***New York*** (7 Viewers)

[Major]

who even thinks they're gonna get good BBQ in NYC

love Le Bernardin.. Petit Oven.. and Golden apple.

I love hearing people make these comments.What is so different about BBQ-ing in the south vs. the north, is the air different, the wood, the meat??

Dino voted #1 on Good Morning America beating out the 3 other finalists:

* Cousin's BAR B Q in Fort Worth, Texas

* Woody's Smoke Shack in Des Moines, Iowa

* Archibald's BAR B QUE in Northport, Ala.

http://www.syracuse.com/news/index.ssf/2009/05/dinosaur_voted_americas_best_b.html

Born/Raised in Dallas which has several great BBQ places so maybe Im biased..Ive had good BBQ in NYC but I more meant its not comparable to some places Ive been to in the Dallas/Ft. worth area.. Memphis, Kansas City, Mississipi, Arkansas

Why do people insist on jumping all over a comment. I can get good BBQ, good Mexican, good anything in NY. I never said world's best. I've had BBQ in places like Dallas, Memphis and other "BBQ Capitals of the World" that weren't very good either.

You probably don't know what constitutes good Mexican food. There's some decent authentic spots like Rosa Mexicana but when people are talking Mexican food they're normally not referring to this, they're referring to Tex-Mex (chips, salsa, fajitas, enchilladas,etc). La Esquina is ok but again very expensive for what you're getting. I still have yet to find a decent Mexican spot that serves great chili con queso (a staple of Mexican food). Last time I asked for chili con queso the waiter looked at me funny and brought me a bowl of melted jalapeno jack cheese that instantly hardened up when I tried to dip my chip in the bowl

 

[Nick Vermeil]

Along the Mexican theme, I have a question for you:

Subway platform churro- delicious afternoon snack or express train to food born pathogen?

 

[Tremendous Upside]

Along the Mexican theme, I have a question for you:Subway platform churro- delicious afternoon snack or express train to food born pathogen?

Those aren't mutually exclusive

 

[Major]

Along the Mexican theme, I have a question for you:Subway platform churro- delicious afternoon snack or express train to food born pathogen?

Those aren't mutually exclusive

Good point although I never been tempted to buy a street churro. Ever had those warm sugar coated peanuts they sell on the streets? Haven't tried those either.

 

[Tremendous Upside]

Along the Mexican theme, I have a question for you:Subway platform churro- delicious afternoon snack or express train to food born pathogen?

Those aren't mutually exclusive

Good point although I never been tempted to buy a street churro. Ever had those warm sugar coated peanuts they sell on the streets? Haven't tried those either.

With both the churro and the nuts, it all comes down to freshness. While hot/recently cooked they are quite tasty, but both quickly cool and become inedible tooth crackers. Similar to jumbo pretzels in that respect.

 

[jamny]

Love the peanuts!

 

[Jojo the circus boy]

where the rich live:

http://www.wnyc.org/blogs/wnyc-news-blog/2011/dec/08/census-locates-citys-wealthiest-and-poorest-neighborhoods/

 

[Donsmith753]

Anyone been to WD-50, heard mixed things and was curious...

 

[Bigboy10182000]

That's right, a thread just about New York.

Heading into Prospect Park tomorrow. Any good restaurant recommendations?

RC94's NYC Restaurant Masterlist

I've never been to NY but me and the family are going to the Al Hirschfeld Theatre in January to see How to Succeed and we're looking for a good place to eat after the show.

How many in the above list are near the Al Hirschfeld Theatre? By near I'd mean like a 15-20 minute walk. All the help is appreciated!

 

[Nick Vermeil]

where the rich live:http://www.wnyc.org/blogs/wnyc-news-blog/2011/dec/08/census-locates-citys-wealthiest-and-poorest-neighborhoods/

It's really easy to pick out the projects. You would think the lower east would be richer with the shear volume of knock off handbags they sell over there.

 

[Major]

Anyone been to WD-50, heard mixed things and was curious...

It's interesting food to look at but I'm not crazy about the place. I just want to eat quality food with decent portions. I don't care about how creative you are in your preparation. If you're a :foodie: you'll probably love it.

 

[Eephus]

That's right, a thread just about New York.

Heading into Prospect Park tomorrow. Any good restaurant recommendations?

RC94's NYC Restaurant Masterlist

I've never been to NY but me and the family are going to the Al Hirschfeld Theatre in January to see How to Succeed and we're looking for a good place to eat after the show.

How many in the above list are near the Al Hirschfeld Theatre? By near I'd mean like a 15-20 minute walk. All the help is appreciated!

If you want to stay in the vicinity of the theater, there are a ton of restaurants on 9th Avenue between 42nd and 57th, and also on 46th between 8th and 9th Avenues. You can hit a wide variety of cuisines and price points. Are you going to a matinee or evening show?

