While I agree that the OP here was being a bit too optimistic, many in this thread right now (including yourself to limited degree) are far too pessimistic.At WR, we have arguably the best group ever under AR, and Jackson looks like a real threat. While we lack a dominant #1, it's a solid group now (finally). NONE of the WR's out there this year are a dominant #1...so why are we even discussing it????Uhh, we're going to have to agree to disagree here. Yes, they return 10 starters, but they have no depth at CB, Safety, or arguably LB. As for Demps he looked hesitant, out of position, and tentative last year, so i am not sure what you saw that you likedDefinately work to do. On D, Philly was already #3 in the league and returns 10 starters. Replacing the 11th, Dawkins, is the job. Demps may be the guy here. I liked what I saw of Demps the last 6-7 weeks of 2008. Depth then becomes an issues via draft or FA.
Whoa, i mean WHOAAAAAA there fella. Stacey just had surgery on his ACL AND MCL on Jan 13. An aggressive rehab would have him ready in 7-8 months, placing him back on the field in mid to late August. That's an aggressive rehab, assuming nothing goes wrong, and says zero regarding the shape he will be in at that point in mid August. As for Shawn, the guy has been plagued by mental issues and back problems. To just assume he will be good to go for 16 games at OT is optimistic at best, and really just plain sanguine.RT - StaceyAndrews. Done. I like his game and - while coming off an injury - should be ready for 2009.
LT - Shawn Andrews should be back at RG, and I can see Herremans shifting out to LT.
Really, we lose Tra and Runyon, add Andrews and Andrews. Younger for certain. Assuming Cole/MJG fight it out for the RG spot, we have the 'loser' to go with Justice, Dunlap, etc. as depth. See can see OL - not necessarily OT - being the choice in the first round. We could pick a T, but I do not see this as a priority.I have no idea wtf COP stands for, but the Birds havent exactly shown a propensity to draft RBs, let alone draft them in rds 1 or 2. Maybe they change their tune this year and use one of the 1st Rd picks, but i will beleve it when i see it. PLus, they still have no answer for short yardage (not that they would use him). Whoever they get HAS to be ready to go week 1 as Westy cannot survive another year of 300+ touches. And only 2 offensive rookies have ever started for Reid in his tenure. So again you're being WAY too optimistic here.RB - Draft round 1 or 2 (I hope) to get the COP back to complement Westbrook
TE - Celek and ???? (But really, Celek is ok here...)You say "replace 4 starters" like its no problem. Even after the Eagles have done basically nothing in FA. I dont know if we're in the "doom and gloom" panic rating just yet. But, this team barely made the playoffs last year, looked like crap in half of their games, have not filled any glaring needs yet this offseason (unless you count the gamble on Andrews), and still are ignoring the WR position. You didnt even mention anything at WR as if we have 3 studs ready to suit up outside. This is still the same bunch that couldnt catch and couldnt get open last year (or the year before...or before that, or before that...)Sorry, it may not be doom and gloom, but there isnt exactly a lot to be optimistic about right now. i know i asked for someone to give me some hope, but you're gonna have to bring it stronger than thatReplace 4 starters and a reserve RB...Andrews and Andrews take two of those spots, Demps and Celek the other...draft the RB complement and depth at OL and S.
Why all the doom and gloom?
AT OL, the Andrews signing seems a good one. Obviously, we still need at least one starter quality OT (or G if we move Herremans)
Celek is, at worst, a lateral move. With another year of experiance, he's probably an improvement over LJ Smith. We need another for depth, but this isn't a glaring need.
We need a COP (that's change of pace) RB and a Safety.
So our biggest real need is at OT...a position with at least 3 possible answers already on the team?
The eagles aren't that aggressive in FA because the holes really aren't that numerous, and some of those holes aren't half as big or glaring as some in here make them out to be. This team was inconsistant last year, but downright great at times. Blowing up the team is NOT the answer.
Take a deep breath guys....
All I know is that Herremanns, Justice and Dunlap are all natural LTs...
All I know is that Herremanns, Justice and Dunlap are all natural LTs...
what he said
Damn!

Damn!


And it underscores yet another reason to be optimistic rather then pessiistic. Although there are a few questions on O...this D should be BETTER, possibly a lot better. The line and the LB corps were/are YOUNG and were already good. Returning basicly intact with another year of experiance...they could be downright awesome.IN short BK...we may only need positive answers to half of your questions to compete deep in the playoffs...and answering half of them shouldn't be that hard.
Jones is a very solid player; for the life of me can't figure out how a player like him has lasted on the market this long. I am sure a lot of fans don't know him because of playing in the AFC and on a terrible Browns team, but he is a player.All I know is what I watch every week---and what I watch every week is a young, big,fast,hard hitting safety that plays in the box extremely well, is decent in pass coverage, and has a knack for the ball. If they get the deal done, this is an absolute upgrade over what Dawkins brought the last 2 years. Mikell + Jones could be a solid tandem for the next 3-4 years. Mikell moves to FS, Demps in the Considine role IMO. Hope it happens!