Geraldo....doesn't surprise me one bit. What a #####.More like his ratings going up.
I was out there with Geraldo in Afghanistan, he's the biggest piece of crap I ever met. Took off into the Afghan wilderness with no security team and the 10th Mountain Division had to scoop him up wasting like 100 guys who could have been killing the enemies of America. Williams lied, Geraldo put lives in danger. Never hear about that story though. He lied about being in a firefight in Kandahar on the same trip, that ####### made a deal with the devil. On par with those Al-Qaeda ####ers IMO.
Now Ted Kopel, now that guy was someone you could count on.
Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
Ah, ok.Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
why did it take them 12 yrs to do so?Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
I love this shtickBilly Bats said:
He was largely outed via social media that didn't exist 12 years ago. It's possible they said something and it never got picked up or they didn't want to make a big deal about it and never said anything. Their only channels back then would have been through standard media.shadyridr said:why did it take them 12 yrs to do so?avoiding injuries said:Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.jamny said:How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
I'm not sure it matter much. We know he wasn't in a helicopter that was shot down by an RPG. That's not something you misremember. It was a flat out lie either way.GroveDiesel said:Interesting subplot developing. The pilot that CNN interviewed who claimed he flew Williams in a chopper right behind the one that took the RPG hit, and who claims their bird took small arms fire, is being accused of being a liar. Another pilot says HE was the one that flew Williams and that he wasn't part of the same chopper squadron. The NYT reported the 2nd guy as being Williams's pilot and other soldiers seem to be backing his version.
This one should ultimately be easy to get to the bottom of and it makes a somewhat significant difference in how people are perceiving this. If the CNN guy is telling the truth, Williams lie is closer to large exaggeration. If the CNN guy is lying, then it was just a flat out lie by Williams.
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/02/06/cnns-pilot-called-into-question-by-man-who-says-he-was-really-in-command-of-brian-williams-flight/
FixedTom Servo said:Alrockaction said:My question for people who are invested in this: Who is NBC going to replace him with, Brent Bozell?RokerSharpton
A couple of dudes on FB also said they've been calling him out on it for years, although where I don't know, but simply it didn't get "picked up" like it has now.He was largely outed via social media that didn't exist 12 years ago. It's possible they said something and it never got picked up or they didn't want to make a big deal about it and never said anything. Their only channels back then would have been through standard media.shadyridr said:why did it take them 12 yrs to do so?avoiding injuries said:Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.jamny said:How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
The military newspaper Stars and Stripes is the one that decided to look into it and exposed him.A couple of dudes on FB also said they've been calling him out on it for years, although where I don't know, but simply it didn't get "picked up" like it has now.He was largely outed via social media that didn't exist 12 years ago. It's possible they said something and it never got picked up or they didn't want to make a big deal about it and never said anything. Their only channels back then would have been through standard media.shadyridr said:why did it take them 12 yrs to do so?avoiding injuries said:Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.jamny said:How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
I can't imagine any serious person being invested in this, but I'll take a stab at it:rockaction said:My question for people who are invested in this: Who is NBC going to replace him with, Brent Bozell?
We already know, chief. He lied.Boston said:I'm very interested to see the intensity of scrutiny this gets...Williams is a major figure and I would think trust and honesty are key components of his position...what he says does have an effect on what some people think about current events...like any other situation we should wait until the investigation and facts are known but if he did lie it's inexcusable for him to keep his job...fibbing about exploits in this area are pretty black and white...there should be no gray area with this...if he did lie and is protected a new organization with questionable integrity becomes totally unreliable...
The chopper wasn't "shot down" by an RPG, it took a hit by RPG shrapnel. Williams' chopper took hits from small arms fire. The pilot who recalls him being in HIS chopper cuts him slack for his embellishments of the facts. Why? Because here we had reporters who were used to standing in front of a camera back in the safe confines of the US of A now being imbedded for the first time right in the middle of the ####. Hell- even the soldiers stories became bigger and better over time. They just resent his doing so because he wasn't truly a member of the club. News people were considered interlopers and liabilities...I'm not sure it matter much. We know he wasn't in a helicopter that was shot down by an RPG. That's not something you misremember. It was a flat out lie either way.GroveDiesel said:Interesting subplot developing. The pilot that CNN interviewed who claimed he flew Williams in a chopper right behind the one that took the RPG hit, and who claims their bird took small arms fire, is being accused of being a liar. Another pilot says HE was the one that flew Williams and that he wasn't part of the same chopper squadron. The NYT reported the 2nd guy as being Williams's pilot and other soldiers seem to be backing his version.
