Need expert help rating these young QBs in Dynasty format (1 Viewer)

[KellysHeroes]

I've seen these guys drafted as QB#3 and 4s as a stash and hope for the best type deal. Most of them have a solid starter infront of them and have a 1.5 too 2 yr wait. Looking for some expert rankings on these (maybe) future starting QBs.

Thank you

 

[Colin Dowling]

I like Beck and Stanton for the future.

I think Croyle is terrible. Plus, he can't stay healthy. Plus, he plays in KC for Edwards.

Clemmens, Kolb, Rodgers don't excite me. THey may start someday and be really good somewhere, but the wait is likely to be too long IMO to hang on to them in any league but a big/deep one.

 

[Illegal Pants Downfield]

Clemens is #1 by far and away for me.

Croyle is #6 by far and away for me.

Rodgers/Stanton/Kolb/Beck fall 2-5 and I could be talked into almost any order here, though right now I'm hearing good things about Rodgers' progression as a player this offseason, so maybe now is the time to get him...

 

[KellysHeroes]

Based on his Pre-season preformance; Clemens is most likely #1 on this vote.... the problem I see is that people are reaching for him thinking Clemens should be starting next yr, Pennington may last 2 or more yrs.

Even though he his IR this yr, I still see Stanton as #2 in this list. The weapons that await him are amazing, the QB he has to pass will be 35 yrs old next season. Plus, Kitna will probably take another beating this yr in mad mike's system.

Kolb and Beck are pick ems... both have great reports coming out of camps... I selected Kolb since he'll be playing in Andy Reid's system which is favorable to QBs. Cam Cam's is more favorable to RBs. Beck will most likely be taking NFL snaps before Kolb though; however Beck is 3 yrs older.

Rodgers, don't know what to make here... I fell bad for this kid. As long as Farve is there; Rodgers will never see NFL action and his skills will never get polished. And I don't see Farve calling it quits this season unless he suffers a serious injury. Rodgers most likely won't see Regular NFL action until yr 5. Even then; how will that area react to him.

Croyle, just haven't seen anything impressive here. I got the feeling that this season is it for Big Herm. Bring in a new staff which will strip down that team; and if that happens... will Croyle be part of their future plans? Someone will most likely be brought in to compete with him next season.

 

[KellysHeroes]

Wow... Stanton taking over.

 

[kurtrudder]

Stanton was No.1 for me, Clemens No.2. IMO, the ?? on Clemens is the fact that he's a Jet and is playing on a run first team, not his ability, he appears NFL ready to me. What I'd like to hear from the Shark Pool is what opinion they have on that, whether perhaps it's a matter of the Jets offense being hamstrung by Pennington's arm limitations. Being a dynasty question, could Mangini open up the offense more to suit Clemens once he takes over as the starter or is it likely the Jets would remain a run heavy team?

 

[KellysHeroes]

Bump for the start of the season