Andy Dufresne
Footballguy
What I wrote was that you don't have to if you adjust your offensive philosophy.Sure. But who are you going to replace him with?
What I wrote was that you don't have to if you adjust your offensive philosophy.Sure. But who are you going to replace him with?
That’s the thing though he’s good enough to get us 14 points in the first quarter he’s done that a couple times. Zimmer was the wrong coach I don’t think cousins necessarily the wrong QB.Cousins just isn't a guy that can dig you out of a hole. Which is where the team found itself far too often as a result of defensive failure.
Had the offensive philosophy been "pass to establish the run" rather than the more traditional & conservative "run to establish the pass", I think they'd have had more success. But by the time they got to their fourth possession - kicking up clouds of dust to get three or six points - they'd look up and see they were down 14-3 and have to start playin catch up. Which that offense just couldn't do.
That's what I'm saying. Trying to, anyway.That’s the thing though he’s good enough to get us 14 points in the first quarter he’s done that a couple times. Zimmer was the wrong coach I don’t think cousins necessarily the wrong QB.
So based on this trend, January 2026 the Vikings should lose the NFC title game again.Random interesting stat:
Every year the Vikings play the Ravens its the most important game of the season. Since 1998, if the Vikings beat the Ravens they make the NFC Title game(Falcons in 98', Saints in 09' and Eagles in 2017') if the Vikings lose to the Ravens, they fire their HC(Green, Tice, Frazier, Zimmer)
Probably in a huge blowout too. Each loss got progressively worse.So based on this trend, January 2026 the Vikings should lose the NFC title game again.
Yeah I agree. It is so hard to separate him from the system in a lot of peoples minds.That's what I'm saying. Trying to, anyway.
Maybe they already had preliminary talks and upcoming interviews are a formality. Maybe they asked each GM who they would be interested in hiring ahead of their interviews and are lining things up after.I’m stumped at all this HC chatter before GM.
Eagles fan here. Here’s what I wrote about Pedersen in the Dolphins thread.My take was the wheels fell off the two seasons after the Super Bowl with significant injuries to OL, WR and secondary, and he became a victim of circumstance. I don’t really understand the negativity. Clearly he was good enough to coach a team to a 13-3 record and super bowl win.
From what I have read, they have just requested permission with the teams on each which they would have to do anyway. I don't think they have set up any interviews at all. I'm assuming the GM gets hired this week, then they can interview whoever they want but at least have taken the first step that would need to be done at some point anyway. Doesn't mean they have to interview everyone they have asked permission...I’m stumped at all this HC chatter before GM.
The Reagor/Jefferson point is eyebrow raising. As for the rest of your assessment... what role do you give the Eagle's OL in offensive demise? As mentioned, the team gave up 65 sacks in 2020. Isn't it sort of impossible for any offensive scheme to work under that circumstance?Eagles fan here. Here’s what I wrote about Pedersen in the Dolphins thread.
“From an Eagles fan perspective -- Pederson was a very good leader, but his offenses were pretty much awful after Reich and DeFillipo left after the SB win. His offensive staff hires after that were laughable and he played a big role in the bungling of the Wentz/Hurts situation.
He's certainly the kind of coach you turn to if your goal is to get someone with the opposite persona of Flores, but I'd grill him heavily on what he would do to avoid repeating the mistakes of 2018-20.”
In addition to that, it’s been reported that the team drafted Reagor over Jefferson because that’s who Pedersen wanted.
Another reason Jeffrey Lurie fired Pedersen is that he refused to make changes to his coaching staff after 2020 despite them being desperately needed.
His playcalling became a source of frustration for fans by the end of his tenure. He had morphed from someone who was smartly aggressive in contrast to most NFL coaches at the time into someone who was often needlessly aggressive.
He could be a good hire if he learns from his mistakes and has a Reich type to design the offense. But there were many more reasons beyond injuries why he was fired.
You are predicting a GM hire from a non playoff team or one of the 4 wild card losers?From what I have read, they have just requested permission with the teams on each which they would have to do anyway. I don't think they have set up any interviews at all. I'm assuming the GM gets hired this week, then they can interview whoever they want but at least have taken the first step that would need to be done at some point anyway. Doesn't mean they have to interview everyone they have asked permission...
