In 1QB I’d take Rice alone over the other side. Hurts is certainly an upgrade but it's much easier to find QB's in that format than pay this much. Way to sell high on some aging vets close to expiration.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (8 Viewers)
- Thread starter Gottabesweet
- Start date
In 1QB I’d take Rice alone over the other side. Hurts is certainly an upgrade but it's much easier to find QB's in that format than pay this much. Way to sell high on some aging vets close to expiration.
Andrews, not close. TEP FFPC makes it even more tilted IMO although the 3.06 is a nice pick in that format
Blick
Footballguy
I made another move with this team.
JT/Rice/Shakir/Gesicki
For
Bijan/Odunze/Shaheed/Elijah Moore
Overall I gave up
Hurts/JT/Evans/Conner/Whittington/Geskcki
For
Stroud/Bijan/Odunze/Shaheed/Elijah Moore
I think I did ok.
Last edited:
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
That seems awful light for Walker III, nice work!
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Has Walker really been that big of a deal? That 4.2 avg, with 3.7 last year (12 games), and one season just barely over 1000 yards, doesn’t scream stud to me. Plus Charbonnet isn’t going anywhere in 2025. I like that side because of the first also thrown in, not just focusing on Walker.
Gottabesweet
Footballguy
people still REALLY like Anthony Richardson apparently.
PPR 12 team league: DEEP benches
Team A gets: Anthony Richardson, Joshua Palmer, Malik Davis, Carson Steele, Cylde Edwards Helaire, and a 3rd, 4th, 5th in 2026
Team B gets: Drake Maye, DK Metcalf, R. Ali, W. Shipley, Tyler Goodson, Joe Milton, 1st in 2026 (late)
PPR 12 team league: DEEP benches
Team A gets: Anthony Richardson, Joshua Palmer, Malik Davis, Carson Steele, Cylde Edwards Helaire, and a 3rd, 4th, 5th in 2026
Team B gets: Drake Maye, DK Metcalf, R. Ali, W. Shipley, Tyler Goodson, Joe Milton, 1st in 2026 (late)
sheerterror
Footballguy
veto-able
Gatorade
Footballguy
The top three players in this deal all go to one team. Something is wrong there.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Id be crying like a little girl if I was in that league.
joey
Footballguy
Horrible trade.Id be crying like a little girl if I was in that league.
And throw in a 1st while you’re at it
ffmail4me
Footballguy
Those grade school kids have no chance at beating you. Congrats!
Boston
Footballguy
Is there any way you can get the Owner to explain the thinking behind this trade? It would be fascinating.
Gottabesweet
Footballguy
12 team PPR: 1QB 6 per TD, -2 INT
Team A: Gets Joe Burrow, Bucky Irving
Team B: Gets Kyler Murray, DK Metcalf, Michael Pittman , 3.1 (25th overall) 2025.
Team A: Gets Joe Burrow, Bucky Irving
Team B: Gets Kyler Murray, DK Metcalf, Michael Pittman , 3.1 (25th overall) 2025.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Team A and it isn’t close.
Boston
Footballguy
I don't understand the thinking on this one at all...two best players are Burrow and Irving by a good amount...Murray is not fun to own...DK's name is bigger than his fantasy production and Pittman is not in a great situation...there is more name than substance here...that pick should at least be a #1.
Wigglytuff's Gruff
Footballguy
Well that's just silly isn't it
Blick
Footballguy
Team B must be a contender.
Birdie048
Footballguy
Fixed
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Yeah, I get the joke considering the two trades before his post. I laughed.
roar_lions
Footballguy
A couple of recent trades in a 12 team, 1 QB, 1/2 PPR league
Team A receives Marvin Harrison, Jr
Team B receives 2025 picks 1.04 and 3.04
Team C receives Mike Evans
Team B receives 2025 pick 2.05 and 2026 round 2 pick
Team A receives Marvin Harrison, Jr
Team B receives 2025 picks 1.04 and 3.04
Team C receives Mike Evans
Team B receives 2025 pick 2.05 and 2026 round 2 pick
Blick
Footballguy
Players on both.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
That sure seems like a light return for Harrison after the owner most likely invested a top two pick last year on him. I am not super high on him, but it would be a no-brainer hold for me if that is what I was getting in return. Especially not knowing landing spots or players available at the four spot. Odd trade…
Boston
Footballguy
Harrison very easily...it is not a "star-studded" draft up top and the fact it isn't SF makes it that much worse...I don't understand the thinking at all on this one...on the other one I get wanting to move on from Evans but this isn't a trade you need to make in February...especially since only one of those picks is in 2025.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
I think the Cardinals need to quit thinking of Harrison as a deep threat and start viewing him as a true alpha WR where he's used all over the field. Throw more 5-8 yard outs and see what he does. I don't think the Cardinals did a very good job in how they used Harrison. This is more a reflection of the Cardinals than Marvin Harrison Jr. Just my opinion.