 

[Bigboy10182000]

That's right, a thread just about New York.

Heading into Prospect Park tomorrow. Any good restaurant recommendations?

RC94's NYC Restaurant Masterlist

I've never been to NY but me and the family are going to the Al Hirschfeld Theatre in January to see How to Succeed and we're looking for a good place to eat after the show.

How many in the above list are near the Al Hirschfeld Theatre? By near I'd mean like a 15-20 minute walk. All the help is appreciated!

If you want to stay in the vicinity of the theater, there are a ton of restaurants on 9th Avenue between 42nd and 57th, and also on 46th between 8th and 9th Avenues. You can hit a wide variety of cuisines and price points. Are you going to a matinee or evening show?

We're going to the 2:00 PM show

 

[Jojo the circus boy]

where the rich live:http://www.wnyc.org/blogs/wnyc-news-blog/2011/dec/08/census-locates-citys-wealthiest-and-poorest-neighborhoods/

city wide median income = $50,285 - what is middle class? I am guessing middle class is really upper middle clss.

 

[Koya]

where the rich live:http://www.wnyc.org/blogs/wnyc-news-blog/2011/dec/08/census-locates-citys-wealthiest-and-poorest-neighborhoods/

city wide median income = $50,285 - what is middle class? I am guessing middle class is really upper middle clss.

Cost if living in / around NYC = ridiculous

 

[Jojo the circus boy]

where the rich live:http://www.wnyc.org/blogs/wnyc-news-blog/2011/dec/08/census-locates-citys-wealthiest-and-poorest-neighborhoods/

city wide median income = $50,285 - what is middle class? I am guessing middle class is really upper middle clss.

Cost if living in / around NYC = ridiculous

Stupid little stuff like electricity which you don't even think of, I was paying $200 a month for it, for my studio (higher in the peak of summer).I moved to South Florida where I find myself running an AC 24/7 between bedroom and living room (I work out of my apartment). My electric bill has not been higher than $60 a month.I also have a free parking spot - in nyc what will that run $250 a month (minimum!), granted you do not need a car when living in nyc.When you add up all of the expenses, cost to go out for beers (typically $1-2 here every night, sometimes 3-for-1), food, etc... I agree, it adds up FAST.

 

[El Floppo]

I wasn't sure of the best place for this, so I posted it in the gmtan... not the best place for it, since I haven't posted there in a long while and can't possbly distract folks from SLB's beard and unfinished basement as a non-regular. Since it's NYC related, I'll post it here because I can't brag to my IRL NYC friends about it, but still am busting at the seams and need to let it out.

warning: Kvelling parent disclaimer..

Here in NYC, kids have to take a test to get into private schools- starting at the age of 4! It's called the ERB and in applying to a new private school for Kindergarten (to cover our bases), we were forced to have 4 yo Floppolinho take the damned thing. It's an hour of cognitive and developmental abilities administered one on one with only the kid. I have no idea what the could possibly mean for a 4yo old, but for the Type A NYC parent (which we are not), it's an occasion for even more head-asplode/helicopter-parenting/throwing money at the private school application industry insanity.

So, our son's test giver showed up an hour ####### late- forcing our kid to just hang out in the damn waiting room for that time before jumpng into the actual test. Kudos to my wife for keeping him entertained and sane for that time, but we both assumed the test was going to be a total wash as a result and were already planning our protest (or at least refund).

Just got the results today... and no need for a protest after all; he topped out- 99th percentile in both areas and got some glowing praise in a written evaluation by the administrator of the test! He's pretty much a richard most of the time, but at least he's got this going for him . But seriously- I couldn't be more proud of the guy. I don't know how bright he is relative to other kids, but I do know he's amazing one-on-one with adults- so whatever it it they "test" for a 4yo, if it was just him and an adult he was always going to do pretty well. Or at least charm the pants of the test-taker. And If only this was for the gifted and talented test for public schools and not just for the privilege of dropping a year's salary on Kindergarten... if he even gets in.

 

[El Floppo]

Yah. My wife worked as a tester for ERB for a number of years while getting her PhD. It's a completely crazy cottage industry. Some parents even send their kids to test prep beforehand... just wrong to do a 4yo.I imagine you've already looked at all the options, but I've heard very good things about the U.N. school. It's mostly for the kids of U.N. diplomats but they do have some limited number of spots for general admission.In any case, mazel tov on having a smart cookie.

THanks! He gets his looks from me.I still have no idea what the hell the test was, but I know first hand that parents get ape-#### over it; it's no surprise that there are test-prep services for it.Some of his buddies are applying to the UN School- sounds amazing. He's already in a school that we kind-of like, so we are only applying to Friends- we fell in love with the place and live relatively nearby. Hopefully the testing abilities translate to the G&T test so he can get into Anderson or NEST (which is down the street from us) as finances will likely force us/him into the public schools. If so, I actually like the 4 local schools in our district, so there could be far worse things for him... and not shelling out almost 40k would be nice too.