Very fair point about the OL. One other thing I’ll interject about Pederson that @Pip's Invitation didn’t mention but there were heavy rumors about over intrusion by Roseman and Lurie into his HC responsibilities including deciding who was active on game day. If true Pederson probably had 1 foot out the doorThe Reagor/Jefferson point is eyebrow raising. As for the rest of your assessment... what role do you give the Eagle's OL in offensive demise? As mentioned, the team gave up 65 sacks in 2020. Isn't it sort of impossible for any offensive scheme to work under that circumstance?
The OL was decimated by injuries in 2020. That plus Wentz trying to play hero ball all the time were the main reasons why the team was so bad.The Reagor/Jefferson point is eyebrow raising. As for the rest of your assessment... what role do you give the Eagle's OL in offensive demise? As mentioned, the team gave up 65 sacks in 2020. Isn't it sort of impossible for any offensive scheme to work under that circumstance?
I hear you, thanks for the input. It's maybe just me, but sort of hard to say a QB played hero ball, knowing his OL gave up 65 sacks. My reaction is of course, he had to. Just like Cousins checked down too often. Offense is all cause/effect stuff, and it almost always ties back to the OL. JMHO.The OL was decimated by injuries in 2020. That plus Wentz trying to play hero ball all the time were the main reasons why the team was so bad.
If there's a team who knows how to build the right way, and finding tough players with a fighting mentality, it's Tennessee.
The GM hire isn't going to be an active GM and not sure there is much anyone can do building a roster between now and the Super Bowl...Can they not hire a GM from a team currently playing?You are predicting a GM hire from a non playoff team or one of the 4 wild card losers?
I assumed they could only interview... could be mistaken.The GM hire isn't going to be an active GM and not sure there is much anyone can do building a roster between now and the Super Bowl...Can they not hire a GM from a team currently playing?
I never thought Josh Allen would develop into the QB he is now and I think Daboll deserves some credit for Allens improvement.I loved the agressiveness Brian Daboll's Bills had tonight. But then again can we find a Josh Allen to go with him?
Of course the offensive line was a factor in this.I hear you, thanks for the input. It's maybe just me, but sort of hard to say a QB played hero ball, knowing his OL gave up 65 sacks. My reaction is of course, he had to. Just like Cousins checked down too often. Offense is all cause/effect stuff, and it almost always ties back to the OL. JMHO.
With a new GM/head coach TBD, too early to tell anything other than there's not many alternatives to riding out his 2022 contract. Depending on how the new regime views Cousins, there's a possibility they extend him in a way that reduces his cap hit for 2022.What's Cousins situation - 1 more year due to cap? You probably have enough talent overall that you don't need to do full tank rebuild, but I could be wrong.
Its my understanding that the Vikings are on the hook for $35 million in 2022 even if they trade him.What's Cousins situation - 1 more year due to cap? You probably have enough talent overall that you don't need to do full tank rebuild, but I could be wrong.
If accurate, the reporting that Spielman was surprised he got the axe is crazy.
I agree that Spielman being surprised he was fired is hard for me to believe.If accurate, the reporting that Spielman was surprised he got the axe is crazy.
I agree that Spielman being surprised he was fired is hard for me to believe.
I tend to think what Sanders said about him and Zimmer not talking the last 2 months was accurate. It kind of makes sense considering that Spielman was doing chats with Paul Allen near the end which is something Zimmer would normally do.
That is something Zimmer was never good at, talking to the press. He hated it but that is part of a head coaches job.
Maybe Spielman thought he was doing things that would help him be retained. There was some talk about that possibility just a week or so before the last game.
That is something good that comes from these changes is now we are hearing things about the dysfunction of the leadership that otherwise would not really come to light. Such as Spielman recently owning up to some of his mistakes on the move the sticks podcast.