So likely Tet or RB3 along with rookie 28 for Marvin? If a team is super stacked with young WR's and dying at RB I can see the appeal/temptation but give me Marvin.
Seems about right, really think it's one of those team makeup situations that I can see it making sense for both sides
Is it the same team B in both trades? If so I'm guessing he's what I described above, deep at WR and hurting for RB.
roar_lions
Footballguy
Team B is the same in both trades. Unfortunately for them MHJ and Evans were the best WRs they had while also being weak at RB. Justice Hill was their highest scoring RB last year and the highest scoring WR they have left is Calvin Austin III. Looks like they're rebuilding but in that situation I would have kept MHJ.
Yikes, that's more desperate at RB then I could have imagined but with also being weak at WR I agree with you, I'd have looked longer term and kept MHJ as central part of my rebuild.
Do like the Evans trade for them however.
joey
Footballguy
This
ghostguy123
Footballguy
FFPC single QB
Breece Hall
for
picks 1.03 and 2.03
Breece Hall
for
picks 1.03 and 2.03
rockaction
Footballguy
Huh. That's a free pick 2.03 according to KeepTradeCut.
Somehow I think it's even.
eighsse2
Footballguy
Feels pretty close to me as well.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
People who rely on KTC to make their trades are probably making less trades. It still puts too much weight on quantity.
rockaction
Footballguy
It's a ballpark thing. I don't think they're really in the ballpark with this one and that it's not lopsided but even. People love Hampton, though, so who am I?
eighsse2
Footballguy
Definitely this. Put in any sort of 3-mediums-for-1-big trade, they adjust the 1-big side up, but you'll find they don't adjust enough. I just look at what KTC says, and boost the adjustment in my head for my own purposes. And like rock said, it's a ballpark thing. No one considering a trade should put it in on KTC, see that they're getting 12,000 for 11,000, and be instantly convinced they should take it. But I think it makes for a good piece of evidence and/or sanity check if you can adjust it some for your league specifications and preferences.
sheerterror
Footballguy
Interesting. I've been thinking about putting Breece out there in a league of the same format. Sitting on Bucky, Brown and Rhamondre behind him, but have 1.1 and 4 2nd rounders.
As a Hall owner, I think I keep him over 1.3 and 2.3 pre NFL draft. I'd want 1.2 for him so I could get WR1 or RB2 in this draft, which I think is fair given that he's probably still in that 2nd tier of dynasty RBs.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
Ok, let's assume you get the 1.2 and prefer the RB2 over Tet McMillan. My question to you is why hope to draft someone that is as good as a young Breece Hall? He's only 23 years old. Kind of like the bird in the hand old saying.
sheerterror
Footballguy
For my specific team, I wouldn't do it as I'm looking to get a good young WR for him (BTj, London type). I should have prefaced my "I'd want 1.2" sentence with "In general," but in my specific case I will be trying to move him differently.
As for Breece himself, I'm an owner and a Jet fan. I love the guy and think he's the most talented RB we've had maybe ever (no disrespect to Curtis Martin) but the questions about team situation/QB as well as a bit of a decline in running efficiency last year MIGHT have SOME owners preferring to reset their RB core with rookie RB2 who will have 3 years less NFL wear and tear (as well as a Hall ACL injury). And given the overall strength of this RB class, RB2 going to the right situation might vault them right there with Breece in start up ADP anyway.
Williams easy. After Jeanty, this draft has a lot of guys I like but no studs. 1.7 to 1.11 is not killing me. Robinson value only going down. Give me Jameson
Olave's a hard guy to value, but I'd take the Jacobs side, if I were in a rebuild maybe I'd take a chance on the Olave side but think could do a little better than that, not seeing a huge jump from 12 to 8 in TE premium Superflex.
steelcityman
Footballguy
Am I goofy to turn down pick 2.07 for the likes of Flowers, or Olave, or Addison? I have all 3, plus Puca, and McMillan and Coleman and McCaffery.
Every trade chart I look at says any of the 3 are worth more than 2.07.
I have a title and a 3rd place finish with this team in the last 2 years, its getting kind of boring. Want to change some things in a league that barely trades, but also dont want to get taken advantage of either.
Every trade chart I look at says any of the 3 are worth more than 2.07.
I have a title and a 3rd place finish with this team in the last 2 years, its getting kind of boring. Want to change some things in a league that barely trades, but also dont want to get taken advantage of either.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
The players you listed have much greater value than the 2.07.
sheerterror
Footballguy
All 3 are worth soundly more than 2.7, especially in a draft class that doesn't seem particularly deep at WR.
Boston
Footballguy
2.7 is not even close.
JohnnyU
Footballguy
I wouldn't think one would need confirmation on that. Isn't it obvious? I wouldn't need some trade calculator to tell me that.
