What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Most Disappointing Career Ever (1 Viewer)

Tony Mandarich deserves a mention. Not to mention Todd Marinovich.
I was thinking Dan McGwire of that draft class, who went before Marinovich, too. I remember having some NFL preview mag favorably comparing that draft class to the 1983 QB class. Also had Browning Nagle and Brett Favre. 1 for 4.

 
Without doing research:

Draft busts who were thought highly of:

Mandarich (hell the first 5 picks of that draft were: Aikman, Mandarich, Barry Sanders, Derrick Thomas, Deion Sanders). I don't know if you can get more disappointing considering who he was drafted among. Being drafted ahead of the GOAT RB and CB along with a top 10 OLB and not even making a pro bowl is about as disappointing as it gets. Sam Bowie and Darko might compare - but that isn't even in the same sport.

Leaf

Guys who looked promising but had very early injuries:

Emtman, Ickey Woods

Guys who looked like HOFers that got injured

Easley, Boselli, Bo Jackson

 
Aaron Hernandez. What a waste.

Bo Jackson , absolutely.

Charles Rogers

Brian bosworth.
Bo Jackson? He was super human. Way too short, but quite the opposite of disappointment.
Huge disappointment when you look at what he could have been. Zero 1000 seasons and had HOF talent. That's a tremendous disappointment IMO.
Disappointment in the sense of what could have been. His skills and his play (what little we saw) had hall of fame written all over it. Had he been a 100% full time football player, solely dedicated to being the best football player he could be and not been injured, I think its at least an even money bet that a good handful of the best memories a lot of kids would have had of watching football in that era would have included Bo Jackson. That's the disappointment.

Really good mention by someone on Daunte Culpepper. He looked to be on the verge of being a truly game changing type of player in that very brief time where he was so good. That is a very disappointing career also.

Of course, its easy to call out all the knuckleheads who we THINK had the talent to be difference makers but its just a bit different when you KNOW it and saw it and then it got cut short. Terrell Davis healthy for a decade would have been fantastic. That's more of a disappointment for this football fan than a guy that flashed big for a day or two and then smoked weed or committed a crime. There are probably some older fans out there that would say the same thing for Gayle Sayers, etc.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Really good mention by someone on Daunte Culpepper. He looked to be on the verge of being a truly game changing type of player in that very brief time where he was so good. That is a very disappointing career also.
For people who don't remember, it would be like Cam Newton 'getting it' as a passer this year and then never playing a meaningful season ever again due to injury.

 
Seems people have taken a different direction than the OP stated ("Nominate some candidates for most disappointing NFL career (relative to college career/hype/talent"). A lot of the people mentioned had a very good year or two in the NFL, but then lost it either due to injury or change in circumstances. Two different things really. Billy Sims had a great couple of years, but never got over a turf-toe injury or otherwise would of had a Hall of Fame career. He lived up to his hype, but his career was a disappointment. As opposed to someone like Ryan Leaf who was considered equal to Peyton Manning and never did squat.

 
Trev Alberts, the Boz, Blair Thomas, Trent Richardson is perhaps the worst ever with two first round picks dropped on him, Johnnie Mitchell, Dave Brown suppl pick, Sehorn was a bust not sure he counts, JaMarcus Russel, Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Tony Mandarich, relative to ADP you can say Reggie Bush, Curtis Enis, etc

 
12punch said:
he's probably not at the top, but wasn't there a tampa rb who maybe went to cle?

I forget the guy's name
Errict Rhett? Guy had a couple 1000-yard seasons for Tampa and then held out for more money....was never the same after that. Ended up playing a year for the Browns.

 
bostonfred said:
Could also say Randy Moss then. Moss while spectacular, I don't think he accomplished as much as he could have had he been less of a head case. A future HoF player that underachieved when he very well could have broken every record.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
bostonfred said:
Could also say Randy Moss then. Moss while spectacular, I don't think he accomplished as much as he could have had he been less of a head case. A future HoF player that underachieved when he very well could have broken every record.
It will take a perfect storm to break Jerry Rice's records. A great receiver, teamed with a great quarterback, workout nut who can extend a highly productive career to the late 30's/early 40's, all while avoiding losing any serious time to injury. At age 42 Rice had a 145 yard game. Rice is the only player to have 100 yard games over the age of 39 and he did it 10 times. Rice had over 1200 yards in the season he turned 40. No other WR has come close to matching his longevity. What Rice did over 40, only a handful have done over the age of 35.

 
Mandarich. He looked to be the JJ Watt of offensive tackles. Pure dominance at Michigan State. Never gave up a sack in his time there despite playing against future NFL defensive ends. Then he got to the NFL and got routinely beaten.

 
Mandarich. He looked to be the JJ Watt of offensive tackles. Pure dominance at Michigan State. Never gave up a sack in his time there despite playing against future NFL defensive ends. Then he got to the NFL and got routinely beaten.
Pretty common for college players to dominate but fail in the NFL where they can't get away with using steroids as easy.

 
:lol: at Randy Moss. Dude is 3rd all time in receiving yards and 2nd all time in receiving TDs. What more do you want from the guy?

 
bostonfred said:
Could also say Randy Moss then. Moss while spectacular, I don't think he accomplished as much as he could have had he been less of a head case. A future HoF player that underachieved when he very well could have broken every record.
The only reason Moss didn't break every record is that the end of his career came much earlier than it does for most wr's. He's only 37 and he hasn't been a factor since 2009. So yeah, there is an element of disappointment that he wasn't able to play effectively past 32 years of age, but he was still an absolute beast for 11 years, which is a long time.