 

[El Floppo]

Yah. My wife worked as a tester for ERB for a number of years while getting her PhD. It's a completely crazy cottage industry. Some parents even send their kids to test prep beforehand... just wrong to do a 4yo.I imagine you've already looked at all the options, but I've heard very good things about the U.N. school. It's mostly for the kids of U.N. diplomats but they do have some limited number of spots for general admission.In any case, mazel tov on having a smart cookie.

THanks! He gets his looks from me.I still have no idea what the hell the test was, but I know first hand that parents get ape-#### over it; it's no surprise that there are test-prep services for it.Some of his buddies are applying to the UN School- sounds amazing. He's already in a school that we kind-of like, so we are only applying to Friends- we fell in love with the place and live relatively nearby. Hopefully the testing abilities translate to the G&T test so he can get into Anderson or NEST (which is down the street from us) as finances will likely force us/him into the public schools. If so, I actually like the 4 local schools in our district, so there could be far worse things for him... and not shelling out almost 40k would be nice too.

Yah, the idea of spending 40k a year on pre-college education for kids blows my mind. If we do have some kids of our own and are still living in NYC (which I hope not to do) they'd definitely do public.If you clear a spot in your PMs, I'll give you a little insight into the test if you like.

If my kid did well in it, I can go ahead and assume the test was about Legos and Phineas and Ferb. Is there more to it than that?

 

[Jojo the circus boy]

I wasn't sure of the best place for this, so I posted it in the gmtan... not the best place for it, since I haven't posted there in a long while and can't possbly distract folks from SLB's beard and unfinished basement as a non-regular. Since it's NYC related, I'll post it here because I can't brag to my IRL NYC friends about it, but still am busting at the seams and need to let it out.warning: Kvelling parent disclaimer..Here in NYC, kids have to take a test to get into private schools- starting at the age of 4! It's called the ERB and in applying to a new private school for Kindergarten (to cover our bases), we were forced to have 4 yo Floppolinho take the damned thing. It's an hour of cognitive and developmental abilities administered one on one with only the kid. I have no idea what the could possibly mean for a 4yo old, but for the Type A NYC parent (which we are not), it's an occasion for even more head-asplode/helicopter-parenting/throwing money at the private school application industry insanity.So, our son's test giver showed up an hour ####### late- forcing our kid to just hang out in the damn waiting room for that time before jumpng into the actual test. Kudos to my wife for keeping him entertained and sane for that time, but we both assumed the test was going to be a total wash as a result and were already planning our protest (or at least refund). Just got the results today... and no need for a protest after all; he topped out- 99th percentile in both areas and got some glowing praise in a written evaluation by the administrator of the test! He's pretty much a richard most of the time, but at least he's got this going for him . But seriously- I couldn't be more proud of the guy. I don't know how bright he is relative to other kids, but I do know he's amazing one-on-one with adults- so whatever it it they "test" for a 4yo, if it was just him and an adult he was always going to do pretty well. Or at least charm the pants of the test-taker. And If only this was for the gifted and talented test for public schools and not just for the privilege of dropping a year's salary on Kindergarten... if he even gets in.

Congrats! Now you just need to work on his dribbling and shooting skills (soccer of course).

 

[INRIhab]

I have a bunch of family members coming to the city Saturday night and I'm looking for suggestions on where to take them. There's a pretty wide age range - youngest is 17, a few are 20, another eight of us are 20-30. NYC nightlife to me means "bars", but that's obviously not an option this time around so I'm clueless as to where to take them. The plan is to visit my apartment around 10:30pm, playing some drinking games for a few hours, then go out for a few hours.

I've done some google searches for fun nightlife activities that don't require an ID, but was hoping to get a suggestion or two from FBGs. Seems like my best bet is a cafe or some similar venue that has music. Was thinking a hookah bar may be fun, but the few that I've called up said they're 21 to enter. Any ideas? In our drunken stupor we may be into some more touristy sight-seeing (even late at night), but I'm not too sure...

