Brazil is a pretty big country. And soccer is absurdly popular there. But tall rangy guys who can jump out of the gym play basketball or volleyball in Brazil. Because those are sports that fit their skill set. The Brazilian team has a lot of very athletic players, but their best player is a guy who looks like he should be on the Bad News Bears, not the Chicago Bears.
I don't want to hijack the thread on WC draw day too much but to me it would come down to how much of what Neymar does was learned versus how much was he born with? I could very well be wrong and it's mostly the latter but with all the great athletes we produce it seems unlikely to me that we couldn't find at least a few world class players somewhere in there. And it would only take a few for us to move from a good team to a very good team.
The World Cup is six months away. There are no hijacks.
I'm sure it comes down to what Neymar learned at an early age. But the US does not lack soccer players who have played from an early age. We have plenty of them. And we're certainly no lacking in athleticism. Neymar went out as a kid with nothing but a ball and some other kids and just screwed around. By the time he was being "coached" things like controlling the ball were second nature to him.
I would bet the same is true of many of our best basketball players. They didn't become great ball handlers or shooters through AAU teams. They did by long hours by themselves with a basketball. But no matter how many hours Neymar put in, the things he does with the ball would have become much harder if he grew to be 6'4". Because 9 out of 10 players who are explosive off the dribble have a low center of gravity. Ronaldo is uncommonly tall for such a great dribbler. There's a reason why most world class midfielders are generally between 5'7" and 5'11" or so,
and it's not because tall guys don't like soccer.