The Commish
Footballguy
I don't see how the scholarship allowance has anything to do with it. If he didn't ever sign a NLI, he wouldn't have been bound, regardless of how many scholarship agreements he signed. He's not bound to a school until he signs that NLI regardless of the scholarship agreement. To me, the only thing signing these things does is guarantee a scholarship. You asked if I thought that was a huge advantage and I said I didn't because most weren't there for school. I did acknowledge there are a few this would be a benefit for.I think football comes first for 99% of all recruits. They are going to college for free based on football and most want to do well. The exception seems to be those that go (well, went, prior to Harbaugh) to Stanford.
The advantage isn't simply that they are guaranteed a scholarship. The advantage is that they aren't bound to a particular school.
For example, Florida St. Frosh LB Matthew Thomas did not want to go to Florida St. He wanted to go to Southern Cal. I'm pretty sure he was under the age of 18 on signing day, so he needed a parent to sign the NLI, too. His mom would not sign his NLI for Southern Cal. She told him he had to go to FSU. So, he signed an NLI with Florida St., grudgingly. A couple months later, he made a bunch of noise about wanting to get out of his NLI. He couldn't. There was no hardship. And, Florida St. refused to let him out of his NLI. Because of that, if he chose to go to Southern Cal anyway, he was going to lose a year of competition. He'd have three years to play three. He decided to remain at Florida St.
If Thomas had signed a scholarship agreement instead (or not signed an NLI at all), then he could have simply told Florida St. that he wasn't going there in May or June or whenever it was that he wanted out, contacted Southern Cal, asked if they had room, signed a scholarship agreement with them, and played last year at Southern Cal as he originally wanted.
Granted, it worked out for the best as a player since he saw PT before an injury and his team won a national title.
But, it's a huge advantage to a recruit to not be bound to a school lest you lose a year of competition if you change your mind. The NLI is a one-sided agreement that benefits ONLY the school. The scholarship agreement benefits the players and allows them the ability to go elsewhere should something happen between signing day and the start of fall camp in August.
To you slider, I think it's a big advantage for the school these athletes sign their first scholarship agreement with. When it's signed, the school has unlimited access to the student while everyone else trying to recruit him has to abide by the silly rules. Not saying the loophole should be closed, just that it exists and how dumb it's existence is. That's all