EDIT: A few of my cousins love karaoke ... I'm afraid to suggest this to them because I'll end up getting hammered and embarrassing myself as I rap to Notorious BIG somewhere in k-town...but I guess I need some options at this point

 

[El Floppo]

I have a bunch of family members coming to the city Saturday night and I'm looking for suggestions on where to take them. There's a pretty wide age range - youngest is 17, a few are 20, another eight of us are 20-30. NYC nightlife to me means "bars", but that's obviously not an option this time around so I'm clueless as to where to take them. The plan is to visit my apartment around 10:30pm, playing some drinking games for a few hours, then go out for a few hours. I've done some google searches for fun nightlife activities that don't require an ID, but was hoping to get a suggestion or two from FBGs. Seems like my best bet is a cafe or some similar venue that has music. Was thinking a hookah bar may be fun, but the few that I've called up said they're 21 to enter. Any ideas? In our drunken stupor we may be into some more touristy sight-seeing (even late at night), but I'm not too sure...EDIT: A few of my cousins love karaoke ... I'm afraid to suggest this to them because I'll end up getting hammered and embarrassing myself as I rap to Notorious BIG somewhere in k-town...but I guess I need some options at this point

is there a late show of Fuerza Bruta? those ages are right in the wheelhouse for that. When I saw their last show, there were lots of young-uns whi were very clearly high or drunk. Sfterwards you can roam around the EVil/LES for some live music spots that allow underage... or maybe that horrible NYU/B&T stretch of Bleecker St that has all the cafes.Disclaimer- I haven't actually gone "out" in 10 years.

 

[Major]

I have a bunch of family members coming to the city Saturday night and I'm looking for suggestions on where to take them. There's a pretty wide age range - youngest is 17, a few are 20, another eight of us are 20-30. NYC nightlife to me means "bars", but that's obviously not an option this time around so I'm clueless as to where to take them. The plan is to visit my apartment around 10:30pm, playing some drinking games for a few hours, then go out for a few hours.

I've done some google searches for fun nightlife activities that don't require an ID, but was hoping to get a suggestion or two from FBGs. Seems like my best bet is a cafe or some similar venue that has music. Was thinking a hookah bar may be fun, but the few that I've called up said they're 21 to enter. Any ideas? In our drunken stupor we may be into some more touristy sight-seeing (even late at night), but I'm not too sure...

EDIT: A few of my cousins love karaoke ... I'm afraid to suggest this to them because I'll end up getting hammered and embarrassing myself as I rap to Notorious BIG somewhere in k-town...but I guess I need some options at this point

I found a lot of places don't ID in NYC (compared to other cities) but probably best to be safe. A hooka bar/restaurant and karaoke are good ideas. I'd normally take groups like this to Fat Cat - Part game room, part bar, part jazz club. Pretty sure everyone can get in there. Pretty fun place.edit: checked the website. As long as you get to Fat Cat before 10:30, under 21 are welcome

All ages are welcome to enter anytime EXCEPT after 10:30pm on Fridays & Saturdays. Early arrivals -21 are welcome to stay.

 

[RUSF18]

Restaurant to recommend/add to this list if it's still being updated

Upstate

It has a gastro-pub feel but is small. Probably seats 25-30 tops. All the furniture is very rustic; I think the owner made the tables and benches out of scrap wood with his father. Open kitchen. Good atmosphere.

Three things jump out about the place.

1: Awesome oysters.

2: Very welcoming/friendly staff.

3: Limited menu.

The place is run by a husband and a wife who AFAIK are there every night. The husband comes around and offers suggestions on the menu. The wife hangs in back but bakes 10 rum cakes every day which is their complimentary (and only) dessert. Their oysters run from $1.75ea - $3.25ea and are extremely good. For the rest of the menu, there's something like 8-10 shared apps to choose from and maybe half a dozen entrees. They're a seafood joint that don't have refrigeration (they keep everything on ice) so the options are limited but very fresh. I went there a few weeks ago with the wife and another couple and the bill came to around $300 for the four of us incl. tax, tip, and drinks. Very much worth it. Oh, and the background noise isn't too loud so you can go there and actually chat with the people you came with. It's not a white tablecloth kinda joint but it's also not grabbing a burger at whatever faux Irish bar you stumble across throughout Manhattan. If you want a quality and casual dinner, I'd strongly suggest it.

I went here a couple weeks ago, picked by my fiancee's best friend who tends to know about EV places like this. I agree with pretty much everything you said. The husband was a good guy and was very helpful especially when detailing the oyster choices. The craft beer selections are very good as well (love Southampton Double White). We went expecting "dinner" and happened to be pretty hungry that night also, and the other couple had eaten earlier so they were more in the mood for the light food served here. We went through oysters, scallops, and mussels and were still hungry...no problem, it was nothing a block walk to Cheep's for a $2.50 falafel couldn't fix.

 

[dgreen]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.

There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

 

[Major]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.

There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250. The cheap places go fast. However, one of my go to spots for friends is Off Soho Suites. Great location and reasonable price (depending on time of year/vacancies). There are some dumps in Times Square for under $150/night. Also check jetsetter. Here's my invite (you'll get a $25 credit as well). Looks like they have some place called Gild Hall for $120 which looks like a great deal: http://www.jetsetter.com/invite/drussell75. You'll be in the Financial District/Wall St. area which sucks at night but a good deal at that price.

 

[dgreen]

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250.

Thanks for the info. Does "NYC" mean "Manhattan" here?

