Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (18 Viewers)
- Thread starter Gottabesweet
- Start date
JohnnyU
Footballguy
smbkrypt24
Footballguy
12 team PPR. Start 1 QB:
Gave: Goff, 2.06, 2.07, 2.10
Received: Burrow
I overpaid, but I had 11 draft picks so I had to consolidate somewhere. It makes me feel better about dropping some depth QBs now that I have a stud in Burrow. I still have a few too many picks in this short bench league, but at least they are 3rds (1.01-1.04, 2.03, 3.03, 3.06, 3.08).
Gave: Goff, 2.06, 2.07, 2.10
Received: Burrow
I overpaid, but I had 11 draft picks so I had to consolidate somewhere. It makes me feel better about dropping some depth QBs now that I have a stud in Burrow. I still have a few too many picks in this short bench league, but at least they are 3rds (1.01-1.04, 2.03, 3.03, 3.06, 3.08).
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
With short benches and an abundance of picks it is not a bad move imo. You improved a position on paper and got a few years younger. If Burrow can stay healthy he should be a top QB.
ghostguy123
Footballguy
Yes these are startup picks. An obvious distinction, lol.
Anyway, now the 3.10 was traded for 6.05 and a future 1st (could obviously be anywhere).
Pick 10 was Laporta
So in all, pick 1.01 is now Laporta, pick 6.05 (basically rookie pick 9 or decent vet), and a future 1st, 2nd, and 3rd
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Start 1 QB it’s an overpay, but it’s one I’d make to get younger/better at QB.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
12 Team SF QB, 2RB, 3WR, TE, 3FLex, SF
Entered the season in complete rebuild mode needing QB help badly with Goff and Howell as my starters
Gave: 1.06, 1.12
Got 1.02
Traded up to put myself in position to get Caleb if he fell and MHJ if he didn't with the assumption that JJM would be there at 1.07.
1.02 - drafted MHJ. Definitely went back and forth between him and Daniels at this point, but (stubbornly) stuck to my original plan
(Daniels, Maye and JJM all went before 1.07)
1.07 Drafted Odunze with the idea that I could at least pull Bo Nix in the early 2nd.
(nope, drafted 1 pick in front of me)
Pivoted and made the following trade:
Gave: MHJ
Got: Nabers, Levis, and 3.05
I had MHJ and Nabers as rough equivalents predraft and trading down from MHJ to get a 2nd year starting QB seemed like a reasonable thing to do.
Net - Gave: 1.06, 1.07, 1.12 Got: Nabers, Levis, Odunze, 3.05
Trying to follow my own rebuild advice by starting with QB and WR then filling out TE, and Finally RB. I have 2 25 1sts and 2 25 2nds to work with in a draft that is supposed to be RB heavy. We shall see...
TL/DR: Trying to make lemonade out of lemons when you're draft goes exactly the way you don't want it to.
Entered the season in complete rebuild mode needing QB help badly with Goff and Howell as my starters
Gave: 1.06, 1.12
Got 1.02
Traded up to put myself in position to get Caleb if he fell and MHJ if he didn't with the assumption that JJM would be there at 1.07.
1.02 - drafted MHJ. Definitely went back and forth between him and Daniels at this point, but (stubbornly) stuck to my original plan
(Daniels, Maye and JJM all went before 1.07)
1.07 Drafted Odunze with the idea that I could at least pull Bo Nix in the early 2nd.
(nope, drafted 1 pick in front of me)
Pivoted and made the following trade:
Gave: MHJ
Got: Nabers, Levis, and 3.05
I had MHJ and Nabers as rough equivalents predraft and trading down from MHJ to get a 2nd year starting QB seemed like a reasonable thing to do.
Net - Gave: 1.06, 1.07, 1.12 Got: Nabers, Levis, Odunze, 3.05
Trying to follow my own rebuild advice by starting with QB and WR then filling out TE, and Finally RB. I have 2 25 1sts and 2 25 2nds to work with in a draft that is supposed to be RB heavy. We shall see...
TL/DR: Trying to make lemonade out of lemons when you're draft goes exactly the way you don't want it to.
smbkrypt24
Footballguy
Superflex. Large rosters.
Sent: 2.06
Received Kupp
I am finally looking to compete. This season added J Jefferson and now Kupp so I should be one of the top teams.
Sent: 2.06
Received Kupp
I am finally looking to compete. This season added J Jefferson and now Kupp so I should be one of the top teams.
Birdie048
Footballguy
I like the overall effect but didn’t you all get a 2025 1st in the “net return”?
Also who was available at 1.06 & 1.07?
You indicated 4 QBs went before 1.07?
So MHJ & Nabers were only non-QB selected?? Ouch!
Good recovery on the unexpected draft!
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
That’s a good price for Kupp’s upside. He could always surprise with a healthy top 15 season. Or at least a half-season of good games. Regardless, it’s worth a mid-2nd to find out.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Didn't get a 25 1st in this deal. Already have mine and a likely mid to high 25 1st in the bank.
Our draft went:
Caleb
Mhj
Daniels
JJM
Nabers
Maye
Odunze
I should have anticipated the QB needy teams reaching higher in the draft to take JJM and Maye. I think I get hyperfocused on ADP and lose sight that teams often draft for need. It's something I need to work on for sure.
NE_REVIVAL
Footballguy
FFPC 1qb - had 29 players after the draft and did some consolidating
Gave
Freiermuth,Pat
Ferguson, Jake
Tracy, Tyrone
Got
Kincaid, Dalton
2nd deal with same owner
Gave
Kirk, Christian
McConkey, Ladd
Got
London, Drake
WRs include
Nacua, London, Metcalf, Waddle, Nico, Rashee Rice
Ja'Lynn Polk, Roman Wilson and Marvin Mims (haven't given up on Mims yet!)
TEs include
Dalton Kincaid, Evan Engram
I like the guys I traded, but short roster is tuff and I don't think I have Kincaid or London on any of my other teams so there's that.
Gave
Freiermuth,Pat
Ferguson, Jake
Tracy, Tyrone
Got
Kincaid, Dalton
2nd deal with same owner
Gave
Kirk, Christian
McConkey, Ladd
Got
London, Drake
WRs include
Nacua, London, Metcalf, Waddle, Nico, Rashee Rice
Ja'Lynn Polk, Roman Wilson and Marvin Mims (haven't given up on Mims yet!)
TEs include
Dalton Kincaid, Evan Engram
I like the guys I traded, but short roster is tuff and I don't think I have Kincaid or London on any of my other teams so there's that.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Both of these are downright abusive. I can see why you went back to the well after the 1st one.
How does that package net you Kincaid?
And how do McConkey + Kirk possibly add up to London?
I’m mystified. Congratulations on identifying the sucker in your league.
candian fantasy guy
Footballguy
QB’s are really hard to acquire in SF. I took Daniels over MHJ @ 1.02 due to the fact of not being able to trade out of that spot. Nobody was willing to pay for it.
QB’s in these particular leagues are very difficult to acquire.
NE_REVIVAL
Footballguy
I think Freirmuth and Fergy for Kincaid is pretty close, Fergy finished ahead of Kincaid last yr and could again this year. He offered Kincaid out of the blue and I accepted and he offered london unsolicited as well. He is a new and very aggressive owner.Both of these are downright abusive. I can see why you went back to the well after the 1st one.
How does that package net you Kincaid?
And how do McConkey + Kirk possibly add up to London?
I’m mystified. Congratulations on identifying the sucker in your league.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Was gonna post the exact same thing. I offered 2x 1sts for Wilson and was rejected with no counter.
Nice pull.
Seems equitable to me.
Wilson over the 1.4 but not as much as I’d have the 1.6 over Evans.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Yeah, I don't see it as too imbalanced - I've just found that Wilson shareholders have unreasonably high demands for him in trade talks.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Generally speaking, in any 2:1 or 3:1 trade, the team getting the 1 is winning the trade.I think Freirmuth and Fergy for Kincaid is pretty close, Fergy finished ahead of Kincaid last yr and could again this year. He offered Kincaid out of the blue and I accepted and he offered london unsolicited as well. He is a new and very aggressive owner.Both of these are downright abusive. I can see why you went back to the well after the 1st one.
How does that package net you Kincaid?
And how do McConkey + Kirk possibly add up to London?
I’m mystified. Congratulations on identifying the sucker in your league.
IMO you won both of these pretty convincingly. Especially the 2nd.
I agree that the 1st is closer, but I still think Kincaid is significantly more valuable. Mouth might or might not finally break out - and while Ferguson outscored Kincaid, that was also Kincaid's rookie season and he is headed into 2024 looking like the #1 receiving target on that team. He could have a Kelce-like season.
I agree with you and especially the two for one on smaller rosters though I actually though the second trade was closer then the first.Generally speaking, in any 2:1 or 3:1 trade, the team getting the 1 is winning the trade.I think Freirmuth and Fergy for Kincaid is pretty close, Fergy finished ahead of Kincaid last yr and could again this year. He offered Kincaid out of the blue and I accepted and he offered london unsolicited as well. He is a new and very aggressive owner.Both of these are downright abusive. I can see why you went back to the well after the 1st one.
How does that package net you Kincaid?
And how do McConkey + Kirk possibly add up to London?
I’m mystified. Congratulations on identifying the sucker in your league.
IMO you won both of these pretty convincingly. Especially the 2nd.
I agree that the 1st is closer, but I still think Kincaid is significantly more valuable. Mouth might or might not finally break out - and while Ferguson outscored Kincaid, that was also Kincaid's rookie season and he is headed into 2024 looking like the #1 receiving target on that team. He could have a Kelce-like season.
Blick
Footballguy
If you drop Evans out of this I think its much closer than with him in.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Agreed.
I am Wilson shareholder fwiw and like I said I'd take him over the 1.4 but if I could for instance turn Evans into Brian Thomas I'd be ok turning Wilson into Bowers or Odunze. Not to say it's a slam dunk either way, just seems equitable to me.
As a Wilson owner I'd slam dunk accept someone offering me 4 and 6 for him.
He's a proven really good NFL player, he's not a proven elite fantasy producer, has been the lowest end WR2 range both of his seasons. Now TD's can be flukey and he'll do better in that department and of course Rodgers is going to be huge for him. But as bad as the QB's have been his 1.37 fantasy points per target is pretty terrible and elite WR's should be able to overcome some of the obstacles and do better IMO and it makes me start to wonder if Wilson is merely really good but a step down from elite. We all talked about a big 4 in this format but I had two other players right after that big 4 in a tier of their own and if I can add a big 4 and one of Thomas or Brooks that would be an easy accept to me.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
All of that is why I thought maybe I could buy him reasonably in 2 leagues.
In each I offered a 2024 1st + 2025 1st.
Both rejected flat. Both owners let me know he was “their best WR” and I’d “have to do better than that.”
I knew I was out at that point. ARod is what, a 1-year fix at best? Then the Jets are back to the QB search, something they’ve been historically bad at.
The talent is there. But GW may never deliver on it.
I'd probably turn that down flat as well tbh.
Would need that 2024 to be top 4 and that 2025 to project as very high. Put another way I had zero interest trading 6 this year for a future first, would have needed it to feel like a lock high pick next year. I did have a drop off after the top 6 this year, if this offer was 4 and 7 for Wilson I'd tell the owner he'll have to check back with me when 7 is OTC. What he did at 4, which was generally Odunze or Bowers, would not have mattered to me.
-OZ-
Footballguy
PPR, TEP, IDP currently in the 3rd round. The more interesting trades involving veterans:
Jameson Williams for H riddick, Jerome Baker, pick 47
Zach charbonnet for pick 48
Jonathan Mingo for pick 46
Stefanski, Kevin CLE Coach; Bosa, Joey LAC DE; Rozeboom, Christian LAR
For
McCarthy, Mike DAL Coach; Overshown, DeMarvion DAL LB
CJ Mosley for 2026 3rd
Downs, Josh IND WR; Year 2025 Round 3 Draft Pick
For
Mixon, Joe HOU RB
1.16, 2.16, 4.12
For
Chris Godwin, Terry McLaurin
Jameson Williams for H riddick, Jerome Baker, pick 47
Zach charbonnet for pick 48
Jonathan Mingo for pick 46
Stefanski, Kevin CLE Coach; Bosa, Joey LAC DE; Rozeboom, Christian LAR
For
McCarthy, Mike DAL Coach; Overshown, DeMarvion DAL LB
CJ Mosley for 2026 3rd
Downs, Josh IND WR; Year 2025 Round 3 Draft Pick
For
Mixon, Joe HOU RB
1.16, 2.16, 4.12
For
Chris Godwin, Terry McLaurin
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Yeah, I get that. I'm just not a fan of Daniels and didn't think his risk/reward was worth it for the 1.02.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Oh I get it - but to date Wilson hasn’t done anything to justify that cost other than making a highlight reel catch or 2.
I’ve seen Pitts go significantly cheaper, and that’s in a TE-P coming off a single down season after setting rookie records.
It seems reasonable that there would be a value proposition for Wilson based on his circumstances and production to date, but his shareholders are clutching him like they drafted him last night.
Birdie048
Footballguy
Not sure what a coach trade value …
But this looks low for the 2 WR
Smart move during draft to acquire starting talent
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
That seems like a lot for Jamo. I don’t know your IDP scoring though.
I’d pay that easily for Charbs.
I’d pay that as well to get extra picks.
How do your coaches score? I like Overshown the most of the players.
Not a bad return on a 31 y/o LB
Seems like a bargain for Mixon for a ready to win team.
That seems about right. Good value on still decent players. If I were selling I’d have asked for a 2025 1st over the 2024 2.16, but yeah.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Edited to make it clear I like the Charbs side of this one.
-OZ-
Footballguy
Coach's Win = 5 pts
Coach's Point Differential = 1 pt per 5 (So win by 10 and get 7 pts. Lose by 10 and get -2 pts. Win by 3 and get 5 pts. Lose by 3 and get 0 pts).
Choosing not to start a HC when one is available (either on your roster or WW) = -5 pts
Having no HC available to start = -2 pts
The best coach gives you about a 3pt advantage over an average starter. You can definitely win without a good one but having one you’re confident in is nice.
Few people use picks on coaches but you won’t find a decent one on waivers after the first couple weeks. This year Harbaugh might get drafted in the 7th if someone likes him.
titusbramble
Footballguy
I'll post up trades that went down during our draft as there's a few interesting ones, but will wait for the thing to complete as we still have a couple of rounds to go
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Dez
Footballguy
Draft begins Friday night
Dez
Footballguy
Well I know who I am taking it is now up to the player to not fail me
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Fair deal. I am assuming 1QB league?
I wouldn’t panick about Herbert. I think he’s going to be fine.
Well, now you should have 2 above average QBs.
The price wasn’t terrible, but you can always deal one down the road. I doubt you’ll lose value here.
