SFO 1989

Ron Heller SFO 1989

Milt McColl SFO 1988

Joe Cribbs SFO 1988

Russ Francis SFO 1988

Robert Jackson CIN 1988

Larry Kinnebrew CIN 1988

Dave Rimington CIN 1988

Curtis Jordan WAS 1987

Calvin Daniels WAS 1987

Ken Coffey WAS 1987

Paul Howard DEN 1987

Louis Wright DEN 1987

Steve Foley DEN 1987

Curtis McGriff NYG 1986

George Adams NYG 1986

Rob Carpenter NYG 1986

Barney Chavous DEN 1986

Steve Busick DEN 1986

James Wright DEN 1986

Darryl Haley NWE 1985

Rick Sanford NWE 1985

Tim Golden NWE 1985

Todd Bell CHI 1985

Al Harris CHI 1985

Jeff Fisher CHI 1985

Pete Kugler SFO 1984

Willie Harper SFO 1984

Eason Ramson SFO 1984

Bob Kuechenberg MIA 1984

Gerald Small MIA 1984

David Overstreet MIA 1984

Curt Marsh RAI 1983

Burgess Owens RAI 1983

Dave Browning RAI 1983

Tony Peters WAS 1983

Mat Mendenhall WAS 1983

Jeris White WAS 1983

Terry Metcalf WAS 1982

Karl Lorch WAS 1982

Melvin Jones WAS 1982

Don Bessillieu MIA 1982

Ken Poole MIA 1982

Nick Giaquinto MIA 1982

**** Jauron CIN 1981

Andrew Melontree CIN 1981

Ron Simpkins CIN 1981

Ron Singleton SFO 1981

Steve DeBerg SFO 1981

Charles Johnson SFO 1981

Ken Stabler OAK 1980

Phil Villapiano OAK 1980

Jack Tatum OAK 1980

Bob Howard PHI 1980

Wade Key PHI 1980

Terry Tautolo PHI 1980

Cody Jones RAM 1979

Tom Mack RAM 1979

Bill Simpson RAM 1979

Ray Pinney PIT 1979

Tony Dungy PIT 1979

Fred Anderson PIT 1979

Ralph Neely DAL 1978

Mel Renfro DAL 1978

Bill Gregory DAL 1978

Jim Clack PIT 1978

J.T. Thomas PIT 1978

Glen Edwards PIT 1978

John Rowser DEN 1977

Steve Ramsey DEN 1977

Bill Bain DEN 1977

Lee Roy Jordan DAL 1977

Blaine Nye DAL 1977

Charley Young DAL 1977

John Gilliam MIN 1976

Ed Marinaro MIN 1976

Terry Brown MIN 1976

Gerald Irons OAK 1976

Tony Cline OAK 1976

Horace Jones OAK 1976

Ron Shanklin PIT 1975

Preston Pearson PIT 1975

Steve Davis PIT 1975

Bob Lilly DAL 1975

Calvin Hill DAL 1975

Pat Toomay DAL 1975

Carroll Dale MIN 1974

Ron Porter MIN 1974

John Ward MIN 1974

Bruce Van Dyke PIT 1974

Henry Davis PIT 1974

John Rowser PIT 1974

Otto Stowe MIA 1973

Jim Dunaway MIA 1973

Howard Kindig MIA 1973

Gene Washington MIN 1973

Karl Kassulke MIN 1973

John Henderson MIN 1973

Jim Riley MIA 1972

Bob DeMarco MIA 1972

John Richardson MIA 1972

Jim Snowden WAS 1972

Boyd Dowler WAS 1972

Tommy Mason WAS 1972

Lance Rentzel DAL 1971

Pettis Norman DAL 1971

Steve Kiner DAL 1971

Ted Davis MIA 1971

Maxie Williams MIA 1971

Stan Mitchell MIA 1971

Willie Richardson BAL 1970

Lenny Lyles BAL 1970

Terry Cole BAL 1970

Malcolm Walker DAL 1970

John Wilbur DAL 1970

Mike Gaechter DAL 1970

Larry Bowie MIN 1969

Bill Martin MIN 1969

King Hill MIN 1969

Ernie Ladd KAN 1969

Bud Abell KAN 1969

Dave Martin KAN 1969

Sherman Plunkett NYJ 1968

Jim Harris Jr. NYJ 1968

Dennis Randall NYJ 1968

Raymond Berry BAL 1968

Tony Lorick BAL 1968

Jim Parker BAL 1968

Art Powell OAK 1967

Tom Flores OAK 1967

Joe Krakoski OAK 1967

Paul Hornung GNB 1967

Jim Taylor GNB 1967

Bill Curry GNB 1967

Lloyd Voss GNB 1966

Bud Marshall GNB 1966

Hank Gremminger GNB 1966

Frank Jackson KAN 1966

Mack Lee Hill KAN 1966

Mel Branch KAN 1966

 
both parts of the Eagles longtime CB duo(Troy Vincent and Bobby Taylor) left right before they made the superbowl. people think the Al Harris/Charles Woodson CB duo are physical CB's

 
Faneca left Pitt for Jets this season..