 

[El Floppo]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.

There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250. The cheap places go fast. However, one of my go to spots for friends is Off Soho Suites. Great location and reasonable price (depending on time of year/vacancies). There are some dumps in Times Square for under $150/night. Also check jetsetter. Here's my invite (you'll get a $25 credit as well). Looks like they have some place called Gild Hall for $120 which looks like a great deal: http://www.jetsetter.com/invite/drussell75. You'll be in the Financial District/Wall St. area which sucks at night but a good deal at that price.

THat's near all the Fulton St subways, Wall St, Ground Zero, the Battery (Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island ferries) and South St Seaport area. Sounds like it fits the bill, although god knows what kind of room they're going to get for that... oops- just checked those dates and it's back up to the $250 range in that span.I just checked the new Comfort Inn that opened up down the street in the LES- it's in the $250 range.

 

[Major]

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250.

Thanks for the info. Does "NYC" mean "Manhattan" here?

Yes, I was referring to Manhattan...you can probably stay in the Bronx or Queens for cheaper but it's not worth the hassle. Unless you stay in Williamsburg or Dumbo, BK will be a hassle. I think that Soho Suites place could be awesome for your family. It's nothing luxurious but you actually have a kitchen, etc and is a lot bigger than your standard NYC hotel. Great location without the $500 price tag. You're pretty much in an area that contains Soho, Chinatown and Little Italy.

 

[dgreen]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.

There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250. The cheap places go fast. However, one of my go to spots for friends is Off Soho Suites. Great location and reasonable price (depending on time of year/vacancies). There are some dumps in Times Square for under $150/night. Also check jetsetter. Here's my invite (you'll get a $25 credit as well). Looks like they have some place called Gild Hall for $120 which looks like a great deal: http://www.jetsetter.com/invite/drussell75. You'll be in the Financial District/Wall St. area which sucks at night but a good deal at that price.

THat's near all the Fulton St subways, Wall St, Ground Zero, the Battery (Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island ferries) and South St Seaport area. Sounds like it fits the bill, although god knows what kind of room they're going to get for that... oops- just checked those dates and it's back up to the $250 range in that span.

Weird site. I say it quickly flash $114, then change to $214. The $214 looks like a good deal.The Soho one has a room with two twins for $159. That's really good, but won't work for our family. The suite for 4 is $250.

I may just suck it up, not be cheap, and go for something like these two. But, again, if there's a cool neighborhood in Brooklyn with a good hotel for a much better price, I'm fine with that.

Question: Any chance NYC hotels are unlike every other location and actually care about how many people are staying in a room? I ask because to do online reservations at most places for 2 adults and 3 kids, they don't allow you to reserve one room. But, the Gild ($229) offers a King Suite with a sofa bed. That would be great for us. But, online they allow 3 or less as part of the reservation. I've never had a hotel stop me when I walk to my room with three kids, so I'm hoping NYC is the same?

 

[Major]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.

There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250. The cheap places go fast. However, one of my go to spots for friends is Off Soho Suites. Great location and reasonable price (depending on time of year/vacancies). There are some dumps in Times Square for under $150/night. Also check jetsetter. Here's my invite (you'll get a $25 credit as well). Looks like they have some place called Gild Hall for $120 which looks like a great deal: http://www.jetsetter.com/invite/drussell75. You'll be in the Financial District/Wall St. area which sucks at night but a good deal at that price.

THat's near all the Fulton St subways, Wall St, Ground Zero, the Battery (Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island ferries) and South St Seaport area. Sounds like it fits the bill, although god knows what kind of room they're going to get for that... oops- just checked those dates and it's back up to the $250 range in that span.

Weird site. I say it quickly flash $114, then change to $214. The $214 looks like a good deal.The Soho one has a room with two twins for $159. That's really good, but won't work for our family. The suite for 4 is $250.

I may just suck it up, not be cheap, and go for something like these two. But, again, if there's a cool neighborhood in Brooklyn with a good hotel for a much better price, I'm fine with that.

Question: Any chance NYC hotels are unlike every other location and actually care about how many people are staying in a room? I ask because to do online reservations at most places for 2 adults and 3 kids, they don't allow you to reserve one room. But, the Gild ($229) offers a King Suite with a sofa bed. That would be great for us. But, online they allow 3 or less as part of the reservation. I've never had a hotel stop me when I walk to my room with three kids, so I'm hoping NYC is the same?

No idea....probably better to leave them outside with the lady while you check in.

 

[dgreen]

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250.

Thanks for the info. Does "NYC" mean "Manhattan" here?

Yes, I was referring to Manhattan...you can probably stay in the Bronx or Queens for cheaper but it's not worth the hassle. Unless you stay in Williamsburg or Dumbo, BK will be a hassle. I think that Soho Suites place could be awesome for your family. It's nothing luxurious but you actually have a kitchen, etc and is a lot bigger than your standard NYC hotel. Great location without the $500 price tag. You're pretty much in an area that contains Soho, Chinatown and Little Italy.

