More Likely to Throw For 3k Passing Yards (1 Viewer)

[bagger]

Been having a Leinart themed Monday so I thought I would add a poll.

Who is more likely to throw for 3k yards? Leinart or Campbell.

Leinart has a much better offense in terms of weapons, but is obviously less experienced.

Campbell has the skills, but is on the Raiders.

gogo

 

[Chase Stuart]

Campbell, and I don't think it's particularly close. Bush/McFadden are good receiving backs, and Schillens/DHB/Murphy/Higgins/Miller are solid options. Campbell would only need to have 462 pass attempts at a 6.5 Y/A average to hit 3,000. He's basically a lock to do that barring injury, whereas there's a decent chance that Leinart loses his job this season.

 

[Iwannabeacowboybaby!]

Campbell, and I don't think it's particularly close. Bush/McFadden are good receiving backs, and Schillens/DHB/Murphy/Higgins/Miller are solid options. Campbell would only need to have 462 pass attempts at a 6.5 Y/A average to hit 3,000. He's basically a lock to do that barring injury, whereas there's a decent chance that Leinart loses his job this season.

This is my line of thinking. If you tell me that both QB's play 16 games, then I'd say both would throw 3k. However, as sad as it is, Campbell is the more established NFL QB of the two and has proven he can play 16 games in a season. Who knows, maybe Leinart grows up this year and has a big year but there's also that chance the guy just doesn't have it, the Cards have seen enough and midseason they pull the chain and go another direction at QB. He's not reaching 3k if that happens so my vote goes to Campbell.

 

[kutta]

Campbell, and I don't think it's particularly close. Bush/McFadden are good receiving backs, and Schillens/DHB/Murphy/Higgins/Miller are solid options. Campbell would only need to have 462 pass attempts at a 6.5 Y/A average to hit 3,000. He's basically a lock to do that barring injury, whereas there's a decent chance that Leinart loses his job this season.

This is my line of thinking. If you tell me that both QB's play 16 games, then I'd say both would throw 3k. However, as sad as it is, Campbell is the more established NFL QB of the two and has proven he can play 16 games in a season. Who knows, maybe Leinart grows up this year and has a big year but there's also that chance the guy just doesn't have it, the Cards have seen enough and midseason they pull the chain and go another direction at QB. He's not reaching 3k if that happens so my vote goes to Campbell.

I agree with both of these guys.

 

[Captain Hook]

I think that both will throw for 3,000 yards but my question is outside of two QB leagues, what differrence will it make?

I don't think either will be drafted as a QB1 or really depended on in a QBBC, so it would be those in 16 team leagues that might be interested

 

[fightingillini]

Campbell, and I don't think it's particularly close. Bush/McFadden are good receiving backs, and Schillens/DHB/Murphy/Higgins/Miller are solid options. Campbell would only need to have 462 pass attempts at a 6.5 Y/A average to hit 3,000. He's basically a lock to do that barring injury, whereas there's a decent chance that Leinart loses his job this season.

This is my line of thinking. If you tell me that both QB's play 16 games, then I'd say both would throw 3k. However, as sad as it is, Campbell is the more established NFL QB of the two and has proven he can play 16 games in a season. Who knows, maybe Leinart grows up this year and has a big year but there's also that chance the guy just doesn't have it, the Cards have seen enough and midseason they pull the chain and go another direction at QB. He's not reaching 3k if that happens so my vote goes to Campbell.

Campbell.While I wouldn't consider him a very good NFL QB, Campbell has at least shown he can play, and if OAK can improve even a little on the OL, they could be a very improved offense. Russell was just that bad. They have good RBs that can catch the ball, OAK's WRs have a lot of upside, and Z Miller is a solid TE. At QB25, I like his upside.AZ should throw for about 3200-3300 for the year....the question is will Leinart play all 16 games.

 

[rzrback77]

both, lienart and the Cards do enough and win enough to stick with him

 

[MAC_32]

Easy.

As long as Campbell stays healthy the job should be his for the duration of the season, even if he doesn't play that well.

I wouldn't bet on Leinart keeping the job through November.

 

[David Yudkin]

Team total passing yards last year, the Cardinals went for 4200 while the Raiders were at 2875.

 

[Kree]

And the Redskins threw for how many? (Just getting different no.s on the NFL website)

I would think Campbell's approximate 3500 yards last year is more indicative of what he could do this year than what Russell did with the Raiders.