My Rankings Critique (1 Viewer)

[LHUCKS]

Now that I've finished my rankings I'm ready to perform my annual critique, but before I waste 30 hours of my life I'm open to any suggestions/requests that would make these more useful for the forum.

 

[pizzatyme]

Now that I've finished my rankings I'm ready to perform my anual critique, but before I waste 30 hours of my life I'm open to any suggestions and requests that would make these more useful for the forum.

You're either short an "N" or plus a "U".

 

[CommuterMan]

Now that I've finished my rankings I'm ready to perform my anual critique, but before I waste 30 hours of my life I'm open to any suggestions and requests that would make these more useful for the forum.

You're either short an "N" or plus a "U".

 

[radballs]

1. I know it's a bit more work, but it would be great if you have maybe two or three more players who you think are over- and underrated for each position. Your analysis is usually really good so a bit more would be better.

2. A master link in each position's thread that links you to the other position breakdowns.

Other than that, it's a shame that these rankings are based off of non-ppr leagues. I wish the numerical rankings were based off of actual projections so that rankings could be adjusted and commented on separately for ppr leagues. Looking forward to it LHUCKS.

 

[Blackjacks]

I like your rankings the way you usually do them but if you want one idea it would be to maybe put a negative sign and a positive sign by players you really like to achieve better than your ranking and worse than your ranking. CBS Sportsline does that and I for one kind of like it. It shows where you have them put also gives an extra idea if you are really big on them or not.

Except for that looking forward to it.

 

[Maurile Tremblay]

I would suggest that if you think Player A is underrated, you name a couple players you think he's clearly better than who are ranked above him.

Likewise, if you think Player B is overrated, you should name a couple players better than him who are ranked below him.

 

[LHUCKS]

I would suggest that if you think Player A is underrated, you name a couple players you think he's clearly better than who are ranked above him.Likewise, if you think Player B is overrated, you should name a couple players better than him who are ranked below him.

Yeah, this makes a lot of sense and I did that for about half the players last year if I recall, but not for all.

 

[LHUCKS]

Now that I've finished my rankings I'm ready to perform my anual critique, but before I waste 30 hours of my life I'm open to any suggestions and requests that would make these more useful for the forum.

You're either short an "N" or plus a "U".

I forget to spell check when I'm multi-tasking at work.

 

[Tampa Buc]

I would also like to see some reference to PPR. It doesn't give us much help when you got Bush ranked 10 - 15 where in a PPR league he might be in the top 5. I still enjoy seeing your rankings.

 

[Jason Wood]

Please try to agree with me on the vast majority of these picks, as usual.

 

[caglassc]

Your rankings are always well thought out and presented in a professional manner. Looking forward to them.

 

[BassNBrew]

Please segregate the black and white players into separate lists for those of us playing in southern based leagues.

I liked your format from last year, excellent read and thought provoking even if the results came up short.

 

[Blackhawk 69]

Your rankings are always well thought out and presented in a professional manner. Looking forward to them.

 

[chook]

Now that I've finished my rankings I'm ready to perform my anual critique, but before I waste 30 hours of my life I'm open to any suggestions and requests that would make these more useful for the forum.

You're either short an "N" or plus a "U".

:X You win. Bestest post on these forums.

 

[wannabee]

one thing I have thought of is looking at the ADP movement as a component in determining "sleeper" status. I say that because all ADP data taken at this time is equally weightedof drafts in June as drafts in April. Seeing how the ADPs have moved might shed a little light.

 

[Bri]

Now that I've finished my rankings I'm ready to perform my annual critique, but before I waste 30 hours of my life I'm open to any suggestions/requests that would make these more useful for the forum.

adjust your rankings to disagree most with one particular staff member so we can enjoy the back and forth debate

 

[ookook]

Maybe PPR people should have a separate forum so they do not need to mentally adjust the official FBG scoring format.

 

[rzrback77]

Just do you rankings how you want to, they are always enjoyable.

 

[Colin Dowling]

PLease point out how every staffer but 1 has Cedric Benson too low.

 

[LHUCKS]

ETA = 7 Hours for QBs

 

[AB in DC]

You mean 7 hours, or 7 days?

 

[ImTheScientist]

You mean 7 hours, or 7 days?

WHERE IS IT??

 

[KellysHeroes]

Is this a WDID? sounds like it too me

 

[Gatorman]

LHUCKS...

Just to be clear, you are going over RANKINGS, not ADP. In terms of over vs. undervalued, it is on how people think of them, not where they are going in drafts.

(ADP is not something you can really look at until we get a few more drafts under our belt)

 

[Captain Hook]

ETA = 7 Hours for QBs

Did you get lost in a bottle... or kidnapped by a band of Scotsdale virgins?

 

[3nOut]

I can't ecall how you set up your rankings. Do you put them in tiers/buckets? It would be helpful (if you dont already) to group them whee you think there is a considerable dropoff. Can you also povide a link to your last year's rankings?

 

[pantherclub]

link to said rankings please

 

[LHUCKS]

I don't put out my rankings untill all of my money drafts are finished. What I will put out today is a "critique" of the FBG consensus rankings.

 

[JAMMIN]

I actually used your rankings before when deciding between two players that were really close.