What are the hassles? Just the longer train ride to our desired locations?

 

[Bigboy10182000]

I've never been to NY but me and the family are going to the Al Hirschfeld Theatre in January to see How to Succeed and we're looking for a good place to eat after the show.How many in the above list are near the Al Hirschfeld Theatre? By near I'd mean like a 15-20 minute walk. All the help is appreciated!

BTW, we ended up eating at Ellen's Stardust Diner for lunch and the Celtic pub for dinner.

 

[dgreen]

Ahh, the $114 at Gild Hall is for Sunday, Feb 26. Really good deal.

 

[Major]

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250.

Thanks for the info. Does "NYC" mean "Manhattan" here?

Yes, I was referring to Manhattan...you can probably stay in the Bronx or Queens for cheaper but it's not worth the hassle. Unless you stay in Williamsburg or Dumbo, BK will be a hassle. I think that Soho Suites place could be awesome for your family. It's nothing luxurious but you actually have a kitchen, etc and is a lot bigger than your standard NYC hotel. Great location without the $500 price tag. You're pretty much in an area that contains Soho, Chinatown and Little Italy.

What are the hassles? Just the longer train ride to our desired locations?

45-1 hour commute home, long walk from subway, potential crime, not tourist friendly, etc....i never lived in the other boroughs but always found them to be a pain in the ### to get to at night via subway. Lots of cabs won't take you out there.

 

[Redwes25]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.

There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250. The cheap places go fast. However, one of my go to spots for friends is Off Soho Suites. Great location and reasonable price (depending on time of year/vacancies). There are some dumps in Times Square for under $150/night. Also check jetsetter. Here's my invite (you'll get a $25 credit as well). Looks like they have some place called Gild Hall for $120 which looks like a great deal: http://www.jetsetter.com/invite/drussell75. You'll be in the Financial District/Wall St. area which sucks at night but a good deal at that price.

THat's near all the Fulton St subways, Wall St, Ground Zero, the Battery (Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island ferries) and South St Seaport area. Sounds like it fits the bill, although god knows what kind of room they're going to get for that... oops- just checked those dates and it's back up to the $250 range in that span.

Weird site. I say it quickly flash $114, then change to $214. The $214 looks like a good deal.The Soho one has a room with two twins for $159. That's really good, but won't work for our family. The suite for 4 is $250.

I may just suck it up, not be cheap, and go for something like these two. But, again, if there's a cool neighborhood in Brooklyn with a good hotel for a much better price, I'm fine with that.

Question: Any chance NYC hotels are unlike every other location and actually care about how many people are staying in a room? I ask because to do online reservations at most places for 2 adults and 3 kids, they don't allow you to reserve one room. But, the Gild ($229) offers a King Suite with a sofa bed. That would be great for us. But, online they allow 3 or less as part of the reservation. I've never had a hotel stop me when I walk to my room with three kids, so I'm hoping NYC is the same?

Hotel option in Brooklyn suck. Problem is that traditionally these neighborhoods did not have hotels and now that there is growing demand for them you end up with hotels on the edges of good neighborhoods. There are a few on 4th ave but that is really on the dreary end of park slope. Also, there is a hotel on the edge of Boreum Hill at the end of smith street (http://www.nuhotelbrooklyn.com). Problem is that it is next to the newly reopened jail so don't think it is worth it.Unfortunately, there aren't any hotels in the good neighborhoods like in the middle of Smith street, 7th Ave in Park slope, in Dumbo or Williamsburg. Unfotunately, Manhattan really is the only good option if you want a good location to explore near the hotel.

ETA - There are a number of good bed and breakfasts in brownstone brooklyn neighborhoods. Not sure how affordable they are and don't think that is the direction you are going for.

 

[El Floppo]

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250.

Thanks for the info. Does "NYC" mean "Manhattan" here?

Yes, I was referring to Manhattan...you can probably stay in the Bronx or Queens for cheaper but it's not worth the hassle. Unless you stay in Williamsburg or Dumbo, BK will be a hassle. I think that Soho Suites place could be awesome for your family. It's nothing luxurious but you actually have a kitchen, etc and is a lot bigger than your standard NYC hotel. Great location without the $500 price tag. You're pretty much in an area that contains Soho, Chinatown and Little Italy.

What are the hassles? Just the longer train ride to our desired locations?

45-1 hour commute home, long walk from subway, potential crime, not tourist friendly, etc....i never lived in the other boroughs but always found them to be a pain in the ### to get to at night via subway. Lots of cabs won't take you out there.

