What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (25 Viewers)

16 team SF PPR IDP
50 man rosters, 10 taxi,

I gave: $101 FAAB dollars (of $1000)
I rec’d: Scotty Miller

No, it’s not exciting, but the schedule hosed me for week 13 WR. I probably coulda waited & added some as yet to be known FA asset, but dude was clearing roster space & put a bunch of dudes on the block. We got to talking

But if Miller was on the FA list, I would probably bid $101 on him. Whatever - it’s fake $. Hopefully I get 5-10 points out of Miller in week 13. :shrug:
 
16 team SF PPR IDP
50 man rosters, 10 taxi,

I gave: $101 FAAB dollars (of $1000)
I rec’d: Scotty Miller

No, it’s not exciting, but the schedule hosed me for week 13 WR. I probably coulda waited & added some as yet to be known FA asset, but dude was clearing roster space & put a bunch of dudes on the block. We got to talking

But if Miller was on the FA list, I would probably bid $101 on him. Whatever - it’s fake $. Hopefully I get 5-10 points out of Miller in week 13. :shrug:

Sorry dude, this is terrible process. There’s just zero reason to trade for a week 13 spot start in May. There’s a million things that can happen between now and then and none of them are good. The odds of this playing out in your favor are extremely slim and the payoff is hoping to get 5-10 points? Very bad.
 
Sorry dude, this is terrible process. There’s just zero reason to trade for a week 13 spot start in May. There’s a million things that can happen between now and then and none of them are good. The odds of this playing out in your favor are extremely slim and the payoff is hoping to get 5-10 points? Very bad.
I was bored. :lol:

Cmon - it’s not an earth shattering deal. Basically free, I have the roster space, and it lays the groundwork for future trades with this dude.

And I kinda like Scotty Miller in ATL. ;)
 
Well, I went on a spending spree with some draft capital….
12 Team 1QB 0.5 PPR (TE-P 1.0 PPR) Full rebuild
1-4 RB / 2-6 WR / 1-4 TE
I had 10 picks for 2023 & 8 in 2024 at end of 2022 season

Today’s activity …

I traded away 2024 late 1st (2021 Champ & lost finals 2022)
I received Juju Smith-Schuster NEP WR & pick 2.02 (selected NOS RB Kendre Miller)

I also traded 2.08 away for Den WR Courtland Sutton
(I like his 2024 prospects better than 2023)

The first one is fine. Maybe even good. JuJu will soak up targets and maybe you can flip him in season. Kendre is a nice prospect, like his game and should pay off with a bit of patience on your part. I say this knowing very little about 2024 draft prospects (don’t watch much college, play catch-up on rookies each off-season which I think actually helps because I don’t get attached, but I digress lol) but the fact I haven’t seen any major hype like 2020 for example is enough to let me know the value is fine.

I don’t like the 2nd one at all based on who has been available at 2.08 in my drafts…especially if you’re rebuilding. Hope it works out for you though.
 
Last edited:
Sorry dude, this is terrible process. There’s just zero reason to trade for a week 13 spot start in May. There’s a million things that can happen between now and then and none of them are good. The odds of this playing out in your favor are extremely slim and the payoff is hoping to get 5-10 points? Very bad.
I was bored. :lol:

Cmon - it’s not an earth shattering deal. Basically free, I have the roster space, and it lays the groundwork for future trades with this dude.

And I kinda like Scotty Miller in ATL. ;)

I mean it as constructive criticism. Yes it’s a small deal and no it won’t hurt much when it inevitably goes bad lol. But remember what Joey Knish taught Mike McDermott…never give anything away.

If your initial comment was “I really like Scotty” then meh, ok, but you specifically made it about filling a bye week so I must take you at your word. That’s not personal preference on a player…that’s bad process my man.
 
Sorry dude, this is terrible process. There’s just zero reason to trade for a week 13 spot start in May. There’s a million things that can happen between now and then and none of them are good. The odds of this playing out in your favor are extremely slim and the payoff is hoping to get 5-10 points? Very bad.
I was bored. :lol:

Cmon - it’s not an earth shattering deal. Basically free, I have the roster space, and it lays the groundwork for future trades with this dude.

And I kinda like Scotty Miller in ATL. ;)

I mean it as constructive criticism. Yes it’s a small deal and no it won’t hurt much when it inevitably goes bad lol. But remember what Joey Knish taught Mike McDermott…never give anything away.

If your initial comment was “I really like Scotty” then meh, ok, but you specifically made it about filling a bye week so I must take you at your word. That’s not personal preference on a player…that’s bad process my man.
I save my good processes for big trades.
:hifive:

On a more serious note, it’s a 16-team league with 60 players rostered by every team. This time of year it’s 75

75 x 16 = 1200 players rostered.

