I was never high on Mendenhall this year for 2 reasons - he is not an impressive runner to me and his o-line is patchwork at best. With their o-line in even worse shape, I'm even less high on him. I'd be surprised if he averaged 4 ypc. The loss of Colon certainly doesn't help. They can only pray they can sign a veteran off the street because if past history is any guide, then there will be more injuries on the line.
I don't get this line of thinking. So Mendenhall is not an "impressive runner" to you. Do you think his skills have gotten worse than last year? If not, his schedule is absolute cake. Pittsburgh's line is always a mess and year after year their offense gets it done. Their D will keep them ahead (especially with this schedule) and Mendy will pound the ball in the 2nd half most of the year.Man, are people really overreacting after 1 week, on the road, against a very good arch rival.
I'm trading for Big Ben and Mendy in every league I didn't have them already. It's the schedule people - it's the schedule!
I'm not overreacting. I expected poor performances like this. He averaged 3.9 yards per carry last year and a whopping 23 receptions for 167 yards. He's in a great situation because there isn't another back stealing carries, but he's anything but an top talent. That's not 1st round talent to me.
For my money, he's more like Tim Hightower (fantasy-production wise) than Ray Rice, but he was drafted just a pick or two after Rice in most leagues and 40-50 picks ahead of Hightower.
So are you saying you expect similiar FF production from Mendenahall and Hightower?I was not overly impressed with Mendenhall either when he first came out but I've become more impressed with him over the last two years. And FWIW, most people who evaluate talent for a living had a pretty high opinion of the guy coming out of college. In fact Mike Mayock, whose opinion I respect, had him as the top rated RB in a class that included Rice as well as Chris Johnson, McFadden, Jamaal Charles, Felix Jones, and Jonathan Stewart. Extremely impressive class now that I look at it.
Obviously Mendenhall was not the top talent in that class but IMO, Rice is not an uber talent either (he averaged a whopping .1 more ypc at 4.0 last year). He's a tough runner, who has a versatile skill set, and is used in all aspects of Baltimore's offensive gameplan. I think Mendy could do the same things if he was used that way.
But opinions on talent aside, you say that Mendenhall is in a great situation but think he is like Hightower fantasy production wise. So, I'm not sure what you're really saying here. You expect them to have similar years? Where do you think they both end up at the end of the season?