Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
My really rough Top 100 List (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter David Dodds
- Start date
The Ref
Footballguy
I am not sure if I should love or hate that most of the things I see are items that have been pointed out by other in the Shark Pool so far.
Having Hass at QB2 and D-Jax at WR15 isn't in line.
Vick at QB 7 isn't where I think he should go, but I am a hater.
Edge at RB6 in Arizona isn't worth the risk IMHO - But I am willing to admit that this should be one of the larger pre season discussions this year.
Kevin Jones at RB 15 isn't going to happen in my rankings, I'll tell you that much.
Tom Jones, W Dunn and FWP are all values at RB 18,19 and 20.
One or the other Indi RB will have to end up in the top 20 when it's all said and done. But it's too early to tell now.
My gut feeling is Chris Cooley is too low, but then again I am not sure I would put him ahead of anyone on the list. Guess this shows how deep TE will be this year.
One of the NE Running backs will have to be top 20 as well. I am also confused why you think the NE D will be worse this year? They will have Brushi back for the whole year, Seymour will have better health (one would hope) and there is a good chance Harrison will be back. Plus the schedule is so much easier this year then last.
Still - a great job DD!
Having Hass at QB2 and D-Jax at WR15 isn't in line.
Vick at QB 7 isn't where I think he should go, but I am a hater.
Edge at RB6 in Arizona isn't worth the risk IMHO - But I am willing to admit that this should be one of the larger pre season discussions this year.
Kevin Jones at RB 15 isn't going to happen in my rankings, I'll tell you that much.
Tom Jones, W Dunn and FWP are all values at RB 18,19 and 20.
One or the other Indi RB will have to end up in the top 20 when it's all said and done. But it's too early to tell now.
My gut feeling is Chris Cooley is too low, but then again I am not sure I would put him ahead of anyone on the list. Guess this shows how deep TE will be this year.
One of the NE Running backs will have to be top 20 as well. I am also confused why you think the NE D will be worse this year? They will have Brushi back for the whole year, Seymour will have better health (one would hope) and there is a good chance Harrison will be back. Plus the schedule is so much easier this year then last.
Still - a great job DD!
Weapon of Mass Instruction
Watch my feet!
LenDale's going to be doing the George Jefferson.
rovidedwegetalefttackle:
rovidedwegetalefttackle:For Eli to maintain that ranking, he'd have to have as many other top QBs injured next year as there were last year. I simply don't think that's very likely. Even if he stays in the range of QB4-7, though, he's certainly too early with the 48th pick, unless it's a dynasty league.Roeth, on the other hand, should be moving way up.
Couch Potato
Footballguy
Do we have an updated guess as to when projections might be posted?
David Dodds
Administrator
I am five teams away as I speak. They will definitely get done today, but require adding all the playerid tags to the database to get to the web. They should be posted tonight or tomorrow at the latest.Magazine efforts killed my earlier schedule.
Last edited by a moderator:
Dancing Bear
Footballguy
Hi David,
I am just curious about one choice in your list.
Why did you choose to list Fitzgerald over Boldin?
Boldin averaged more than 12 yards per game higher last year, and 0.5 ppg from a Fantasy perspective.
What gives Fitzgerald the edge to you?
I am just curious about one choice in your list.
Why did you choose to list Fitzgerald over Boldin?
Boldin averaged more than 12 yards per game higher last year, and 0.5 ppg from a Fantasy perspective.
What gives Fitzgerald the edge to you?
Dancing Bear
Footballguy
Actually, I guess I lied. Sorry, but I have another question ...
Why is Ben Roethlisberger so low? The others that you have around him are all injured and recovering. Are you expecting him to revert?
He led the league last year with pass completions of 40+ yards.
He is in his third year now and should show improvement in all aspects of his game.
He has the best record of any QB starting out of the blocks in NFL history.
Last year he would have finished 12th in QB Fantasy ranking for ppg [16.96 ppg] if the Footballguys.com Web site corrected his number of games played to the correct number [12 instead of 13]. He did not start or take a single snap against Baltimore in Week 11 and this counts as the 13th game for him and dramatically lowers his standing. I reported this in December to Joe and never got a response or the correction ...
I think that he deserves at least the same ranking as he obtained last year and should certainly be listed before all of the walking wounded.
Why is Ben Roethlisberger so low? The others that you have around him are all injured and recovering. Are you expecting him to revert?
He led the league last year with pass completions of 40+ yards.
He is in his third year now and should show improvement in all aspects of his game.
He has the best record of any QB starting out of the blocks in NFL history.
Last year he would have finished 12th in QB Fantasy ranking for ppg [16.96 ppg] if the Footballguys.com Web site corrected his number of games played to the correct number [12 instead of 13]. He did not start or take a single snap against Baltimore in Week 11 and this counts as the 13th game for him and dramatically lowers his standing. I reported this in December to Joe and never got a response or the correction ...
I think that he deserves at least the same ranking as he obtained last year and should certainly be listed before all of the walking wounded.
TheFanatic
Footballguy
That was the biggest thing that jumped out at me as well....
2005Patriots total rushing: 1512y 3.4 y/c49ers total rushing: 1689y 3.9 y/cPatriots scored 7 more TDs on the ground which obviously pushes them way ahead, but if this dynamic should change even a little... I think its reasonable to assume the 9ers will improve their offense compared to last years debacle, in which case I could see them comparable to the Patriots on the ground.If anything this reveals New England cant run the ball for crap outside of the redzone. They better straighten that out.
gregjcross
Footballguy
I like the rankings:
If Larry Fitzgerald and Anquan Boldin are that high, where does that leave Warner? Either the WRs have to go lower with a Rookie throwing ot them or Warner a lot higher.
On the contrary: Warner could play in 12 full games, throw a lot of INTs/TDs and end up as a pedestrian QB while the receivers do really well.
If Larry Fitzgerald and Anquan Boldin are that high, where does that leave Warner? Either the WRs have to go lower with a Rookie throwing ot them or Warner a lot higher.
On the contrary: Warner could play in 12 full games, throw a lot of INTs/TDs and end up as a pedestrian QB while the receivers do really well.