Scott Miller is worth $100 FAAB in that format on the off-chance he’s the slot WR in ATL. There’s a very tiny amount of upside here.
:shrug:

After cut-downs I’ll scoop up some odds and ends with some of my remaining bankroll and let the crap shoot begin.
 
Sorry dude, this is terrible process. There’s just zero reason to trade for a week 13 spot start in May. There’s a million things that can happen between now and then and none of them are good. The odds of this playing out in your favor are extremely slim and the payoff is hoping to get 5-10 points? Very bad.
I was bored. :lol:

Cmon - it’s not an earth shattering deal. Basically free, I have the roster space, and it lays the groundwork for future trades with this dude.

And I kinda like Scotty Miller in ATL. ;)

I mean it as constructive criticism. Yes it’s a small deal and no it won’t hurt much when it inevitably goes bad lol. But remember what Joey Knish taught Mike McDermott…never give anything away.

If your initial comment was “I really like Scotty” then meh, ok, but you specifically made it about filling a bye week so I must take you at your word. That’s not personal preference on a player…that’s bad process my man.
I save my good processes for big trades.
:hifive:

On a more serious note, it’s a 16-team league with 60 players rostered by every team. This time of year it’s 75

75 x 16 = 1200 players rostered.

Scott Miller is worth $100 FAAB in that format on the off-chance he’s the slot WR in ATL. There’s a very tiny amount of upside here.
:shrug:

After cut-downs I’ll scoop up some odds and ends with some of my remaining bankroll and let the crap shoot begin.

If this was your explanation when you posted the trade I woulda just kept scrolling…but you said differently :coffee:
 
If this was your explanation when you posted the trade I woulda just kept scrolling…but you said differently :coffee:
Just saying the reason I needed a WR.

I didn’t think I needed to write a novel about a Scott Miller trade.

I respect the gravity with which you’re handling this trade. 😂

Haha I know I know but every trade matters! No but really…not trying to give you a hard time, just my honest feedback.

I made a really dumb trade once years ago but the lesson was valuable. Sent Kirk Cousins for a bye week fill in. Problem was, I wasn’t looking at details and dealt him to my weekly opponent whose QB was on bye and that ended up costing me the matchup and a bye week at the end of the season. I got bounced in the first round. Would have finished 2nd place in that format if I had the bye which was $2500. So that insignificant deal ended up being very expensive.

Anywho
 
If this was your explanation when you posted the trade I woulda just kept scrolling…but you said differently :coffee:
Just saying the reason I needed a WR.

I didn’t think I needed to write a novel about a Scott Miller trade.

I respect the gravity with which you’re handling this trade. 😂

Haha I know I know but every trade matters! No but really…not trying to give you a hard time, just my honest feedback.

I made a really dumb trade once years ago but the lesson was valuable. Sent Kirk Cousins for a bye week fill in. Problem was, I wasn’t looking at details and dealt him to my weekly opponent whose QB was on bye and that ended up costing me the matchup and a bye week at the end of the season. I got bounced in the first round. Would have finished 2nd place in that format if I had the bye which was $2500. So that insignificant deal ended up being very expensive.

Anywho
“A Scotty Miller trade killed my whole family!”
:rant:
 
Gave: A Richardson (drafted him at 1.05, 1qb ppr league)
Got: E Moore

I was pretty "mobile qb rich" (LJax, Fields, Richardson,) and could always use WR. I took Richardson because I figured he'd be a better value than the "3rd best" rb or wr that was available at 5. I don't think anyone else I could have picked at 5 gets me Moore, so I'm happy.
 
Gave: A Richardson (drafted him at 1.05, 1qb ppr league)
Got: E Moore

I was pretty "mobile qb rich" (LJax, Fields, Richardson,) and could always use WR. I took Richardson because I figured he'd be a better value than the "3rd best" rb or wr that was available at 5. I don't think anyone else I could have picked at 5 gets me Moore, so I'm happy.
Ouch. Elijah Moore's trade value isn't a first round pick. Moore's value is a 2nd round or 2nd round bump. Even in a start 1qb league you're going to regret this one most likely, but I could be wrong obviously. Good luck.
 