This one should ultimately be easy to get to the bottom of and it makes a somewhat significant difference in how people are perceiving this. If the CNN guy is telling the truth, Williams lie is closer to large exaggeration. If the CNN guy is lying, then it was just a flat out lie by Williams.
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/02/06/cnns-pilot-called-into-question-by-man-who-says-he-was-really-in-command-of-brian-williams-flight/
Ok Chief...whether it's Travon Martin, Ferguson, Deflatgate or something like this I think the rush to judgment on current events is getting out-of-control...once people make-up their mind they dig their heels in deep...if Williams lied I hope he gets canned and is publicly humiliated (as well as NBC which I do believe is a biased news organization)...he would be a disgrace...but let's wait for all the facts before we call for his head...in this case it should not be difficult to confirm what went on...We already know, chief. He lied.Boston said:I'm very interested to see the intensity of scrutiny this gets...Williams is a major figure and I would think trust and honesty are key components of his position...what he says does have an effect on what some people think about current events...like any other situation we should wait until the investigation and facts are known but if he did lie it's inexcusable for him to keep his job...fibbing about exploits in this area are pretty black and white...there should be no gray area with this...if he did lie and is protected a new organization with questionable integrity becomes totally unreliable...
Except that it seems like quite a few of the soldiers involved are saying that the guy claiming to have been Williams's pilot and taking small arms fire is a liar and that Williams wasn't even close to the copter that went down.The chopper wasn't "shot down" by an RPG, it took a hit by RPG shrapnel. Williams' chopper took hits from small arms fire. The pilot who recalls him being in HIS chopper cuts him slack for his embellishments of the facts. Why? Because here we had reporters who were used to standing in front of a camera back in the safe confines of the US of A now being imbedded for the first time right in the middle of the ####. Hell- even the soldiers stories became bigger and better over time. They just resent his doing so because he wasn't truly a member of the club. News people were considered interlopers and liabilities...I'm not sure it matter much. We know he wasn't in a helicopter that was shot down by an RPG. That's not something you misremember. It was a flat out lie either way.GroveDiesel said:Interesting subplot developing. The pilot that CNN interviewed who claimed he flew Williams in a chopper right behind the one that took the RPG hit, and who claims their bird took small arms fire, is being accused of being a liar. Another pilot says HE was the one that flew Williams and that he wasn't part of the same chopper squadron. The NYT reported the 2nd guy as being Williams's pilot and other soldiers seem to be backing his version.
This one should ultimately be easy to get to the bottom of and it makes a somewhat significant difference in how people are perceiving this. If the CNN guy is telling the truth, Williams lie is closer to large exaggeration. If the CNN guy is lying, then it was just a flat out lie by Williams.http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/02/06/cnns-pilot-called-into-question-by-man-who-says-he-was-really-in-command-of-brian-williams-flight/
Williams already admitted that he lied about being on the helicopter that went down. Well, admits he "misremembered" it.Ok Chief...whether it's Travon Martin, Ferguson, Deflatgate or something like this I think the rush to judgment on current events is getting out-of-control...once people make-up their mind they dig their heels in deep...if Williams lied I hope he gets canned and is publicly humiliated (as well as NBC which I do believe is a biased news organization)...he would be a disgrace...but let's wait for all the facts before we call for his head...in this case it should not be difficult to confirm what went on...We already know, chief. He lied.Boston said:I'm very interested to see the intensity of scrutiny this gets...Williams is a major figure and I would think trust and honesty are key components of his position...what he says does have an effect on what some people think about current events...like any other situation we should wait until the investigation and facts are known but if he did lie it's inexcusable for him to keep his job...fibbing about exploits in this area are pretty black and white...there should be no gray area with this...if he did lie and is protected a new organization with questionable integrity becomes totally unreliable...
He was in a chopper in the #### that took small arms fire. How close he was to an RPG falls under the "bigger and better" defense...Except that it seems like quite a few of the soldiers involved are saying that the guy claiming to have been Williams's pilot and taking small arms fire is a liar and that Williams wasn't even close to the copter that went down.The chopper wasn't "shot down" by an RPG, it took a hit by RPG shrapnel. Williams' chopper took hits from small arms fire. The pilot who recalls him being in HIS chopper cuts him slack for his embellishments of the facts. Why? Because here we had reporters who were used to standing in front of a camera back in the safe confines of the US of A now being imbedded for the first time right in the middle of the ####. Hell- even the soldiers stories became bigger and better over time. They just resent his doing so because he wasn't truly a member of the club. News people were considered interlopers and liabilities...I'm not sure it matter much. We know he wasn't in a helicopter that was shot down by an RPG. That's not something you misremember. It was a flat out lie either way.GroveDiesel said:Interesting subplot developing. The pilot that CNN interviewed who claimed he flew Williams in a chopper right behind the one that took the RPG hit, and who claims their bird took small arms fire, is being accused of being a liar. Another pilot says HE was the one that flew Williams and that he wasn't part of the same chopper squadron. The NYT reported the 2nd guy as being Williams's pilot and other soldiers seem to be backing his version.
