dboysrock94
Footballguy
Which one will end with the best year I have a feeling mcfadden finishes top 5 mjd is looking healthy as ever and we all know what cj is capable of the question is will he get back to how he was playing
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Mcfadden vs mjd vs cj2k (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter dboysrock94
- Start date
socrates
Footballguy
So many factors to consider. Assuming they play a 16-game schedule, I would go McFadden, Johnson, Jones-Drew, in that order, but that is a big assumption.
MJD's knees worry me. Will the team limit he carries all season? I am also concerned with the effect Gabbert will have on MJD. Defenses will likely stack the line against MJD, and challenge Gabbert to beat them.
McFadden is an injury concern, but he is playing like the best of the three. You have to really like McFadden this season, and a top 5 finish is almost a lock if he remains healthy.
Johnson is off to a dreadful start, no doubt, but that is likely a product of missed time. He did not just suddenly lose his skills and speed. Johnson will get it going real soon, and any talk of his decline will seem ridiculous.
MJD's knees worry me. Will the team limit he carries all season? I am also concerned with the effect Gabbert will have on MJD. Defenses will likely stack the line against MJD, and challenge Gabbert to beat them.
McFadden is an injury concern, but he is playing like the best of the three. You have to really like McFadden this season, and a top 5 finish is almost a lock if he remains healthy.
Johnson is off to a dreadful start, no doubt, but that is likely a product of missed time. He did not just suddenly lose his skills and speed. Johnson will get it going real soon, and any talk of his decline will seem ridiculous.
fantasizing
Footballguy
If DMac can stay healthy for 16 games, then I think he tops the list. He IS the entire Oakland offence, and gets
so many touches that it's hard for him not to put up alot of numbers just by virtue of the sheer volume of work he gets.
Hell, he might as well play QB too.
so many touches that it's hard for him not to put up alot of numbers just by virtue of the sheer volume of work he gets.
Hell, he might as well play QB too.
wiscstlatlmia
Footballguy
Talent = CJ(barely) > McFadden > MJD
Jersey35
Footballguy
Wow. This is ######ed.
DAMAC3
Footballguy
Wow, really? I like all three guys, and I guess when the talent is that good you are splitting hairs. But the only reason McFadden wasn't a top five pick in most all drafts was the injury risk. That has nothing to do with talent. I actually think the most likely outcome is CJ ending up with the best year of the three. I own all three in different leagues (CJ owned the most), but I think the risk of injury to McFadden & MJD are much higher. McFadden is almost a lock to miss some time, and I think that MJD will wear down even if he doesn't get hurt. Plus, the Jags have BY FAR the worst offense of the three.