Gave: A Richardson (drafted him at 1.05, 1qb ppr league)
Got: E Moore

I was pretty "mobile qb rich" (LJax, Fields, Richardson,) and could always use WR. I took Richardson because I figured he'd be a better value than the "3rd best" rb or wr that was available at 5. I don't think anyone else I could have picked at 5 gets me Moore, so I'm happy.
are you talking Elijah Moore? Wow, if so and if I had Moore and got this offer from someone, I am accepting it QUICKLY.
 
heh, after I posted that I read up on Moore in this thread, and can see the love is definitely not there. So these comments don't surprise me (and could be spot on). I'm a Jet fan so I am likely clouded by that - I know how good he looked his rookie year, and am giving him a pass for 22. I truly feel if he were somehow a draftable FA in this draft, I'd have grabbed him at 1.05 without thinking about it. But yea, we'll see.
 
heh, after I posted that I read up on Moore in this thread, and can see the love is definitely not there. So these comments don't surprise me (and could be spot on). I'm a Jet fan so I am likely clouded by that - I know how good he looked his rookie year, and am giving him a pass for 22. I truly feel if he were somehow a draftable FA in this draft, I'd have grabbed him at 1.05 without thinking about it. But yea, we'll see.
I believe you could have got him for a 2nd round pick easily. Hell, some might trade him for a 3rd.
 
Gave: A Richardson (drafted him at 1.05, 1qb ppr league)
Got: E Moore

I was pretty "mobile qb rich" (LJax, Fields, Richardson,) and could always use WR. I took Richardson because I figured he'd be a better value than the "3rd best" rb or wr that was available at 5. I don't think anyone else I could have picked at 5 gets me Moore, so I'm happy.
Value is not on your side but fantasy players tend to over-react to a bad year and if we are just isolating this to comping him vs rookie WR's I'd only take JSN and Addison over him.
 
heh, after I posted that I read up on Moore in this thread, and can see the love is definitely not there. So these comments don't surprise me (and could be spot on). I'm a Jet fan so I am likely clouded by that - I know how good he looked his rookie year, and am giving him a pass for 22. I truly feel if he were somehow a draftable FA in this draft, I'd have grabbed him at 1.05 without thinking about it. But yea, we'll see.
I believe you could have got him for a 2nd round pick easily. Hell, some might trade him for a 3rd.
In FFPC 1 QB rookie drafts, he wasn't available in a lot of leagues but he was drafted 13 times with an ADP of 2.07 and a high of 1.12
 
Gave: A Richardson (drafted him at 1.05, 1qb ppr league)
Got: E Moore

I was pretty "mobile qb rich" (LJax, Fields, Richardson,) and could always use WR. I took Richardson because I figured he'd be a better value than the "3rd best" rb or wr that was available at 5. I don't think anyone else I could have picked at 5 gets me Moore, so I'm happy.
Value is not on your side but fantasy players tend to over-react to a bad year and if we are just isolating this to comping him vs rookie WR's I'd only take JSN and Addison over him.

I have 5 rookies that I would clearly take over Moore... Smith-Njigba, Addison, Johnston, Flowers, Mingo. And overall, I have Moore barely in the top 50 WRs.
 
heh, after I posted that I read up on Moore in this thread, and can see the love is definitely not there. So these comments don't surprise me (and could be spot on). I'm a Jet fan so I am likely clouded by that - I know how good he looked his rookie year, and am giving him a pass for 22. I truly feel if he were somehow a draftable FA in this draft, I'd have grabbed him at 1.05 without thinking about it. But yea, we'll see.
I believe you could have got him for a 2nd round pick easily. Hell, some might trade him for a 3rd.
In FFPC 1 QB rookie drafts, he wasn't available in a lot of leagues but he was drafted 13 times with an ADP of 2.07 and a high of 1.12
I never even checked his ADP but sounds about right. I offered seconds for him in a bunch of leagues, all after cuts, and could not get an accept but was not surprised since the earliest second I had to offer was 2.4.
 
heh, after I posted that I read up on Moore in this thread, and can see the love is definitely not there. So these comments don't surprise me (and could be spot on). I'm a Jet fan so I am likely clouded by that - I know how good he looked his rookie year, and am giving him a pass for 22. I truly feel if he were somehow a draftable FA in this draft, I'd have grabbed him at 1.05 without thinking about it. But yea, we'll see.
I believe you could have got him for a 2nd round pick easily. Hell, some might trade him for a 3rd.
In FFPC 1 QB rookie drafts, he wasn't available in a lot of leagues but he was drafted 13 times with an ADP of 2.07 and a high of 1.12
I never even checked his ADP but sounds about right. I offered seconds for him in a bunch of leagues, all after cuts, and could not get an accept but was not surprised since the earliest second I had to offer was 2.4.

It was earlier in this thread, but I had posted that during an FFPC rookie superflex draft, I traded the 3.05 and Elijah Moore for a '24 R2 that should be mid-round. (That team took Jalin Hyatt.) I like Moore, but my team isn't going anywhere this season, and it's a best-ball dynasty league, so I also don't mind giving up points this season for a better 2024 rookie draft slot.