This one should ultimately be easy to get to the bottom of and it makes a somewhat significant difference in how people are perceiving this. If the CNN guy is telling the truth, Williams lie is closer to large exaggeration. If the CNN guy is lying, then it was just a flat out lie by Williams.http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/02/06/cnns-pilot-called-into-question-by-man-who-says-he-was-really-in-command-of-brian-williams-flight/
Agreed...pretty obvious the path this is heading...just want everything confirmed by the proper sources...than if it's what we think it is he has to pay the piper...no way he should be allowed to keep his job if this fabrication is totally confirmed...Williams already admitted that he lied about being on the helicopter that went down. Well, admits he "misremembered" it.Ok Chief...whether it's Travon Martin, Ferguson, Deflatgate or something like this I think the rush to judgment on current events is getting out-of-control...once people make-up their mind they dig their heels in deep...if Williams lied I hope he gets canned and is publicly humiliated (as well as NBC which I do believe is a biased news organization)...he would be a disgrace...but let's wait for all the facts before we call for his head...in this case it should not be difficult to confirm what went on...We already know, chief. He lied.Boston said:I'm very interested to see the intensity of scrutiny this gets...Williams is a major figure and I would think trust and honesty are key components of his position...what he says does have an effect on what some people think about current events...like any other situation we should wait until the investigation and facts are known but if he did lie it's inexcusable for him to keep his job...fibbing about exploits in this area are pretty black and white...there should be no gray area with this...if he did lie and is protected a new organization with questionable integrity becomes totally unreliable...
Yeah, you keep saying that and I keep trying to explain to you that there's a good chance that he was NOT in a chopper that took small arms fire. Just read the link that I posted.He was in a chopper in the #### that took small arms fire. How close he was to an RPG falls under the "bigger and better" defense...Except that it seems like quite a few of the soldiers involved are saying that the guy claiming to have been Williams's pilot and taking small arms fire is a liar and that Williams wasn't even close to the copter that went down.The chopper wasn't "shot down" by an RPG, it took a hit by RPG shrapnel. Williams' chopper took hits from small arms fire. The pilot who recalls him being in HIS chopper cuts him slack for his embellishments of the facts. Why? Because here we had reporters who were used to standing in front of a camera back in the safe confines of the US of A now being imbedded for the first time right in the middle of the ####. Hell- even the soldiers stories became bigger and better over time. They just resent his doing so because he wasn't truly a member of the club. News people were considered interlopers and liabilities...I'm not sure it matter much. We know he wasn't in a helicopter that was shot down by an RPG. That's not something you misremember. It was a flat out lie either way.GroveDiesel said:Interesting subplot developing. The pilot that CNN interviewed who claimed he flew Williams in a chopper right behind the one that took the RPG hit, and who claims their bird took small arms fire, is being accused of being a liar. Another pilot says HE was the one that flew Williams and that he wasn't part of the same chopper squadron. The NYT reported the 2nd guy as being Williams's pilot and other soldiers seem to be backing his version.
This one should ultimately be easy to get to the bottom of and it makes a somewhat significant difference in how people are perceiving this. If the CNN guy is telling the truth, Williams lie is closer to large exaggeration. If the CNN guy is lying, then it was just a flat out lie by Williams.http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/02/06/cnns-pilot-called-into-question-by-man-who-says-he-was-really-in-command-of-brian-williams-flight/
I think this one is photoshopped.Billy Bats said:
This is the kind of blowback that will be the nail in the coffin.I love this shtickBilly Bats said:
The chopper wasn't "shot down" by an RPG, it took a hit by RPG shrapnel. Williams' chopper took hits from small arms fire. The pilot who recalls him being in HIS chopper cuts him slack for his embellishments of the facts. Why? Because here we had reporters who were used to standing in front of a camera back in the safe confines of the US of A now being imbedded for the first time right in the middle of the ####. Hell- even the soldiers stories became bigger and better over time. They just resent his doing so because he wasn't truly a member of the club. News people were considered interlopers and liabilities...I'm not sure it matter much. We know he wasn't in a helicopter that was shot down by an RPG. That's not something you misremember. It was a flat out lie either way.GroveDiesel said:Interesting subplot developing. The pilot that CNN interviewed who claimed he flew Williams in a chopper right behind the one that took the RPG hit, and who claims their bird took small arms fire, is being accused of being a liar. Another pilot says HE was the one that flew Williams and that he wasn't part of the same chopper squadron. The NYT reported the 2nd guy as being Williams's pilot and other soldiers seem to be backing his version.