Not to mention, only the minivan cabs can fit 5.I think it's a question of what he wants out of this trip. Staying in Brooklyn or LIC might have it's charms- but not sure it's going to get the kids the full NYC (ie: tourist Manhattan) experience. And that's not necessarily a bad thing.

 

[Jojo the circus boy]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

Checkout two places, I got this one off of hotwire for March:http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g60763-d488793-Reviews-Solito_Soho_Hotel-New_York_City_New_York.htmlHere's another one I would look into:http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g60763-d1465008-Reviews-Holiday_Inn_Express_New_York_City_Wall_Street-New_York_City_New_York.htmlI was actually hoping I got the Holiday Inn Express on Wall St., but ended up getting Solito Soho. Prices should both be within your budget. I am paying $620 for 4 nights so $155/night (includes all taxes and fees).

 

[Major]

Near impossible to find good hotels in NYC for under $200-250.

Thanks for the info. Does "NYC" mean "Manhattan" here?

Yes, I was referring to Manhattan...you can probably stay in the Bronx or Queens for cheaper but it's not worth the hassle. Unless you stay in Williamsburg or Dumbo, BK will be a hassle. I think that Soho Suites place could be awesome for your family. It's nothing luxurious but you actually have a kitchen, etc and is a lot bigger than your standard NYC hotel. Great location without the $500 price tag. You're pretty much in an area that contains Soho, Chinatown and Little Italy.

What are the hassles? Just the longer train ride to our desired locations?

45-1 hour commute home, long walk from subway, potential crime, not tourist friendly, etc....i never lived in the other boroughs but always found them to be a pain in the ### to get to at night via subway. Lots of cabs won't take you out there.

Not to mention, only the minivan cabs can fit 5.I think it's a question of what he wants out of this trip. Staying in Brooklyn or LIC might have it's charms- but not sure it's going to get the kids the full NYC (ie: tourist Manhattan) experience. And that's not necessarily a bad thing.

Good point since he's traveling with family. Some cabs will let you ride 5 if you give them a hefty tip $10-20 but most will tell you

 

[dgreen]

I need some hotel options. Planning on spending a few days in NYC this spring (possibly first week of April) with my wife and three kids (8, 6, and 4). I want a decent room (Holiday Inn, Comfort Inn, etc. is fine - I'm not looking for the Ritz) in a decent neighborhood with good access to the subway. If the hood around the hotel is cool with good restaurants and good character, that's a bonus. But, if it's kind of boring and lame but I can feel safe walking with my family from the subway to the hotel at night, that's all I really need. Yeah, I could go online and pick a Manhattan hotel in an obviously cool/fun/nice area close to everything, but I don't want to pay the prices I've been seeing ($250+). If that's the route I go, we'd probably only stay one night due to the price. If I can find something I like, even if it's not in Manhattan, for a much better price, I think we'd make this a two-night trip. Obviously Manhattan is the preference (all else being equal), but good areas in Brooklyn and Queens would be cool too.There was a Brooklyn hotel on Groupon recently for only $100 per night, but it had to be used earlier than we're going. I'm going to keep checking Groupon for good offers.

Checkout two places, I got this one off of hotwire for March:http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g60763-d488793-Reviews-Solito_Soho_Hotel-New_York_City_New_York.htmlHere's another one I would look into:http://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotel_Review-g60763-d1465008-Reviews-Holiday_Inn_Express_New_York_City_Wall_Street-New_York_City_New_York.htmlI was actually hoping I got the Holiday Inn Express on Wall St., but ended up getting Solito Soho. Prices should both be within your budget. I am paying $620 for 4 nights so $155/night (includes all taxes and fees).

Looks like prices rise towards the end of March and early April. It's our kids spring break, probably with a lot of other school districts, and Easter week. Probably a popular week.

 

[dgreen]

I think it's a question of what he wants out of this trip. Staying in Brooklyn or LIC might have it's charms- but not sure it's going to get the kids the full NYC (ie: tourist Manhattan) experience. And that's not necessarily a bad thing.

This all started with my first-grader learning about the Statue of Liberty in school and asking if we could go see it sometime. We said "Sure" and briefly talked about making a day trip from DC soon. Then I did taxes over the weekend and got back more than expected and started talking about making it a multi-day trip.Whenever we do this, we'll probably ride the train up from DC ($350 roundtrip for all 5 of us, pretty good deal and a fun experience for the kids) and definitely do the Statue of Liberty. Other than that, we really haven't thought about what we want to do. I'm sure we'll hit the Empire State Building, a stroll through Central Park, and Ground Zero. Once I nail down a few things, I'll be back to ask for additional sites and food advice.