Kinda funny, but during Moore's rookie season, the team that had Moore also had an injured CMC. I traded Chuba Hubbard to him straight up for Moore. I think he ended up cutting Hubbard after the season. I was ridin' high! Of course, then Moore's value plummeted too. I just traded Moore back to that same team.
 
12 team 0.5 ppr SF

gave
Alec Pierce and Rashaad Penny

got
Diontae Johnson
No telling what A Pierce will be with A Rich @ QB and Penny as Philly RB with Swift RBBC (and JHurts getting GL carries).
I think Diontae will no have another >100 Target ZERO TD season ... But it feels like a gamble on both sides and Diontae less risk.
Lean DJ but not overwhelming ...
 
12 team SF; draft starts in a few days.
Was offered Andrews for my 1.12. Didn’t love it as I’m content to start Waller, Chig (I’m big on Chig) or Dulcich. Andrews is an upgrade for sure.
Countered asking for Metcalf, he accepted rather quickly.

So 1.12 for Metcalf ppr.
I would do that every day and twice on Sunday. I like the first deal more and would have accepted Andrews for the 1.12.
Yeah, I can understand that. I probably feel more confident in my TEs than I should but I don’t feel like the upgrade for 23 from Waller to Andrews is large enough. But I’m quite happy to upgrade from Mike Evans to Metcalf as my WR3.
I'm not warm and fuzzy about Waller. I saw a big decline last year when on the field and he is 30 now. He's a sell IMO.
Decided you might be right. So dealt the 2.06 and Dulcich for Andrews. (SF)
So now the lineup is
Carr, Watson
Barkley, Henry, Ekeler, K Walker
Kupp, Metcalf, G Wilson
Andrews
K and IDPs are solid enough.
 
12 tm, FFPC, one QB, bestball

Gave: Tyreke Hill
Got: Davante Adams, Mike Evans
---------------------------
Tyreke has the best situation, but that can quickly change. I like my side by a decent amount
This is a tough one as I'm scared of Mike Evans value this year so think I would have wanted a different asset than that. Adams and Hill aren't that far off and Hill already said he doesn't plan on playing after this contract and wasn't near as good when Tua was hurt. I could see both sides for sure but in Best Ball I might side with Hill over Adams but Evans has some value so you probably got the upside and don't have to worry about starting Evans when he gets you nothing due to format. Probably a good move overall.
I'm less concerned about Evans in bestball
Totally agreed. I play best ball but only in leagues where you can't trade, no waivers, and no free agents. It is just a draft so hard to value. Like I said, not having to worry about the weeks where he has 2 catches for 25 yards definitely helps. A good move in that league format. Think I might slightly lean Hill in regular leagues but don't see a problem with either side.
 
16 team SF PPR IDP
50 man rosters, 10 taxi,

I gave: $101 FAAB dollars (of $1000)
I rec’d: Scotty Miller

No, it’s not exciting, but the schedule hosed me for week 13 WR. I probably coulda waited & added some as yet to be known FA asset, but dude was clearing roster space & put a bunch of dudes on the block. We got to talking

But if Miller was on the FA list, I would probably bid $101 on him. Whatever - it’s fake $. Hopefully I get 5-10 points out of Miller in week 13. :shrug:
Damn....50 man rosters on 16 teams. Holy crap. I thought our 22 roster, 2 IR, and up to 15 taxi for 2 years was decent size in 12 teams. That is nutso. You didn't pay much so no biggie but I think I'd have waited to make any more for week 13. Who knows, you may make a trade that gets you a regular WR before then, or may draft someone that could play, or Miller could get cut, or hurt, or a ton of other stuff. I'd have held off but it doesn't hurt either.
 
Gave: A Richardson (drafted him at 1.05, 1qb ppr league)
Got: E Moore

I was pretty "mobile qb rich" (LJax, Fields, Richardson,) and could always use WR. I took Richardson because I figured he'd be a better value than the "3rd best" rb or wr that was available at 5. I don't think anyone else I could have picked at 5 gets me Moore, so I'm happy.
1.05 is too high for A-Rich in 1 QB leagues and Moore isn't worth that pick. Even if you took A-Rich, you might as well hold him until his value is at his peak and you could have done better than this. Plus, Moore is on the field with Cooper as the easy #1. Then they have Schwartz, DPJ, and David Bell that they have spend 3rd rounders on in recent history so Moore may not be a great. I would want Addison, QJ, or Flowers all day over him. It isn't even close.
 