This one should ultimately be easy to get to the bottom of and it makes a somewhat significant difference in how people are perceiving this. If the CNN guy is telling the truth, Williams lie is closer to large exaggeration. If the CNN guy is lying, then it was just a flat out lie by Williams.
http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/02/06/cnns-pilot-called-into-question-by-man-who-says-he-was-really-in-command-of-brian-williams-flight/
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/stelter-pilot-who-claimed-he-flew-brian-williamss-helicopter-withdraws-his-account/In an admission that will turn Brian Williams‘ Iraq War story even murkier, the pilot who told CNN that Williams’ account was correct suddenly recanted his statement, saying he was now “questioning” his memories.
CNN’s media reporter Brian Stelter, who initially reported that Rich Krell piloted the helicopter that Williams was on and that it did indeed get hit by small arms fire, took full responsibility for getting the story wrong after many soldiers contradicted Krell’s claims.
“This week, I’ve been urging Brian Williams to be fully transparent about what happened on his embed in Iraq and about why his story evolved over the years,” he said. “I’m going to practice complete transparency.”
All this happened in Iraq in 2003 right? I mean, that was THAT long ago, right? With all this misremembering are we sure it wasn't WWII?And now the pilot changes his story
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/stelter-pilot-who-claimed-he-flew-brian-williamss-helicopter-withdraws-his-account/In an admission that will turn Brian Williams‘ Iraq War story even murkier, the pilot who told CNN that Williams’ account was correct suddenly recanted his statement, saying he was now “questioning” his memories.
CNN’s media reporter Brian Stelter, who initially reported that Rich Krell piloted the helicopter that Williams was on and that it did indeed get hit by small arms fire, took full responsibility for getting the story wrong after many soldiers contradicted Krell’s claims.
“This week, I’ve been urging Brian Williams to be fully transparent about what happened on his embed in Iraq and about why his story evolved over the years,” he said. “I’m going to practice complete transparency.”
Oof. More "misremembering." Looks like Krell lied to protect Williams for some reason and immediately realized he was caught. Shame on CNN for not doing a better job of verifyng,And now the pilot changes his story
http://www.mediaite.com/tv/stelter-pilot-who-claimed-he-flew-brian-williamss-helicopter-withdraws-his-account/In an admission that will turn Brian Williams‘ Iraq War story even murkier, the pilot who told CNN that Williams’ account was correct suddenly recanted his statement, saying he was now “questioning” his memories.
CNN’s media reporter Brian Stelter, who initially reported that Rich Krell piloted the helicopter that Williams was on and that it did indeed get hit by small arms fire, took full responsibility for getting the story wrong after many soldiers contradicted Krell’s claims.
“This week, I’ve been urging Brian Williams to be fully transparent about what happened on his embed in Iraq and about why his story evolved over the years,” he said. “I’m going to practice complete transparency.”
I misremembered that was you...Yeah, you keep saying that and I keep trying to explain to you that there's a good chance that he was NOT in a chopper that took small arms fire. Just read the link that I posted.He was in a chopper in the #### that took small arms fire. How close he was to an RPG falls under the "bigger and better" defense...Except that it seems like quite a few of the soldiers involved are saying that the guy claiming to have been Williams's pilot and taking small arms fire is a liar and that Williams wasn't even close to the copter that went down.The chopper wasn't "shot down" by an RPG, it took a hit by RPG shrapnel. Williams' chopper took hits from small arms fire. The pilot who recalls him being in HIS chopper cuts him slack for his embellishments of the facts. Why? Because here we had reporters who were used to standing in front of a camera back in the safe confines of the US of A now being imbedded for the first time right in the middle of the ####. Hell- even the soldiers stories became bigger and better over time. They just resent his doing so because he wasn't truly a member of the club. News people were considered interlopers and liabilities...I'm not sure it matter much. We know he wasn't in a helicopter that was shot down by an RPG. That's not something you misremember. It was a flat out lie either way.GroveDiesel said:Interesting subplot developing. The pilot that CNN interviewed who claimed he flew Williams in a chopper right behind the one that took the RPG hit, and who claims their bird took small arms fire, is being accused of being a liar. Another pilot says HE was the one that flew Williams and that he wasn't part of the same chopper squadron. The NYT reported the 2nd guy as being Williams's pilot and other soldiers seem to be backing his version.