Edgerrin James left Indy the year they won it, right?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Doug Drinen said:
Here are, by my reckoning, the top three players in Year N-1 who did not play for that team in Year N for each team that made a Super Bowl in Year N:

Tiki Barber NYG 2007

Will Demps NYG 2007

Carlos Emmons NYG 2007

Artrell Hawkins NWE 2007

Reche Caldwell NWE 2007

Corey Dillon NWE 2007

Edgerrin James IND 2006

David Thornton IND 2006

Corey Simon IND 2006

Michael Green CHI 2006

Bobby Wade CHI 2006

Kyle Orton CHI 2006

Ken Lucas SEA 2005

Cedric Woodard SEA 2005

Chike Okeafor SEA 2005

Plaxico Burress PIT 2005

Oliver Ross PIT 2005

Keydrick Vincent PIT 2005

Troy Vincent PHI 2004

N.D. Kalu PHI 2004

Duce Staley PHI 2004

Bobby Hamilton NWE 2004

Ted Washington NWE 2004

Damien Woody NWE 2004

Lawyer Milloy NWE 2003

Kenyatta Jones NWE 2003

Otis Smith NWE 2003

Mark Fields CAR 2003

Hannibal Navies CAR 2003

Emmanuel McDaniel CAR 2003

Warrick Dunn TAM 2002

Jerry Wunsch TAM 2002

Jamie Duncan TAM 2002

Grady Jackson OAK 2002

Greg Biekert OAK 2002

William Thomas OAK 2002

Chad Eaton NWE 2001

Chris Slade NWE 2001

Bruce Armstrong NWE 2001

Trent Green STL 2001

Mike Jones STL 2001

Ray Agnew STL 2001

Roman Oben NYG 2000

Scott Gragg NYG 2000

Corey Widmer NYG 2000

DeRon Jenkins BAL 2000

Everett Lindsay BAL 2000

Errict Rhett BAL 2000

Mike D. Jones STL 1999

Tony Banks STL 1999

Eric Hill STL 1999

Gary Walker TEN 1999

Lonnie Marts TEN 1999

Darryll Lewis TEN 1999

Gary Zimmerman DEN 1998

Allen Aldridge DEN 1998

Brian Habib DEN 1998

Bert Emanuel ATL 1998

Dan Owens ATL 1998

Matt Willig ATL 1998

Anthony Miller DEN 1997

Broderick Thompson DEN 1997

Dan Williams DEN 1997

Sean Jones GNB 1997

Edgar Bennett GNB 1997

Keith Jackson GNB 1997

Vincent Brown NWE 1996

Myron Guyton NWE 1996

Reggie E. White NWE 1996

Harry Galbreath GNB 1996

George Teague GNB 1996

John Jurkovic GNB 1996

Mark Stepnoski DAL 1995

Alvin Harper DAL 1995

James Washington DAL 1995

Eric Green PIT 1995

Duval Love PIT 1995

Gerald Williams PIT 1995

Guy McIntyre SFO 1994

Bill Romanowski SFO 1994

John Johnson SFO 1994

Anthony Miller SDG 1994

Mike Zandofsky SDG 1994

Donald Frank SDG 1994

Vinson Smith DAL 1993

Kelvin Martin DAL 1993

Issiac Holt DAL 1993

Will Wolford BUF 1993

James Lofton BUF 1993

Shane Conlan BUF 1993

Leon Seals BUF 1992

Leonard Smith BUF 1992

Hal Garner BUF 1992

Jack Del Rio DAL 1992

Manny Hendrix DAL 1992

Robert Awalt DAL 1992

Darryl Grant WAS 1991

Todd Bowles WAS 1991

Greg Manusky WAS 1991

John Hagy BUF 1991

Don Smith BUF 1991

Jamie Mueller BUF 1991

Fred Smerlas BUF 1990

Art Still BUF 1990

Joe Devlin BUF 1990

Terry Kinard NYG 1990

Zeke Mowatt NYG 1990

Damian Johnson NYG 1990

Jim Ryan DEN 1989

Bill Bryan DEN 1989

Mike Harden DEN 1989

Randy Cross SFO 1989

Riki Ellison SFO 1989

Ron Heller SFO 1989

Milt McColl SFO 1988

Joe Cribbs SFO 1988

Russ Francis SFO 1988

Robert Jackson CIN 1988

Larry Kinnebrew CIN 1988

Dave Rimington CIN 1988

Curtis Jordan WAS 1987

Calvin Daniels WAS 1987

Ken Coffey WAS 1987

Paul Howard DEN 1987

Louis Wright DEN 1987

Steve Foley DEN 1987

Curtis McGriff NYG 1986

George Adams NYG 1986

Rob Carpenter NYG 1986

Barney Chavous DEN 1986

Steve Busick DEN 1986

James Wright DEN 1986

Darryl Haley NWE 1985

Rick Sanford NWE 1985