14 team 1.5 TE PPR 1 QB (not my trade)

DK Metcalf
for
1.12
2024 2nd
I know everyone is going to post Metcalf and it isn’t close, but it depends on the team makeup. Some could argue for Mayer, LaPorta, Bryce Young, Miller and of course the 2nd. All things being equal, Metcalf of course.
 
14 team 1.5 TE PPR 1 QB (not my trade)

DK Metcalf
for
1.12
2024 2nd
I know everyone is going to post Metcalf and it isn’t close, but it depends on the team makeup. Some could argue for Mayer, LaPorta, Bryce Young, Miller and of course the 2nd. All things being equal, Metcalf of course.
It might be close in a Superflex draft. 14 tm, start one QB? No thanks. Metcalf and it isn't close!
 
12 Team 1 QB PPR / Not involved

Team A - competitive: Gave up 2024 1st (likely Top 4), 2024 2nd (late) & 2024 2nd (top 4)
Team B - starting rebuild effort - Gave up DK Metcalf

Team B also put A Jones, Njoku & Terry McLaurin on the block ...
 
Same league as above -12 Team 1 QB

I gave up 2024 1st & 3rd
I received Was WR Terry McLaurin, 3.09 & 2024 2nd

My 1st could be anywhere, 4-9 likely but start 2-6 WR league WR depth is key. His 2nd could be 7-10 range
While I like Scary Terry, QB Howell(??) is a question. Only need him to be “average QB 12-15 range” for Terry to be of value
 
14 team 1.5 TE PPR 1 QB (not my trade)

DK Metcalf
for
1.12
2024 2nd
I know everyone is going to post Metcalf and it isn’t close, but it depends on the team makeup. Some could argue for Mayer, LaPorta, Bryce Young, Miller and of course the 2nd. All things being equal, Metcalf of course.
I disagree. Value is value. I don’t see one reason why someone would give up Metcalf for this.

I don’t understand how team make up plays into it. A rebuild should keep Metcalf. A contender shouldn’t wait for the points. I don’t get it.
 
Sutton is what he is at this point. To expect anything different is insanity. I wouldn't touch him in any format
I was targeting him for 2024. I expect him to be on a new team and value increase... since the WR Draft class was so thin, the potential he is moved looks promising.

Just for the comedy of it all... I traded away Sutton last year for 2023 2.03 & 2.08 and 2022 2.03 pick (Alec Pierce) . I traded the the 2.08 back for him... so net value was Mayer & Pierce for free
 
Same league as above -12 Team 1 QB

I gave up 2024 1st & 3rd
I received Was WR Terry McLaurin, 3.09 & 2024 2nd

My 1st could be anywhere, 4-9 likely but start 2-6 WR league WR depth is key. His 2nd could be 7-10 range
While I like Scary Terry, QB Howell(??) is a question. Only need him to be “average QB 12-15 range” for Terry to be of value
I really like this deal for you. Seems like a great price for McLaurin.
 
12 Team SuperFlex

Team A gives
Bryce Young, 24 2nd (mid likely)

Team B gives

Trey Lance, Zach Evans, 24 1st (mid likely)
 
12 Team 1 QB PPR / Not involved

Team A - competitive: Gave up 2024 1st (likely Top 4), 2024 2nd (late) & 2024 2nd (top 4)
Team B - starting rebuild effort - Gave up DK Metcalf

Team B also put A Jones, Njoku & Terry McLaurin on the block ...
I think I prefer the picks side of this, especially if the 24 1st and 2nd are likely top 4.

I tend to be a bit lower on Metcalf than most. I just worry about that QB situation. Was that the real Geno last year? If not, they seem like they could be stuck drafting too low to address the position with confidence.
 
14 team 1.5 TE PPR 1 QB (not my trade)

DK Metcalf
for
1.12
2024 2nd
I get this is TEP and every team has different needs but this feels like selling very low on a big time fantasy asset at WR who isn't old. No way I make this trade. I could get behind it more if that 24 pick was a 1st but a 2nd that you don't know where it is seems dangerously low and losing many trades like this would seriously harm your dynasty team.
 
12 Team 1 QB PPR / Not involved

Team A - competitive: Gave up 2024 1st (likely Top 4), 2024 2nd (late) & 2024 2nd (top 4)
Team B - starting rebuild effort - Gave up DK Metcalf

Team B also put A Jones, Njoku & Terry McLaurin on the block ...
As long as those picks end up in the top 4 of the round next year, this is much better value than the other DK deal above. Still think DK is a good rebuild piece but this is decent value and if that 24 1st ends up being Marvin Harrison Jr. then you made out really well.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top