This one should ultimately be easy to get to the bottom of and it makes a somewhat significant difference in how people are perceiving this. If the CNN guy is telling the truth, Williams lie is closer to large exaggeration. If the CNN guy is lying, then it was just a flat out lie by Williams.http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2015/02/06/cnns-pilot-called-into-question-by-man-who-says-he-was-really-in-command-of-brian-williams-flight/
Wasn't he a member of NWA?What's next, are we gonna find out hes not really a rapper?
![]()
Close.Wasn't he a member of NWA?What's next, are we gonna find out hes not really a rapper?
![]()
Williams told the story, other people who were there called him out. Pilot said Williams story was wrong, but close to the truth. Other people who were there then called out the pilot, who now says he misremembered as well. All of this came back to light because Williams went to a Rangers game with one of the soldiers who protected him. The story was told over the speaker system at MSG. Then it was broadcasted on his NBC news show and social media took over from there.I'm confused on this because I haven't really been following it. But if someone could explain this to me, I'd appreciate it. I saw an article that said the pilot is now recanting his story. But the more I read, that made it seem like Brian Will.I.ams was actually more in hot water. Was there a pilot that was backing his story that now is lying too?![]()
The pilot that recanted was the one that chimed in later and was more supportive of Williams.I'm confused on this because I haven't really been following it. But if someone could explain this to me, I'd appreciate it. I saw an article that said the pilot is now recanting his story. But the more I read, that made it seem like Brian Will.I.ams was actually more in hot water. Was there a pilot that was backing his story that now is lying too?![]()
He hasn't been saying this for 12 years that we know of. He started misremembering back in 2013 or so as I understand it.shadyridr said:why did it take them 12 yrs to do so?avoiding injuries said:Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.jamny said:How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
He has described the incident several times including right after it happened.He hasn't been saying this for 12 years that we know of. He started misremembering back in 2013 or so as I understand it.shadyridr said:why did it take them 12 yrs to do so?avoiding injuries said:Soldiers in the other helicopters outed him.jamny said:How did this all come out?
Someone else broke the story or did he know it was coming out and he admitted it before it did?
That's odd. I've never been in a war zone, but it seems odd that multiple people are having trouble remembering things. Although, there was an article on CNN.com today by a doctor who said it's not uncommon.Williams told the story, other people who were there called him out. Pilot said Williams story was wrong, but close to the truth. Other people who were there then called out the pilot, who now says he misremembered as well.All of this came back to light because Williams went to a Rangers game with one of the soldiers who protected him. The story was told over the speaker system at MSG. Then it was broadcasted on his NBC news show and social media took over from there.I'm confused on this because I haven't really been following it. But if someone could explain this to me, I'd appreciate it. I saw an article that said the pilot is now recanting his story. But the more I read, that made it seem like Brian Will.I.ams was actually more in hot water. Was there a pilot that was backing his story that now is lying too?![]()
If only there was news crew there to document the event so there would be no doubt what actually happened.That's odd. I've never been in a war zone, but it seems odd that multiple people are having trouble remembering things. Although, there was an article on CNN.com today by a doctor who said it's not uncommon.Williams told the story, other people who were there called him out. Pilot said Williams story was wrong, but close to the truth. Other people who were there then called out the pilot, who now says he misremembered as well.All of this came back to light because Williams went to a Rangers game with one of the soldiers who protected him. The story was told over the speaker system at MSG. Then it was broadcasted on his NBC news show and social media took over from there.I'm confused on this because I haven't really been following it. But if someone could explain this to me, I'd appreciate it. I saw an article that said the pilot is now recanting his story. But the more I read, that made it seem like Brian Will.I.ams was actually more in hot water. Was there a pilot that was backing his story that now is lying too?![]()
![]()
No.I haven't spent any time in the American Sniper thread - are the same folks who are blasting Williams here also blasting the Sniper in that thread?
That seems odd. It's okay for the Sniper to lie, but not Williams? Not sure how folks reconcile that position.No.I haven't spent any time in the American Sniper thread - are the same folks who are blasting Williams here also blasting the Sniper in that thread?
About 90% are ripping The State News Liar, while 90% are fellating The State Sniper Murderer.
Who the #### cares?I haven't spent any time in the American Sniper thread - are the same folks who are blasting Williams here also blasting the Sniper in that thread?