Tim Golden NWE 1985

Todd Bell CHI 1985

Al Harris CHI 1985

Jeff Fisher CHI 1985

Pete Kugler SFO 1984

Willie Harper SFO 1984

Eason Ramson SFO 1984

Bob Kuechenberg MIA 1984

Gerald Small MIA 1984

David Overstreet MIA 1984

Curt Marsh RAI 1983

Burgess Owens RAI 1983

Dave Browning RAI 1983

Tony Peters WAS 1983

Mat Mendenhall WAS 1983

Jeris White WAS 1983

Terry Metcalf WAS 1982

Karl Lorch WAS 1982

Melvin Jones WAS 1982

Don Bessillieu MIA 1982

Ken Poole MIA 1982

Nick Giaquinto MIA 1982

**** Jauron CIN 1981

Andrew Melontree CIN 1981

Ron Simpkins CIN 1981

Ron Singleton SFO 1981

Steve DeBerg SFO 1981

Charles Johnson SFO 1981

Ken Stabler OAK 1980

Phil Villapiano OAK 1980

Jack Tatum OAK 1980

Bob Howard PHI 1980

Wade Key PHI 1980

Terry Tautolo PHI 1980

Cody Jones RAM 1979

Tom Mack RAM 1979

Bill Simpson RAM 1979

Ray Pinney PIT 1979

Tony Dungy PIT 1979

Fred Anderson PIT 1979

Ralph Neely DAL 1978

Mel Renfro DAL 1978

Bill Gregory DAL 1978

Jim Clack PIT 1978

J.T. Thomas PIT 1978

Glen Edwards PIT 1978

John Rowser DEN 1977

Steve Ramsey DEN 1977

Bill Bain DEN 1977

Lee Roy Jordan DAL 1977

Blaine Nye DAL 1977

Charley Young DAL 1977

John Gilliam MIN 1976

Ed Marinaro MIN 1976

Terry Brown MIN 1976

Gerald Irons OAK 1976

Tony Cline OAK 1976

Horace Jones OAK 1976

Ron Shanklin PIT 1975

Preston Pearson PIT 1975

Steve Davis PIT 1975

Bob Lilly DAL 1975

Calvin Hill DAL 1975

Pat Toomay DAL 1975

Carroll Dale MIN 1974

Ron Porter MIN 1974

John Ward MIN 1974

Bruce Van Dyke PIT 1974

Henry Davis PIT 1974

John Rowser PIT 1974

Otto Stowe MIA 1973

Jim Dunaway MIA 1973

Howard Kindig MIA 1973

Gene Washington MIN 1973

Karl Kassulke MIN 1973

John Henderson MIN 1973

Jim Riley MIA 1972

Bob DeMarco MIA 1972

John Richardson MIA 1972

Jim Snowden WAS 1972

Boyd Dowler WAS 1972

Tommy Mason WAS 1972

Lance Rentzel DAL 1971

Pettis Norman DAL 1971

Steve Kiner DAL 1971

Ted Davis MIA 1971

Maxie Williams MIA 1971

Stan Mitchell MIA 1971

Willie Richardson BAL 1970

Lenny Lyles BAL 1970

Terry Cole BAL 1970

Malcolm Walker DAL 1970

John Wilbur DAL 1970

Mike Gaechter DAL 1970

Larry Bowie MIN 1969

Bill Martin MIN 1969

King Hill MIN 1969

Ernie Ladd KAN 1969

Bud Abell KAN 1969

Dave Martin KAN 1969

Sherman Plunkett NYJ 1968

Jim Harris Jr. NYJ 1968

Dennis Randall NYJ 1968

Raymond Berry BAL 1968

Tony Lorick BAL 1968

Jim Parker BAL 1968

Art Powell OAK 1967

Tom Flores OAK 1967

Joe Krakoski OAK 1967

Paul Hornung GNB 1967

Jim Taylor GNB 1967

Bill Curry GNB 1967

Lloyd Voss GNB 1966

Bud Marshall GNB 1966

Hank Gremminger GNB 1966

Frank Jackson KAN 1966

Mack Lee Hill KAN 1966

Mel Branch KAN 1966
Click to expand...
I have to ask, how did you come up with this list?
 
The Man With No Name said:
NFL rosters don't stay the same year after year. There always will be many players not on a team one year that were on it the previous year. Alvin Harper left Dallas before their 3rd Super Bowl win in the 90's.
Click to expand...
Right. But I think there's a difference between role players and franchise-type players. Two recent ones that stick out are Edge and Tiki. They were both workhorses for their teams for at least seven years without winning a SB. They both leave and the very next year their teams win the SB. That has to sting just a little.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Top