 
I'll toss in another guy with stats seemingly way too gaudy to be in the discussion, but those of you who remember the college hype and that draft cycle will understand.

Despite 46233 passing yds and 275 TDs, Vinny Testaverde gets my vote.

In my lifetime, only three QB's have generated this amount of pre-draft buzz: Elway, Luck, and Vinny. Given his size, arm strength, and all-around prototype measurables, I'm not sure there's ever been a draft he wouldn't have gone #1.

21 seasons of relentless mediocrity later, he hung them up. He didn't shine bright and then burn out, he didn't completely fail like so many poorly scouted Houston and BYU QBs, he just hung around as a consistently blah reminder of failed promise for two decades.
I'll raise you Drew Bledsoe.
Testaverde goes to bed at night dreaming that he had the career Bledsoe had.

 
This could be a list of just Jets - but 2 stand out the most....even though Gholston was probably less productive than both - have to go with the 2 below - maybe not most disappointing per se - but heartbreaking when looking at what could have been!

Browning Nagle - he was a 2d rd pick but he gets listed because player drafted right before him was Brett Favre - Jets had Favre #1 on their entire draft board but didnt have a 1st rder due to using it in Supp draft....had a trade up set but it fell through....went with Nagle after Favre drafted...then Wolf who was Assist GM at the time goes to GB and trades for Favre...rest history.

Blair Thomas - 2d pick in the draft.....next RB off the board 15 picks later...Emmit Smith

 
I really thought Harrington had it all. Still very disappointed in his career.

William Green was the blueprint for what an NFL rb should be. What an idiot.

Charles Rogers was a lock to be the next Moss. Ooof.

 
Just in terms of the effect it had on me, I'll go Hernandez. Part of me liking the Patriots was them drafting character and smarts. In one swoop it was, well so much for character.

He's dead to me now. I don't have any interest in the trial, nothing. "You broke my heart, Fredo."

 
Sean Taylor
Don't agree here. Maybe disappointing to the fans since we didn't get to see more of him, but the guy was a beast who had his life cut way too short. Nothing about his play was disappointing.
I'm late to this party, but I agree 100% here...I'm not sure what about Sean Taylor's career on the field could be considered disappointing. He was an absolute beast. Our secondary hasn't been the same since he passed. If anyone recalls, our options that year were likely to be Taylor or Kellen Winslow. I'd take Taylor again without blinking.

Disappointing that it was cut short? #### yes. Disappointing when he played? #### no.

 
This question to me is supposed to be answered by players that were great in college, drafted very early due to their extreme promise in the NFL but then did nothing. And, they did nothing based on their inability to work or simply did not have NFL ability. Busts due to injury are a different list. That is simply bad luck. My list would include guys like:

Leaf

J Russell

Mandarich

Charles Rogers

It would not include guys that did not live up to the hype but did something such as Testaverde or Trent.

 
After a lot of thought I'm going with Sam Bradford.

I think the pick needs to be a top 3 draft pick. I think they need to have shown the ability and talent to play in the nfl (rules out guys like Leaf, Schuler, marinovich). Then sidelined by injury or stupidness.

So Bradford. Next up Vince Young and Bo Jackson.

And no. I see no shot Bradford ever plays again.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Relative to college career? Archie Griffin, Ohio State. 5th in Heisman voting in 1973 then won the Heisman in both 1974 and 1975 -- still the only player to win it twice.

1st round pick of Bengals in 1976, so Ohio fans had huge expectations.

But In a 7 year pro career he rushed for only 2808 yards and 7 touchdowns, rushed for 100 yards or more in only three games, never topped 688 yards in a season, never had more than 3 rushing TDs in a season. And it wasn't due to injury. He only missed a few games due to injury,

 
Last edited by a moderator:
This question to me is supposed to be answered by players that were great in college, drafted very early due to their extreme promise in the NFL but then did nothing. And, they did nothing based on their inability to work or simply did not have NFL ability. Busts due to injury are a different list. That is simply bad luck. My list would include guys like:

Leaf

J Russell

Mandarich

Charles Rogers

It would not include guys that did not live up to the hype but did something such as Testaverde or Trent.
+1

 
Soon to be Jameis Winston.

Literally all the talent in the world - extremely gifted throwing the ball and the mind to understand the game...yet it won't be enough to overcome his lack of character. Once he get his $20M guaranteed he's a ticking time bomb...tick...tick...tick...

 
Relative to college career? Archie Griffin, Ohio State. 5th in Heisman voting in 1973 then won the Heisman in both 1974 and 1975 -- still the only player to win it twice.

1st round pick of Bengals in 1976, so Ohio fans had huge expectations.

But In a 7 year pro career he rushed for only 2808 yards and 7 touchdowns, rushed for 100 yards or more in only three games, never topped 688 yards in a season, never had more than 3 rushing TDs in a season. And it wasn't due to injury. He only missed a few games due to injury,
Not that he would have done better elsewhere, but being the semi-hometown guy just adds to the pressure and ultimate disappointment.

Winston might be better off somewhere outside of Florida.

 
Some of these guys were just busts - some over-rated to begin with...

I'm going with Josh Gordon in that we've seen he was capable of being the best WR in the game but couldn't overcome his personal demons. Yes, it may be premature... but it may not be either...

 
I have to toss Jonathan Stewart in this conversation only because he is going to start getting some unwarrented hype due to DWill's release. JStew is one of the worst first round picks in history and I don't think anyone can adequately explain why the panthers spent an ealry 1st on him with DWill on the roster and continue to pay him......talk about dumb. BTW, good luck to anyone buying into his offseason hype.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top