Offered L Jackson/Guice for Murray/R Freeman (1 Viewer)

[Jamesinaz]

Standard non-PPR league.  I passed but wondering now.  I think both Freeman and Guice have a chance to be a starter in their offenses.  And Murray and Jackson are pretty much a wash too.  Not clear why it was offered.

That is Kyle Murray BTW.

 

[lostxn]

Would have jumped on that deal. Guice looks ready to live up to his potential. I would have taken Jackson over Murray without question. Jackson could be a top 5 this year and top 10 looks very plausible. Murray is a maybe at best this year. If you can still get, I would do it without losing a bit a sleep. 

 

[Jamesinaz]

Thanks.  Here was my take.  Murray has a slightly higher upside to Jackson IMO.  They both run well but Murray has a pinpoint arm on the run.  Close I agree.  Problem with Guice is battle for playing time AND injury history.  Freeman has one year of an injury and also has upside.  

Honestly I won't be surprised if both Murray and Jackson end up top 10 QBs.  And if both Freeman and Guice end up lead backs.  

I thought it was a fair offer just really not much change for either of us.  Two potential upsides but no sure things.