 

[Koya]

I have a bunch of family members coming to the city Saturday night and I'm looking for suggestions on where to take them. There's a pretty wide age range - youngest is 17, a few are 20, another eight of us are 20-30. NYC nightlife to me means "bars", but that's obviously not an option this time around so I'm clueless as to where to take them. The plan is to visit my apartment around 10:30pm, playing some drinking games for a few hours, then go out for a few hours. I've done some google searches for fun nightlife activities that don't require an ID, but was hoping to get a suggestion or two from FBGs. Seems like my best bet is a cafe or some similar venue that has music. Was thinking a hookah bar may be fun, but the few that I've called up said they're 21 to enter. Any ideas? In our drunken stupor we may be into some more touristy sight-seeing (even late at night), but I'm not too sure...EDIT: A few of my cousins love karaoke ... I'm afraid to suggest this to them because I'll end up getting hammered and embarrassing myself as I rap to Notorious BIG somewhere in k-town...but I guess I need some options at this point

Is bowlmar lanes or whatever the bowling / lounge still going? Could be an option

 

[dgreen]

Holy crap, this place looks money. Then I saw this and I'm not sure what's going on there.

 

[Nick Vermeil]

Holy crap, this place looks money. Then I saw this and I'm not sure what's going on there.

Its probably worth looking on airbnb.com with a family of five. The NYC hotel rooms will be smaller than the cabs. You might find a deal. I've had decent luck with it though I've never looked in manhattan.

 

[El Floppo]

Holy crap, this place looks money. Then I saw this and I'm not sure what's going on there.

When I clicked on "directions" it's pretty much around the corner from where I live in the EVil. It's also two doors down from the Hells Angels' headquarters (not to worry though, it's also next to law school dorm).I honestly have no idea what's going on with that. But I wonder if it has something to do with a freaky older lady who wanders around the neighborhood singing about being Vegan and trying to hand out literature.

 

[Tremendous Upside]

El Floppo. Congrats on the einsteinbaby. Have you looked into Hunter College Elementary at all? You get 13 yrs of one of the premier educations in America for free.

 

[Major]

Holy crap, this place looks money. Then I saw this and I'm not sure what's going on there.

When I clicked on "directions" it's pretty much around the corner from where I live in the EVil. It's also two doors down from the Hells Angels' headquarters (not to worry though, it's also next to law school dorm).I honestly have no idea what's going on with that. But I wonder if it has something to do with a freaky older lady who wanders around the neighborhood singing about being Vegan and trying to hand out literature.

Good ol' 3rd st. btw 2/3 avenue....one of the few streets in the EV that hasn't been gentrified.

 

[El Floppo]

Holy crap, this place looks money. Then I saw this and I'm not sure what's going on there.

When I clicked on "directions" it's pretty much around the corner from where I live in the EVil. It's also two doors down from the Hells Angels' headquarters (not to worry though, it's also next to law school dorm).I honestly have no idea what's going on with that. But I wonder if it has something to do with a freaky older lady who wanders around the neighborhood singing about being Vegan and trying to hand out literature.

Good ol' 3rd st. btw 2/3 avenue....one of the few streets in the EV that hasn't been gentrified.

x

 

[PinkydaPimp]

Went to Momofuku Ko this weekend and had a great dinner! Pretty cool setup. its about 12 stools and the kicthen is open. everything being made in front of you. Then they do an 11 course dinner! The food was very creative and amazing! I would definitely do it again and recommend it to those looking to have a special night out or do something different.

 

[dgreen]

Trip is booked for April 1-2. Took someone's suggestion from here and we're staying at the Off Soho Suites on Rivington. Looking for some meal suggestions. Keep in mind: family of 5, three kids (ages 4-9), and looking for budget-friendly meals. We're also looking for stuff that's unique and "New York".

1. We'll probably be going from Central Park down to Batter Park for a 2 PM ferry ride to the Statue of Liberty. So, lunch ideas at either location would be good. We either need to lunch around Central Park around 12 to get down to the ferry or we can probably be down to Battery Park around 12:30 and have lunch down there.

2. Breakfast near the hotel? I'm not big on bagels, but I'm sure the rest of my family would like some genuine NY bagels. Our room will have a kitchen, so even a good nearby market to eat in our room would be fine.

3. Lunch around Rockefeller Center? We'll be at the American Girl Doll store (don't act like you don't know where that is) for my daughter Monday morning, so we'll probably be in that general area around lunch time.

4. Dinner near Penn Station? Train leaves at 7:40 Monday evening, so doesn't have to be right next to Penn Station. I think we are just going to do a lot of walking around Midtown Monday afternoon, so anything in that general area should be fine and should easily allow us to get to Penn Station around 7.

We are planning on dinner at Grimaldi's in Brooklyn Sunday night and then walking across the Brooklyn Bridge back towards our hotel. I stumbled across The Original Chinatown Ice Cream Factory on the internet. Any good? I was thinking that would be a good place to go for dessert after walking back to Manhattan.

Right now the weather isn't look good Sunday, so many of these plans could change.