Newbie Help (long) (1 Viewer)

[s d lynn]

My 1st year in IDP - my keeper league is in its inaugural year.We start 2 linemen/end, 2 LB, and 2 def backsScoring: 0.75 (asist), 1.5(solo), 1 (PD), 3 FR, 3 FF, 3 safety, 4 int, 6 TDHow do these rankings look:(1) LinemenKevin WilliamsPatrick KerneyCharles GrantJason TaylorJulius PeppersAaron SchobelJohn AbrahamMichael StrahanTerrell SuggsDwight FreeneyJustin SmithJohn HendersonShaun EllisSimeon RiceBertrand BerryShaun RogersAaron KampmanKabeer Gbaja-BiamilaJevon KearseRod ColemanJames HallOsi UmenyioraGrant WistromLeonard LittleGreg EllisAaron SmithKelly GreggAlex BrownGreg SpiresReggie HaywardMarcus StroudCornelius GriffinAdewale OgunleyeDarren HowardWill Smith(2) LBRay LewisKeith BulluckDonnie EdwardsBrian UrlacherMike PetersonLondon FletcherJonathan VilmaZach ThomasNick BarnettDerrick BrooksAntonio PierceTakeo SpikesJamie SharperJames FarriorKeith BrookingKailee WongDerek SmithDan MorganD.J. WilliamsSam CowartDat NguyenLavar ArringtonAndra DavisTeddy LehmanDanny ClarkEdgerton HartwellEric BartonJeremiah TrotterAl WilsonBrian SimmonsWill WitherspoonMorlon GreenwoodLance BriggsOdell ThurmanJulian Peterson(3) Def BacksRodney HarrisonTroy PolamaluRoy WilliamsMadieu WilliamsRonde BarberMichael LewisBryan ScottErik ColemanTony ParrishLawyer MilloyTerrance KielAdrian WilsonSammy KnightEdward ReedTerrence McGeeSean TaylorWill DempsMichael BoulwareDarren SharperSean JonesDonovin DariusMike BrownBrian DawkinsSheldon BrownAdam ArchuletaThomas DavisTank WilliamsMarcus TrufantGibril WilsonAntoine WinfieldNate ClementsJerametrius ButlerRobert GriffithKen HamlinKenoy KennedySorry so long - please advise newbie on this keeper IDP leagueTHANKS ........

 

[coolnerd]

I think you have the correct players around the correct spots...i.e. I think your tiers are about right, which is more important than have the exact order as i or anyone else sees them.I think Peppers is the best DLman so having him 5 or so would be the thing that I would "argue" with the most, but even that is not a "how the heck could not think" issue.

 

[Tick]

Even with the legal issues, I think Sean Taylor is worth an earlier pick. Suggs still wasn't listed as a DE last time I noticed, and with the goofy Ravens scheme, I'm starting to wonder if he ever will be. Personally, I'd put Kevin Williams lower than you have him. I don't see ranking Dat Nguyen that high. Jamie Sharper seems a bit high as well with the new team not funneling tackles to him anymore. I own both Greg Spires and Will Smith, and I'm at least five times happier I own Smith. Spires was playing a bit of DT last season and isn't someone I feel I know what to expect from.Overall, it looks like a good list - I have as many things others would disagree with.

 

[Beaumont]

I think you should have Bob Sanders on your DB list ... somewhere in the top 20 ...

 

[Beaumont]

I also think Brian Scott is too high ... he is having a hard time coming back from injury and he will likely be playing more FS than close to the line ...