Ok been to Virgil's, sides were small but that didn't bother me, always get full on the meat anyway. Brisket was nothing special, seemed like it was on par with Brother Jimmy's also had the pulled chicken, again not bad but nothing super. Still on my list: Dinosaur BBQ, Blue Smoke (ate there once many years ago) and Daisy Mays only because everyone here raves about it, but we used to get DM catered here at work and was never impressed.My personal favorite nyc BBQ joints:1. Hill Country (moist brisket, ribs)2. Dinosaur BBQ (ribs, sides - creole potato salad, mac n' cheese)3. Righteous Urban BBQ (burnt ends: limited availability, bacon)4. Southern Hospitality (biscuit, sides, ribs)5. Waterfront Ale House (pulled pork sandwich, house hot sauce)6. Spanky's7. Wildwood8. Virgil's9. Brother Jimmy's (on the list out of courtesy because I like their bars but their food does not stack up against the competition)10. Duke's (a step below Bro J's, meh)