Rick Spielman: 'It was constantly like a moving target all the time'
 
 Spielman’s comments could shine light on the Vikings’ fluid situation at guard. Zimmer gave the front office a mandate to find bigger guards which led to the selection of Wyatt Davis in last year’s draft. But Davis showed up overweight for minicamp and was rarely active during his rookie season.
“If you have an immobile quarterback…those guys [interior OL] cannot get collapsed,” Spielman said. “Especially if the quarterback has to step up to throw the ball and you see some of these athletic quarterbacks that can make up for that."
Scheme schmeme. I think that is a bunch of fandom fiction if Zimmer was to the point of declaring a mandate, and Spielman agreed and drafted Davis because we can't have collapsing pockets with an immobile QB (I'd argue even mobile QBs need a pocket).Well there is definitely a disconnect where Zimmer is insisting that the interior offensive linemen be bigger but then when they do acquire a bigger guard such as Davis he doesn't fit the scheme that the offensive coaches are running.
There is a difference in blocking scheme where they are asking a interior lineman to be able to reach a certain point quickly as is used by the Kubiaks and other schemes that are not asking the linemen to do that.BigJim® said:Scheme schmeme. I think that is a bunch of fandom fiction if Zimmer was to the point of declaring a mandate, and Spielman agreed and drafted Davis because we can't have collapsing pockets with an immobile QB (I'd argue even mobile QBs need a pocket).
JMHO -There's no NFL scheme that requires undersized/turnstile interior OL like Bradbury and Elflein to get rag-dolled whenever they're asked to pass protect. OC changes aren't the reason they get heaved into a pocket; they just aren't NFL capable, and I'd wager won't succeed anywhere else either if they can't do the whole job of an interior OL. Also, scheme seemingly had nothing to do with Davis not playing (if this report is true). They drafted a guy who got too out of shape to contribute in 5 short months. That's player mentality. There's too much poor history drafting this position to blame anyone but scouting.
I'd also probably move the word 'hopefully' before naming Cleveland. O'Niell I'll grant you, but my eyes tell me the jury is still out on Cleveland.
I just didn’t notice any particular difference getting push in short yardage runs or decrease pocket collapse on either side. I don’t know, we’ll see I guess. I think this OL is a long, long way from winning in the trenches.What did you see specifically from Cleveland that makes this questionable?
Yeah I am not talking about the Vikings offensive linemen being elite, just that they have some pieces that are competent.I just didn’t notice any particular difference getting push in short yardage runs or decrease pocket collapse on either side. I don’t know, we’ll see I guess. I think this OL is a long, long way from winning in the trenches.
I hope so too. Call me greedy but having an OL that is not only serviceable, but actually controls the line of scrimmage, makes life so much better. Running, for QB, for elite receivers to run routes, and even for the defense. I look at teams like Tennessee, San Fran, Baltimore, Indianapolis... who basically churn our yards on the ground at will even when everyone knows its a run. I can't even fathom being that. New front office has its work cut out.Yeah I am not talking about the Vikings offensive linemen being elite, just that they have some pieces that are competent.
Garrett Bradbury had a 60.2 grade from PFF in 2021 61.4 in 2020 and 58.1 in 2019. we know he has not played good enough. Those grades are worse if you are just looking at pass protection also, as Bradbury does get good grades for his run blocking. Mostly because of his ability to block guys downfield not because he blows anyone off the line. He is much worse in pass protection.
All of this is relative. Dakota Dozier had a 44.6 grade in 2020. Now that is horrifically bad for how many snaps he played.
So the point I am trying to make is not that any of these linemen are great. Just that they might be good enough to not be considered a weakness compared to their peers around the league.
Of course I am hoping that Cleveland can improve some more in his 3rd season as well as Darrisaw. If Darrisaw improves and they get better play at center than Bradbury it could help Cleveland improve just from not having to over compensate for the weakness of the players on each side of him.
This.I'm even more greedy... What I want to see is both lines becoming strengths.
I hope the next GM builds by starting in the trenches. I really liked the San Fran approach a couple years ago where they specifically mentioned their effort in putting together a "championship defensive line".
I prefer Poles for the reasons Judd mentioned.cap'n grunge said:
