Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I like it. Any time you can get offense for defense it seems like a win. Gibson should be startable. Davis is 35
Solid deal.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
****OFFICIAL DYNASTY TRADES**** (30 Viewers)
- Thread starter Gottabesweet
- Start date
Solid deal.
wgoldsph
Footballguy
Even if you're rebuilding, trading Hill mid season will net you more than D Smith ever could.
-OZ-
Footballguy
So he basically offered Tyreek for smith? Easy trade imo.
heckmanm
Footballguy
Same league
Gave: Okonkwo (I could only keep 2 out of him, Olave and Pitts)
Got: 2.12 (28th overall)
I was gonna cut the guy on Thursday so any return was a bonus
Just traded my pick at 2.06 in our dynasty rookie draft for Davante Adams. The offer was made to me by the Adams owner who must not like his age or situation, etc. I suspect he'd get someone like Roman Wilson to replace him. I already have some youth at WR so having a solid vet for even just a couple years makes sense to make a run at a title. Seemed like a fair trade that worked for both of us.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Nice pick up. Rookie fever must be hitting that dude HARD!
This is very easily the Bijan side.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
12 team SF PPR no d/st, no K start 10
I gave: Quentin Johnston
I rec’d: Chase Brown
Gobbling up shares of Brown.
Also that was my only other share of Johnston, so I’m now QJ-free.
Plus, my team could use a top end WR, and there’s one team in the league that needs RB & is loaded at WR. My RB room is now Bijan, ETN, Mixon, Monty, Brown, Pierce, Gray, Guerendo, Prince, AJD
So maybe I can swing a 2:1 to upgrade my receiver room. WRs are AJB, ARSB, Higgins, Jeudy, Gabe Davis, Bateman, Mike Williams, AT Perry, Iosivas
Getting a 4th upper tier WR would be very helpful.
I gave: Quentin Johnston
I rec’d: Chase Brown
Gobbling up shares of Brown.
Also that was my only other share of Johnston, so I’m now QJ-free.
Plus, my team could use a top end WR, and there’s one team in the league that needs RB & is loaded at WR. My RB room is now Bijan, ETN, Mixon, Monty, Brown, Pierce, Gray, Guerendo, Prince, AJD
So maybe I can swing a 2:1 to upgrade my receiver room. WRs are AJB, ARSB, Higgins, Jeudy, Gabe Davis, Bateman, Mike Williams, AT Perry, Iosivas
Getting a 4th upper tier WR would be very helpful.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
DJM for 2.02 is highway robbery.
Update: He took Ricky Pearsall at 2.06. I'm thrilled that Roman Wilson stuck around for me to grab at 3.06. I think his recent injury took him off the radar of drafters. Don't sleep on the next Hines Ward.
Related: I offered Aaron Rodgers straight up for Drake Maye (pick 2.11 in our league) and I'm being ghosted. I get that Rodgers is old and in a dynasty league youth is king. But I didn't think it was that much of a reach. Rodgers doesn't hold much dynasty value at this point.
King of the Jungle
Footballguy
I know for a fact I could not land DJ for a first in my league, that seems very light to me. On that note, I do think he regresses quite a bit from last year. Too many factors that will water down his production (rookie QB, Keenan Allen, Odunze).
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Rebuild for a SF TE+ bestball team that had/has very few tradeable assets. QB/RB/RB//WR/WR/TE/SF/FLEX/FLEX/FLEX
Gave: KIncaid 2.12
Got: Hockenson, 26 1st, 26 2nd
Gave: KIncaid 2.12
Got: Hockenson, 26 1st, 26 2nd
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I don’t mind it. I have Hock & Kindaid very close. Hock might even be the better FF TE. Regardless, I see this as basically a free 1st & 2nd.
Boston
Footballguy
Fair deal...if you believe in Kincaid this makes sense...TJH is coming off of an ACL (i.e. you can let someone else deal with it) and you have 2 years to replace those picks while adding a #2 in 25...on the other-side if TJH makes a full recovery he and Kincaid are right in the same ballpark and you added a future #1 which is important in a rebuild...makes sense for both teams.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Exactly my analysis as the rebuilder with a roster that is very, very likely to be in 12th place at the end of the season.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Same league. SF, TE+, Bestball start 10. Rebuild with zero starting QBs currently.
Gave: Waddle, 3.10
Got: Nix, 2.08
Gave: Waddle, 3.10
Got: Nix, 2.08
Protest worthy, IMO. Odunze is currently WR17 in ADP of startups per DLF, Moore is WR18
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Sounds about right. Maybe a bargain depending who’s on the board at 17.
heckmanm
Footballguy
Charts liked it and with it being a contract league I don’t really want the extra body
joey
Footballguy
Seems like a really good deal in SF. With QBs, especially young ones, being at a premium, I’m surprised you got a pick upgrade.
BearsFan4Life
Footballguy
14 Team .. Standard Scoring
Gave: Fant, 2 04, 2.13, 3.09
Got: TDell
Have no roster room left. Also have Andrews, McBride, and Hockenson at TE
Gave: Fant, 2 04, 2.13, 3.09
Got: TDell
Have no roster room left. Also have Andrews, McBride, and Hockenson at TE
FFPC Triflex (superflex, TE premium, start 3 WRs)
Gave: Trey Benson, Christian Watson
Got: Jonathan Brooks, 2025 R3
My partner and I made an offer for Brooks, and this was the counter (minus the rookie pick, which he agreed to throw in). It was probably an overpay, but we cleared a roster spot, and we really like Brooks, despite the recent news that he's likely to miss the early part of the season (which we always assumed anyway).
Gave: Trey Benson, Christian Watson
Got: Jonathan Brooks, 2025 R3
My partner and I made an offer for Brooks, and this was the counter (minus the rookie pick, which he agreed to throw in). It was probably an overpay, but we cleared a roster spot, and we really like Brooks, despite the recent news that he's likely to miss the early part of the season (which we always assumed anyway).
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Thievery.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Been reading that Allgeier has been splitting reps, and will be used a lot.
It has me a bit concerned as a Bijan shareholder.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
If that's the case, it sheds a little new light on Arthur Smith's decision to split time between the backs...
wgoldsph
Footballguy
I saw a similar report before making the offer. Every team splits reps at rb now, especially teams that like to line an rb out wide (like I'm sure they will start doing in ATL). I've watched Allgeier because I've got him in two leagues and while he's a serviceable back, he's never going to be a guy who steals real carries from a guy like Bijan unless the coach is an idiot. *cough* The stats from his first year (200 carries, 1k yards, 15 catches for nothing) are his ceiling even if he's starting from day one imo.
There's also the possibly he's better at pass pro than Bijan which is why he will be "used a lot".
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Oh, sure, Bijan can be a league winner in a split just like Gibbs can.
But he’d be a lot more valuable at 80:20 than he could be at 60:40
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
12 team SF PPR No K, no D/ST
Start 10, very flexy.
I gave: Bijan Robinson+AT Perry
I rec’d: Ja’Marr Chase
My 1st Chase dynasty share.
RB after the deal: ETN, Mixon, Monty, Chase Brown, some scraps
WR after the deal: Chase, AJB, ARSB, Higgins, Jeudy, Gabe, Bateman, Mike Williams
Start 10, very flexy.
I gave: Bijan Robinson+AT Perry
I rec’d: Ja’Marr Chase
My 1st Chase dynasty share.
RB after the deal: ETN, Mixon, Monty, Chase Brown, some scraps
WR after the deal: Chase, AJB, ARSB, Higgins, Jeudy, Gabe, Bateman, Mike Williams
titusbramble
Footballguy
Seems cheap for Chase
-OZ-
Footballguy
horrible dealAs much as I like Kincaid, makes sense imo. Could be a great deal when / if Hock completely recovers.
I prefer waddle but in SF it makes sense.
Given roster space, great deal.
Could be an overpay but one that won’t hurt.
I don’t see Franklin as near that potential but I’ve been wrong on occasion so
in a rebuild I like the deal for you. Perry is one of my preferred last round dart throws and I like Bijan a lot. I’d take that side but fair.
Winning IS Everything
Footballguy
A couple I completed the last couple days:
I gave: 2026 second
I got: Cooper Kupp
I am two time defending champ and am loaded at WR (Lamb, Sun God, AJ Brown) looked to add a stable WR to cover in case the Lamb holdout stretches
I gave: Zamir White, Trey McBride
I got: James Cook
I kind of just threw this offer out there not expecting an accept. I have LaPorta so I could afford to trade McBride. The guy I traded with has Kyler and the 1.1 (MHJ) so I thought he would like the stack
I gave: Tee Higgins, Chuba Hubbard
I got: 2027 1st rounder
With my depth, I figured this was a good buy cheap first round pick.
I gave: 2026 second
I got: Cooper Kupp
I am two time defending champ and am loaded at WR (Lamb, Sun God, AJ Brown) looked to add a stable WR to cover in case the Lamb holdout stretches
I gave: Zamir White, Trey McBride
I got: James Cook
I kind of just threw this offer out there not expecting an accept. I have LaPorta so I could afford to trade McBride. The guy I traded with has Kyler and the 1.1 (MHJ) so I thought he would like the stack
I gave: Tee Higgins, Chuba Hubbard
I got: 2027 1st rounder
With my depth, I figured this was a good buy cheap first round pick.
wgoldsph
Footballguy
Any two years away pick for a guy who can win you the chip right now is a good trade. Anyone making moves for two years from now picks as the goal is simply moving them like chips at a poker table and not directly improving their team.
I'm a big fan of Mcbride this year, he will end the season in the top five, potentially TE1, in fact I predicted him as top te this year in another thread considering mhj is the only other option and no matter how good he is, he's still a rookie. Imo he seems like the perfect storm for him this year.
Then throw a presumptive starting rb who ended last year with the same new coaching staff giving him the ball after he preformed well when they gave it to him to end the season...
If James Cook is a top three rb you might hit even, but I feel like you hosed yourself here.
Higgins in worth much much more than a 1st 3 years from now. Heck you'd be selling low for a 2nd/3rd next year and then you can just move that second for a first the next year during the draft. I don't understand this move even from a long term perspective, you have absolutely no idea what that first could possibly be valued at that far in advance. Even the theoretical 2nd/3rd next season has such a wide range of value possibilities they're not good investments in return for proven weekly starters like Higgins unless you're completely rebuilding.
But I haven't won a championship in years, so what do I know?
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I like Perry too, but he was a 4th round draft pick for me, and Bijan my 1.01
i love the return on Bijan’s hype. I am high on the dude too, but Allgeier isn’t going away, and Chase seems like the more proven commodity.
Plus I have quite a few good RB still, and the positional shelf-life is always in the back of my mind.
Perry was a balancing piece - didn’t love losing him, but for Chase? Easy call.
Last edited:
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Total steal. I sent the same offer to a Kupp shareholder and he said it wasn’t close since the pick was 2 years out.
And now with Puka hurt & Kupp reportedly fully recovered? League-winning stuff there.
I’m on the white+mcbride side of this one.
I’m on the Tee+Chuba side here. IMO Chuba has season-long value even after Brooks returns, but if I’m gonna deal him I’m gonna wait for early production to bump his value.
Tee alone should have brought in more than a 2027 1st IMO.
I’m holding Tee to see where he goes next year - this one seems like a mistake, IMO.
Da Franchise
Footballguy
FFPC TriFlex
Gave: Garrett Wilson, JJ McCarthy, Dulcich
Got: Jayden Daniels, Marshawn Lloyd, Hollywood Brown
Fun one. This was all about Daniels, he’s been getting nothing but glowing reports.
Gave: Garrett Wilson, JJ McCarthy, Dulcich
Got: Jayden Daniels, Marshawn Lloyd, Hollywood Brown
Fun one. This was all about Daniels, he’s been getting nothing but glowing reports.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
I don't think the difference between JJM and Daniels is as large as Wilson minus Lloyd. That said, I'm a JJM fanboy and think GW is a QB away from being the true WR1.
Da Franchise
Footballguy
Fair take. I do believe in JJ and think he will stick as a starter in the league for a long time and it’s based mostly on his intangibles. That said, think he takes awhile to get going.
Agree on Wilson’s talent no doubt. I worry about Rodgers surviving the season and what happens after he’s gone? We’ve seen his floor. If he doesn’t get a QB, we may never see his ceiling.
I’m just gonna
on Daniels for now. Safe to say I’m buying the camp reports I’m seeing.
InDitkaWeTrust
Footballguy
Yeah, Daniels is looking good in camp. As always, go get your guy even if it is something of a perceived overpay. It's just so much more fun in this hobby if you have at least a few of "your guys".
Fair take. I do believe in JJ and think he will stick as a starter in the league for a long time and it’s based mostly on his intangibles. That said, think he takes awhile to get going.
Agree on Wilson’s talent no doubt. I worry about Rodgers surviving the season and what happens after he’s gone? We’ve seen his floor. If he doesn’t get a QB, we may never see his ceiling.
I’m just gonna
Da Franchise
Footballguy
Yeah, Daniels is looking good in camp. As always, go get your guy even if it is something of a perceived overpay. It's just so much more fun in this hobby if you have at least a few of "your guys".
Fair take. I do believe in JJ and think he will stick as a starter in the league for a long time and it’s based mostly on his intangibles. That said, think he takes awhile to get going.
Agree on Wilson’s talent no doubt. I worry about Rodgers surviving the season and what happens after he’s gone? We’ve seen his floor. If he doesn’t get a QB, we may never see his ceiling.
I’m just gonna
What really solidified my belief in him was going to camp the other day. It was a lame session but I just watched him the entire time and how he interacted with the guys. He’s really chill and looks super comfortable out there. Guys are responding to him big time. Already feels like his team. Has a different vibe than most QBs and I can’t even think of anyone at the moment to compare it to. Back at draft time I was thrown by it and wasn’t even sure if I wanted Wash to draft him, but now I’m seeing it differently and he’s won me over.
He needs more weapons and that will limit his ceiling for now, but there’s going to be some great flash this year IMO.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
“Get your guy” trade.
I get it. It’s a lot to pay to swap rookies. JJM about to have the best receiver room in the NFL, but it’s gonna take a minute. Darnold is impressing in camp.
So if you’re in a win now window I like it more. I like Hollywood & Lloyd regardless, so yeah - probably fair.
If you were trading from 1.06 to 1.02 in SF rookie draft that’d likely be the cost.
Wilson is such a potential breakout, but QB challenged in the long term.
Da Franchise
Footballguy
Thanks and yes, for context my team is a contender this year. There are no super teams and I’m firmly in the mix with two other top contenders IMO. So that boosts Hollywood a bit in terms of relative value in my eyes and definitely Daniels. Rest of my team is strong but had only Purdy, Rodgers, McCarthy as QB options. Hopefully this pushes Rodgers to QB3 or else I’ve made a horrible mistake lol.
Tried hard to move Rodgers instead of JJ but it wasn’t happening.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
I’d recommend letting AARProd play a few games - get some value up.
You should be able to move him by week 2-3.
Da Franchise
Footballguy
Fair deal to me but I prefer to hold my value in WRs rather than RBs, so it’s Chase in theory. You have plenty of solid RB options so in theory becomes reality for me. Would take Chase easily.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Thanks - yeah, I have Pierce, Deneric Prince, Guerendo, AJD, too. Nothing special, but seems like enough depth that it’s worth having Chase, AJB, ARSB
Nasty trio. Feels good. Feels real good.
I don’t think I got a bargain, but I’m super happy with it. Bijan has a lot of shine, but I don’t know if he’ll deliver. Chase is a monster.
Da Franchise
Footballguy
My personal choice would be easy but think they are basically dead even in value. No bargains either way just a fair deal to me. Couldn’t care less about Perry in a deal like this tbh.
Hopefully we get a healthy Burrow this year.
Hot Sauce Guy
Footballguy
Does it change your equation with Higgins as my WR4? That's the only part I'm a little off on - 2 WR same team.
